Legal gaps in crypto adoption
EDITORIAL: Pakistan's push to embrace cryptocurrency has seen the government take a host of measures over the last few months to promote the adoption of digital assets like Bitcoin.
From the establishment of the Pakistan Crypto Council and appointing entrepreneur Bilal bin Saqib as its CEO with the status of minister of state, to allocating 2,000MW of surplus electricity for Bitcoin mining and the finance minister's declaration that Pakistan wishes to be a leader in this space, all reflect a coordinated effort to position the country at the forefront of the digital economy.
What completely boggles the mind, however, is that amid this enthusiastic drive for crypto adoption, one basic fact has been persistently overlooked: cryptocurrency remains illegal in Pakistan. All transactions involving such assets are prohibited under current regulations, and anyone dealing in these currencies is liable to be investigated by the Financial Monitoring Unit and the FIA.
This was made clear in no uncertain terms by senior officials of the State Bank of Pakistan and the finance ministry during a meeting of the National Assembly's Standing Committee on Finance and Revenue on May 29.
Finance Secretary Imdadullah Bosal's categorical statement that 'crypto is not a legal tender in Pakistan' is something that casts a long shadow over the government's recent actions in this space. It highlights a shocking lack of policy coherence and prompts broader questions about the prudence of promoting crypto initiatives without first putting in place a clear legal framework.
The result is a climate of confusion and uncertainty, leaving investors, regulators and the public unsure of the government's true policy direction and intent behind these contradictory signals.
While some of the government's moves in this space may be seen as attempts to garner influence with the Trump Administration, which includes strong advocates of cryptocurrency, its actions appear to go beyond merely symbolic gestures.
At the recent 2025 Bitcoin Conference held in Las Vegas, for instance, Bilal bin Saqib unveiled Pakistan's first government-led Strategic Bitcoin Reserve, intended to hold digital assets in state custody as a sovereign reserve. This, along with other initiatives, suggests a clear intent to integrate crypto into national economic strategy despite the legal and regulatory contradictions, and the inherent risks of embracing an asset class, which thus far has been known for its volatility, lack of effective oversight mechanisms and susceptibility to speculative bubbles.
The fact of the matter is that cryptocurrency is not considered legal tender in most countries of the world, including in the US. There is still little regulatory clarity to the cryptocurrency space in most jurisdictions, with it long having operated on the fringes of the mainstream global financial system due to its volatile nature, resistance from central banks and limited mainstream adoption by businesses. This is not to say that cryptocurrencies cannot achieve legitimate adoption in a safe and regulated manner that preserves financial stability.
But for that to happen, governments would need to establish clear regulatory frameworks that address consumer protection, financial stability risks and anti-money laundering concerns while fostering innovation.
In Pakistan's case, crypto adoption demands carefully crafted regulations that balance risk — particularly regarding capital flight — with opportunities for financial inclusion and improved remittance flows.
Given our fragile economic position and IMF commitments, we must proceed cautiously by first establishing a clear regulatory framework developed through collaboration between blockchain specialists, technologists and economic managers who understand both our economic challenges and risks of crypto adoption.
The current approach of haphazard adoption without proper legal safeguards creates dangerous uncertainty: it encourages public investment in an illegal asset class, exposing citizens to potential legal consequences, and leaves our economy vulnerable to capital flight and money laundering risks. The government must rethink this blind embrace of crypto and first build legal guardrails before proceeding further.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
2 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Senate body concerned at absence of legal cover for PCC establishment
ISLAMABAD: The Senate Standing Committee on Information Technology and Telecommunication raised serious concerns over the absence of legal cover for establishment of Pakistan Crypto Council, while saying that crypto currency adoption could become a mega scandal. The parliamentary panel met with Palwasha Khan in the chair here on Monday to review the scope and mandate of Pakistan Crypto Council recently launched by the federal government. The committee questioned the legal standing of the council and reiterated that the legislature has not been taken into confidence prior to the establishment of the Council. Senator Humayun Mohmand inquired as to whether or not the council could be created by the Executive orders? The committee further inquired about the role of IT Ministry in Crypto Council. The ministry failed to satisfy the committee over the legal cover for Crypto Council. The IT Secretary,ZarrarHasham Khan, stated that the ministry has a role of providing input with regard to TORs. The committee was of view that the Crypto Council should be under the preview of the Ministry of IT, rather than the Finance Ministry. After due deliberations, the committee deferred the matter and decided to invite the Finance Ministry in the next meeting for a comprehensive briefing. The IT secretary said that information technology and IT-enabled services (ITeS) exports target of $5 billion is set for the next fiscal year. The country is likely to miss the exports target of $4.2 billion set for the outgoing fiscal year. IT exports is expected to reach $3.8 billion by the end of current fiscal year i.e. end June 2025 compared to $3.2 billion during the same period of last fiscal year. Discussing the issue of renewalof LDI/FLL licenses, the IT secretary informed that the consultation with the stakeholders has been completed as per the directions of the Sindh High Court (SHC), and the final decision will be announced in two to three weeks. Furthermore, the committee was briefed on the role of the IT Ministry in Pakistan Digital Authority. The IT secretary apprised that the Pakistan Digital Authority has been tasked to implement digital transformation initiatives focused on making the economy and governance digital, and will eventually play a major role in creating citizens centered 'Digital Society'. However, the IT Ministry is mainly responsible for policy formulation, legislation, governance in IT and telecommunications sector, he added. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
7 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Coinbase breach linked to customer data leak in India, sources say
