No respite for Google; HC rejects plea against billing policy lawsuit
Google India
Pvt Ltd and Google India Digital Services Pvt Ltd,
Madras high court
dismissed their request to reject a plaint moved by Textbook Edu Solutions Pvt Ltd challenging Google's new user choice billing policy.
The policy required all app developers to use its Google Play Billing System (GPBS) for all transactions, including paid app downloads and in-app purchases.
The developers were charged a commission between 13% and 15%.
Though the high court dismissed 13 such suits moved against Google in the past, Justice Senthilkumar Ramamoorthy refused to reject the suit moved by Textbook Edu on the ground that it does not relate to the superior bargaining position of Google but to the bilateral contracts between the parties.
Rejecting the contention of Google that the issue falls under the Competition Commission of India (CCI), the court said, "…in the present suit, the plaintiff has only requested relief in relation to the specific bilateral contracts between the parties.
Such in personam disputes cannot be adjudicated by the CCI."
As to the argument of Google that the plaint does not disclose a cause of action, the court said, "While deciding whether a plaint discloses a cause of action, it is unnecessary to examine whether the plaintiff would be in a position to establish all elements of the cause of action so as to obtain the relief sought in the suit."
It is sufficient if the averments in the plaint disclose a cause of action and the sustainability thereof is not germane at this stage, the judge added.
Follow more information on
Air India plane crash in Ahmedabad here
. Get
real-time live updates
on rescue operations and check
full list of passengers onboard AI 171
.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
an hour ago
- The Hindu
Sastra Deemed University in Thanjavur emerges winner of moot court contest
Sastra Deemed University, Thanjavur, has emerged winner of the second All India Moot Court competition, 2025, hosted by the Dr. Ambedkar Government Law College in Puducherry. The winners took home a prize money of ₹50,000. At the conclusion of the final round of the three-day event on Sunday, the School of Excellence of Law, Tamil Nadu Dr. Ambedkar Law University (TNDALU), Chennai finished runners with a prize of ₹25,000. The award for Best Male Counsel (₹10,000) went to Akhilesh of O.P. Jindal Global University, and Best Female Counsel (₹10,000) to R. Sripradha of Crescent School of Law, Chennai. The Best Research award (₹5,000) was given to S. Naveena of Government Law College, Kozhikode and the Best Memorial prize was bagged by Government Law College, Coimbatore. In all, 69 teams from institutions across the country competed in the moot court competition on Consumer Law, organised under the aegis of the Department of Consumer Affairs, Ministry of Consumer Affairs, Food and Public Distribution, Government of India. Justice G.R. Swaminathan, Judge, Madras High Court and Justice R. Surbamanian, former Judge, Madras High Court, Prof. Ashok R. Patil, Vice-Chancellor, National University of Study and Research in Law, Ranchi, and Prof. S. Srinivasan, Principal, Dr. Ambedkar Government Law College, Puducherry gave away the prizes. They also served as the jury for the finals that took place on Sunday in the moot court hall of the institution. A group of judicial officers, academicians and senior advocates, adjudicated the various rounds of the competition. Kalapet MLA P.M.L. Kalyanasundaram was present.
