Raging Edinburgh locals halt council meeting as they fume at noise from Fringe venue
Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info
Edinburgh residents have 'taken matters into their own hands' after years of living beside 'constant' noise from the Fringe during August.
Dumbiedykes residents have branded it 'mental torture for over a month', when The Pleasance is set up for the festival. They spoke of young children going to school on 'no sleep', and said they 'can't take it anymore'.
On June 11, an Edinburgh Council meeting was held - and residents made a 'desperate bid to finally be heard'. Councillor Hal Osler halted the meeting after residents, who she claimed were 'unable to speak', interrupted - in footage shared by Southside Community Council.
The meeting covered various proposals, including the proposed temporary festival venue east of 60 Pleasance. This included temporary performance venues, catering units, bars and 'other movable structures', on an annual basis for a minimum of three years.
In a live stream of the meeting, where The Pleasance festival venue was opened up for discussion, one of the residents can be heard saying: "Sorry folks, if you don't mind - just for two seconds."
Before he is able to finish the councillor interjects. She states: "Excuse me, would you mind sitting down please.
"You are unable to speak."
Speaking over each other, the resident continues: "You haven't actually represented the people in regards to this.
"Could you address the residents of Dumbiedykes as a committee."
Sign up for Edinburgh Live newsletters for more headlines straight to your inbox
Another resident interjects, adding: "The residents that are being tortured by this noise just want to be included as stakeholders.
"Please reply to the Dumbiedykes residents that have emailed you all. We totally agree with some of the things councillors have said, and we want to work with them."
Jessica Fenn, a member of the Southside Community Council, spoke to Edinburgh Live after the meeting. She told us: "They made it clear that they were really struggling to sleep.
"They had constantly emailed and called councillors, and nothing has come of it. Complaints have been ignored or brushed aside.
"We spoke to one resident who said his daughter gets so unwell in August. She can't sleep, missing school.
"It's absolute torture for them."
Residents in Dumbiedykes are pushing for closing time to be earlier during the week, and have said the 'big companies come from London to Edinburgh and make a lot of money that doesn't benefit residents'.
Jessica continued: "Residents aren't seeing that trickle down that's supposed to happen from these companies.
Join Edinburgh Live's Whatsapp Community here and get the latest news sent straight to your messages.
"It's at the expense of the residents."
One resident said: "They need to either scale it down or spread it out a bit more.
"The back of my house literally backs on to it. Then you've got your mess with food trucks and beer trucks and it flies all over the place.
"I've got kids that need to get up and go to school from 6am. We can't take it anymore."
Since the meeting, councillors have decided to only give The Pleasance a one year contract - and have asked for a noise impact assessment.
Jessica continued: "That was a small win, but it's not enough."
Edinburgh Council have been approached for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
3 hours ago
- Telegraph
Oasis fans have been branded rowdy, middle-aged and fat. At least they're not boring
Oasis fans are drunk, middle-aged and fat, according to secret documents written by Edinburgh council ahead of the band's three sold-out reunion concerts at Murrayfield Stadium in August. 'Medium to high intoxication' is to be expected among the 'rowdy' fans, the documents warn, while the large proportion of 'middle-aged men' in the audience will 'take up more room' than average. The comments, obtained by a newspaper under Freedom of Information laws, drew the ire of Liam Gallagher. 'Quite frankly your attitude f—ing stinks,' the Oasis frontman told the council on X. 