Farmers 'frustrated' over exclusion and small payments under Young Farmers Scheme
IFA
The IFA (Irish Farmers' Association) has called on agriculture minister Martin Heydon to deliver a more ambitious Young Farmers Scheme.
IFA rural development chair John Curran said: 'After years in the making and countless political promises to finally support 'forgotten farmers', we've a scheme on the table that falls far short of expectations and will again exclude many farmers from necessary support.
"Our regional offices are getting calls daily from frustrated farmers, with complaints over those excluded, the short window to apply, and small potential payment, etc.
'We've looked for a meeting with the minister to try to get some resolution here. Our view is clear. Commitments made in Budget 2025 for increased funding allocations will need to be honoured.
A more ambitious Young Farmer Scheme has to be delivered that caters for all eligible farmers, including those starting out in 2008 and thereafter. The support must be at least equivalent to what they would have received under the installation aid,' Mr Curran added.
Mr Curran also said the three-week application window, which ends August 13, is far too tight for farmers to secure documentation and submit their applications online.
'Farmers are finding it difficult to get queries addressed and assemble the required supporting documentation (eg educational qualifications, etc) to accompany applications. This must be extended to a more realistic timeframe,' he added.
ICMSA
The Irish Creamery Milk Suppliers Association (ICMSA) has doubled down on the issues with the deadline, with deputy president Eamon Carroll repeating his call for an extension for the application deadlines.
Mr Carroll said the deadline for applications should be pushed back to the end of September to accommodate farmers who are scrambling to find the necessary documentation to apply, which is proving near impossible within the time frame set out by the Department of Agriculture.
He said: 'There are numerous instances where farmers who are trying to apply for the scheme can't contact their advisers who are on normal holidays. Even more frustrating are the cases where farmers are trying to attain their relevant records from their agriculture college that are closed over the summer.
"It would surely make sense for the application deadline to be pushed to at least 30 September when normal administration resumes, and it would be that much easier to access the records and information that the department itself is insisting accompany applications to the scheme?'
Mr Carroll said the scheme's introduction was a step in the right direction, but the unrealistic deadline had wiped out any good intentions the announcement represented. He added it was 'very obvious' some form of phase two should be added to the scheme to accommodate those who were excluded within the current requirements of the scheme.
'There is still significant concern that the 'cut-off' date of December 31, 2007, has excluded many farmers — the very individuals who began farming just as we were about to enter a period of national economic hardship, with very limited supports for young farmers.
"In the context of the calls and feedback we are getting, that are surely being communicated to the other stakeholders, it's very obvious that we need a second tranche or phase two that deals with those individuals.
"We don't think the numbers are excessive, and neither would the amounts involved. But they have a completely valid case to be covered, and we think that on reflection the minister would be wise to fix all the problem, once and for all,' Mr Carroll added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
a day ago
- Irish Independent
Suckler farmers can now earn up to €225 per cow/calf pair, says Minister Heydon, as 2025 Beef Welfare Scheme opens
The standalone Beef Welfare Scheme offers payments of up to €35 per eligible calf, with a maximum of 45 calves per herd, an increase from 40 last year. Additional optional payments include €15 per calf for vaccination against clostridial diseases and/or calf pneumonia, and €25 per calf for faecal or forage testing. Minister Heydon said: 'This year's scheme represents a substantial increase in funding for suckler farmers. The measures are practical and aimed at optimising calf performance throughout its lifetime, while supporting the economic efficiency and welfare standards of the herd.' The BWS is open to farmers aged 18 or over with an active herd number, who have eligible suckler calves born between 1 July 2024 and 30 June 2025, and who submit a 2025 Basic Income Support for Sustainability (BISS) application. Applications must be made online via by 11.59pm on 24 September 2025. Payments for validated applications will commence in December 2025. Farmers should keep receipts for meal feeding, vaccination, and testing, as these may be requested to facilitate payment. The IFA has sought removal of the upper limit on eligible animals per herd, warning that the cap restricts the scheme's benefits for larger suckler farms. Payments are available through three actions: Action 1 – Meal Feeding (Mandatory): €35 per eligible calf for up to 45 calves. Calves must be meal-fed for four weeks pre-weaning and two weeks post-weaning to reduce stress at weaning. Action 2 – Vaccination (Optional): €15 per eligible calf for up to 45 calves. Vaccinations must cover clostridial diseases and/or calf pneumonia, with records kept for submission. Action 3 – Faecal or Forage Testing (Optional): €25 per eligible calf for up to 45 calves. Farmers may carry out two faecal tests at least four weeks apart, or submit three forage samples for analysis. Full terms and conditions, including penalties for non-compliance, are available on
Irish Examiner
a day ago
- Irish Examiner
Farmers 'frustrated' over exclusion and small payments under Young Farmers Scheme
