logo
China was on the sidelines of the Iran-Israel war. That's just where it wanted to be

China was on the sidelines of the Iran-Israel war. That's just where it wanted to be

Hong Kong
CNN —
Weeks after his country was battered by waves of Israeli strikes and the US bombed three of its prized nuclear facilities, Iran's foreign minister came to a gathering of regional diplomats in China this week with a simple ask.
Their group, the Beijing and Moscow-backed Shanghai Cooperation Organization, should have a way to coordinate response to military aggression and play a 'central role' in addressing such threats, Abbas Araghchi said, according to Iranian state media.
Along with Iran, fellow SCO members China and Russia are key members of what lawmakers in Washington have dubbed an 'axis' of authoritarian nations or a growing anti-American alignment of Iran, North Korea, China and Russia.
But Iran's proposal didn't seem to get the direct endorsement of the group, a regional security body whose 10 members include close partners China and Russia, but also rivals India and Pakistan.
And contained in Araghchi's message was a public hint of Iran's disappointment: that in its time of need last month – when Israeli and US forces struck at will at top military and technological targets – its powerful friends in Beijing and Moscow appeared to sit on the sidelines.
Even still, in a meeting with Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi in China's Tianjin on Wednesday, Araghchi 'thanked China for its valuable support to Iran,' according to a Chinese readout.
Earlier this month at a summit of BRICS, another China- and Russia-backed grouping of major emerging economies, member state Iran got little more than a statement of 'serious concern over deliberate attacks on civilian infrastructure and peaceful nuclear facilities.'
The declaration 'condemned' the strikes but did not name Israel or the US.
China's public response – to explicitly condemn the attacks, but not take an evident direct role in peacemaking – however, was widely seen as a sign of the limits to its power in the Middle East, despite its bid in recent years to ramp up its economic and diplomat clout in the region.
Beijing has instead focused on using the conflict to play up another message: that China does not want to be a global leader that uses power in the same way as the US.
Iran's Minister of Foreign Affairs Abbas Araghchi mets Russian counterpart Sergei Lavrov of a Shanghai Cooperation Organization meeting on July 15 in Tianjin, China.
Russian Ministry of Foreign Affair/Anadolu/Getty Images
China's security vision
The propaganda machine of China's ruling Communist Party has long decried America's 'hegemony' and its 'wanton use' of force as its rolls out examples of US' involvement in multiple conflicts of recent decades.
Frictions with Washington over trade and tech make selling that messaging more important for Beijing, as it needs friends now more than ever. And it sees US President Donald Trump's brash 'America First' foreign policy as creating an opening there.
Over the past decade, Chinese aggression to enforce its disputed claims in the South China Sea, its military intimidation of Taiwan, and the growing reach of its expanded navy, whose aircraft carrier strike groups recently conducted drills further from home shores and in greater strength than ever before, have raised alarm among its neighbors – and fueled Washington's urgent warnings to its allies against dealing too closely with China.
Beijing has cried 'hypocrisy' and, in 2022, Chinese leader Xi Jinping unveiled his own vision for global security architecture – short on detail, but clear that it opposed the US-led alliance system and military intervention.
That vision has brought together Xi and Russian President Vladimir Putin, whose shared mistrust for NATO – and view that it's a provocative actor – is a key point of alignment, and a subtext for why Beijing has never condemned Russia's invasion of Ukraine.
Experts say China's apparent lack of a role even in mediating the conflict between Israel and Iran, a country with which Beijing has deep historic and economic ties, shows the limits of its influence in the region.
But they also say Beijing has little interest in wading into the region's security as a power player.
'In terms of providing mediation, (China) has offered and is more than willing … but it has little capacity to project military power in the Middle East, and even less political will to be openly and directly involved,' said William Figueroa, an expert of China-Iran relations and an assistant professor at the University of Groningen in the Netherlands.
Unlike the US, which maintains substantial military assets to back its allies and interests in the region, China's on the ground military presence is limited to a naval base in the Horn of Africa nation of Djibouti. Indeed, Beijing's only military alliance is a historic one with neighboring and fellow one-party communist state North Korea.
