logo
Akbar misrepresented in textbooks? JNU scholar takes on NCERT over jizya claim

Akbar misrepresented in textbooks? JNU scholar takes on NCERT over jizya claim

Time of India6 days ago
Dr. Ruchika Sharma
Dr. Ruchika Sharma, a historian specializing in medieval India, has raised questions about the recent revisions in NCERT history textbooks, particularly concerning the portrayal of Emperor Akbar and the tax system known as jizya.
Sharma has announced her intention to file a Right to Information (RTI) request against NCERT, challenging the accuracy and completeness of the content related to this period.
During a televised debate on a private channel, Dr. Sharma criticized the depiction of the Mughal era in the textbooks, calling out what she described as factual discrepancies and biased evaluations of historical figures. She specifically contested the claim that jizya was imposed as a means to pressure non-Muslims into converting to Islam, a point she says lacks credible historical backing.
Historian challenges textbook narrative on jizya
During the televised discussion, Dr Sharma stated that the textbooks misrepresent the timeline of Akbar's abolition of the jizya tax. According to her, the revised content suggests that Akbar abolished the tax only after consolidating his rule. Sharma contested this, asserting that Akbar began his reign in 1560 and abolished jizya by 1562, a time when he was still a young ruler and had not fully established control over the empire.
Dr Sharma cited the Ain-i-Akbari, a contemporary administrative document, as evidence that Akbar removed the jizya tax early in his rule due to its discriminatory nature. She said this decision had moral significance and was not simply a political strategy taken after gaining complete power.
Questions over conversion claims and demand for sources
Dr Sharma also raised concerns about the textbook's explanation of the purpose behind the jizya tax.
The textbook reportedly states that the tax was imposed to pressure non-Muslims to convert to Islam to avoid paying it. She refuted this claim, asking where it is documented in historical records that jizya served as an incentive for conversion.
'If NCERT is presenting this claim, I would like to file an RTI asking for the source,' she said during the debate. Dr Sharma emphasised the need for academic transparency and demanded that NCERT provide the original references for the content presented in the revised material.
Criticism of selective portrayal and terminology
In the same debate, Dr Sharma questioned the use of the term 'dark period' in describing certain historical eras. She called the label historically irrelevant and pointed to what she described as double standards in how different rulers are evaluated in the textbook content.
She further alleged factual discrepancies and incomplete narratives in several textbook sections.
'A lot of what has been written is simply false, and I can point out the facts to prove it. The portrayal of history is incomplete in many places,' she said.
Remarks on Shivaji draw political response
Dr Sharma also made a remark involving Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj, which prompted a response from the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). Amit Malviya, head of the BJP's IT cell, responded on social media platform X, stating that 'Comparing Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj to Mughal tyrants is not only a historical distortion but also a grave insult to the nation.'
He added that there is no historical evidence that Shivaji Maharaj looted or plundered Chikka Devaraja Wodeyar, who ruled Mysore from 1673 to 1704.
Scholar's background and public presence
Dr Ruchika Sharma holds a PhD in History from JNU and is known for her work on medieval Indian history. She regularly appears in national media debates on historical representation in education. She also runs a YouTube channel titled Eyeshadow & Etihaas, where she combines historical discussions with makeup tutorials.
TOI Education is on WhatsApp now. Follow us
here
.
Ready to navigate global policies? Secure your overseas future. Get expert guidance now!
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Congress wants to give share of BC quota to muslims: Kishan
Congress wants to give share of BC quota to muslims: Kishan

New Indian Express

timean hour ago

  • New Indian Express

Congress wants to give share of BC quota to muslims: Kishan

HYDERABAD: Union Minister G Kishan Reddy on Friday alleged that the Congress was attempting to extend reservations to Muslims under the guise of BC quotas, which he described as unjust to the OBCs. Addressing a press conference in New Delhi, Kishan accused the Congress of proposing a 10% reservation for Muslims under the BC category. 'This move is an expansion of the earlier 4% BC-E quota implemented by the Congress, which was later raised to 6% and is now being proposed at 10%,' the Union minister said, stressing that the BJP remained opposed to religion-based reservations. Kishan also referred to the previous BRS regime's implementation of 34% reservation for BCs, which included 10% for Muslims. He said this had led to an unfair outcome in the Greater Hyderabad Municipal Corporation elections, with the AIMIM benefiting from the arrangement. He stated that the Centre, under Prime Minister Narendra Modi's leadership, had introduced a 10% reservation under the Economically Backward Class (EBC) category, from which Muslims could also benefit. However, he said the proposal of the Congress government in Telangana to add a further 10% under the BC quota was 'unacceptable'. Kishan also criticised Chief Minister A Revanth Reddy for his remarks on 'converted BCs' and questioned whether the CM would similarly refer to the Lambada community, which was included under the Scheduled Tribe (ST) category in 1972, as 'converted STs'. He added that several castes were added to the BC list in 1994 during the Congress regime based on the Mandal Commission, at a time when Narendra Modi was not even an MLA. The Union minister also claimed that the Congress had never appointed a BC leader as chief minister and challenged the party's commitment to BC welfare. 'If Revanth Reddy truly cares about the BC community, he should make way for a BC as chief minister,' Kishan stated, adding that the BJP had promoted a BC leader to the post of prime minister. Kishan further claimed that Congress would not win elections even if they were held immediately and predicted the party would lose the states it currently governs. He said Rahul Gandhi, who aspired to become prime minister, had already been rejected thrice.

