Nicola Sturgeon hints she could debate JK Rowling over trans rights controversy
She was first minister when the Scottish Government introduced legislation – which was eventually blocked by Westminster – which would have given transgender people the right to self-identify into their preferred gender.
Despite the furious row that erupted over the controversial policy – which critics claimed would allow biological men to access women-only spaces – Ms Sturgeon declared she would 'always stand up for rights, for equality, for minority rights'.
She said she believes 'forces on the far right' have sought to 'weaponise' the issue to seek to 'push back on rights more generally, whether those are gay rights, minority rights, women's rights actually'.
Ms Sturgeon spoke out on the issue as she appeared on BBC Breakfast as her memoir, titled Frankly, was published.
She accepted there are 'many, many people' who disagreed with her on the issue of gender reforms, adding 'probably the majority' of her opponents 'come from a genuine place'.
But Ms Sturgeon said: 'There are also people – and I don't know how anybody can deny this – forces on the far right who have weaponised this issue, who want to use the trans issue to push back on rights more generally, whether those are gay rights, minority rights, women's rights actually.'
She told how she had come in for 'probably the most horrific abuse on this issue' than on any other topic, with the former first minister adding some of the abuse had been 'deeply misogynistic'.
She added: 'There's some people in this debate who definitely seem to spend a lot more time thinking about me than I spend thinking about them.
Thank you for your many kind offers, of which there were a considerable amount. Watch my website for my review of 'Frankly', the memoir of Scotland's (checks notes) most persecuted, misunderstood, self-critical, open-to-debate, feminist-to-her-fingertips ex-First Minister. https://t.co/fCz1fD6QiJ
— J.K. Rowling (@jk_rowling) August 12, 2025
'But I will always stand up for rights, for equality, for minority rights.
'There have been many times in my political career when I would have made my own life easier by staying silent on some things.
'I don't want to be that person, I want to stand up for things I believe in.'
Asked if she would debate Rowling, Ms Sturgeon said: 'I will debate with many people, but I don't think JK Rowling would be willing to do that.
'But who knows, maybe she would.'
She added: 'One of the things my critics cannot say about me is I don't debate with people – I have probably done more debates than any other leader in the UK, I will debate with anybody.'
Rowling, meanwhile, said on X – formerly known as Twitter – that she would review Frankly on her website, describing the book as being 'the memoir of Scotland's (checks notes) most persecuted, misunderstood, self-critical, open-to-debate, feminist-to-her-fingertips ex-first minister'.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scotsman
2 hours ago
- Scotsman
JK Rowling claims Sturgeon created a 'dystopian nightmare' in foul-mouthed review of Frankly
JK Rowling has published a review of Nicola Sturgeon's Frankly - and the Harry Potter author has not held back Sign up to our Politics newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... JK Rowling has called Nicola Sturgeon a 'f**kwit' as she accused the former First Minister of creating a 'dystopian nightmare' for women. The Harry Potter author published a review of Sturgeon's memoir, Frankly, on her own website, saying the politician's push for gender recognition reform had led to 'real, lasting harm' for women. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad In blunt language, she said the former SNP leader had looked like a 'complete f**kwit' when asked directly whether the transgender double rapist Isla Bryson is a man or a woman. Bryson, who had been born Adam Graham, was held and assessed in a women's prison before being moved to the male prison estate. 'Bryson, a convicted double rapist, had decided he was a woman and would rather be incarcerated with the sex against which he'd already committed the most male of crimes,' Ms Rowling writes in her review. 'When asked on television whether bald, blonde wig-wearing Bryson was a man or a woman, the first minister, whose composure and articulacy under fire had, for years, been her most potent political asset, made herself look – and forgive me for employing a PR term here – a complete f**kwit.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The author then suggests Ms Sturgeon tries in her memoir to shift the blame for the Isla Bryson furore to other people. 'Of course, the blame for her looking like a complete f**kwit lies with others,' she adds. 'Nobody had warned [Sturgeon] about Bryson, you see. 'She apparently had no idea that the very thing feminists had warned her was likely to happen, and had already happened – trans-identified man Katie Dolotowski had already sexually assaulted a ten-year-old girl in a public bathroom, and served his time in a women's prison in Scotland – would happen again. 'She explains in Frankly that she was worried about the impact it would have on trans people if she denied Bryson was a woman.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Despite copies of Frankly going on sale in Waterstones earlier in the week, Ms Sturgeon officially launched her book at the Edinburgh International Book Festival with an interview by the veteran broadcaster Kirsty Wark. During the interview, Ms Sturgeon said the gender critical feminist movement, which argued against gender recognition reform, had been 'hijacked' by the 'soft underbelly of prejudice'. Ms Rowling considers the question of whether Frankly is a 'good read' and says Ms Sturgeon lacks humour and adds that the book 'reads like a PR statement that's been through sixteen drafts.'
