‘A missed opportunity': West Australians react to the state budget
Every line item in Labor's ninth consecutive budget handed down on Thursday will have a real impact on West Australians.
The reactions to those items have been steadily flowing in, in the aftermath of the budget's release on Thursday afternoon, and while some are happy with the results others are furious.
Laura West, 44, is living on a carer's pension as she looks after her 11-year-old daughter with complex health issues full-time.
'We've ended up with another big billion-dollar surplus, and it's actually quite devastating for families like mine, who could be helped by redirecting that money to provide some assistance,' she said.
'I scrimp and save as much as I can to meet our needs ... but it's a real struggle. Families like ours who are vulnerable and depended on an income support payment – our standard of living is decreasing.
'I feel like the cost of living crisis is increasing, and we are a wealthy state. That should not be the case.'
Casey Pateman, 39, is also struggling with the cost of living.
She used to work in Kalgoorlie in the mining industry until she decided to move to Perth five years ago, and that was when things changed.
As cost of living went up, Pateman became homeless and was living out of her car with her children.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Perth Now
an hour ago
- Perth Now
Tech speedbumps may frustrate social media ban for kids
There is no guarantee that technologies aimed at blocking young kids from social media will always work, according to early trial results. A ban on children younger than 16 from accessing platforms like Snapchat, TikTok and Instagram is expected to commence in six months, and yet, there are glaring questions about how and whether the plan will work. While the early findings of a federal government-commissioned trial found age assurance technologies are available, there's no silver bullet. "Age assurance can be done in Australia and can be private, robust and effective," the report found. "We found a plethora of approaches that fit use cases in different ways. "But we did not find a single ubiquitous solution that would suit all use cases, nor did we find solutions that were guaranteed to be effective in all deployments." Under the social media ban, platforms will have to take reasonable steps to prevent under-16s from creating new accounts and could face millions in fines for systemic breaches of the new rules. Cabinet minister Murray Watt maintained the need for restrictions around social media. "The Australian people believe that we do need to see some restrictions around social media use when it comes to young people," he told ABC News on Friday. "Unfortunately, it has become an insidious force, both for young people and more widely." Australia's ban is world-leading and, in the aftermath of the November passage of federal laws, other nations indicated a desire to emulate the measure. However, the legislation does not indicate how exactly the ban will be executed. The report found parental control and consent systems could be effective when first introduced. But there is "limited evidence" that they would be effective as children grow up or allow kids the right to participate in the breadth of digital experiences. Even after the coalition helped secure an amendment to ensure Australians wouldn't have to provide any form of government identification to verify their age, the trial found there was a risk of privacy breaches. Some age assurance service providers had over-anticipated the needs of regulators and built tools that led to an "unnecessary and disproportionate collection and retention of data". Opposition communications spokeswoman Melissa McIntosh has urged Labor to confirm what technology or verification tools will be used to protect kids online. "No more young lives can be lost or families destroyed because of the toxicity of social media," she said in a statement. The Age Assurance Technology Trial's final report is expected to be published later in 2025.
