logo
I fear a state monopoly of the rail timetable, fares and capacity

I fear a state monopoly of the rail timetable, fares and capacity

Times6 days ago
'N o room, No room,' said Network Rail, which owns and manages railway infrastructure. And the regulator, the Office of Rail and Road, agreed. In its decision of July 3, the office rejected three companies' applications, made in 2024, for track access contracts for the west coast main line — the railway that has its London terminus at Euston.
Virgin wanted to operate three new services including Euston to Birmingham; First Group applied to operate new services from Euston to Rochdale; and Wrexham, Shropshire & Midlands Railway Company applied to operate new services to Wrexham.
Their problem was that in May 2020 — four years before they made their applications — Network Rail had made a formal declaration that part of the route, from London to Leighton Buzzard, counted as 'congested infrastructure'. They made applications that seemed doomed to fail, unless the rail regulator intervened.
• Great Bolshevik Railways going the wrong way
The regulator concluded that this part of the line was 'currently unable to accommodate any of the proposed applications'. That verdict depended heavily on the value the regulator placed on Network Rail having some spare capacity available for existing and planned services. Also, critically, it depended on the existing timetable and service specifications for the incumbent operators, and for the HS2 line north of Birmingham.
Will the 'existing timetable and service specifications' be maintained by Great British Railways, the planned state-owned railway company? If not, will the private or 'open-access operators' like Virgin be able to use the spare capacity ? If the answer to both questions is no, the future for passengers is bleak.
Subject to there being any appeal, the regulator's decision has brought to the fore first, to my mind, a predictable clash between an independent regulator and a government hostile to any engagement by the private sector in its state-owned and controlled railway, and secondly a complete absence of any sense of direction or commitment on the part of the government as to the future of the timetable and service specifications.
• Virgin Trains' attempt to get back on to the railways blocked
The regulator's decision also showed how its so-called 'not primarily abstractive', or NPA, test would work, even though its decision was not based on it.
This test is used to help the regulator to balance its statutory duties, in particular those to promote competition for the benefit of users and to have regard to the funds available to the secretary of state. Of five applications it looked at, four would have passed the test. However, the government argued that only one of the five would have passed the test.
Moreover, the regulator's decision refers to Department for Transport submissions made to it in June this year in which the government 'stressed the need for ORR to take steps to fully understand and consider the cumulative scale and impact of abstraction when it assesses open-access applications'.
My concern is that a state monopoly in control of the timetable, fares and capacity, and intolerant of any risk that competition may erode that monopoly through the provision of better services, is a bleak future for us all.
John Swift KC was Rail Regulator, 1993-1998
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

DANIEL HANNAN: Think things are bad now? This is what Angela Rayner would do on the day she got into No 10 (and the terrifyingly plausible way it could happen)
DANIEL HANNAN: Think things are bad now? This is what Angela Rayner would do on the day she got into No 10 (and the terrifyingly plausible way it could happen)

Daily Mail​

time26 minutes ago

  • Daily Mail​

DANIEL HANNAN: Think things are bad now? This is what Angela Rayner would do on the day she got into No 10 (and the terrifyingly plausible way it could happen)

Angela Rayner narrows her eyes and grips the podium outside No 10. The moment calls for plain speaking – and plain speaking, she tells herself, is what she does best. 'All right, let's be honest. The markets are out to get us. The bankers, the investors, the money men. The pinstriped scum, absolute pile of asset-stripping Old Etonian piece of scum.'

Shoppers spot new Nestle chocolate pouches on shelves of major supermarket
Shoppers spot new Nestle chocolate pouches on shelves of major supermarket

The Sun

time26 minutes ago

  • The Sun

Shoppers spot new Nestle chocolate pouches on shelves of major supermarket

A NEW Nestle product has left chocolate-lovers overjoyed as it lands on the shelves of a major supermarket. Shoppers shared their excitement on social media as they were desperate to get their hands on the new product. An eagle-eyed shopper spotted the Milkybar Buttons Crispy Cookie White Chocolate Sharing Bag at their local Sainsburys. With hundreds of comments flooding in, the sharing bag is clearly a hit among chocolate lovers. And for just £2 it's the perfect opportunity to try out the sweet treat with friends and family. The new crispy cookie flavour is described as "white chocolate pieces with crispy cocoa flavoured rice inclusions". It includes their beloved " smooth white chocolate". A description from Milkybar adds: "No wonder we are the nation's favourite white chocolate brand." Inspired by a bakery, the new flavour offers an exciting texture with the rice inclusions. For those looking to stick to the classic flavours, Sainsburys also sell the Milkybar White Chocolate Giant buttons for £2, You can even get a supersized bag for just £2.50 with Nectar. It's part of a wider range of white chocolate products sold by the brand. Shoppers can enjoy the Milkybar White Chocolate mousse for a refreshing chilled snack, or individual bars for the perfect lunchbox filler. Nestle offer a plethora of sharing pouches across their range of chocolates. For those looking for milk chocolate, the Aero Melts Milk Chocolate might be a good choice. Or for those after something a bit more exciting, Sainsburys also sell bags of Munchies. Earlier this week it was revealed that the brand would be bringing back a popular Quality Street chocolate - to the delight of fans. Shoppers spotted the Green Triangle-inspired sharing bar at Asda. It costs just £3.50 for an 84 gram bar, and features all of the delicious flavours of the iconic Green Triangle. The Green Triangle is described as having a "smooth, silky praline filling coated in a milk chocolate shell". Of course, it has a distinctive triangle shape and comes wrapped in a green foil. Nestle spokesperson said: "Quality Street is launching a new Green Triangle-inspired sharing bar, due to hit shelves over the next few weeks. "Inspired by our iconic Green Triangle, we've created a bar filled with Hazelnut flavour filling so that fans don't have to wait until Christmas to enjoy sharing the taste of one of their favourite Quality Street sweets as a delicious treat!" 2

England ace and love rat Jermain Defoe, 42, dating stunning recruiter 11 years his junior
England ace and love rat Jermain Defoe, 42, dating stunning recruiter 11 years his junior

The Sun

time26 minutes ago

  • The Sun

England ace and love rat Jermain Defoe, 42, dating stunning recruiter 11 years his junior

FORMER England striker JERMAIN DEFOE can never stay single for too long. And now I can reveal that the ex-Premier League star is dating recruiter Farran Tomlin - 11 years his junior. 4 4 The pair were spotted in the British Airways First Class lounge at London's Heathrow Airport last week - before jetting off on a romantic getaway to Bodrum in Turkey. A source said: 'The pair were very loved-up and enjoying the perks of the lounge before their flight.' Turkish singer Dilek Sert Erdogan posted a snap of the couple at the five-star Lujo Hotel Bodrum, captioned: 'The amazing Jermain Defoe and his lovely wife Farran came to see our show. 'Even after I got off stage, they were still there… 'Later, Farran messaged me saying: 'Jermain said: 'We have to stay afterwards - and let her know what an amazing voice she has.' How sweet is that?' 'We had a lovely little chat - they're such warm, genuine people. One by one they sparkle but together they shine!' In 2023 Jermain was caught kissing wedding planner Paige Mallabourn-Edmondson at a hotel in Lancashire - days after appearing on a red carpet with his influencer girlfriend Alisha LeMay. It came after Jermain left his wife Donna Tierney for Alisha after less than a year of marriage. Let's hope Jermain doesn't stray this time… 4

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store