Daily Record
4 hours ago
- Daily Record
JK Rowling rips into Nicola Sturgeon's memoir in brutal foul mouthed review
JK Rowling has published a scathing review of Nicola Sturgeon's memoir, Frankly, on her website. JK Rowling has ripped into Nicola Sturgeon's memoir, branding her 'flat out Trumpian' in the trans rights debate. The Harry Potter author has released a scathing review of Nicola Sturgeon's new book 'Frankly', calling her a 'f***kwit', and saying that she has "caused real, lasting harm" in the trans debate. She accused the former First Minister of "encouraging a culture in which women have been silenced, shamed, persecuted and placed in situations that are degrading and unsafe, all for not subscribing to her own luxury beliefs". Rowling accuses Sturgeon of being 'flat out Trumpian in her shameless denial of reality and hard facts'. She added: " Sturgeon hasn't been remotely humbled by the Supreme Court ruling that proved her government was forcing a misinterpretation of the UK-wide Equality Act on Scotland, one that robbed women of many single sex spaces and of their very existence as a definable class with rights protected in law. "She remains stubbornly wedded to her belief that it is possible to let some men into women's spaces on the men's say so, without letting any man who fancies it come inside. She denies there are any risks to a policy of gender self-identification. "She can't imagine any male predator capitalising on such policies, in spite of the fact that it has, demonstrably, happened many times." In a more person attack, Rowling hit out at some of Sturgeon's more personal reflections, often comparing her to Twilight heroin Bella Swan. She wrote: "Just as Bella's propensity for accidents doesn't stop her riding motorcycles, jumping off cliffs or choosing to meet evil vampires for a spot of unarmed combat, Sturgeon's alleged imposter syndrome and constant crises of confidence don't prevent her admitting to 'the raw talent I had for politics', or that 'I certainly wasn't lacking in ability', that 'far from being the weak link, I was seemingly the star attraction', 'it all added to the sense that I had the Midas touch' or that 'there is no doubt that I was a massive electoral asset.'"
Scottish Sun
4 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
JK Rowling brands Nicola Sturgeon a ‘complete f**kwit' in scathing review of her memoir
She also went after her time in office Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) JK Rowling branded Nicola Sturgeon a f***wit over her gender ID views in a scathing review of her memoir. The former First Minister's memoir, Frankly, was launched today and is packed full of personal admissions and bombshells from some of the most infamous moments in her political career. Sign up for the Politics newsletter Sign up 3 JK Rowling launched a scathing attack on the former First Minister Credit: EPA 3 3 Frankly contains a number of bombshells from Ms Sturgeon's career Credit: Alamy Harry Potter author JK penned her own review of the book which included a foul-mouthed feedback about Ms Sturgeon's time in office. Ms Rowling - a vocal critic of Ms Sturgeon over her gender self-ID bid - delivered a furious takedown of Ms Sturgeon over the scandal of male-bodied trans double-rapist Isla Bryson, previously known as Adam Graham, being sent to Cornton Vale prison in January 2023. Ms Sturgeon famously refused to say Bryson was male or female in a car-crash press conference, which came weeks before she quit as First Minister. The author wrote in her review: 'Bryson, a convicted double rapist, had decided he was a woman and would rather be incarcerated with the sex against which he'd already committed the most male of crimes. 'When asked on television whether bald, blonde wig-wearing Bryson was a man or a woman, the First Minister, whose composure and articulacy under fire had, for years, been her most potent political asset, made herself look – and forgive me for employing a PR term here – a complete f***wit.' Ms Rowling said Ms Sturgeon had made out that the 'the blame for her looking like a complete f***wit lies with others.' Raising another high-profile Scottish case, she said: 'Nobody had warned her about Bryson, you see. "She apparently had no idea that the very thing feminists had warned her was likely to happen, and had already happened – trans-identified man Katie Dolotowski had already sexually assaulted a ten-year-old girl in a public bathroom, and served his time in a women's prison in Scotland – would happen again. 