Nurul Izzah's victory may fuel family dynasty narrative, analyst warns
PETALING JAYA : The narrative surrounding Nurul Izzah Anwar's rise to PKR's No 2 spot must be tempered to counter claims about her family's grip on the party, an analyst said.
Universiti Malaya's Awang Azman Pawi said if Nurul Izzah's camp fails to manage and explain the situation properly, she risks losing PKR's ideological diehards and younger supporters.
'If not handled inclusively, this victory could also cause internal splits or dissatisfaction among other leaders, including Rafizi Ramli's supporters, thereby weakening the party from within,' he told FMT.
Nurul Izzah won by a landslide in a two-way fight with incumbent Rafizi for the PKR deputy presidency on Friday.
According to the party election committee, she garnered a total of 9,803 votes, or 71.7%, while Rafizi obtained 3,866 votes.
Awang Azman said Nurul Izzah's win was not a personal victory, but a reflection of a trend within PKR which was trying to balance idealism and pragmatism of power.
'For PKR, this is an opportunity to show that familial ties do not necessarily equate to nepotism. Instead it could represent a blend of tradition and modernity, and a form of strategic unity.
'However, this must be managed wisely and inclusively ahead of the next general election,' he said.
University of Tasmania's James Chin said Rafizi should refrain from making any disruptive moves for now, as he plays a crucial role in holding the government together.
'I hope Rafizi will not leave PKR, will not throw tantrums and choose to remain in the Cabinet. I hope they can accommodate him. Because I think over the long term, Rafizi and Nurul Izzah make a good team, and will be PKR's strength,' he said.
Merdeka Center's Ibrahim Suffian agreed that the Rafizi-Nurul Izzah combination would prepare PKR well for the next general election.
He said Rafizi's polling numbers showed he has significant support from the grassroots, and that this is not the end of the road for the economy minister.
As for Nurul Izzah, he said, her win was about the continuity of Anwar's vision for the party and the government that he currently leads.
'It will also mean that she will have a prominent role in preparing the party for the general election and making up for the shortfalls that have dogged it in the past.
'While Anwar will lead the government, she will be strengthening the party in clear coordination with him,' he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Focus Malaysia
10 minutes ago
- Focus Malaysia
Not Ismail Sabri, not KJ: So who has Rafizi offended? Can PKR still be saved?
Editor's Note: Pandan MP Datuk Seri Rafizi Ramli has described the latest attempt by his detractors to link the recent syringe attack on his son to PM9 Datuk Seri Ismail Sabri Yaakob and former health minister Khairy Jamaluddin (KJ) as a malicious attempt to divert attention. Instead, Rafizi confirmed that a week before the attack, he had met with a whistleblower regarding a scandal that he was investigating. 'The information provided is about Datuk Seri Farhash Wafa Salvador, the former political secretary to Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim and the dealings of his companies,' he exposed on his latest Facebook post. 'It has nothing to do with DS Ismail Sabri, KJ or any other politicians. I've contacted DS Ismail Sabri and fully support his decision to file a police report regarding this piece of false news.' MANY people shook their heads in dismay, saying this is worse than the underworld, even worse than loan sharks. I'm referring to the incident where Datuk Seri Rafizi Ramli's young son was injected with a syringe threatening AIDS – vicious and despicable! When in conflict, the underworld and rivals usually try to resolve matters through negotiation. If talks fail, they may issue threats – but they do not target children. Loan sharks, when collecting debts, also go after the debtor. The harsher ones may harass family members – splashing paint, pasting threatening notices – but I have never heard of injecting a child with a syringe. As the saying goes, even thieves have their code of conduct. Bad people too have a bottom line. Otherwise, they're not human. But Rafizi's young son was dragged out of a car in broad daylight by helmeted masked men and injected with an unknown liquid from a syringe. After that, Rafizi's wife received a text message warning her to 'keep quiet or else, AIDS,' followed by three syringe emojis. Hogh-profile exposes It has yet to be confirmed whether the liquid contained HIV but the shadow of fear will haunt the child and his family for a long time, perhaps for life. This is no ordinary crime. Almost everyone believes it is politically related. The masked men were likely hired thugs. Behind them, there could be be someone else with a specific motive – to intimidate and warn Rafizi through this act. Since resigning as a minister, Rafizi has become one of the boldest political voices. He criticises government policies, exposes cases of abuse of power and corruption, even revealing names. He reveals the failures and wrongdoings of the unity government for all to see and also exposes dirty dealings within PKR to the public. Because of Rafizi's revelations, some people's political-business connections have been forced into the spotlight, making them retreat temporarily where their interests were affected. For that, they hate him to the core. Even when PKR was still in the opposition, Rafizi already had bitter enemies within the party. PKR at the lowest ebb And I'm not referring to Datuk Seri Mohamed Azmin Ali, Datuk Seri Saifuddin Nasution Ismail or Nurul Izzah Anwar. When PKR came to power, conflicts grew worse and irreconcilable. Rafizi and his faction later lost in the party elections and it is said that certain hidden manoeuvres played a role. Rafizi himself suspects his son's assault is linked to information he recently obtained from a whistleblower – the very person he has been exposing relentlessly these past two months. Rafizi can give up his position and resign voluntarily; he has also faced court cases before and is unafraid of prison. He cannot be silenced, cannot be bought over and cannot be intimidated. Since his enemies couldn't deal with him, they turned their attacks toward his family. This is the lowest of the low – something one might expect only in lawless countries ruled by gangs and drug cartels. Yet it has now happened in Malaysia, showing how degraded our politics has become. What's worse, it involves PKR – a party that claims to stand for justice and fairness and yet is riddled with dirty power struggles. As the party's founder and president Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim waves the banner of reformation and anti-corruption yet has failed to build a disciplined party. PKR is perpetually plagued by in-fighting and factionalism with power abused for personal gain. This is Anwar's inescapable responsibility. Anwar's way of appointing people is often misguided, placing trust in the wrong individuals. This has led to endless scandals, turned PKR into a liability, and fuelled factional rivalries – dragging what was once a promising party into chaos and decline. Whether PKR can still be saved depends largely on how Anwar handles this incident. He has the authority to direct the police to fully pursue and arrest the attackers, and to investigate the masterminds behind them. He also has limited time left to clean up corruption within PKR, build an honest and transparent team and lead the party on a new path. If not, PKR has no future. It will fail by voters and suffer a humiliating defeat. Anwar will not have a second term. – Aug 20, 2025 Tay Tian Yan is deputy chief editor of Sin Chew Daily. This opinion editorial first appeared in MySinchew which is the EWnglish version of the Sin Chew Daily's news portal. The views expressed are solely of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Focus Malaysia.