WASHINGTON: Cryptocurrency exchange Coinbase knew as far back as January about a customer data leak at an outsourcing company connected to a larger breach estimated to cost up to $400 million, six people familiar with the matter told Reuters. At least one part of the breach, publicly disclosed in a May 14 SEC filing, occurred when an India-based employee of the U.S. outsourcing firm TaskUs was caught taking photographs of her work computer with her personal phone, according to five former TaskUs employees. Three of the employees and a person familiar with the matter said Coinbase was notified immediately. The ex-employees said they were briefed on the matter by company investigators or colleagues who witnessed the incident in the Indian city of Indore, noting that the woman and a suspected accomplice were alleged to have been feeding Coinbase customer information to hackers in return for bribes. The ex-employees and person familiar with the matter said more than 200 TaskUs employees were soon fired in a mass layoff that drew Indian media attention. Coinbase had previously blamed 'support agents overseas' for the breach, which it estimated could cost up to $400 million. Although the link between TaskUs and the breach was previously alleged in a lawsuit filed last week in federal court in Manhattan, details of the incident, reported here for the first time, raise further questions over when Coinbase first learned of the incident. Bitcoin Vegas in US: Pakistan unveils first govt-led Bitcoin reserve Coinbase said in the May SEC filing that it knew contractors accessed employee data 'without business need' in 'previous months.' Only when it received an extortion demand on May 11 did it realize that the access was part of a wider campaign, the company said. In a statement to Reuters on Wednesday, Coinbase said the incident was recently discovered and that it had 'cut ties with the TaskUs personnel involved and other overseas agents, and tightened controls.' Coinbase did not disclose who the other foreign agents were. TaskUs said in a statement that two employees had been fired early this year after they illegally accessed information from a client, which it did not identify. 'We immediately reported this activity to the client,' the statement said. 'We believe these two individuals were recruited by a much broader, coordinated criminal campaign against this client that also impacted a number of other providers servicing this client.' The person familiar with the matter confirmed that Coinbase was the client and that the incident took place in January. Reuters could not determine whether any arrests have been made. Police in Indore did not return a message seeking comment.
Business Recorder
2 days ago
- Business Recorder
Legal gaps in crypto adoption
EDITORIAL: Pakistan's push to embrace cryptocurrency has seen the government take a host of measures over the last few months to promote the adoption of digital assets like Bitcoin. From the establishment of the Pakistan Crypto Council and appointing entrepreneur Bilal bin Saqib as its CEO with the status of minister of state, to allocating 2,000MW of surplus electricity for Bitcoin mining and the finance minister's declaration that Pakistan wishes to be a leader in this space, all reflect a coordinated effort to position the country at the forefront of the digital economy. What completely boggles the mind, however, is that amid this enthusiastic drive for crypto adoption, one basic fact has been persistently overlooked: cryptocurrency remains illegal in Pakistan. All transactions involving such assets are prohibited under current regulations, and anyone dealing in these currencies is liable to be investigated by the Financial Monitoring Unit and the FIA. This was made clear in no uncertain terms by senior officials of the State Bank of Pakistan and the finance ministry during a meeting of the National Assembly's Standing Committee on Finance and Revenue on May 29. Finance Secretary Imdadullah Bosal's categorical statement that 'crypto is not a legal tender in Pakistan' is something that casts a long shadow over the government's recent actions in this space. It highlights a shocking lack of policy coherence and prompts broader questions about the prudence of promoting crypto initiatives without first putting in place a clear legal framework. The result is a climate of confusion and uncertainty, leaving investors, regulators and the public unsure of the government's true policy direction and intent behind these contradictory signals. While some of the government's moves in this space may be seen as attempts to garner influence with the Trump Administration, which includes strong advocates of cryptocurrency, its actions appear to go beyond merely symbolic gestures. At the recent 2025 Bitcoin Conference held in Las Vegas, for instance, Bilal bin Saqib unveiled Pakistan's first government-led Strategic Bitcoin Reserve, intended to hold digital assets in state custody as a sovereign reserve. This, along with other initiatives, suggests a clear intent to integrate crypto into national economic strategy despite the legal and regulatory contradictions, and the inherent risks of embracing an asset class, which thus far has been known for its volatility, lack of effective oversight mechanisms and susceptibility to speculative bubbles. The fact of the matter is that cryptocurrency is not considered legal tender in most countries of the world, including in the US. There is still little regulatory clarity to the cryptocurrency space in most jurisdictions, with it long having operated on the fringes of the mainstream global financial system due to its volatile nature, resistance from central banks and limited mainstream adoption by businesses. This is not to say that cryptocurrencies cannot achieve legitimate adoption in a safe and regulated manner that preserves financial stability. But for that to happen, governments would need to establish clear regulatory frameworks that address consumer protection, financial stability risks and anti-money laundering concerns while fostering innovation. In Pakistan's case, crypto adoption demands carefully crafted regulations that balance risk — particularly regarding capital flight — with opportunities for financial inclusion and improved remittance flows. Given our fragile economic position and IMF commitments, we must proceed cautiously by first establishing a clear regulatory framework developed through collaboration between blockchain specialists, technologists and economic managers who understand both our economic challenges and risks of crypto adoption. The current approach of haphazard adoption without proper legal safeguards creates dangerous uncertainty: it encourages public investment in an illegal asset class, exposing citizens to potential legal consequences, and leaves our economy vulnerable to capital flight and money laundering risks. The government must rethink this blind embrace of crypto and first build legal guardrails before proceeding further. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
