Monash IVF admits second bungled embryo implant this time at Melbourne clinic
Monash IVF said in a statement on Tuesday that on 5 June 'a patient's own embryo was incorrectly transferred to that patient, contrary to the treatment plan which designated the transfer of an embryo of the patient's partner'.
'Monash IVF has extended its sincere apologies to the affected couple, and we continue to support them,' the fertility company said.
The first error was announced in April. In that case, a patient at one of its Brisbane clinics had an embryo incorrectly transferred to her, meaning she gave birth to a child of an unrelated woman.
The mistake was blamed on human error. Monash IVF asked senior counsel Fiona McLeod to investigate.
Lawyers described the incident as a legal and ethical nightmare while Monash IVF said it was confident it was an isolated incident.
The latest incident happened in a Melbourne laboratory in Clayton.
Monash IVF said it was 'conducting an internal investigation into the incident'. The company also 'extended the scope of the independent review' being conducted by McLeod.
It further said on Tuesday it would put extra verification processes and patient confirmation safeguards in place 'over and above normal practice and electronic witness systems, to ensure patients and clinicians have every confidence in its processes'.
Sign up to Morning Mail
Our Australian morning briefing breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters
after newsletter promotion
'Whilst industry-leading electronic witness systems have and are being rolled out across Monash IVF, there remains instances and circumstances whereby manual witnessing is required,' the statement to the ASX said.
Monash IVF also notified assisted reproductive technology regulators and its insurers.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
5 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Wylie thought he was fit and healthy. Now he's fighting for his life at just 39 after doctors dismissed his 'vague' symptom
Wylie Dixon was excited to build a future with his beautiful wife - from travelling across Australia to starting the family they had always dreamed of. But everything came to a halt when the 'fit and healthy' retail manager received devastating news that he had an aggressive form of appendix cancer. The then 38-year-old had been struggling with months of fatigue, but doctors dismissed the 'vague' symptom so he assumed there was nothing to worry about. It wasn't until he began experiencing excruciating stomach pains and vomiting that he was rushed to the emergency room - where he learned he had stage four cancer. 'I was heartbroken,' Wylie, now 39, told FEMAIL. 'I was in disbelief as I'd never heard of the cancer before... I wasn't someone who had scheduled health check-ups but I went to the doctor often when something would arise. 'I was fit and healthy, not overweight, I was very active and walking 10,000 to 20,000 steps per day was normal for me at work.' By the time he was diagnosed in August 2024, Wylie was told he may have just three months to live - completely turning his world upside down. He explained that he just can't fathom how his condition turned into such an extremely rare case, especially since there were no alarming symptoms before his appendix cancer diagnosis. 'I didn't have any major symptoms besides fatigue. That's the problem with this cancer, everything was vague and didn't persist, besides the fatigue,' he said. For Wylie, the most disheartening part of his diagnosis was feeling a 'massive sense of being let down' by doctors. 'Unfortunately the many GP visits over two years failed to diagnose me,' he said. 'Ultimately I ended up in emergency one night with acute abdominal pain and vomiting caused by a blockage right where the appendix is located. 'I trusted what I was being told but as I now know from my own research many GP visits were caused by the cancer.' Wylie has lived in Cairns, Far North Queensland, for most of his life but after the diagnosis, he and his wife Ked relocated to Sydney to be closer to the only specialist cancer centre offering the urgent care he needs. As he was spending more time in Sydney, it only made sense for the couple to move. The couple made the heartbreaking decision to sell their home, quit their jobs and leave behind their family and friends so they could give Wylie a fighting chance. He underwent a 19-hour peritonectomy surgery, a highly invasive surgical procedure to remove the cancerous tumours from his body. Since then, he has been enduring intense rounds of chemotherapy. 'It's been a very long recovery from the operation, I'm still going eight months on. It's very much a watch and wait game at the moment,' he explained. Despite getting the all-clear, his cancer has returned, and he's now looking into travelling to Japan or Germany for new treatment options. 'The likelihood of recurrence is very high,' he explained. With both Wylie and his wife unable to work, the rising cost of flights, temporary accommodation, medications, ongoing treatment, and countless specialist appointments have become overwhelming. 'The stress of mounting bills threatens to overshadow the one thing that matters most: Wylie's recovery,' his cousin Ashleigh said on his GoFundMe page. 'We are asking for your help. Your donation, no matter the size, will help lift some of this burden - giving Wylie the chance to focus on healing without the added weight of financial stress. It will help ensure he can continue receiving the lifesaving care. 'Please consider supporting Wylie during this incredibly difficult chapter. Every dollar and every message of encouragement means more than you can imagine.' Signs and symptoms of appendix cancer Appendix cancer may not cause symptoms in its early stages. However, some people may experience symptoms such as: appendicitis (lower right abdominal pain) gradual increase in waist size build-up of fluid in the abdomen bloating changes in bowel habits hernia ovarian mass or lump Source: Cancer Council According to Cancer Council, appendix cancer occurs when cells in the appendix become abnormal and continue to grow, forming a tumour. The causes are unknown, and there are no clear risk factors - it also does not appear to run in families. Increasing age, however, may raise the risk of developing appendix cancer. It's a rare condition, with the most common types occurring in Australians aged between 40 and 60. In 2024, an estimated 874 people were diagnosed with appendiceal cancer. There is currently no screening available for appendix cancer in Australia. It is often discovered during abdominal surgery for a different condition or after surgical removal of the appendix due to a suspected case of appendicitis. 'I just hope there's more awareness of appendix cancer because there is no real screening process for it,' Wylie said. By sharing his story, he hopes to encourage young people to push for more answers if their symptoms are overlooked simply because they're considered 'too young to have cancer'. 'GPs shouldn't dismiss symptoms just because someone is young,' Wylie said. 'We're now seeing cancer rates in younger people go through the roof.'