'She explains in Frankly that she was worried about the impact it would have on trans people if she denied Bryson was a woman. 'Therein lies the problem in the smallest of nutshells. If you're prepared to accept the foundational falsehood that some men are women, you'll inevitably find yourself panicking like a pheasant caught in headlights one day, because to admit that even a single man who says he's a woman isn't means the whole edifice of gender self-ID collapses.' Five of the biggest BOMBSHELL moments from Nicola Sturgeon's new memoir Ms Rowling widened her criticism of the ex First Minister with a rundown on subjects not focused on in the memoir, called Frankly. Following praise for the book from commentators south of the border, Ms Rowling scornfully mentioned 'liberal London' types who also hailed her pandemic performance. Ms Rowling wrote: 'Her English fans can't be expected to know about every single cluster**** over which the supposedly competent Sturgeon presided, and they certainly won't find out about them from Frankly. 'The mysteriously vanished government WhatsApp messages from the pandemic, the tanking educational outcomes, the CalMac Ferry disaster, the disappearance of a half a million pounds of her own supporters' money that was supposedly ringfenced for a new independence referendum: you'll search in vain for candid accounts of these in Frankly; indeed, most aren't mentioned at all. 'Perhaps the most disgraceful omission – and I'll admit to a personal interest here, because I'm married to a doctor who used to run a methadone clinic, so saw the national scandal up close – is the fact that Scotland continues to lead the whole of Europe in drug deaths.' Ms Rowling's review was titled "The Twilight of Nicola Sturgeon" and poked fun at Ms Sturgeon with a comparison between her and Bella Swan, the heroine of Twilight book and movie series. She says they are borth "shy, awkward, bookish girls" who move to "small, rainswept towns" - one called Forks, one Dreghorn in Ayrshire. Ms Rowling quotes a line saying "I don't yet realise it but in this moment the course of my life will be set. Everything that has gone before has been leading me here". And she adds: "These are Sturgeon's words, but they could just as easily be Bella Swan's, for both shy, insecure teenagers have dates with destiny. Nicola Sturgeon will one day become First Minister of Scotland. Bella Swan will join the ranks of the undead." Delivering the verdict on the book as a whole, Ms Rowling says: "And so to the three hundred thousand pound question: is Frankly a good read? "Honestly, only if you find Nicola Sturgeon so fascinating the dull details of her political decision-making intrigue you, and are prepared to accept all her special pleading. "The biggest impediment to enjoyment is that Sturgeon, like Bella Swan, has a complete void where a sense of humour should be. "Bella's best attempt at a witticism in Twilight is when she says, in answer to a query as to why she isn't tanned, 'my mother is half albino'. The only time Sturgeon makes what I think is supposed to be a joke is when she says of a teenage boyfriend, 'His nickname was Sparky (he wasn't an aspiring electrician).'" She adds that "most of the time, Frankly reads like a PR statement that's been through sixteen drafts" and says: "The best anecdote is on page 120, when Sean Connery teaches Sturgeon an acting trick to lower her voice. But if you're looking for a more scintillating read, I recommend The Women Who Wouldn't Wheesht – especially if you want the real low down on the dystopian nightmare Sturgeon's gender beliefs have imposed on Scottish women." And poking fun at Ms Sturgeon's apparent modesty in passages of the book, Ms Rowling pointed to various boasts in Frankly. She wrote: "Sturgeon's alleged imposter syndrome and constant crises of confidence don't prevent her admitting to 'the raw talent I had for politics', or that 'I certainly wasn't lacking in ability', that 'far from being the weak link, I was seemingly the star attraction', 'it all added to the sense that I had the Midas touch' or that 'there is no doubt that I was a massive electoral asset.'"