Malay Mail
10 minutes ago
- Malay Mail
Gobind: Malaysia in final stages of National AI Action Plan, to ensure transparency, privacy, and accountability
KUALA LUMPUR, Aug 20 — Digital Minister Gobind Singh Deo today said Malaysia is in the final stages of finalising the National Artificial Intelligence (AI) Action Plan, which aims to establish a clear governance framework while balancing security and privacy concerns. He said the plan is built on three core principles which are ensuring AI accountability and transparency, embedding privacy and security from the design stage, and maintaining human oversight to prevent errors. 'The first is transparency and accountability, ensuring that all AI models are auditable and clearly identify who is responsible in cases of misuse or breaches,' he told the Dewan Rakyat here. 'The second principle is privacy and security-by-design, mandating that personal data protection and system security are embedded from the algorithm and system design stage, rather than being added as an afterthought. 'The third is human-in-the-loop control, recognising that AI cannot yet operate autonomously, and human oversight is necessary to prevent critical errors, discrimination, and bias,' he added, Gobind was responding to a question from Sri Aman MP Datuk Seri Doris Sophia Anak Brodi who asked about how Malaysia ensures AI in cybersecurity adheres to ethical and privacy principles while balancing security and individual freedom. He also said the plan is developed collaboratively, considering existing and ongoing government initiatives, including the Personal Data Protection Act 2010 (Act 709) and the Cybersecurity Act 2024 (Act 854). Addressing Doris Sophia's supplementary question on control mechanisms or 'kill switch' measures for cybersecurity AI, Gobind said Malaysia is preparing for emerging technological challenges by establishing structures to identify and mitigate risks. He said the government is establishing structures to identify and address emerging AI risks, monitor technological developments, enforce existing laws through the National AI Office and Data Committee, and implement the Digital Trust and Data Safety Strategy planned for 2026–2030.
Malay Mail
10 minutes ago
- Malay Mail
Anti-Bullying Act proposal to go to Cabinet soon, Azalina says amid vague definition of offence and penalties
KUALA LUMPUR, Aug 20 — The proposal to draft an Anti-Bullying Act is expected to be tabled at a Cabinet meeting soon, said Minister in the Prime Minister's Department (Law and Institutional Reform) Datuk Seri Azalina Othman Said. She said discussions at the policy level are crucial, as each relevant ministry, such as the Ministry of Women, Family and Community Development (KPWKM), the Education Ministry (MoE), the Higher Education Ministry (MoHE), and the Ministry of National Unity may have their views regarding the enforcement aspects of the law. 'After each ministry submits its feedback, the Legal Affairs Division (BHEUU) will conduct a detailed study and engagement sessions before the matter is brought to the policy level and subsequently to Parliament,' she said. She was speaking at the ASEAN Law Forum 2025 themed 'Empowering Access to Justice in the ASEAN Economic Community: Bridging Legal Cooperation for Inclusive Growth in the Digital Era' at the Kuala Lumpur Convention Centre today. Azalina said the main issue currently is the absence of a specific definition of bullying or penalties for such offences under existing legal provisions. She said bullying-related cases are currently dealt with under various laws including the Online Safety Act, the Anti-Sexual Harassment Act, labour laws as well as several provisions under the Penal Code. As such, BHEUU will soon issue a list of Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) to clarify the differences between the Penal Code and the Child Act, to avoid confusion among the public. 'Many misunderstand… children can still be charged under criminal law. However, the procedure is different. For example, they cannot be tried in an open court. 'I want to give assurance that wrong is still wrong. The law applies to everyone, whether children or adults,' she said. Azalina also said that MoE has outlined comprehensive procedures in addressing bullying cases in schools through a detailed guideline document. 'I've seen the book, it's quite thick and it provides detailed, step-by-step instructions on what to do and how to resolve cases,' she said. Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim, at the Finance Ministry's Monthly Assembly in Putrajaya earlier today, said the proposal to establish a tribunal on bullying cases involving students and children will also be brought to the Cabinet meeting. The three-day ASEAN Law Forum 2025 gathered 58 speakers and moderators in 15 sessions, with over 300 participants from ASEAN and international bodies discussing various topics, including alternative dispute resolution, commercial law reform and human rights in the digital era. Among those present were Deputy Prime Minister Datuk Seri Fadillah Yusof, Deputy Minister in the Prime Minister's Department (Law and Institutional Reform) M. Kulasegaran, Secretary of the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law (UNCITRAL) Anna Joubin-Bret, Timor-Leste's Justice Minister Sérgio de Jesus Fernandes da Costa Hornai and Laos' Deputy Justice Minister Ketsana Phommachanh.