The Guardian
7 hours ago
- The Guardian
Milk, carbohydrates or a late-night pudding: what's the secret to eating for a good night's sleep?
Have a glass of warm milk. No, a cup of herbal tea. Eat carbs, but only the right carbs. Have fats, but not too much. Have a filling meal. No, not that filling. Eat early, but not too early or you'll get hungry again later. Ask the internet for advice on how to eat for a good night's sleep and you could lose a whole night trying to find a clear answer. But amid a global shortage of good sleep (48% of Australian adults report having at least two sleep-related problems), dietary habits are emerging as an important factor that can make the difference between refreshing rest and a night spent regretting every food choice you made in the previous 24 hours. Some of the most useful insights into the effect of timing, size and quality of meals on sleep come from studies of those who work through the night to keep our world running. At CQUniversity in Adelaide, research psychologist Dr Charlotte Gupta has been studying how different eating patterns affect shift workers' performance. Her most important piece of advice for a good night's sleep is to eat well before bedtime. 'We're not primed to be digesting food at night,' Gupta says. A meal eaten too close to sleep forces the body to focus energy and resources on digestion, when it should be resting and performing other tasks that take place while we rest. 'So it's likely to impact the quality of our sleep; we're more likely to wake up during the night, remember our dreams, not get that really restorative sleep,' she says. The ideal is to eat your last food at least two hours before going to sleep, which means no pre-sleep pecking at leftovers or midnight raid of the fridge for a spoonful of cold pudding. The size of that final meal can also make a difference. Ideally, we should be having a bigger meal in the middle of the day, when light exposure means our body is very much awake and primed for digestion, and a smaller meal in the evening. But not too small. 'We don't want it to be so small for dinner that you feel really hungry during the night, that your body's going to wake you up and want food,' Gupta says. Sign up for our rundown of must-reads, pop culture and tips for the weekend, every Saturday morning On the question of what to eat for a good night's sleep, the answer is less clearcut, says exercise physiologist and nutritionist Dr Elizabeth Machan from the Woolcock Institute of Medical Research and the University of Sydney. 'We haven't got extensive research that has given us the perfect recipe for what the evening meal should be,' she says. There's some evidence that higher-fat meals are more filling, so in theory people will have more restful sleep, Machan says. But diets high in fat are also associated with shorter sleep duration. Similarly, despite the popular idea that eating carbs before bedtime is bad, some studies suggest having a meal higher in carbohydrate can actually help people get to sleep faster. 'I think a lot of people might avoid carbs in the evening, for instance, or they'll reduce their carb intake in the evening, and that's when they can become more food-seeking later in the night as a result,' she says. Machan says it's important to include vegetables in that evening meal to help slow the digestive process. 'Your gut's going to be exposed to those nutrients for longer, it'll have a better chance of absorbing them,' she says. 'So if you've got a meal that is lower energy, for instance, it's going to keep you full, you're not going to wake up in the middle of the night hungry.' There's a lot of interest in micronutrients such as the amino acid tryptophan, which the body can convert into the sleep hormone melatonin, and which is found in a range of foods including eggs, tofu, salmon, milk, turkey and some nuts and seeds. While some studies suggest increasing tryptophan intake might boost melatonin and improve sleep quality, Machan is more sceptical, arguing that light exposure is much more important in regulating melatonin. 'You're not going to make [melatonin] if you're sitting in light – it's a signal that we're not needing to go to sleep, that it's daytime,' she says. One of the challenges with exploring the link between diet and sleep is that it's a two-way street, says Dr Jen Walsh, director of the Centre for Sleep Science at the University of Western Australia. Studies connecting late meal times with poor sleep are measuring not necessarily sleep quality on one night, but over the past month. 'I think what it's telling us is that individuals who have poorer sleep are more likely to eat later in the evening.' While one way of looking at it is that eating later means poorer-quality sleep, another way of interpreting the data is that people who have poorer-quality sleep are more likely to eat later. 'It's potentially [the case] that people who eat later have worse health behaviours in general,' she says. Like so many other health stories, good sleep ultimately seems to come back to that same old chestnut of healthy diet, healthy lifestyle. 'I say that sleep impacts diet and it also impacts exercise, so really we need to be getting the sleep right, and it will get everything else right,' Walsh says.