'I'd leave town that day if I was any of you lot.' I haven't always agreed with Liam. This is, after all, the man who said that he might be God, and once described SpongeBob SquarePants as 'mad for it'. But in this instance the 52-year-old is correct. Edinburgh council's attitude stinks because rowdy fans are precisely what the first Oasis concerts in 16 years need. More than that, they are what live music needs. Not only are unruly audiences the most fun to be part of, but they provide a vivid counterbalance to the sea of tranquillity – people holding their phones aloft, heads gently bobbing – that mars most concerts these days. The first thing to say is that Edinburgh council are simply doing what all councils do. Speaking to a concert insider this morning, such due diligence on a large crowd is 'absolutely normal'. Venues, councils and other bodies get together to form a Safety Action Group, which identifies potential issues in written reports. Audiences are ranked on their likely levels of drinking, rowdiness, age and so on. 'The issue here is that Edinburgh has been caught out,' the insider says. The council's assertion that 'middle-aged men… take up more room' comes with an interesting side question. Most stadiums allow between 0.35 and 0.4m square per person to calculate safe numbers on a pitch, my insider says. Will the Oasis venues allow more space per person to take account of fans' middle-aged spread? Stand By Me, the band once sang. 'If my beer belly doesn't get in the way' might be an appropriate next line. And, yes, the council does have legitimate cause for concern. Oasis fans' behaviour deteriorated as the band's career progressed. By the early-2000s, prior to their eventual split in 2009, wee-throwing among the crowd was on the increase (deposited into a plastic pint cup and spun through the air – I'm not condoning it, it's gross); some fans took to wearing ponchos to protect themselves. I once pulled pints at an Oasis concert in Finsbury Park in 2002. The fans were ghastly. But let's do a fag-packet age analysis here. If those fans were in their twenties then – a reasonable expectation if they were teenagers during Oasis's 1994-1997 imperial phase – they will be in their mid-to-late forties now. You'd hope they'd be beyond the 'Catherine Wheel of p–ss' shenanigans today. Yes, they've got more money to spend – a recent survey by Barclays predicted that the average Oasis fan will spend a whopping £75.20 on pre-concert food and drink – but they'll also want to be tucked up in bed within an hour of the encore. There might even be a babysitter to relieve. How dangerous can they be? Ahh, I hear you say, but what about their older offspring? A whole new generation of Oasis fans exists out there, having grown up with the sound of their dad's Definitely Maybe CD wafting up from the kitchen stereo. Will this younger cohort pick up the boorish gauntlet that their parents laid down decades ago? I'm not sure. Gen Z are impeccably behaved compared to their parents. They drink less and hate crowds – I'd be surprised if they caused the havoc that their parents once did. A friend of the band had a slightly different take when I chatted last week. He reckons that, contrary to the above, older Oasis fans will be keen to recreate the mayhem of their youth – but their behaviour will be tempered by the presence of their children. 'Like a football match, you hope the presence of enough kids will calm it,' he said. But whoever misbehaves, I'm all for it. Gigs are far too sedate these days. People's obsession with filming things means they're more interested in bragging on Instagram that they were there than actually enjoying the show as it happens. Oasis's music is perfectly suited to disorderly in-the-moment euphoria. The band's album and song titles say it all: Be Here Now, Stay Young, Cigarettes & Alcohol, Rock 'N' Roll Star. One of the most fun crowds I've ever been part of was for a band not dissimilar to the Oasis of 2025. In December 1991, the Ramones played O2 Brixton Academy. Like Oasis, the US punk band were a loud, brash and middle-aged heritage act. Joey, Johnny and Marky Ramone were actually a decade or so younger than Liam and Noel are today. But the crowd was full of barrel-chested older men bouncing around as if their lives depended on it. At one point, in the thick of the moshpit, I slipped and fell. A plump hand reached down and yanked me up. I was clapped on the back by a man who looked like a fat Lovejoy in a grandad sweater. He checked I was OK and bounded off. Legend. And then there was Pulp last week. The audience was the same age as the Oasis fans will be. The band came on early and played Disco 2000 before 9pm. The place went bananas. And they were in bed by midnight. Let the middle-aged chaos begin.