Farming organisations have called for more to be done regarding the long-established Young Farmers Scheme. IFA The IFA (Irish Farmers' Association) has called on agriculture minister Martin Heydon to deliver a more ambitious Young Farmers Scheme. IFA rural development chair John Curran said: 'After years in the making and countless political promises to finally support 'forgotten farmers', we've a scheme on the table that falls far short of expectations and will again exclude many farmers from necessary support. "Our regional offices are getting calls daily from frustrated farmers, with complaints over those excluded, the short window to apply, and small potential payment, etc. 'We've looked for a meeting with the minister to try to get some resolution here. Our view is clear. Commitments made in Budget 2025 for increased funding allocations will need to be honoured. A more ambitious Young Farmer Scheme has to be delivered that caters for all eligible farmers, including those starting out in 2008 and thereafter. The support must be at least equivalent to what they would have received under the installation aid,' Mr Curran added. Mr Curran also said the three-week application window, which ends August 13, is far too tight for farmers to secure documentation and submit their applications online. 'Farmers are finding it difficult to get queries addressed and assemble the required supporting documentation (eg educational qualifications, etc) to accompany applications. This must be extended to a more realistic timeframe,' he added. ICMSA The Irish Creamery Milk Suppliers Association (ICMSA) has doubled down on the issues with the deadline, with deputy president Eamon Carroll repeating his call for an extension for the application deadlines. Mr Carroll said the deadline for applications should be pushed back to the end of September to accommodate farmers who are scrambling to find the necessary documentation to apply, which is proving near impossible within the time frame set out by the Department of Agriculture. He said: 'There are numerous instances where farmers who are trying to apply for the scheme can't contact their advisers who are on normal holidays. Even more frustrating are the cases where farmers are trying to attain their relevant records from their agriculture college that are closed over the summer. "It would surely make sense for the application deadline to be pushed to at least 30 September when normal administration resumes, and it would be that much easier to access the records and information that the department itself is insisting accompany applications to the scheme?' Mr Carroll said the scheme's introduction was a step in the right direction, but the unrealistic deadline had wiped out any good intentions the announcement represented. He added it was 'very obvious' some form of phase two should be added to the scheme to accommodate those who were excluded within the current requirements of the scheme. 'There is still significant concern that the 'cut-off' date of December 31, 2007, has excluded many farmers — the very individuals who began farming just as we were about to enter a period of national economic hardship, with very limited supports for young farmers. "In the context of the calls and feedback we are getting, that are surely being communicated to the other stakeholders, it's very obvious that we need a second tranche or phase two that deals with those individuals. "We don't think the numbers are excessive, and neither would the amounts involved. But they have a completely valid case to be covered, and we think that on reflection the minister would be wise to fix all the problem, once and for all,' Mr Carroll added.
Agriland
2 days ago
- Agriland
Former farm leaders oppose Mercosur deal at Tullamore Show
Former leaders of two of the country's leading farm organisations joined forces at the 2025 Tullamore Show and FBD National Livestock Show to opposed the EU-Mercosur Trade Agreement. Former Irish Farmers' Association (IFA) president John Dillon and former Irish Creamery Milk Suppliers' Association (ICMSA) president Pat O'Rourke – now a political and agriculture adviser to MEP Ciaran Mullooly - made a joint effort at the event on Sunday (August 10) to warn about the deal. The two men said that said the Mercosur deal will have a "devastating impact" on Irish beef farmers. If ratified by EU member states, the deal would grant significantly increased access for South American beef into the European market. Speaking at the show, the two former farm leaders highlighted what they called a "massive price gap" between Brazilian and Irish beef, which they said was driven by a differences in production standards. Dillon claimed: "The farmgate price for beef in Brazil is just €3.20/kg. In Ireland, it's €9.50/kg. That difference is explained by the lower animal welfare standards, use of growth hormones, and weaker environmental protections in Mercosur countries. "The structural disadvantages for Irish farmers are equally stark. While farms in Mercosur countries can be as large as 15,000ha, the average Irish family farm is just 34ha. 'Irish farmers cannot and will not be able to compete on price with beef produced under vastly different rules and on an industrial scale. If the government is serious about backing Irish farmers, there's only one option – say no to Mercosur," O'Rourke said. The two men jointly called on the government to take a firm stand against the deal in upcoming EU negotiations, warning that its ratification would undermine the Irish beef sector, threaten rural livelihoods, and reward production systems that fail to meet the high standards demanded of EU farmers. The Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade, Simon Harris, recently said he had discussed international trade developments, including the Mercosur agreement, with his counterparts from France and Germany, among others. He said: "The government is committed to supporting free, fair and open trade. Indeed, recent developments in the global trading environment have highlighted the importance of market diversification via an expanded set of EU free trade agreements. "We have always been clear, that such agreements must defend our most vulnerable sectors and that our farmers' livelihoods must not be undermined through weak or ineffective environmental standards in other countries." "Our position is clearly outlined in the Programme for Government, which states that the government will work with like-minded EU countries to stand up for Irish farmers and defend our interests in opposing the current Mercosur trade deal," the Tánaiste said.