The Advertiser
2 hours ago
- The Advertiser
'Meat in the sandwich': back-and-forth about Sonia Hornery derails Wallsend violence debate
COUNCILLORS want solutions to combat an "uptick" in anti-social behaviour and violent attacks at Wallsend Library that have made staff and residents feel unsafe. Newcastle Liberal deputy lord mayor Callum Pull tabled a motion this week urging the state government to increase police patrols and help stop troublemakers in their tracks. Cr Pull said ratepayers are covering the cost of a security guard at the library, and now, the council is in the "extraordinary" position of considering paying police. He said library patrons, shoppers and bus users are being "terrorised". "Policing is the responsibility of the NSW government, and our region pours billions of dollars every year into the state government's coffers," Cr Pull said. "So I think it's a reasonable expectation of Wallsend residents that they'd be able to feel safe in their own suburb, and that we be given the resources, and police be given the resources, that they need to effectively do their job. "For the sake of our town and the good name of our town, I think we can expect that." In May, youths carrying hammers attacked the windows of the library. Two weeks earlier, a group of people blocked the entry and refused to allow people to enter or leave. That same month, Wallsend Swimming Pool was broken into and trashed for the third time this season. The council has restricted access to the library, requiring visitors to scan their cards to enter after 3pm on weekdays. Labor councillor Deahnna Richardson said the majority of bad behaviour in the area is perpetrated by children aged 11 to 17. She requested targeted diversionary programs for youth and a memo detailing the agencies that have been engaged and those needed beyond police to address the issue. "I'm incredibly sad staff do not feel safe in their workplace," Cr Richardson said. "I'm also deeply saddened that we have a group of children ... who are so disengaged ... that they've taken to intimidating other patrons of the library, assaulting Newcastle bus drivers and vandalising our precious community spaces in quite a violent way." Cr Richardson said there is an opportunity to intervene and put supports in place. That tack had the support of Greens councillor Joel Pringle, who said policing alone would not address the issue. He suggested looking at something similar to the Cairns Community Safety Plan, introduced in 2022 to measure behaviour, introduce interventions and evaluates how effective they are. Council chief executive Jeremy Bath said the council had considered the Cairns strategy, but he had reservations about a mass CCTV rollout. "The total number of offences in Cairns two years was 6932, it's increased to 7836 in January of this year, so it's having a limited effect," he said. "I think it's got a lot of PR and a lot of sensationalism to it, but I don't know that it's necessarily the holistic solution that we want to be looking at." Newcastle police have met with the council to discuss a joint response. "A user-pays policing response is not being considered by police, as reducing anti-social behaviour and crime at the location sits within the remit of the Newcastle City Police District," a NSW Police spokesman said. "Police have increased high-visibility patrols of the area in response to those reports and have issued move-on directions to youths at the location on two occasions in recent days." In the last month, police have received three reports of anti-social behaviour near the library. The council debate was momentarily derailed over whether or not Mr Bath or independent lord mayor Ross Kerridge had responded to correspondence from Wallsend MP Sonia Hornery on the issue. Mr Bath claimed there had been no correspondence since Cr Kerridge took office and said Ms Hornery "made a decision in October last year" that she "wanted to communicate exclusively" with the lord mayor on operational issues. "The only emails that I've received from the state member for Wallsend since the election have been to say that she will not meet with me, she will not meet with council staff, she wants to meet exclusively with you," Mr Bath said. "I can't allow the council to think that I'm not responding to the state member for Wallsend, because I am bending over backwards to try and communicate with her." Cr Kerridge described himself as the "meat in the sandwich". "We need to work on it," he said. Ms Hornery took to Facebook on Wednesday to blast Mr Bath for claims he made at the council meeting. "Mr Bath stated that there is no correspondence from me to him relating to the Wallsend Library that has not been responded to," she said. "I can establish that I did indeed write to Mr Bath on 8 November 2024, and the CEO did not respond." Ms Hornery said the letter to Mr Bath was a "sincere representation" on behalf of a Wallsend constituent. Community members are urged to report suspicious activity to local police or Crime Stoppers on 1800 333 000 or call Triple Zero in an emergency. COUNCILLORS want solutions to combat an "uptick" in anti-social behaviour and violent attacks at Wallsend Library that have made staff and residents feel unsafe. Newcastle Liberal deputy lord mayor Callum Pull tabled a motion this week urging the