BBC apologises to Jenrick over suggestions he is xenophobic in Radio 4 broadcast
While appearing on the radio on Wednesday, Krish Kandiah, a director of Sanctuary Foundation, claimed Mr Jenrick had increased 'fear of the stranger' among people.
Mr Kandiah added: 'The technical name for this is xenophobia.
'All phobias are by definition irrational. Nevertheless, they have a huge impact.
'Over the past year, xenophobia has fuelled angry protests outside hotels housing asylum seekers, deepening divisions in our communities.'
In a letter to the Conservative MP, the broadcaster's head of editorial standards Roger Mahony said the comments 'went beyond' what is expected of its Thought For The Day segment.
Mr Mahony said: 'I have concluded that, while its reflection on fear in society from a faith perspective is broadly in line with expectations of Thought For The Day, some of the language it used went beyond that.
'I have asked for the two references to xenophobia to be edited from the programme on BBC Sounds. Please accept my apology for their original inclusion.'
The content has since been removed from the programme on BBC Sounds.
Mr Jenrick said: 'Illegal migration is obviously fuelling crime and the public are right to be concerned about it.
'It's extremely disappointing the BBC thought it was acceptable to smear millions of worried citizens as 'xenophobic' for their completely understandable fears about undocumented men entering illegally.'
A series of protests have been held outside the Bell Hotel in Epping, Essex, over recent weeks after an asylum seeker was accused of attempting to kiss a 14-year-old girl.
Hadush Gerberslasie Kebatu, 38, denies the charges of sexual assault and is due to stand trial this month.
In a statement, the BBC said: 'During this episode of Thought For The Day, criticism was made of recent comments by shadow secretary of state for justice Robert Jenrick, about hotels housing asylum seekers.
'While the programme's reflection on fear in society from a faith perspective was broadly in line with expectations of Thought For The Day, some of the language used went beyond that and we apologise for its inclusion.
'It has been removed from the version on BBC Sounds.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
4 hours ago
- BBC News
Anger and confusion as Meta overturns more Instagram account bans
Instagram users have told the BBC of their confusion, fear and anger after having their accounts suspended, often for being wrongly accused by parent company Meta of breaching the platform's child sex abuse months, tens of thousands of people around the world have been complaining Meta has been banning their Instagram and Facebook accounts in say they have been wrongly accused of breaching site rules - including around child sexual than 500 of them have contacted the BBC to say they have lost cherished photos and seen businesses upended - but some also speak of the profound personal toll it has taken on them, including concerns that the police could become acknowledged a problem with the erroneous banning of Facebook Groups in June, but has denied there is wider issue on Facebook or Instagram at has repeatedly refused to comment on the problems its users are facing - though it has frequently overturned bans when the BBC has raised individual cases with are some of the stories users have shared with BBC News. 'I put all of my trust in social media' Yassmine Boussihmed, 26, from the Netherlands, spent five years building an Instagram profile for her boutique dress shop in April, she was banned over account integrity. Over 5,000 followers, gone in an instant. She lost clients, and was devastated."I put all of my trust in social media, and social media helped me grow, but it has let me down," she told the week, after the BBC sent questions about her case to Meta's press office, her Instagram accounts were reinstated."I am so thankful," she said in a tearful voice note. Five minutes later, her personal Instagram was suspended again - but the account for the dress shop remained. Lucia, not her real name, is a 21-year-old woman from Austin, Texas. She was suspended from Instagram for just over two weeks for breaching Meta's policy on child sexual exploitation (CSE), abuse and with all the other cases, she was not told what post breached the platform's has left wondering if a picture she posted of herself and her 21-year-old friend wearing bikini tops somehow triggered the artificial intelligence (AI) moderation tools, as she thinks they "look a little bit younger".She also uses her account to interact with under 18s, such as sending Reels to her younger sister."It is deeply troubling to have an accusation as disgusting as this one," she told BBC News."Given that I have a desire to work in juvenile justice as an attorney and advocate on behalf of children, I am appalled to have been suspended for something I know I did not do and would never do."She appealed, and then about seven hours after the BBC highlighted Lucia's case to Meta's press office, her account was restored with no explanation. Over 36,000 people have signed a petition accusing Meta of falsely banning accounts; thousands more are in Reddit forums or on social media posting about central accusation - Meta's AI is unfairly banning people, with the tech also being used to deal with the appeals. The only way to speak to a human is to pay for Meta Verified, and even then many are has not commented on these