Hans India
3 hours ago
- Hans India
Grok Imagine AI Now Free for Android: Musk's Tool Turns Text and Photos into Creative Images and Videos
Elon Musk's AI venture, Grok, has expanded free access to its Imagine feature for Android users, making it easier than ever to create AI-generated images and videos without spending a dime—at least for now. The feature, already free for iOS users, is available for a limited time, Musk confirmed in a post on X. The Imagine tool allows users to transform simple text prompts—typed or spoken—into high-quality photos or short videos. For those who prefer visuals as a starting point, the feature also supports uploading still images that can be enhanced or animated using AI. This versatility has already proven popular, with Musk claiming over 44 million images generated through the platform and numbers rising rapidly. By offering this feature without cost, Grok steps directly into competition with AI creation tools from OpenAI's ChatGPT and Google's Gemini. While those platforms already provide image and video generation capabilities, Musk's Imagine aims to stand out with its seamless interactivity and creative flexibility. How to Get Started with Grok Imagine Using Imagine is simple: Download the Grok app from the Play Store (Android) or App Store (iOS). Open the app and select 'Imagine' from the top menu. Type or speak your prompt for the AI to generate an image. Alternatively, upload a photo and let Grok's AI enhance or customise it. From Stills to Motion in Seconds One standout feature of Imagine is its ability to convert still images into short videos with just a few taps. After generating or uploading an image, users can select the 'Make video' option and choose from four animation styles: Normal, Fun, Custom, and the more daring Spicy mode. This quick-turnaround motion generation appeals to content creators who want to produce shareable animations without spending hours on editing. Grok vs ChatGPT and Google Gemini This expansion follows the July launch of Grok 4, which Musk's xAI described as 'the world's most powerful AI model' before OpenAI's GPT-5 entered the scene. GPT-5 has been touted for its reduced hallucinations—an accuracy challenge both companies are actively addressing. Musk isn't stopping there. He has already teased the arrival of Grok 5 before the end of 2025, promising it will be 'crushingly good.' The free rollout of Imagine could help Grok attract a larger user base ahead of that milestone, especially as more people test its creative tools. With AI-powered content creation becoming increasingly competitive, Grok's easy-to-use interface and combined image-video generation put it in a strong position. For now, Android and iOS users can take advantage of the free window to explore just how far a few words—or a single image—can go in the hands of Grok's AI.
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
3 hours ago
- Business Standard
House panel backs ex-ante regulation for DCB but calls for nuanced approach
In its report on the evolving role of the Competition Commission of India (CCI), tabled in the Lok Sabha on Monday, the parliamentary panel on finance backed the need to have an ex-ante regulatory framework to address complexities such as self-preferencing and predatory pricing while taking a nuanced approach in adopting the Digital Competition Bill (DCB). The committee has also called for a review of the current deal value threshold so that acquisitions of micro, small and medium enterprises (MSMEs) by larger corporations do not escape regulatory scrutiny. Stressing that the ex-post framework of the present Competition Act was ill-equipped to handle the rapid concentration of power in digital markets, the panel said, 'To address stakeholder concerns, the committee recommends that the (corporate affairs) ministry refine the DCB's thresholds and designation mechanisms to prevent inadvertent capturing of fast-growing domestic firms.' The observations of the committee come at a time when the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA) is launching a market study into the impact of ex-ante regulations, proposed in the draft DCB on the domestic market. MCA secretary Dipti Gaur Mukherjee told the committee, '...The whole issue of digital markets and the best way forward is something which is evolving and the right balance there is very important.' Mukherjee said that the government does not want to harm the domestic industry and the market study being commissioned by the MCA could come up with concrete solutions that will help the government do a balancing act. 'In certain positions, our domestic market has very unique features like the entire quick commerce thing, which is very, very homegrown in India. It is not there in the international arena,' the secretary said. The MCA in 2023 had constituted a committee on digital competition law, which had submitted a draft Bill on Digital Competition Law, proposing an ex-ante regulatory framework. Some of the key concerns of stakeholders on the draft Bill are in relation to thresholds for systemically significant digital enterprises, no provision for rebutting presumption of designation based on quantitative thresholds, and definition of core digital services, among others. The parliamentary panel's report stressed the urgency for the CCI to remain agile and continuously adapt its tools and strategies to keep pace with rapid technological advancements, and ensure effective competition law enforcement in the evolving digital landscape. In order to address the issue of internal resources, the MCA secretary told the committee about CCI's proposal for cadre restructuring for the creation of 55 additional posts in the Commission. The report also highlighted that as of April 30, 2025, out of a total CCI-imposed penalty of ₹20,350.46 crore, ₹18,512.28 crore has been either stayed or dismissed by appellate courts. The antitrust watchdog, however, has managed to realise 99.2 per cent of the remaining amount. 'This data indicates that while the CCI is effective at collecting penalties that are not under litigation, its overall enforcement is significantly undermined by legal challenges,' the committee report said, urging the CCI to expand its sector-specific market studies into emerging areas where new business models are disrupting traditional competition dynamics.