The Guardian
12 hours ago
- The Guardian
As Australia's natural disasters worsen, ‘vets carry on, even while their own clinics are under water'
'Horrific' was how veterinarian Dr Stacey Rae describes what she saw while helicoptering above south-west Queensland farmland in the aftermath of ex-Tropical Cyclone Alfred in March. Scores of livestock were scattered across the formerly dusty plains – some still alive, many dead. As flood waters receded, animals struggled in the thick sludge, slowly succumbing to starvation, exposure and illness. Because rain struck just before shearing time, sheep carried full fleeces, which made the impact 'tenfold' worse, Rae says. Sign up: AU Breaking News email She estimates the final death count of stock stretches into the hundreds of thousands, though that cannot be determined until surviving sheep are shorn and cattle mustered. 'I've not seen this in my lifetime.' Recent figures suggest 150,000 stock losses so far. After the floods in remote Queensland, New South Wales also experienced record-breaking rainfall in May, flooding the Hunter region and mid-north coast. Farmers in the area were forced to bury their dead stock. Rae worries about the wellbeing of farmers. 'It's these months where reality sets in, mental health issues really come to the top.' Veterinarians face complex challenges too – natural disasters are increasingly exhausting those working in rural Australia. The Australian Veterinary Association (AVA) set up a hotline in March to offer advice to flood-affected graziers and vets in Queensland, which remained open until early June due to demand. Calls initially focused on urgent trauma and delivering vital resources such as medicine to suffering livestock. But months later the hotline was still buzzing as sandfly plagues, emerging plant toxicity, chronic disease, viruses and bacterial infections emerged. The role of vets in regional Australia goes beyond serving as a 'small animal wizard', veterinarian Dr Jeannet Kessels says. 'Veterinarians feel very deeply … I've probably shed a tear with every client that came in for euthanasia,' she says. 'Vets carry on, even while their own clinics are under water.' Kessels, the owner of a carbon neutral vet hospital in Springfield, Queensland, founded the group Vets for Climate Action after the black summer bushfires. In March, VfCA hosted Veterinary Voices to Parliament – A Call to Action event in Canberra urging for formal recognition of the impact the climate crisis has on animal welfare. The former chief veterinary officer (CVO) of NSW and inspector general of biosecurity for Australia, Dr Helen Scott-Orr, says extreme weather events are having 'massive economic, animal and vet welfare effects'. She says major animal health issues – infections, disease and insect-borne illnesses – flourish in extreme weather and euthanising animals amid large-scale natural disasters is 'heartbreaking'. When she was a veterinary student in the late 1960s, Scott-Orr recalls being taught that paralysis ticks didn't exist south of Sydney Harbour – but now, they are found as far south as Gippsland, Victoria. A 2018 study estimates about 10,000 dogs and cats are treated annually for tick paralysis, with unquantified but growing impacts on livestock and wildlife. Rural vets bear the brunt of treating animals in extreme weather events, adding pressure to a worsening workforce crisis – with a veterinarian shortage in regional Australia. There are vet shortages in every state, especially in large animal and rural practice, according to a 2025 report by Jobs and Skills Australia, while a 2024 NSW parliamentary inquiry into the veterinary workforce shortage indicated an urgent need for better workforce data and planning. Job vacancies linger longest in the bush: 44% of regional vet jobs remain open for over a year, compared with a lower 28% in metropolitan areas. Research shows vets suffer from high emotional strain, moral conflicts, chronic underpayment and alarming suicide rates, while 42% of vets in remote areas work more than 50 hours per week. 'The veterinary profession already has a higher-than-average suicide rate,' says former Queensland CVO, Dr Ron Glanville – one of 33 former Australian CVOs and senior animal health officials lobbying the government for stronger climate action. Glanville also warns that the threat of climate-related disease is becoming more serious – the spread of Japanese encephalitis virus (JEV), used to be limited to the Top End, he says. 'Now we've seen outbreaks right down into South Australia.' In 2022, an outbreak swept through more than 80 piggeries across Queensland, New South Wales, Victoria and South Australia. Domestic animals were infected and three people died. 'We had to make difficult decisions,' Rae says, recalling the catastrophic Queensland floods. 'Some stock weren't able to be saved and it was more humane to destroy them.' One producer, she recalls, had to shoot 80 bullocks in one paddock out of the helicopter. 'That's hundreds of thousands of dollars just gone, they were booked in to go the following week … It's not like a flooded home you can insure.' Rae encourages Australians to volunteer with BlazeAid, or visit the regions to help local economies. Practical donations are also welcome, including initiative Pay 4 a Panel, helping rebuild fencing. Rae says there has been an 'amazing' community response but many vets and farmers feel forgotten – as if the nation has simply has 'moved on'.
