Tesla ordered by Florida jury to pay US$243m in fatal Autopilot crash
The verdict is a rare win for victims of accidents involving Autopilot. Musk has been pushing to rapidly expand Tesla's recently launched robotaxi business based on an advanced version of its driver assistance software.
Tesla shares fell 1.8 per cent yesterday, and are down 25 per cent this year.
Jurors in Miami federal court awarded the estate of Naibel Benavides Leon, as well as her former boyfriend Dillon Angulo, US$129 million in compensatory damages plus US$200 million in punitive damages, according to a verdict sheet.
Tesla was held liable for 33 per cent of the compensatory damages, or US$42.6 million.
Jurors found the driver George McGee liable for 67 per cent, but he was not a defendant and will not have to pay his share.
'Tesla designed Autopilot only for controlled-access highways yet deliberately chose not to restrict drivers from using it elsewhere, alongside Elon Musk telling the world Autopilot drove better than humans,' Brett Schreiber, a lawyer for the plaintiffs, said in a statement.
'Today's verdict represents justice for Naibel's tragic death and Dillon's lifelong injuries,' he added.
Tesla said it will appeal.
'Today's verdict is wrong and only works to set back automotive safety and jeopardize Tesla's and the entire industry's efforts to develop and implement life-saving technology,' the company said.
The plaintiffs had sought US$345 million of damages. Their lawyers said the trial was the first involving the wrongful death of a third party resulting from Autopilot.
Impact on future cases
Tesla has faced many similar lawsuits over its vehicles' self-driving capabilities, but they have been resolved or dismissed without getting to trial.
In June, a judge rejected Tesla's bid to dismiss the Florida case. Experts said Friday's verdict may spur more lawsuits, and could make future settlements more costly.
'It's a big deal,' said Alex Lemann, a law professor at Marquette University. 'This is the first time that Tesla has been hit with a judgment in one of the many, many fatalities that have happened as a result of its Autopilot technology.'
The verdict could also impede efforts by Musk, the world's richest person, to convince investors that Tesla can become a leader in so-called autonomous driving for private vehicles as well as robotaxis it plans to start producing next year.
As Tesla's electric vehicle sales fall, much of its nearly US$1 trillion market value hinges on Musk's ability to pivot the company into robotics and artificial intelligence.
Driver's role
The trial concerned an April 25, 2019 incident where George McGee drove his 2019 Model S at about 62 mph (100 kph) through an intersection into the victims' parked Chevrolet Tahoe as they were standing beside it on a shoulder.
McGee had reached down to pick up a cellphone he dropped on his car's floorboard and allegedly received no alerts as he ran a stop sign and stop light before hitting the victims' SUV.
Benavides Leon was allegedly thrown 75 feet (23 metres) to her death, while Angulo suffered serious injuries.
'We have a driver who was acting less than perfectly, and yet the jury still found Tesla contributed to the crash,' said Philip Koopman, a Carnegie Mellon University engineering professor and expert in autonomous technology.
'The only way the jury could have possibly ruled against Tesla was by finding a defect with the Autopilot software,' he added. 'That's a big deal.'
Tesla, in its statement, said McGee was entirely at fault.