Beijing also shied away from joining international efforts last winter to protect key shipping lanes under attack from Houthi rebels in Yemen following Israel's war on Gaza.
The attacks put China's commercial interests at risk even though the Houthis said they won't target Chinese or Russian vessels. And when it comes to efforts to push for a ceasefire between Israel and Hamas in Gaza, China has again been on the sidelines, despite positioning itself as leading international voice calling for a ceasefire and criticizing Israel's war.
Some experts have argued that if China had more global military might then it may throw around that weight more outside its own region.
But in the Israel-Iran conflict, Beijing's focus was instead on 'presenting its support for international law as a superior alternative to what it portrays as the West's militaristic, unlawful interventions,' according to Tong Zhao, a senior fellow at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.
'While this narrative has limited traction among Middle Eastern states, it plays well in the Global South—where it serves to burnish China's image and reinforce its strategic competition with Washington at the global level,' Zhao added.
Iran's Defense Minister Aziz Nasirzadeh (second from left) joins SCO counterparts in a meeting in China's Qingdao a day after the Israel-Iran ceasefire last month.
Pedro Pardo/AFP/Getty Images
Fair weather friends?
Even if Beijing's reaction was not surprising to Tehran, going to China and 'acting like everything's great' may have a been 'a bitter pill to swallow' for Araghchi and Iran's Defense Minister Aziz Nasirzadeh as both traveled to China in recent weeks, according to Jonathan Fulton, a senior fellow for the Atlantic Council's Middle East Programs.
Beijing and Tehran have no mutual defense treaty, and the relationship has largely been an economic one. China takes more than 90% of Iran's oil trade, imported through intermediaries, which totaled some $40 billion in profits for Iran last year, according to Muyu Xu, a senior oil analyst at trade intelligence firm Kpler.
Even when it comes to China's closest international partner, Russia, Beijing has tread carefully: stopping short of large-scale supply of military goods for Moscow's war in Ukraine, instead buying up Russian fuel and supplying it with dual-use goods that can power its defense industrial base.
That support, and more direct military backing from Iran and North Korea for Russia's war, has raised alarm in the West about emerging coordination among members into a so-called anti-American 'axis.'
But the latest stress-test of the 'axis' appeared to show its weaknesses: as Israeli and US bombs rained down on Iran, Russia and China looked more focused on their own interests and rhetoric, analysts say, rather than backing Iran materially or using their weight to push Israel or the US to stop the fighting. Xi and Putin did, however, use the conflict to stress their own united front.
That said, when it comes to ties with Iran, the real test is likely what's next.
'This is a good example (that) there are limitations to what China's going to do in terms of direct intervention in a military conflict,' Brian Hart, a fellow of the China Power Project at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) think tank, said during a recent talk held by the Washington-based center. But 'it's too soon to count China's support for Iran out.'
China's model for Russia of 'largely walking right up to that line of not providing overt military support,' could become a dynamic that develops here, Hart said, as Beijing looks to help the regime in Tehran say in power. Dual-use Chinese-made chemicals needed to produce missile fuel were delivered to Iran earlier this year, CNN reporting shows.
Even still, Beijing may be looking more skeptically at Iran as a powerful partner in the region in light of the country's 'inability to project power to defend its airspace' against Israel last month, according to Atlantic Council's Fulton.
And when it comes to how the latest events may impact any coordination between the so-called 'axis' countries, the fundamentals have not changed, he said.
Far from being an alliance or a bloc like those in the West, China, Iran, Russia and North Korea have an 'alignment of grievances' against the West, but 'very different ideas' of how to reshape global rules to address that, Fulton said.
And for Beijing, 'what it needs in the Middle East is economically motivated – it needs a stable region, and Iran doesn't really support that. Iran causes as many problems as it solves for Beijing.'
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