claims. Instagram states AI is central to its "content review process" and Meta has outlined how technology and humans enforce its policies. A community torn away Duncan Edmonstone, from Cheshire, has stage four ALK+ lung cancer. The 55-year-old finds solace in the support network he has on private Facebook 12 days at the end of June, he was banned for breaking cybersecurity guidelines before being reinstated."The support groups are my lifeline, and there are actual examples of where advice from group members has made a difference to other patient's treatment," he said."I draw satisfaction and meaning, in a life that is probably going to be cut short, from helping other people in that group." Banned, unbanned - then banned again Ryan - not his real name - has been banned, reinstated, and banned again from Instagram over the past few former teacher from London was thrown off the platform in May after he was accused of breaching the CSE spent a month appealing. In June, the BBC understands a human moderator double checked and concluded Ryan had breached the his account was abruptly restored at the end of July."We're sorry we've got this wrong," Instagram said in an email to him, adding that he had done nothing was left flabbergasted. "'Sorry we called you a paedophile for two months - here is your account back,'" is how he characterised the tone of the that wasn't the end of the story. Hours after the BBC contacted Meta's press office to ask questions about his experience, he was banned again on Instagram and, for the first time, Facebook."I am devastated and I don't know what to do," he told the BBC."I can't believe it has happened twice."His Facebook account was back two days later - but he was still blocked from Instagram. Ryan says he has been left feeling deeply isolated - and worried the police are going to "knock on the door".His experiences mirrors those of other Instagram users who told the BBC of the "extreme stress" of having their accounts banned after being wrongly accused of breaching the platform's rules on CSE. What has Meta said? Despite taking action on Yassmine, Lucia and Ryan's accounts, Meta has not made any comment to the common with all big technology firms, it has come under pressure from authorities to make its platforms July, Meta said it was taking "aggressive action" on accounts breaking its rules - including the removal of 635,000 Instagram and Facebook accounts over sexualised comments and imagery in relation to wide-ranging policy on child sexual exploitation has changed three times since Boxing Day last year, with all amendments occurring since 17 July. It has not said what impact, if any, these changes had on the cases the BBC has raised with it. Sign up for our Tech Decoded newsletter to follow the world's top tech stories and trends. Outside the UK? Sign up here.
The Guardian
6 hours ago
- The Guardian
Theologian in Jenrick xenophobia row says pair ‘could work together'
The theologian who accused Robert Jenrick of xenophobia on the BBC has invited the shadow justice minister to work with him to ease tensions over migration rather than 'ramping up anti-immigrant sentiment'. Dr Krish Kandiah's comments on Radio 4's Thought for the Day, raising concerns about Jenrick's remarks about the safety of his daughters because of small boat arrivals, caused a row after a complaint from the shadow justice secretary, with the item being retrospectively edited by the BBC. Kandiah expressed concern about the current atmosphere relating to migration and said he was extending an olive branch to Jenrick in the hope the two men could work together on the issue. The initial remarks by Kandiah, who heads the Sanctuary Foundation refugee charity, prompted an angry response from Jenrick. The BBC said it had removed 'some of the language used' by Kandiah from a version of Thought for the Day posted online, saying it was not appropriate for the faith-based radio segment. In his statement, Kandiah said: 'Mr Jenrick, I want your daughters and mine to be able to walk down the road safely and without fear. I worked with you when you were housing minister and the UK welcomed over 200,000 people from Hong Kong. 'I was grateful for your support and compassion during that time. I would love to find a way we could work together to de-escalate the fear and anger many are feeling in our country. I believe we need to focus on the real challenges that are making people worried – housing, jobs and the cost of living – rather than ramping up anti-immigrant sentiment.' In last weekend's Mail on Sunday, Jenrick cited a series of recent crimes he said had been committed by asylum seekers, writing: 'When I see these stories, I can't help but think that it could have been one of my three young daughters. I certainly don't want my children to share a neighbourhood with immigrant men with backward views who broke into Britain illegally, and about whom we know next to nothing.' In his Thought for the Day contribution, Kandiah quoted this passage from Jenrick, adding: 'These words echo a fear many have absorbed. Fear of the stranger. The technical name for this is xenophobia.' While the government has not criticised Jenrick's tone, and say the current row is a matter for the BBC, some MPs and others have said Kandiah's description was accurate. The Labour MP John McDonnell said: 'Jenrick has become the byword for political opportunism. There is no prejudice he won't pander to and no harm to our community he won't risk to further his political career.' Siân Berry, the Green MP for Brighton Pavilion and a former co-leader of the party, condemned Jenrick for his comments and the government for not speaking out against them. 