logo
Post-Pahalgam

Post-Pahalgam

Time of India25-04-2025

Security lapse questions need clear answers. LoC/border infra needs massive upgrade
Undeniably, Pahalgam has been a huge blow to India's security apparatus in J&K. Now, SOPs must be overhauled, systems reoriented, and coordination between agencies sharpened. But the revamp must begin with some tough questions. Was Baisaran Valley opened up to tourists much earlier than other years? Some reports say the area is usually open to visitors during the Amarnath Yatra, when there are stringent security arrangements. Whether or not local hoteliers and tour operators failed to inform authorities about tourist movement isn't clear. Were arrangements this week different to those in the last tourist season? Local tourism industry is arguing that govt didn't provide them with any alerts ahead of the tourist influx. Clearly, vital coordination between security forces and local businesses fell through the cracks.
Border lacunae: Note also that the terrorists had better eyes on the situation, saw an opportunity and struck. This shows that terrorists are constantly probing for weaknesses. That's why terrorists need to be stopped at the border/LoC itself. But there are multiple lacunae with border infra too. Govt had launched the Comprehensive Integrated Border Management System project after the 2016 Pathankot attack to upgrade border fencing with state-of-the-art surveillance systems. But it remains a work in progress, having missed two deadlines in 2018 and 2023.
Bureaucracy that kills: Plus, routine weather-related challenges with border fencing management remain. Damage to fencing due to winter snow takes months to repair because of both terrain and bureaucratic delays. Battery-operated surveillance equipment such as night-vision devices drain power quickly in the cold and can't be charged due to lack of power at many places along the border. Repairs to sensitive surveillance radar can take weeks. Fuel for generators that run searchlights often runs low. Even electrified fencing has proved to be ineffective in some places due to lack of steady electricity supply and low voltage. These leave gaps in the border fencing that terrorists exploit.
Smuggling-terror nexus: Arms – including weapons for Nato – are being smuggled into Punjab via drones. A similar smuggling route exists via Nepal. Nato-grade weapons have been seized from terrorists in J&K. This is happening under our noses. Why hasn't govt been able to crack down on the influx of smuggled weapons?
Response failure: Former army commanders are calling Pahalgam an intelligence failure. It's a familiar pattern, but the history of terrorist attacks this century shows the charge is misplaced. While the facts of Pahalgam are yet to be established, the Oct 7, 2023 Hamas attack, Pulwama, Uri, 26/11, and 9/11 all point to a different problem – 'response failure'. There were warnings in all these cases that weren't acted upon. America's 9/11 Commission report summed up the problem well: 'No analytic work foresaw the lightning that could connect the thundercloud to the ground.' And 9/11 was a colossal response failure. Leads about a possible attack had been coming in all summer, yet 'as late as Sep 4' govt didn't have an answer to the question, 'Is al Qaeda a big deal?' Before 26/11, India received warnings of a major attack from its own sources and US. As for Pulwama, Frontline found there were at least 11 intelligence inputs between Jan 2 and Feb 13, 2019 – a day before the attack. Israel had been getting warnings of Hamas's invasion plan since 2018. At least, its security agency, Shin Bet, has formally accepted its lapses within 18 months. In India, probes take long, and mea culpas are unheard of.
So, the least we expect after Pahalgam is a timely inquiry, and publication of its findings to restore people's confidence. Govt owes it to the 26 victims of the massacre, and to Kashmir, which needs to return to normalcy.
Facebook Twitter Linkedin Email
This piece appeared as an editorial opinion in the print edition of The Times of India.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

'Like cat guarding milk': Rajnath Singh slams UNSC for naming Pakistan in anti-terror panel; says PoK will join 'Bharat' soon
'Like cat guarding milk': Rajnath Singh slams UNSC for naming Pakistan in anti-terror panel; says PoK will join 'Bharat' soon

Time of India

time34 minutes ago

  • Time of India

'Like cat guarding milk': Rajnath Singh slams UNSC for naming Pakistan in anti-terror panel; says PoK will join 'Bharat' soon