French move, global outrage at starving Gaza put recognizing Palestine on map in Europe - War on Gaza
French move, global outrage at starving Gaza put recognizing Palestine on map in Europe - War on Gaza

Al-Ahram Weekly

timean hour ago

  • Al-Ahram Weekly

French move, global outrage at starving Gaza put recognizing Palestine on map in Europe - War on Gaza

Israel's genocidal war and starvation policies in Gaza have sent shivers down the spines of millions around the world and reignited a momentum in several European countries to push leaders to recognise Palestinian statehood. Pressures on various European capitals to return to demanding that Israel accepts a two-state solution increased after French President Emmanuel Macron announced on Thursday that his country would recognise a Palestinian state in September at the upcoming UN General Assembly. The French announcement of intent to become the 143rd country to recognize Palestinian Statehood was met with warm praise in the Arab world from Egypt, Jordan, the Arab Gulf States, and the Palestinian presidency. In the UK, MPs and broad segments of the public were pressuring the government of Prime Minister Keir Starmer to follow in the French steps. In Germany and Italy, two countries that have long supported the two-state solution to the Israel-Palestine conflict in principle, the governments of Chancellor Friedrich Merz and Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni said that while they support a ceasefire in the Gaza war and unfettered entry of aid to alleviate the suffering of the Palestinians but the timing for recognizing aPalestinian statehood might not be right. For nearly two years, endless pro-Palestinian demonstrations across Europe pressured several governments into coming out against the Israeli war, but could not pressure them into recognizing Palestinian statehood. The French announcement came a few days after France, the UK, and Italy joined 23 European nations and Japan, New Zealand, and Australia in calling for an immediate end to the Israeli war in Gaza and the unfettered entry of aid to the strip to prevent famine in the strip. Earlier this month, the EU rejected a proposal put forward by Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez, whose government has led the charge in opposing the Israeli war in Gaza from its start within the old continent, to suspend the EU-Israel Association agreement and block imports from illegal Israeli settlements in the occupied West Bank over Israeli violations of international law. This week, in several European capitals, demonstrations and outrage by broad segments of the public over the death of starving Palestinians on top of 200,000 killed and wounded since October 2023, plus calls by many left-leaning and pro-Palestinian MPs for recognition of the State of Palestine, have increased pressure on several European governments to consider the matter. These public calls in the old continent for leaders to recognise Palestinian statehood have also intensified in the past several days as the images of dead or dying, starving, and emaciated Palestinians, including children, due to the five-month-old Israeli blockade on any food or water to Gaza. They also intensified after Israel and the US walked away from ceasefire talks with Hamas, mediated by Egypt and Qatar, dashing hopes among many around the world that the carnage in Gaza was nearing its end. On Friday, Ireland's Prime Minister Micheál Martin, a staunch opponent of the Israeli war in Gaza, welcomed France's move, calling it 'very significant' and noting it would make France the first G7 nation to take such a step. Ireland, Spain and Norway formally recognized Palestine in May 2024. Mounting pressure In Westminster, a parliamentary report published Friday urged immediate recognition of Palestinian statehood. 'The UK has missed multiple opportunities to act decisively in the past. We must not let another opportunity pass us by,' wrote Emily Thornberry, the chair of the Foreign Affairs Committee in the UK Parliament. Senior Labour figures have expressed support for recognition, while the Liberal Democrats have warned that the UK must not 'fall behind' its European allies. Also on Friday, more than 220 MPs called on Prime Minister Keir Starmer to formally recognise the State of Palestine, less than 24 hours after France announced its intention to do so, according to AFP. The demand came in a letter organised by Labour MP Sarah Champion, who chairs the International Development Committee, Sky News reported. The letter stated that UK recognition would carry particular weight, given Britain's authorship of the Balfour Declaration and its former role as the Mandatory Power in Palestine. "Since 1980 we have backed a two-state solution. Such recognition would give that position substance, as well as fulfil a historic responsibility to the people under that Mandate," it added. So far, Downing Street has resisted these calls, insisting a ceasefire in Israel's war on Gaza must come first. Ministers have maintained that sovereignty should only be recognised 'at the moment of attaining statehood.' On Friday, Germany, a staunch ally of Israel, said it had "no plans to recognise a Palestinian state in the short term." A government spokesperson said Berlin considers recognition one of the final steps toward a two-state solution, adding: "Israel's security is of paramount importance to the German government." Along the same lines, Italian Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani said that while Rome could not accept the "carnage and famine" in Gaza, it was not ready to join France. "We can no longer accept carnage and famine," he said, according to ANSA. He added Italy would only recognise a Palestinian state "at the same time as their recognition of the state of Israel." Italian Prime Minister Meloni called the situation in Gaza "dramatic" on Wednesday, stating: "No military action can justify attacks against civilians." The UK PM Starmer was expected to join an emergency call with Macron and Chancellor Merz to discuss the spiralling humanitarian crisis. More than 100 humanitarian organisations have warned of imminent famine. On Friday, Médecins Sans Frontières (MSF) said its teams are "witnessing catastrophic levels of malnutrition", reporting that one in four young children and pregnant women screened were malnourished. Follow us on: Facebook Instagram Whatsapp Short link:

