logo
Fact check: Misinformation after Biden's cancer diagnosis

Fact check: Misinformation after Biden's cancer diagnosis

Time of India21-05-2025

A statement released by the former US President Joe
's office and cited by international media informed that the 82-year-old had been diagnosed with an "aggressive" prostate cancer that had "metastasized to the bone."
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
The cancer diagnosis drew an outpouring of sympathy from supporters and rivals alike.
But the news also ignited speculations among Trump allies, and misinformation on social media platforms.
Hours after the information became public, inaccuracies started circulating about Biden's diagnosis and speculations about whether his medical condition was known before and hidden from the public. These were shared by prominent political figures and commentators.
DW Fact check analyzed the most viral claims.
Claim: "What I want to know is how did Dr Jill Biden miss stage five metastatic cancer or is this yet another coverup???" Donald Trump Jrwrote on X. The post reached 5.4 million people and was liked by 37K people at the time of publishing.
DW Fact check: False
X Post by Donald Trump Jr. claiming that Biden has "stage five" metastatic cancer (Image: @DonaldJTrumpJr/X)
In the post, the US president's oldest son and CEO of the Trump Organization refers to Biden's prostate cancer as a "stage five" cancer.
This is inaccurate and can lead to confusion.
German Cancer Aid (German: Deutsche Krebshilfe) is a not-for-profit organization that fights cancer in all its forms. It explains that there are two internationally standardized classifications for prostate cancer: the TNM staging system and the Gleason grading system.
How are cancer diagnoses classified?
The TNM classification describes the overall stage of different types of cancer, based on standards that indicate: the size and extent of the tumor (T), if the cancer cells have invaded the lymph nodes (N) and if metastases (M) are present in other organs.
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
Once determined, these values are combined to assign an overall stage, usually described with a Roman number from I (1) to IV (4).
As the American Cancer Society explains, stage I cancers are less advanced and have a better prognosis, while in stage IV the cancer has spread (metastasized) to distant parts of the body and might require intense treatment.
The Gleason grading system, on the other hand, is specific to prostate cancer and is used to assess its aggressiveness in terms of cell differentiation and growth pattern.
Pathologists examine prostate tissue and assign grades from 1 to 5, depending on how much the tumor cells resemble healthy prostate cells. Lower grades indicate bigger similarity, while higher ones describe a bigger difference.
The grades of the two most common tumor cells are then added up, resulting in the Gleason score with a range between 2 to 10.
In short, both medical standards describe different characteristics.
The TNM classification system evaluates the stage of development of different types of cancer, while the Gleason grading system determines how aggressive a prostate cancer is.
What is Biden's diagnosis?
The statement released by the Personal Office of Joe Biden said his prostate cancer was characterized by a Gleason score of 9 (Grade Group 5), meaning a very aggressive cancer.
Claiming that Biden has a "stage five metastatic cancer" is therefore false, as there is no "stage five" (V) cancer in the TNM classification system.
In his post, Donald Trump Jralso talks about "Dr Jill Biden" missing her husband's cancer diagnosis. It is worth clarifying that Jill Biden is not a doctor in the medical sense but in an academic one. According to her biography, she holds a Doctor of Education (EdD) and doesn't have a degree in medicine or health sciences-related areas.
Jill Biden has, nevertheless, dedicated part of her career as an advocate for more cancer education and prevention.
Back in 1993, she launched the Biden Breast Health Initiative to educate high school girls about early detection and prevention of this type of cancer.
Claim: "Prostate cancer is the easiest cancer to diagnose when it first starts and to watch it progress to bone metastases. […] For even with the most aggressive form, it is a 5-7 year journey without treatment before it becomes metastatic. [...] It is highly likely he was carrying a diagnosis of prostate cancer throughout his White House tenure and the American people were uninformed," reads a screenshot of an X post by Dr
, founder and CEO of Atossa Therapeutics, a biopharmaceutical company developing therapeutics for breast cancer.