Defence minister Rajnath Singh addresses a gathering during a dialogue on the topic 'National Security & Terrorism', in Dehradun. (PTI) NEW DELHI: Defence minister Rajnath Singh on Tuesday criticised the United Nations Security Council (UNSC) for appointing Pakistan as the vice-chair of its counter-terrorism panel. Singh said this decision is similar to "making the cat guard the milk" as Pakistan has a known history of protecting and supporting terrorists. "What is astonishing is that this Counter-Terrorism panel, was formed after the 9/11 terror attacks. Pakistan had sheltered the mastermind of the 9/11 attacks. This (decision) is akin to cat guarding the milk," Singh said. At an event in Dehradun, Singh said Pakistan has supported terrorism for many years and described Operation Sindoor, which was carried out in response to the Pahalgam attack, as the "biggest action" against terrorism in India's history. Singh pointed out that both India and Pakistan became independent at the same time, but while India is now seen as the "mother of democracy", Pakistan has gained the label of "father of global terrorism". He said this comparison should be kept in mind. Singh also said Pakistan is "stubborn" and needs to be dealt with using "strategic, diplomatic and economic pressure" from the global community to stop terrorism from its land. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 3.5, 4.5 BHK Homes starting at ₹4.89 Cr.* Hero Homes Learn More Undo "Pakistan has always given shelter to terrorists, trained them on its soil and helped them. Pahalgam (attack) was just an example, but I want to tell you that list of Pakistan-aided terrorists is very long. And, Pakistan always tries to justify terrorism. So, it is important that we eliminate not just these terrorists but the entire terror infrastructure that aids them," he said. He added that Pakistan has not been able to stop development in Kashmir despite efforts. "Udhampur-Srinagar-Baramulla railway link is a shining example of the government's relentless pursuit of progress in Jammu & Kashmir. Soon, PoK will join us and say 'I, too, am Bharat'," he said. Shashi Tharoor, Priyanka Chaturvedi Share Key Insights After Meeting PM Modi At His Residence Calling terrorism a problem for humanity and a global issue, Singh said that no society should accept it. He also mentioned that some people glorify terrorists as "freedom fighters" and said, "no revolution is born out of the womb of terrorism, it only engenders destruction and hatred". Singh further stated that "No religious, ideological or political reason can justify terrorism. No human objective can ever be achieved through bloodshed and violence." He said Pakistan supports terrorism and a large portion of its foreign aid is used to fund this support. "Funding Pakistan means funding the infrastructure of terrorism. Pakistan is a nursery of terrorism. It should not be nourished," he said, asking other countries to stop giving money to Pakistan. Singh said that Pakistan's land has been a shelter for global terror groups. He named terrorists like Hafiz Saeed and Masood Azhar who move freely there, and added that even senior officers of the Pakistan Army have attended terrorists' funerals. "Now, the same country is expected to lead the global community against terrorism. This raises serious questions on the intentions and policies of the international system," he said. Singh urged the international community and organisations like the UN to take the issue of terrorism seriously. He said, "Only when we are free from terrorism, will we be able to move towards the goal of global peace, progress and prosperity."

In New Video, US Spy Chief Tulsi Gabbard Slams Warmongers, Warns Of Nuclear Holocaust
In New Video, US Spy Chief Tulsi Gabbard Slams Warmongers, Warns Of Nuclear Holocaust

News18

timean hour ago

  • News18

In New Video, US Spy Chief Tulsi Gabbard Slams Warmongers, Warns Of Nuclear Holocaust