French move, global outrage at starvation in Gaza pressure Europe leaders on recognizing Palestinian statehood - War on Gaza
French move, global outrage at starvation in Gaza pressure Europe leaders on recognizing Palestinian statehood - War on Gaza

Al-Ahram Weekly

time2 hours ago

  • Al-Ahram Weekly

French move, global outrage at starvation in Gaza pressure Europe leaders on recognizing Palestinian statehood - War on Gaza

Israel's genocidal war and starvation policies in Gaza have sent shivers down the spines of millions around the world and reignited a momentum in several European countries to push leaders to recognise Palestinian statehood. Pressures on various European capitals to return to demanding that Israel accepts a two-state solution increased after French President Emmanuel Macron announced on Thursday that his country would recognise a Palestinian state in September at the upcoming UN General Assembly. The French announcement of intent to become the 143rd country to recognize Palestinian Statehood was met with warm praise in the Arab world from Egypt, Jordan, the Arab Gulf States, and the Palestinian presidency. In the UK, MPs and broad segments of the public were pressuring the government of Prime Minister Keir Starmer to follow in the French steps. In Germany and Italy, two countries that have long supported the two-state solution to the Israel-Palestine conflict in principle, the governments of Chancellor Friedrich Merz and Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni said that while they support a ceasefire in the Gaza war and unfettered entry of aid to alleviate the suffering of the Palestinians but the timing for recognizing aPalestinian statehood might not be right. For nearly two years, endless pro-Palestinian demonstrations across Europe pressured several governments into coming out against the Israeli war, but could not pressure them into recognizing Palestinian statehood. The French announcement came a few days after France, the UK, and Italy joined 23 European nations and Japan, New Zealand, and Australia in calling for an immediate end to the Israeli war in Gaza and the unfettered entry of aid to the strip to prevent famine in the strip. Earlier this month, the EU rejected a proposal put forward by Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez, whose government has led the charge in opposing the Israeli war in Gaza from its start within the old continent, to suspend the EU-Israel Association agreement and block imports from illegal Israeli settlements in the occupied West Bank over Israeli violations of international law. This week, in several European capitals, demonstrations and outrage by broad segments of the public over the death of starving Palestinians on top of 200,000 killed and wounded since October 2023, plus calls by many left-leaning and pro-Palestinian MPs for recognition of the State of Palestine, have increased pressure on several European governments to consider the matter. These public calls in the old continent for leaders to recognise Palestinian statehood have also intensified in the past several days as the images of dead or dying, starving, and emaciated Palestinians, including children, due to the five-month-old Israeli blockade on any food or water to Gaza. They also intensified after Israel and the US walked away from ceasefire talks with Hamas, mediated by Egypt and Qatar, dashing hopes among many around the world that the carnage in Gaza was nearing its end. On Friday, Ireland's Prime Minister Micheál Martin, a staunch opponent of the Israeli war in Gaza, welcomed France's move, calling it 'very significant' and noting it would make France the first G7 nation to take such a step. Ireland, Spain and Norway formally recognized Palestine in May 2024. Mounting pressure In Westminster, a parliamentary report published Friday urged immediate recognition of Palestinian statehood. 