state government to increase police patrols and help stop troublemakers in their tracks. Cr Pull said ratepayers are covering the cost of a security guard at the library, and now, the council is in the "extraordinary" position of considering paying police. He said library patrons, shoppers and bus users are being "terrorised". "Policing is the responsibility of the NSW government, and our region pours billions of dollars every year into the state government's coffers," Cr Pull said. "So I think it's a reasonable expectation of Wallsend residents that they'd be able to feel safe in their own suburb, and that we be given the resources, and police be given the resources, that they need to effectively do their job. "For the sake of our town and the good name of our town, I think we can expect that." In May, youths carrying hammers attacked the windows of the library. Two weeks earlier, a group of people blocked the entry and refused to allow people to enter or leave. That same month, Wallsend Swimming Pool was broken into and trashed for the third time this season. The council has restricted access to the library, requiring visitors to scan their cards to enter after 3pm on weekdays. Labor councillor Deahnna Richardson said the majority of bad behaviour in the area is perpetrated by children aged 11 to 17. She requested targeted diversionary programs for youth and a memo detailing the agencies that have been engaged and those needed beyond police to address the issue. "I'm incredibly sad staff do not feel safe in their workplace," Cr Richardson said. "I'm also deeply saddened that we have a group of children ... who are so disengaged ... that they've taken to intimidating other patrons of the library, assaulting Newcastle bus drivers and vandalising our precious community spaces in quite a violent way." Cr Richardson said there is an opportunity to intervene and put supports in place. That tack had the support of Greens councillor Joel Pringle, who said policing alone would not address the issue. He suggested looking at something similar to the Cairns Community Safety Plan, introduced in 2022 to measure behaviour, introduce interventions and evaluates how effective they are. Council chief executive Jeremy Bath said the council had considered the Cairns strategy, but he had reservations about a mass CCTV rollout. "The total number of offences in Cairns two years was 6932, it's increased to 7836 in January of this year, so it's having a limited effect," he said. "I think it's got a lot of PR and a lot of sensationalism to it, but I don't know that it's necessarily the holistic solution that we want to be looking at." Newcastle police have met with the council to discuss a joint response. "A user-pays policing response is not being considered by police, as reducing anti-social behaviour and crime at the location sits within the remit of the Newcastle City Police District," a NSW Police spokesman said. "Police have increased high-visibility patrols of the area in response to those reports and have issued move-on directions to youths at the location on two occasions in recent days." In the last month, police have received three reports of anti-social behaviour near the library. The council debate was momentarily derailed over whether or not Mr Bath or independent lord mayor Ross Kerridge had responded to correspondence from Wallsend MP Sonia Hornery on the issue. Mr Bath claimed there had been no correspondence since Cr Kerridge took office and said Ms Hornery "made a decision in October last year" that she "wanted to communicate exclusively" with the lord mayor on operational issues. "The only emails that I've received from the state member for Wallsend since the election have been to say that she will not meet with me, she will not meet with council staff, she wants to meet exclusively with you," Mr Bath said. "I can't allow the council to think that I'm not responding to the state member for Wallsend, because I am bending over backwards to try and communicate with her." Cr Kerridge described himself as the "meat in the sandwich". "We need to work on it," he said. Ms Hornery took to Facebook on Wednesday to blast Mr Bath for claims he made at the council meeting. "Mr Bath stated that there is no correspondence from me to him relating to the Wallsend Library that has not been responded to," she said. "I can establish that I did indeed write to Mr Bath on 8 November 2024, and the CEO did not respond." Ms Hornery said the letter to Mr Bath was a "sincere representation" on behalf of a Wallsend constituent. Community members are urged to report suspicious activity to local police or Crime Stoppers on 1800 333 000 or call Triple Zero in an emergency. COUNCILLORS want solutions to combat an "uptick" in anti-social behaviour and violent attacks at Wallsend Library that have made staff and residents feel unsafe. Newcastle Liberal deputy lord mayor Callum Pull tabled a motion this week urging the state government to increase police patrols and help stop troublemakers in their tracks. Cr Pull said ratepayers are covering the cost of a security guard at the library, and now, the council is in the "extraordinary" position of considering paying police. He said library patrons, shoppers and bus users are being "terrorised". "Policing is the responsibility of the NSW government, and