Last Updated: In a foreboding video clip released on X, Gabbard warned of a 'nuclear holocaust' and blamed certain leaders for bringing the world closer to a nuclear war. US Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard has warned the world is closer than ever to 'nuclear annihilation" in a stark three-minute video shared on social media this week. The video shows Gabbard walking through Hiroshima, Japan, where she recently travelled to learn about the aftermath of the 1945 US atomic bombing. Archival footage from the nuclear attack, including images of victims, is interspersed with Gabbard's direct-to-camera remarks. She blamed 'political elite warmongers" for escalating tensions between nuclear powers and claims many of them feel immune from the consequences. 'They believe they'll be safe in nuclear shelters," she says. She then calls on the public to act: 'It's up to us, the people, to speak up and demand an end to this madness. We must reject this path to nuclear war and work toward a world where no one has to live in fear of a nuclear holocaust." I recently visited Hiroshima, and stood at the epicenter of a city scarred by the unimaginable horror caused by a single nuclear bomb dropped in 1945. What I saw, the stories I heard, and the haunting sadness that remains, will stay with me forever. — Tulsi Gabbard 🌺 (@TulsiGabbard) June 10, 2025 It remains unclear when the video was recorded. Gabbard's office has not clarified whether it was made using government resources. She visited Japan last week and toured a US military base with Ambassador George Glass. Her earlier trip to Japan in March did not include a stop in Hiroshima. The former Democratic congresswoman and 2020 presidential hopeful has long criticized foreign interventions and warned about the threat of nuclear conflict. Her comments this week echo earlier warnings. In 2019, during her campaign launch, she said the world was 'on the precipice of nuclear war." She later supported Trump's candidacy and switched parties in 2023. In a post last year, she said: 'The warmongers are trying to drag us into WW3, which can only end in one way: nuclear annihilation and the suffering and death of all our loved ones. Zelensky, Biden, NATO, congressional and media neocons are insane. And we are insane if we passively allow them to lead us into this holocaust like sheep to the slaughter." First Published: June 10, 2025, 22:50 IST

Why did AIMIM chief Asaduddin Owaisi skip Op Sindoor all-party delegations' meet with PM Modi?
Why did AIMIM chief Asaduddin Owaisi skip Op Sindoor all-party delegations' meet with PM Modi?

Hindustan Times

timean hour ago

  • Hindustan Times

Why did AIMIM chief Asaduddin Owaisi skip Op Sindoor all-party delegations' meet with PM Modi?

AIMIM chief Asaduddin Owaisi, who was a part of one of the diplomatic delegations, was notably absent from the high-profile all-party delegation meeting with Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Tuesday evening. His absence from the event soon prompted questions, which Owaisi later clarified that he had to urgently travel to Dubai due to a medical emergency involving a close relative and childhood friend. "I am out of the country. I had to go to Dubai due to a medical emergency. I had to go suddenly due to the ill health of my relative and childhood friend. I informed my delegation leader, Baijayant Panda, about this," ANI news agency quoted Owaisi as saying. Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Tuesday met members of the all-party global delegation under Operation Sindoor global outreach on Tuesday at 7 pm at his official residence, Lok Kalyan Marg. Delegation members briefed the Prime Minister about their meetings in different nations. The delegations, consisting of MPs from across party lines, former MPs and distinguished diplomats, highlighted India's stand against terror and commitment to world peace during their visits to various nations. Prime Minister Narendra Modi said he was proud of how the multi-party delegations presented India's views in various countries on the need to eradicate the menace of terrorism following the Pahalgam attack and Operation Sindoor. "Met members of the various delegations who represented India in different countries and elaborated on India's commitment to peace and the need to eradicate the menace of terrorism. We are all proud of how they put forward India's voice," Modi said in a post on X. The Indian government had sent the multi-party delegations to portray a message of national unity in the fight against terrorism, with the likes of Congress MP Shashi Tharoor and AIMIM MP Asaduddin Owaisi joining the ruling alliance members in championing the Indian cause abroad. Prominent former parliamentarians in the delegations included ex-Union ministers Ghulam Nabi Azad and Salman Khurshid. Four delegations were led by MPs of the ruling alliance, including two from the BJP, one from JD(U) and one from Shiv Sena, while three were led by opposition MPs, one each of the Congress, DMK and NCP(SP). BJP's Ravi Shankar Prasad and Baijyant Panda, Congress's Shashi Tharoor, JD(U)'s Sanjay Jha, Shiv Sena's Shrikant Shinde, DMK's Kanimozhi, and NCP (SP)'s Supriya Sule led their delegations to different parts of the world.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store