'The UK has missed multiple opportunities to act decisively in the past. We must not let another opportunity pass us by,' wrote Emily Thornberry, the chair of the Foreign Affairs Committee in the UK Parliament. Senior Labour figures have expressed support for recognition, while the Liberal Democrats have warned that the UK must not 'fall behind' its European allies. Also on Friday, more than 220 MPs called on Prime Minister Keir Starmer to formally recognise the State of Palestine, less than 24 hours after France announced its intention to do so, according to AFP. The demand came in a letter organised by a Labour MP who chairs the International Development Committee, Sky News reported. The letter stated that UK recognition would carry particular weight, given Britain's authorship of the Balfour Declaration and its former role as the Mandatory Power in Palestine. "Since 198,0 we have backed a two-state solution. Such recognition would give that position substance, as well as fulfil a historic responsibility to the people under that Mandate," it added. So far, Downing Street has resisted these calls, insisting a ceasefire in Israel's war on Gaza must come first. Ministers have maintained that sovereignty should only be recognised 'at the moment of attaining statehood.' On Friday, Germany, a staunch ally of Israel, said it had "no plans to recognise a Palestinian state in the short term." A government spokesperson said Berlin considers recognition one of the final steps toward a two-state solution, adding: "Israel's security is of paramount importance to the German government." Along the same lines, Italian Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani said that while Rome could not accept the "carnage and famine" in Gaza, it was not ready to join France. "We can no longer accept carnage and famine," he said, according to ANSA. He added Italy would only recognise a Palestinian state "at the same time as their recognition of the state of Israel." Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni called the situation in Gaza "dramatic" on Wednesday, stating: "No military action can justify attacks against civilians." The UK PM Starmer was expected to join an emergency call with Macron and Germany's Friedrich Merz to discuss the spiralling humanitarian crisis. More than 100 humanitarian organisations have warned of imminent famine. Médecins Sans Frontières (MSF) said its teams are "witnessing catastrophic levels of malnutrition", reporting that one in four young children and pregnant women screened were malnourished, according to the BBC. Follow us on: Facebook Instagram Whatsapp Short link:

Global outrage at starvation in Gaza pressures European leaders on recognizing State of Palestine - War on Gaza
Global outrage at starvation in Gaza pressures European leaders on recognizing State of Palestine - War on Gaza

Al-Ahram Weekly

time2 hours ago

  • Al-Ahram Weekly

Global outrage at starvation in Gaza pressures European leaders on recognizing State of Palestine - War on Gaza