Edinburgh Live
8 hours ago
- Edinburgh Live
Raging Edinburgh locals halt council meeting as they fume at noise from Fringe venue
Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info Edinburgh residents have 'taken matters into their own hands' after years of living beside 'constant' noise from the Fringe during August. Dumbiedykes residents have branded it 'mental torture for over a month', when The Pleasance is set up for the festival. They spoke of young children going to school on 'no sleep', and said they 'can't take it anymore'. On June 11, an Edinburgh Council meeting was held - and residents made a 'desperate bid to finally be heard'. Councillor Hal Osler halted the meeting after residents, who she claimed were 'unable to speak', interrupted - in footage shared by Southside Community Council. The meeting covered various proposals, including the proposed temporary festival venue east of 60 Pleasance. This included temporary performance venues, catering units, bars and 'other movable structures', on an annual basis for a minimum of three years. In a live stream of the meeting, where The Pleasance festival venue was opened up for discussion, one of the residents can be heard saying: "Sorry folks, if you don't mind - just for two seconds." Before he is able to finish the councillor interjects. She states: "Excuse me, would you mind sitting down please. "You are unable to speak." Speaking over each other, the resident continues: "You haven't actually represented the people in regards to this. "Could you address the residents of Dumbiedykes as a committee." Sign up for Edinburgh Live newsletters for more headlines straight to your inbox Another resident interjects, adding: "The residents that are being tortured by this noise just want to be included as stakeholders. "Please reply to the Dumbiedykes residents that have emailed you all. We totally agree with some of the things councillors have said, and we want to work with them." Jessica Fenn, a member of the Southside Community Council, spoke to Edinburgh Live after the meeting. She told us: "They made it clear that they were really struggling to sleep. "They had constantly emailed and called councillors, and nothing has come of it. Complaints have been ignored or brushed aside. "We spoke to one resident who said his daughter gets so unwell in August. She can't sleep, missing school. "It's absolute torture for them." Residents in Dumbiedykes are pushing for closing time to be earlier during the week, and have said the 'big companies come from London to Edinburgh and make a lot of money that doesn't benefit residents'. Jessica continued: "Residents aren't seeing that trickle down that's supposed to happen from these companies. Join Edinburgh Live's Whatsapp Community here and get the latest news sent straight to your messages. "It's at the expense of the residents." One resident said: "They need to either scale it down or spread it out a bit more. "The back of my house literally backs on to it. Then you've got your mess with food trucks and beer trucks and it flies all over the place. "I've got kids that need to get up and go to school from 6am. We can't take it anymore." Since the meeting, councillors have decided to only give The Pleasance a one year contract - and have asked for a noise impact assessment. Jessica continued: "That was a small win, but it's not enough." Edinburgh Council have been approached for comment.
Scotsman
8 hours ago
- Scotsman
Edinburgh Fringe 2025 Hot Comedy Tickets: Here are 17 of the biggest comedians with shows
August is fast approaching which means it's time to scour the Edinbugh Festival Fringe programme for the best shows to see. The physical programme was launched earlier this month, with 3,352 show across 265 venues, and some are already selling out. It can be a fairly daunting prospect to narrow those down when organising your Fringe. It's always nice to take a chance on something, hoping to be the first to see a hot new act - but sometimes it's just nice to see a couple of familiar faces from television. Edinburgh has been the launching pad for a host of household names - everybody from Emma Thompson to Graham Norton started out with shows in the city. Many enjoy returning with their latest show in August - or to try out a work on progress in front of a comedy-literate crowd before heading out on a nationwide tour. Here are 17 of the biggest, most famous, names performing this year. 1 . Jenny Eclair Jenny Eclair became the first woman to win the Perrier (now the Edinburgh Comedy Award) in 1995 for her show 'Prozac & Tantrums'. This year, she'll be appearing for two shows only to celebrate the 40th anniversary of the Gilded Balloon. She'll be talking about her career, which as seen her branch out into acting, writing and presenting, at the Gilded Balloon from August 8-9. | Getty Images Photo Sales 2 . Rosie O'Donnell First finding fame in a television talent show in 1984, Rosie O'Donnell became one of the most famous faces on American television, winning mumerous Emmy Awards for her daytime talk show that saw her nicknamed the 'Queen of Nice'. She's now a prominent gay rights campaigner who is also a successful actor and author. See her at the Gilden Balloon from August 1-10 where she'll be performing new show 'Here and Now'. | Getty Images Photo Sales 3 . Nish Kumar Former Mash Report host Nish Kumar brought work in progress show to Edinburgh last year. Now he's back with the finished product, 'Nish, Don't Kill My Vibe' at Assembly George Square from August 1-10. | Getty Images Photo Sales 4 . Smack the Pony Emmy Award winning sketch trio Smack the Pony - Sally Phillips, Fiona Allen and Doon Mackichan - will be reforming for four shows only, entitles 'Back in the Saddle'. They'll be chatting to Kirsty Wark and "having a gallop through a few favourite sketches" at the Gilded Balloon from August 17-20. | Channel 4 Photo Sales