X Post by Dr. Steve Quay claiming it was "highly likely he (Biden) was carrying a diagnosis of prostate cancer throughout his White House tenure" (Image: @quay_dr/X)
Quay is also known for co-authoring the book The Origin of the Virus, which supports the hypothesis that the virus causing COVID-19 originated from a laboratory. The post reached 5.5 million users and was liked 39K times, at the time of publishing.
DW Fact check: Unproven
In his viral X post, Donald Trump Jralso raises the question of whether Biden's medical condition had been covered up and shares a screenshot from an X post shared by physician and scientist, Dr Steven Quay.
Dr Quay claims that it is "highly likely" that Biden was diagnosed with prostate cancer while he was still president of the United States and that the "American people were uninformed" about this.
Biden's physical health and mental capacity were the focus of scrutiny during the last months of his presidency. He dropped out of his reelection campaign weeks after a bad performance during a debate against his then-rival, Donald Trump.
On May 20, journalists Jake Tapper and Alex Thompson released the book Original Sin: President Biden's Decline, Its Cover-Up, and His Disastrous Choice to Run Again. The book has made headlines as the authors allege Biden's inner circle hid his physical and cognitive decline from the public during his presidency and particularly in the lead-up to the 2024 election, and Biden's potential re-election. Biden's current prostate cancer diagnosis is not included in the book.
In February 2024, the White House published Biden's official health summary. The document signed by the longtime president'
, Dr Kevin C O'Connor, mentions Biden was being treated for a removed basal cell carcinoma (a common and relatively unaggressive form of skin cancer), obstructive sleep apnea, gastroesophageal reflux and stiffened ambulatory gait.
But there wasn't any mention of the small nodule that was found during Biden's routine physical exam last week, and which the mediahad already reported, before the prostate cancer was confirmed.
As Biden's 2024 health summary describes, it is not the first time that Biden has been diagnosed with some type of cancer. In 2023, the same physician confirmed to the New York Times the removal of the cancerous lesion from the president's chest, as cited in the summary.
X Post by political commentator Nick Sortor (Image: @nicksortor/X)
The information around Biden's cancerous lesion resonates with another claim by the political commentator Nick Sortor. He re-posted an old video of Joe Biden in which he is heard saying he had cancer.
Sortor then asks whether the Biden administration has been covering up his health diagnosis "for years."
Has Biden already admitted to having had cancer in the past?
The video appears to be from a speech Biden gave in Massachusetts in 2022. During his speech, Biden said "that's why I and so damn many other people I grew up [with] have cancer."
The video published by Sortor has not been digitally doctored, as suspected by some users online. The official White House transcript of the speech confirms Biden said those words.
At the time, the clip had caused controversy and was shared, especially by Biden's opponents, to highlight that the US President was announcing he had cancer.
The White House, however, dismissed this claim and said the then-US President was referring to a previous diagnosis of skin cancer.
Biden's former spokesperson, Andrew Bates confirmed the former US President had had non-melanoma skin cancer removed (Image: X)
Biden's former spokesperson, Andrew Bates, posted a link that confirmed Biden had had non-melanoma skin cancers removed before he became president.
This, nevertheless, did not quell the criticism, especially among those who have highlighted that Biden was speaking in the present tense in Massachusetts, not in the past tense.
Now, the post has resurfaced as part of Biden's official cancer diagnosis.
As to whether the Biden administration has covered up his health diagnosis "for years," as Sortor claims, or Donald Trump Jr., this is something Biden's team has denied in the past.
His former spokesperson, Karine Jean-Pierre, said in 2024, as part of the controversy over Biden's health said that the administration had been "transparent" about the former president's health.
"We have put forward a thorough, transparent annual report on his health," she said.
No statement has been made by Biden or his office on the new speculations.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Delhi Confidential: Berlin talk
Delhi Confidential: Berlin talk