Israel's genocidal war and starvation policies in Gaza have sent shivers down the spines of millions around the world and reignited a momentum in several European countries to push leaders to recognise Palestinian statehood. Pressures on various European capitals to return to demanding that Israel accepts a two-state solution increased after French President Emmanuel Macron announced on Thursday that his country would recognise a Palestinian state in September at the upcoming UN General Assembly. The French announcement of intent to become the 143rd country to recognize Palestinian Statehood was met with warm praise in the Arab world from Egypt, Jordan, the Arab Gulf States, and the Palestinian presidency. In the UK, MPs and broad segments of the public were pressuring the government of Prime Minister Keir Starmer to follow in the French steps. In Germany and Italy, two countries that have long supported the two-state solution to the Israel-Palestine conflict in principle, the governments of Chancellor Friedrich Merz and Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni said that while they support a ceasefire in the Gaza war and unfettered entry of aid to alleviate the suffering of the Palestinians but the timing for recognizing aPalestinian statehood might not be right. For nearly two years, endless pro-Palestinian demonstrations across Europe pressured several governments into coming out against the Israeli war, but could not pressure them into recognizing Palestinian statehood. The French announcement came a few days after France, the UK, and Italy joined 23 European nations and Japan, New Zealand, and Australia in calling for an immediate end to the Israeli war in Gaza and the unfettered entry of aid to the strip to prevent famine in the strip. Earlier this month, the EU rejected a proposal put forward by Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez, whose government has led the charge in opposing the Israeli war in Gaza from its start within the old continent, to suspend the EU-Israel Association agreement and block imports from illegal Israeli settlements in the occupied West Bank over Israeli violations of international law. This week, in several European capitals, demonstrations and outrage by broad segments of the public over the death of starving Palestinians on top of 200,000 killed and wounded since October 2023, plus calls by many left-leaning and pro-Palestinian MPs for recognition of the State of Palestine, have increased pressure on several European governments to consider the matter. These public calls in the old continent for leaders to recognise Palestinian statehood have also intensified in the past several days as the images of dead or dying, starving, and emaciated Palestinians, including children, due to the five-month-old Israeli blockade on any food or water to Gaza. They also intensified after Israel and the US walked away from ceasefire talks with Hamas, mediated by Egypt and Qatar, dashing hopes among many around the world that the carnage in Gaza was nearing its end. On Friday, Ireland's Prime Minister Micheál Martin, a staunch opponent of the Israeli war in Gaza, welcomed France's move, calling it 'very significant' and noting it would make France the first G7 nation to take such a step. Ireland, Spain and Norway formally recognized Palestine in May 2024. Mounting pressure In Westminster, a parliamentary report published Friday urged immediate recognition of Palestinian statehood. 'The UK has missed multiple opportunities to act decisively in the past. We must not let another opportunity pass us by,' wrote Emily Thornberry, the chair of the Foreign Affairs Committee in the UK Parliament. Senior Labour figures have expressed support for recognition, while the Liberal Democrats have warned that the UK must not 'fall behind' its European allies. Also on Friday, more than 220 MPs called on Prime Minister Keir Starmer to formally recognise the State of Palestine, less than 24 hours after France announced its intention to do so, according to AFP. The demand came in a letter organised by a Labour MP who chairs the International Development Committee, Sky News reported. The letter stated that UK recognition would carry particular weight, given Britain's authorship of the Balfour Declaration and its former role as the Mandatory Power in Palestine. "Since 198,0 we have backed a two-state solution. Such recognition would give that position substance, as well as fulfil a historic responsibility to the people under that Mandate," it added. So far, Downing Street has resisted these calls, insisting a ceasefire in Israel's war on Gaza must come first. Ministers have maintained that sovereignty should only be recognised 'at the moment of attaining statehood.' On Friday, Germany, a staunch ally of Israel, said it had "no plans to recognise a Palestinian state in the short term." A government spokesperson said Berlin considers recognition one of the final steps toward a two-state solution, adding: "Israel's security is of paramount importance to the German government." Along the same lines, Italian Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani said that while Rome could not accept the "carnage and famine" in Gaza, it was not ready to join France. "We can no longer accept carnage and famine," he said, according to ANSA. He added Italy would only recognise a Palestinian state "at the same time as their recognition of the state of Israel." Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni called the situation in Gaza "dramatic" on Wednesday, stating: "No military action can justify attacks against civilians." The UK PM Starmer was expected to join an emergency call with Macron and Germany's Friedrich Merz to discuss the spiralling humanitarian crisis. More than 100 humanitarian organisations have warned of imminent famine. Médecins Sans Frontières (MSF) said its teams are "witnessing catastrophic levels of malnutrition", reporting that one in four young children and pregnant women screened were malnourished, according to the BBC. Follow us on: Facebook Instagram Whatsapp Short link:

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store