our region pours billions of dollars every year into the state government's coffers," Cr Pull said. "So I think it's a reasonable expectation of Wallsend residents that they'd be able to feel safe in their own suburb, and that we be given the resources, and police be given the resources, that they need to effectively do their job. "For the sake of our town and the good name of our town, I think we can expect that." In May, youths carrying hammers attacked the windows of the library. Two weeks earlier, a group of people blocked the entry and refused to allow people to enter or leave. That same month, Wallsend Swimming Pool was broken into and trashed for the third time this season. The council has restricted access to the library, requiring visitors to scan their cards to enter after 3pm on weekdays. Labor councillor Deahnna Richardson said the majority of bad behaviour in the area is perpetrated by children aged 11 to 17. She requested targeted diversionary programs for youth and a memo detailing the agencies that have been engaged and those needed beyond police to address the issue. "I'm incredibly sad staff do not feel safe in their workplace," Cr Richardson said. "I'm also deeply saddened that we have a group of children ... who are so disengaged ... that they've taken to intimidating other patrons of the library, assaulting Newcastle bus drivers and vandalising our precious community spaces in quite a violent way." Cr Richardson said there is an opportunity to intervene and put supports in place. That tack had the support of Greens councillor Joel Pringle, who said policing alone would not address the issue. He suggested looking at something similar to the Cairns Community Safety Plan, introduced in 2022 to measure behaviour, introduce interventions and evaluates how effective they are. Council chief executive Jeremy Bath said the council had considered the Cairns strategy, but he had reservations about a mass CCTV rollout. "The total number of offences in Cairns two years was 6932, it's increased to 7836 in January of this year, so it's having a limited effect," he said. "I think it's got a lot of PR and a lot of sensationalism to it, but I don't know that it's necessarily the holistic solution that we want to be looking at." Newcastle police have met with the council to discuss a joint response. "A user-pays policing response is not being considered by police, as reducing anti-social behaviour and crime at the location sits within the remit of the Newcastle City Police District," a NSW Police spokesman said. "Police have increased high-visibility patrols of the area in response to those reports and have issued move-on directions to youths at the location on two occasions in recent days." In the last month, police have received three reports of anti-social behaviour near the library. The council debate was momentarily derailed over whether or not Mr Bath or independent lord mayor Ross Kerridge had responded to correspondence from Wallsend MP Sonia Hornery on the issue. Mr Bath claimed there had been no correspondence since Cr Kerridge took office and said Ms Hornery "made a decision in October last year" that she "wanted to communicate exclusively" with the lord mayor on operational issues. "The only emails that I've received from the state member for Wallsend since the election have been to say that she will not meet with me, she will not meet with council staff, she wants to meet exclusively with you," Mr Bath said. "I can't allow the council to think that I'm not responding to the state member for Wallsend, because I am bending over backwards to try and communicate with her." Cr Kerridge described himself as the "meat in the sandwich". "We need to work on it," he said. Ms Hornery took to Facebook on Wednesday to blast Mr Bath for claims he made at the council meeting. "Mr Bath stated that there is no correspondence from me to him relating to the Wallsend Library that has not been responded to," she said. "I can establish that I did indeed write to Mr Bath on 8 November 2024, and the CEO did not respond." Ms Hornery said the letter to Mr Bath was a "sincere representation" on behalf of a Wallsend constituent. Community members are urged to report suspicious activity to local police or Crime Stoppers on 1800 333 000 or call Triple Zero in an emergency. COUNCILLORS want solutions to combat an "uptick" in anti-social behaviour and violent attacks at Wallsend Library that have made staff and residents feel unsafe. Newcastle Liberal deputy lord mayor Callum Pull tabled a motion this week urging the state government to increase police patrols and help stop troublemakers in their tracks. Cr Pull said ratepayers are covering the cost of a security guard at the library, and now, the council is in the "extraordinary" position of considering paying police. He said library patrons, shoppers and bus users are being "terrorised". "Policing is the responsibility of the NSW government, and our region pours billions of dollars every year into the state government's coffers," Cr Pull said. "So I think it's a reasonable expectation of Wallsend residents that they'd be able to feel safe in their own suburb, and that we be given the resources, and police be given the resources, that they need to effectively do their job. "For the sake of our town and the good name of our