Indian Express

time2 hours ago

  • Indian Express

Delhi Confidential: Berlin talk

WHEN GERMAN Foreign Minister Johann Wadephul met senior BJP leader Ravi Shankar Prasad, who was heading an all-party delegation to Berlin to explain India's position on Operation Sindoor, he told the latter that he had the pleasure of meeting External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar earlier. Prasad quipped that the German minister, who had met Jaishankar earlier, is now meeting Ravi Shankar, the head of the Indian delegation. Wadephul told Prasad that he is a lawyer by profession to which the latter replied that he, too, is a lawyer by profession. The Branding DAYS AFTER Union Home Minister Amit Shah introduced the new e-Zero FIR that automatically converts cyber financial crime complaints with a cheating value above Rs 10 lakh, registered on the 1930 helpline, the Indian Cyber Crime Coordination Centre (I4C), which is under the Ministry of Home Affairs, has also renamed its cafeteria as '1930 cafe'. Although it is housed in the NBCC building, which has offices of different departments, just to keep the momentum for I4C, senior officers of the department decided to rename their cafe after the helpline for better branding and greater awareness.

We are reliable partner, eager to have Indian talent, says Germany envoy
We are reliable partner, eager to have Indian talent, says Germany envoy

Indian Express

time2 hours ago

  • Indian Express

We are reliable partner, eager to have Indian talent, says Germany envoy

The German Ambassador Tuesday reassured Indian students that the country is 'a reliable partner' and said that it is 'eager and happy to receive Indian talents'. With other countries capping international student intake, along with the Donald Trump administration's crackdown on top American universities, Philipp Ackermann said: 'We feel that Germany has been a reliable partner for Indian students for a long time and will remain so. We are interested in Indian talent. We are not erratic, we are not volatile, we are very, very steady.' At a press meet in Delhi, he said: 'We don't check social media before you come. We are very eager to have talented young Indians coming to Germany.' 'In the light of difficulties with student admissions and visa procedures in some countries… Germany is very eager and happy to receive Indian students… extremely good experiences with Indian students and we have seen that the number of Indian students is increasing every year.' His comments come in the wake of the Donald Trump administration reportedly considering the vetting of social media accounts of international students applying for student visas. Data by Katja Lasch, Director, Regional Office New Delhi, DAAD (German Academic Exchange Service), shows that the number of Indians enrolled in German universities rose from 13,740 in 2015-16 to 25,149 in 2019-20, and to 49,483 in 2023-24. 'We are aware this number may go up because of the situation elsewhere,' he said, adding: 'Over the past months, applications across the state-owned universities have gone up 35%.'

Modi govt invested Rs 44,859 cr in 3,600+ Northeast projects: Sarbananda Sonowal
Modi govt invested Rs 44,859 cr in 3,600+ Northeast projects: Sarbananda Sonowal