'It is 100% xenophobia, drawing on stereotypes to create unnecessary and inaccurate fears,' she said. 'If you can't call that xenophobic or racist without the person in question kicking off at you, then I don't know what we've learned from the last 80 years. Sign up to First Edition Our morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters after newsletter promotion 'Robert Jenrick knows exactly what he's doing when he is pushing these buttons, and he does need to be called out on it by everybody possible. I'm daily frustrated by the fact that the Labour government is playing along and not standing up for real British values. 'What is [a] Labour government for if it isn't to create a political discourse that backs up what British values really stand for. We're not a country that rejects immigrants in the way that some people on the right and the far right would like us to.' Jacqueline McKenzie, the head of immigration and asylum at Leigh Day solicitors, called Jenrick's comments 'appalling'. She said: 'Not only are his comments xenophobic and without substance, but this is the sort of language that fuels racist tension in an otherwise cohesive society and causes the sorts of attacks on migrants and those who work with them as we are now seeing, and which fans the flames which led to last summer's riots. 'It is irresponsible for a senior member of the opposition to make such statements. Whereas there are a few high profile cases of asylum seekers who have been arrested for sexual offences, this is not at all representative of those who claim asylum, the vast majority of whom go on to prove that they have fled persecution.' Jenrick's office has been contacted for comment.
The Independent
6 hours ago
- The Independent
Narinder Kaur criticises BBC's decision to cast Thomas Skinner on Strictly
TV personality Narinder Kaur has criticised the BBC's decision to cast Thomas Skinner as a celebrity contestant on Strictly Come Dancing. Skinner recently met US vice president JD Vance for a barbecue and drinks, and befriended US President Donald Trump's number two on social media platform X. He recently claimed he had received 'death threats' and 'vile comments about my children', following a series of social media posts claiming 'something's gone wrong' in the UK, and saying 'there is nothing wrong with being proud of where you're from'. In other posts, which drew criticism from some of his followers, Skinner said it is 'not far-right' to be 'flying your flag and loving your country', and he complained 'it ain't safe out there anymore' in London, saying the city is 'hostile' and 'tense'. It comes as Kaur claimed she was told she was 'too controversial' for the show herself. In the caption of a video posted to X, Jeremy Vine panellist and former Big Brother star Kaur, 52, said: 'Apparently I was deemed too controversial for @bbcstrictly because they only hire quiet brown and black women that fit in a box. 'But you can be a white man AND be controversial and you'll be hired on the spot! Hello Thomas Skinner!!' In a statement, she added: 'There's only so much you can say in a short video, but I felt something many others have been feeling all day and that was complete shock and utter bewilderment – to see Thomas be announced in the line-up, considering all the rhetoric about how people with right-wing opinions are cancelled and not allowed on the BBC. 'I've debated Tom on Good Morning Britain before, I supported his book release at his launch party, there is a huge disparity in what certain demographics of people are allowed to say and still get one show after another. 'I met the Strictly team at the TV Choice Awards earlier this year and got talking to one of the bookers about the show generally – and she said 'You're a bit too controversial and we can't have that for the show.'' Social media personality Skinner has been announced as one of the latest celebrities to be taking part in the upcoming series of BBC One show Strictly. Following Skinner's post complaining about alleged abuse, Mr Vance replied with a picture of a cartoon character typing on a keyboard and a message that read: 'Hang in there, my friend. Remember that 90 percent of people attacking your family look like this.' After the Strictly announcement, Skinner said in a social media post: 'They say don't read the comments on social media. But I couldn't help myself. I've had absolute pellets all day on my Instagram lost about going on Strictly… Why are some people so angry that don't even know me.' Among the other celebrity contestants confirmed for Strictly this year are former Geordie Shore star Vicky Pattison and Neighbours actor Stefan Dennis. They join the likes of podcast host and YouTube star George Clarke, RuPaul's Drag Race UK finalist La Voix, former England rugby player Chris Robshaw, and model and CBBC actress Ellie Goldstein, who is to become the first contestant with Down's syndrome to take part in Strictly's full series. The line-up is completed by Love Island winner Dani Dyer-Bowen, EastEnders actress Balvinder Sopal, Gladiators star Harry Aikines-Aryeetey, Doctor Who actress Alex Kingston, and former footballer Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink.