BJP leader writes to CM, highlights dismal state of Chandni Chowk area
BJP leader writes to CM, highlights dismal state of Chandni Chowk area

New Indian Express

time2 hours ago

  • New Indian Express

BJP leader writes to CM, highlights dismal state of Chandni Chowk area

NEW DELHI: Highlighting the extremely poor administrative conditions of the Chandni Chowk Assembly, Delhi BJP spokesperson Praveen Shankar Kapoor has requested CM Rekha Gupta to conduct an administrative inspection of the Old Delhi area. The BJP spokesperson has alleged that all the MLAs and councillors in Old Delhi belong to the Aam Aadmi Party and that they neither did any work while in power nor are focusing on development now. Kapoor, in a letter to the CM, stated that area MP Praveen Khandelwal has conducted four inspections over the past year, but officials from the police, PWD, DJB, and MCD have not taken any action. He said that the Chandni Chowk beautification project has completely failed — the market has become a jungle of illegal encroachments, unmanaged parking, filth, and rickshaws. Roads and footpaths are broken across areas like Cycle Market, Diwan Hall Road, Bhagirath Palace, Main Chandni Chowk, Church Mission Road, Khari Baoli, Lahori Gate Chowk, Chawri Bazaar, and Sitaram Bazaar. Around Town Hall, illegal parking is being operated through the collusion of some corrupt police and municipal officials — with illegal daily collections amounting to lakhs of rupees. Along Chandni Chowk's main road, unlicensed food stalls are openly being operated by Muslims — who are opening shops under Hindu or neutral names. 'I request you to kindly make a visit to assess the poor conditions of this area and the neighboring constituencies of Ballimaran, Sadar Bazar, and Matia Mahal, and issue appropriate directives for necessary corrective action,' Kapoor added in his letter. For the CM's review, Praveen has stated that in the entire constituency stretching from Majnu Ka Tila to Delhi Gate and from Azad Market to Kisan Ghat, the Delhi Jal Board has only one Junior Engineer (JE), two mates (laborers), no Assistant Engineer (AE), and no Executive Engineer (EE). This one JE has also recently been assigned as the nodal officer at the CM's office, so he now only works half-days in the constituency. In the Sadar area of the Municipal Corporation of Delhi, there is no regular Deputy Commissioner — Additional Commissioner Leeladhar is only skilled in blocking work. He has also added that whatever little work gets done is purely due to the grace of the Commissioner. In Chandni Chowk Ward No. 74, the JE from the Maintenance Department who was sincerely working has been transferred due to the insistence of a corrupt senior officer at headquarters. The new JE, Kailash Yadav, does not report to duty for four days a week. Public Works Department (PWD) officers are tired of appealing to their seniors — no one listens. Despite a ban, vehicles — especially scooters — are freely plying in Chandni Chowk, but the Delhi Traffic Police is nowhere to be seen.

Navi Mumbai student thrashed for asking classmates to speak Marathi: ‘Raj Thackeray will…'
Navi Mumbai student thrashed for asking classmates to speak Marathi: ‘Raj Thackeray will…'

Hindustan Times

time3 hours ago

  • Hindustan Times

Navi Mumbai student thrashed for asking classmates to speak Marathi: ‘Raj Thackeray will…'

A 20-year-old student was allegedly beaten up outside a Navi Mumbai college after he asked his classmates in a WhatsApp group to speak Marathi. The student asked everyone to "speak in the Marathi language or else Raj Thackeray will come,"(PTI) The incident occurred when the student, reportedly annoyed with constant messages in Hindi, replied in Marathi, telling everyone to "speak in Marathi language or else Raj Thackeray will come," NDTV reported. The remark, made in reference to Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS) president Raj Thackeray, whose party has been at the centre of the current Marathi controversy, triggered an angry exchange on the messaging group. According to police sources, the student's comment sparked an argument on the WhatsApp group, which kept escalating. Also Read | 'Say we are trying to learn': Ajit Pawar speaks out amid assault cases over Marathi row Around 10:30am the following morning, four students, one of whom was Faizan Naik, assaulted the student who had requested them to use Marathi outside their college in Vashi. Naik also struck the 20-year-old on the head with a hockey stick, leaving him seriously hurt, the publication added. The injured student is undergoing treatment, and an FIR has been filed against the accused. The attack has provoked severe responses from the Maharashtra Navnirman Sena. MNS spokesperson Gajanan Kale, who met with both the student and police authorities, called for stern and speedy action against the accused. Man slapped, punched by MNS workers in Nanded for 'not speaking Marathi' | Video "A First Information Report has been filed at the Vashi police station regarding a quarrel between two groups. The quarrel was over an argument between two people about remarks on the group," Assistant Commissioner of Police (Vashi) Adinath Budhwant told NDTV. Marathi row The language row in Maharashtra began when the state government planned to introduce Hindi as a third language in primary schools in the state. The order had sparked huge backlash from the opposition and language advocacy groups in the state. Also Read | 'If you beat me…': Maharashtra governor on violence over Marathi language The row further gained traction following Raj Thackeray's speech during a recent victory rally in Mumbai, where he told Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS) workers to ensure that non-Marathi speakers in the city learn the local language, but refrained from recording any violent acts.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store