'To be clear, no car in 2019, and none today, would have prevented this crash,' the company said. 'This was never about Autopilot; it was a fiction concocted by plaintiffs' lawyers blaming the car when the driver - from day one - admitted and accepted responsibility.' — Reuters
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Free Malaysia Today
3 hours ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Wall Street futures stabilise after Friday's rout
US S&P 500 E-minis were up 36.75 points, or 0.59% and Nasdaq 100 E-minis were up 177.5 points, or 0.78%. (AP pic) NEW YORK : Wall Street futures rebounded from last week's rout today, as hopes for steeper Federal Reserve (Fed) rate cuts surged after a surprisingly weak jobs report. A dismal US jobs report sent the S&P 500 tumbling to its steepest intraday loss in more than two months on Friday, with downward revisions for May and June compounding the blow. The bleak data did not just trigger the market selloff – it also sparked a dramatic rethink of the Fed's rate path. According to the CME FedWatch tool, traders now see an 85% chance of a September rate cut, up from just over 63% a week ago, as signs of a faltering labour market mount. By this year-end, markets are betting on at least two quarter-point cuts, about 60 basis points – a prospect that helped steady Wall Street in the aftermath. At 6.57am, US S&P 500 E-minis were up 36.75 points, or 0.59%, Nasdaq 100 E-minis were up 177.5 points, or 0.78% and Dow E-minis were up 238 points, or 0.54% The central bank's decision to keep rates unchanged last week drew immediate criticism from President Donald Trump, who has repeatedly threatened to fire chair Jerome Powell, arguing that rates should be much lower than they are. Adding to the intrigue, the surprise resignation of Fed governor Adriana Kugler has handed Trump an earlier-than-expected opportunity to reshape the central bank's leadership. 'It is expected that whoever Trump announces to replace the governor could then become the new chair when current chair Powell vacates his position next May,' Kathleen Brooks, research director at XTB, said in a note. In premarket trading, Tesla rose 1.8% after granting CEO Elon Musk 96 million shares worth about US$29 billion. Investor sentiment soured further last week as new US tariffs kicked in on dozens of trading partners and Trump signed executive orders slapping fresh import duties on countries like Canada, Brazil, India, and Taiwan despite their efforts to negotiate better terms. US factory orders data for June is due at 10am. Tomorrow's business activity report and Thursday's jobless claims figures are the only other key economic indicators in this data-light week. Atlanta Fed president Raphael Bostic will speak later in the week. After a big week for Big Tech earnings, companies from various sectors including Palantir, Eli Lilly, and Disney will report this week. Of the 330 S&P 500 companies that have reported earnings as of Friday, 80.6% have surpassed analyst expectations, the highest beat rate since the third quarter of 2023, according to data compiled by LSEG. Among early movers, Joby Aviation rose 5.3% after Bloomberg News reported that the company was exploring the acquisition of helicopter ride-share operator Blade Air Mobility. Blade Air's shares surged 16.4%. Chemours rises after reaching an agreement with New Jersey to resolve all environmental claims.
Free Malaysia Today
3 hours ago
- Free Malaysia Today
EU to suspend US tariff counter-measures for 6 months
US President Donald Trump set tariffs on most EU goods at 15% last week. (EPA Images pic) BRUSSELS : The European Union will suspend its two packages of counter-measures to US tariffs for six months following a deal with US President Donald Trump, a commission spokesman said today. The EU-US agreement leaves many questions open, including tariff rates on spirits, and Trump's executive order last week setting tariffs on most EU goods at 15% did not include carve-outs such as for cars and car parts. EU officials have said they expect more executive orders to follow soon. 'The EU continues to work with the US to finalise a joint statement, as agreed on July 27,' the spokesman said in a statement. 'With these objectives in mind, the commission will take the necessary steps to suspend by six months the EU's counter-measures against the US, which were due to enter into force on Aug 7.' The retaliatory tariffs are in two parts: one in response to US steel and aluminium duties, and the other to Trump's baseline and car tariffs.
Free Malaysia Today
3 hours ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Tesla approves US$29bil in shares to Musk as court case rumbles on
Tesla chief executive Elon Musk is seeking to prevent a possible ouster by activist shareholders. (AFP pic) WASHINGTON : Electric vehicle maker Tesla handed its chief executive Elon Musk a US$29 billion pay package today, as a lengthy legal battle over his compensation winds on. The company said in a statement it will award an 'interim' distribution of 96 million Tesla shares to Musk as it 'intends to compensate its CEO for his future services commensurate with his contributions to our company and shareholders'. 'We have recommended this award as a first step, 'good faith' payment,' it added when announcing the board's approval of granting new shares to Musk. 'Retaining Elon is more important than ever before.' The massive pay package comes eight months after the judge in a Delaware court rejected Musk's even larger US$55.8 billion compensation package at Tesla, denying an attempt to restore the pay deal through a shareholder vote. In an initial decision in early 2024, the court struck down the package as excessive and unfair to shareholders. Musk has appealed the ruling. The new package would boost Musk's roughly 13% stake in the company, at a time when he seeks to prevent a possible ouster by activist shareholders. Musk would be required to forfeit the new compensation package should the appeals court rule in his favour and grant him the full 2018 compensation, which at the time was valued at US$55.8 billion. The new payout is sure to fuel concerns about the compensation for Musk, already the world's richest man, and whether the Tesla board is placing a sufficient check on the company's chief executive. The statement posted on Tesla's X account came in the form of a letter to shareholders written by Robyn Denholm and Kathleen Wilson-Thompson, the two members of the board's special committee addressing the Musk compensation.