Time of India

time4 hours ago

  • Time of India

Modi govt invested Rs 44,859 cr in 3,600+ Northeast projects: Sarbananda Sonowal

Guwahati: The Union Minister of Ports , Shipping & Waterways, Shri Sarbananda Sonowal , strongly countered the Congress party's criticism of the Modi government's performance over the past 11 years, asserting that the grand old party has 'forfeited the right to criticize' in the court of the people. Emphasizing the transformative progress made under Prime Minister Narendra Modi's leadership, the Minister said the Congress, which neglected the aspirations of the people for more than six decades, now stands exposed before a new India that rewards performance and punishes apathy. 'Congress has lost all moral rights. They had destroyed the prospect of Northeast when they misgoverned the country for more than six decades. The dark days of Congress governments were filled with violence, insurgency, terrorism that dragged our beautiful region in to a vortex of deprivation, devastation, discord and division. Peace was a distant dream. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Top US Doctors Stunned By New German Hearing Aid That Costs Less Than Dinner Out Top Trending News Today Learn More Undo This was reversed only with the dynamic leadership of Prime Minister Narendra Modi ji who took decisive steps to transform the region, respect the aspirations of the people, find solutions, usher a new era of peace and brotherhood, and ultimately, transform it as the Growth Engine of new India,' said Sarbananda . Sonowal highlighted the major achievements of the Narendra Modi led government over 11 years and explained how it delivered unprecedented welfare benefits to every section of the society — uplifting the poor 'Garib Kalyan', empowering the women 'Nari Shakti', transforming agriculture 'Krishak Kalyan' and empowering the youth through skill based training and employment opportunities through innovative policy action via Start Up India or Digital India campaigns. Live Events Sonowal also underlined how more than 2.19 lakh farmers benefitted from the Mission Organic Value Chain Development, 434 Farmer Producer Organizations formed, covering 1.73 lakh hectares. Sonowal said, 'Under the dynamic leadership of PM Narendra Modi ji, the Govt is working towards building Viksit Bharat during this Amrit Kala by focusing on 'Seva, Sushasan and Garib Kalyan' (Service, Good Governance and Welfare of the Poor). Over 81 crore people now receive free rations under the PM Garib Kalyan Anna Yojana, more than 15 crore rural households have access to tap water under 'Har Ghar Jal', and Rs 3.7 lakh crore has been disbursed to farmers through PM-KISAN. Women's empowerment has seen historic strides—from 33% reservation in legislatures under the Nari Shakti Vandan Adhiniyam to direct benefit transfers for more than 3.9 crore pregnant women, and the historic admission of women into the National Defence Academy (NDA).' Since 2014, the Modi government has brought the Northeast into the mainstream of India's development journey with unprecedented investment and focused attention. The Northeast has emerged transformative with 'Insurgency has declined by 64% since 2014, AFSPA has been withdrawn from 75% of the region', added Sonowal. The government has approved over 3,600 projects worth Rs 44,859 crore, built 10 greenfield airports, and expanded connectivity and organic farming through focused missions. 'Under PM Modi's leadership, the Northeast is being repositioned not as a peripheral zone, but as India's vital Gateway to the East, with peace, progress, and prosperity at its core', Sonowal further said. Sonowal highlighted the immense possibilities of tourism sector in the region. Tourism-led growth has emerged as a key pillar of Meghalaya 's development under Prime Minister Narendra Modi's government. Sonowal said, 'Shillong is a beautiful city, Meghalaya is a gift of Mother Earth. We must celebrate her with utmost sincerity and ensure sustainable development through harnessing the immense possibilities in the tourism sector. The boom in tourism in the state is a positive sign as how Meghalaya has become a destination of choice for most domestic as well as international tourists visiting India. Meghalaya is a shining example of success of schemes like Swadesh Darshan. The Modi Govt sanctioned Rs 244 Cr to boost Sustainable Tourism which has created potential in iconic destinations like Umium Lake, Sohpetbneng, Krang Suri Falls, Siju Caves, and Nokrek Reserve are being transformed into world-class tourist attractions. From waterfall trails to the Meghalayan Age Cave Experience, the focus on sustainable and immersive tourism has revitalised local economies and created livelihood opportunities. Spiritual and heritage sites like Nartiang and Mawphlang villages are also being promoted under niche tourism categories, positioning Meghalaya as a vibrant destination within India's Northeast tourism circuit.' Landmark initiatives such as the establishment of South Asia's largest cancer care network in Assam reflect the government's commitment to bridging decades of neglect. The recently held Rising Northeast Investors Summit 2025 further reinforced this vision, securing Rs 4.3 lakh crore in investment commitments that promise to unlock the region's economic potential and generate widespread employment. Northeast is undergoing rapid development in connectivity, agriculture, and industry. Operational airports have increased from 9 in 2014 to 19 in 2024. The region is emerging as a hub for organic farming and edible oil production, with 3.3 lakh gatherers and over 19,000 SHGs supported under Van Dhan Vikas Yojana. The bamboo industry has also grown through reclassification and targeted missions. Healthcare and heritage conservation are also priorities. Cultural initiatives include a tribal museum in Manipur and the development of Sivasagar as a heritage site. Sonowal said, 'Meghalaya, backed by a 105% increase in central grants-in-aid, has seen a substantial scale-up in infrastructure & social welfare. Landmark initiatives include the Rs 22,864 crore Greenfield High-Speed Corridor between Mawlyngkhung & Panchgram, set to drastically improve regional connectivity & logistics. Over 540 km of National Highways have been constructed, and urban mobility projects in New Shillong and Tura are being implemented under PM-DevINE."

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store