town, I think we can expect that." In May, youths carrying hammers attacked the windows of the library. Two weeks earlier, a group of people blocked the entry and refused to allow people to enter or leave. That same month, Wallsend Swimming Pool was broken into and trashed for the third time this season. The council has restricted access to the library, requiring visitors to scan their cards to enter after 3pm on weekdays. Labor councillor Deahnna Richardson said the majority of bad behaviour in the area is perpetrated by children aged 11 to 17. She requested targeted diversionary programs for youth and a memo detailing the agencies that have been engaged and those needed beyond police to address the issue. "I'm incredibly sad staff do not feel safe in their workplace," Cr Richardson said. "I'm also deeply saddened that we have a group of children ... who are so disengaged ... that they've taken to intimidating other patrons of the library, assaulting Newcastle bus drivers and vandalising our precious community spaces in quite a violent way." Cr Richardson said there is an opportunity to intervene and put supports in place. That tack had the support of Greens councillor Joel Pringle, who said policing alone would not address the issue. He suggested looking at something similar to the Cairns Community Safety Plan, introduced in 2022 to measure behaviour, introduce interventions and evaluates how effective they are. Council chief executive Jeremy Bath said the council had considered the Cairns strategy, but he had reservations about a mass CCTV rollout. "The total number of offences in Cairns two years was 6932, it's increased to 7836 in January of this year, so it's having a limited effect," he said. "I think it's got a lot of PR and a lot of sensationalism to it, but I don't know that it's necessarily the holistic solution that we want to be looking at." Newcastle police have met with the council to discuss a joint response. "A user-pays policing response is not being considered by police, as reducing anti-social behaviour and crime at the location sits within the remit of the Newcastle City Police District," a NSW Police spokesman said. "Police have increased high-visibility patrols of the area in response to those reports and have issued move-on directions to youths at the location on two occasions in recent days." In the last month, police have received three reports of anti-social behaviour near the library. The council debate was momentarily derailed over whether or not Mr Bath or independent lord mayor Ross Kerridge had responded to correspondence from Wallsend MP Sonia Hornery on the issue. Mr Bath claimed there had been no correspondence since Cr Kerridge took office and said Ms Hornery "made a decision in October last year" that she "wanted to communicate exclusively" with the lord mayor on operational issues. "The only emails that I've received from the state member for Wallsend since the election have been to say that she will not meet with me, she will not meet with council staff, she wants to meet exclusively with you," Mr Bath said. "I can't allow the council to think that I'm not responding to the state member for Wallsend, because I am bending over backwards to try and communicate with her." Cr Kerridge described himself as the "meat in the sandwich". "We need to work on it," he said. Ms Hornery took to Facebook on Wednesday to blast Mr Bath for claims he made at the council meeting. "Mr Bath stated that there is no correspondence from me to him relating to the Wallsend Library that has not been responded to," she said. "I can establish that I did indeed write to Mr Bath on 8 November 2024, and the CEO did not respond." Ms Hornery said the letter to Mr Bath was a "sincere representation" on behalf of a Wallsend constituent. Community members are urged to report suspicious activity to local police or Crime Stoppers on 1800 333 000 or call Triple Zero in an emergency.
Sydney Morning Herald
4 hours ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
‘A missed opportunity': West Australians react to the state budget
Every line item in Labor's ninth consecutive budget handed down on Thursday will have a real impact on West Australians. The reactions to those items have been steadily flowing in, in the aftermath of the budget's release on Thursday afternoon, and while some are happy with the results others are furious. Laura West, 44, is living on a carer's pension as she looks after her 11-year-old daughter with complex health issues full-time. 'We've ended up with another big billion-dollar surplus, and it's actually quite devastating for families like mine, who could be helped by redirecting that money to provide some assistance,' she said. 'I scrimp and save as much as I can to meet our needs ... but it's a real struggle. Families like ours who are vulnerable and depended on an income support payment – our standard of living is decreasing. 'I feel like the cost of living crisis is increasing, and we are a wealthy state. That should not be the case.' Casey Pateman, 39, is also struggling with the cost of living. She used to work in Kalgoorlie in the mining industry until she decided to move to Perth five years ago, and that was when things changed. As cost of living went up, Pateman became homeless and was living out of her car with her children.
