Grooming gangs report author says 'do-gooders' giving racists 'more ammunition'
Why you can trust Sky News
Ignoring the ethnicity of grooming gang perpetrators gives racists "more ammunition", the author of a new report has said.
Baroness Louise Casey told Sky News' Politics with Sophy Ridge there was a particular issue with some British Asian men that was "abundantly clear" in data analysed from three police forces; West Yorkshire, South Yorkshire and Greater Manchester; which showed a "disproportionately" in child sexual exploitation.
But she added: "Just to give some sort of balance, in Greater Manchester I asked for data on child sexual exploitation that took me to Asian heritage. I asked for data on child abuse and that took me to the general population, which is largely white."
Baroness Casey said "if we just establish the facts, then you can take the pain out of this".
"I think you've got sort of do-gooders that don't really want this to be found because, you know, 'Oh, God, then all the racists are going to be more racist'," she added.
"Well, actually, people that are racist are going to use this anyway. All you're doing with the hate mongers and the racists is giving them more ammunition."
Asked if people were worried about being seen as racist, the cross-bench peer said she came across direct examples of this in Rotherham - one of the towns at the centre of the grooming gangs scandal.
"I was following through on a children's file in archive and found the word 'Pakistani' tippexed out," Baroness Casey said.
"I thought whoever did that inadvertently was giving ammunition to the English Defence League that were every week, in and out, campaigning and doing their stuff in that town.
"I think the problem is that people are worried about being called racist.... if good people don't grasp difficult things, bad people will, and that's why we have to do it as a society."
4:18
The government has announced there will be a full statutory inquiry into grooming gangs, as recommended by Baroness Casey's report.
The government has also accepted her recommendations to introduce compulsory collection of ethnicity and nationality data for all suspects in grooming cases, and for a review of police records to launch new criminal investigations into historic child sexual exploitation cases.
Baroness Casey was asked to produce an audit of sexual abuse carried out by grooming gangs in England and Wales, looking specifically at the issue of ethnicity and the cultural and social drivers for this type of offending.
This had never before been done despite multiple local reviews into child sexual exploitation and a seven-year national inquiry into child abuse more generally, known as the Jay Review, which concluded in 2022.
The government had previously resisted calls for an inquiry into grooming gangs, after a row with tech billionaire Elon Musk brought the issue back into the spotlight in January, saying it would implement the recommendations of the Jay Review that the Tories didn't.
However it changed its position following Baroness Casey's findings.
She found that flawed data has been used repeatedly to dismiss claims about "Asian grooming gangs".
Having examined local data in three police force areas, she found "disproportionate numbers of men from Asian ethnic backgrounds" are among suspects for group-based child sexual exploitation, as well as a "significant number of perpetrators of Asian ethnicity" who have been identified in local reviews and child sexual exploitation prosecutions across the country.
She said all of this warranted further examination, insisting to Sophy Ridge that the decision was not political.
Baroness Casey has also called for a tightening of the laws around the age of consent so that any penetrative sexual activity with a child under 16 is classified as rape, which the government has also accepted.
She told Sophy Ridge that some perpetrators waited until their victims turned 13 as then it is "much harder to prosecute for rape".
She said: "I think we have to be really clear in society that children are children and I don't see the difference between, you know, a four-year-old and a 14-year-old. If somebody is doing to them... what I talk about in my report, it's rape and we need to call it for what it is."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Grooming gang survivor says new inquiry may bring long-awaited answers
A woman who was raped by grooming gangs at the age of 12 and turned away by police when she tried to report the abuse has said victims may finally get answers in from a national inquiry into child sexual government announced the new probe, that would compel witnesses to give evidence, after report by Baroness Casey which found "far too many" perpetrators of abuse had evaded Walker-Roberts from Oldham has been calling for ministers to launch a national inquiry after she was abused by grooming gangs in the town in the 2000s. She said victims were treated like "prostitutes, or just used goods" by authorities who failed to protect them. Ms Walker-Roberts was accused of being drunk in 2006 when she tried to report the abuse at a local police then taken into a car by two men and raped, before she was driven to homes across the town and sexually assaulted by others. 'Scripted' Her experience was at the centre of a review published in 2022, that found vulnerable children in Oldham had been failed by the police and the has chosen to waive her right to anonymity, having previously been given the alias 'Sophie' in the review to protect her was commissioned by the Mayor of Greater Manchester Andy Burnham as part of a series of non-statutory reviews which also included Manchester and Rochdale. In some cases, former police officers, including those in senior ranks, and council officials did not appear to give evidence when asked to Walker-Roberts said "being named and shamed" for not turning up was not justice, and compelling witnesses to appear was important. "They might not tell the truth, it might be scripted, but this is the only option we've got," Ms Walker-Roberts said. She said she had been disappointed with previous inquiries, as they all ended with authorities being "unable to take further action". "I've just accepted now that I'm not going to get any more justice, but it's not going to stop me using the platform I've built to help others get what they want."Assistant Chief Constable Steph Parker of Greater Manchester Police said the national inquiry and the "statutory powers this invokes to ensure accountability". Baroness Casey said she recommended a national statutory review because of the "reluctance" of local areas to do their own reviews. She said Oldham's was the only council which was willing to do a review when five local inquiries were Council Leader Arooj Shah said the authority recognised "the failings of the past" and was "determined not to repeat them". She also said child sexual abuse as perpetrated by people of all races and religions but authorities needed to do more to understand why the "pattern of abuse" was more prevalent in some groups of men."To say so is not racist. What is racist is to suggest that all Pakistani men are groomers or the implication, the suggestion, that any one community condones this behaviour – it does not."Baroness Casey's report found "disproportionate numbers of men from Asian ethnic backgrounds" were suspects in child grooming gangs, but the ethnicity of perpetrators was often not recorded by authorities. Ms Walker-Roberts, who has written a book about her experiences, said while she welcomed the national review, she believed Sir Kier Starmer had been "pushed into a corner" by Baroness Casey's was part of a group of victims who have met with ministers in the past six months to push for a full said until the new probe was announced on Saturday, "Labour had just not wanted to give us anything".Seven men were convicted last week of sexually exploiting two teenage girls in Rochdale, Greater Manchester, between 2001 and 2006. Assistant Chief Constabl Parker said this was the second major investigation into grooming gangs in Rochdale, and meant 32 people had now been brought to justice for sex abuse offences in the said she wanted to reiterate an apology from the force "to all those who have been let down by GMP in the past". "We know we still have a way to go and are not complacent about the scale of what needs to be done."While we are demonstrably better, we will continue to stay true to our apology to those victims we have previously let down, reflecting on our progress, and act on scrutiny to further improve." Listen to the best of BBC Radio Manchester on Sounds and follow BBC Manchester on Facebook, X, and Instagram. You can also send story ideas via Whatsapp to 0808 100 2230.
New Statesman
2 hours ago
- New Statesman
The Casey report reveals fifteen years of establishment denial
Kirsty O'Connor -Eight years ago, when the BBC drama Three Girls was released in May 2017, the UK watched in horror. Reviewers described the series as 'powerful and brave' – it attracted more than 8.24m viewers. The drama, which was set in Rochdale (but could as easily have been based on events in Telford, Rotherham or Oxford) told the story of three teenage girls; each the victim of a grooming gang and subjected to institutional gaslighting which still goes on today. All were under the age of 16 and all were routinely raped and abused by men in their local community, all of whom were of Pakistani heritage. Despite widespread knowledge of the gravity of this long-running scandal (investigations stretch back to the late 1980s) victims of this heinous abuse still feel that little tangible action has been taken. 'One thing is abundantly clear; we as a society owe these women a debt,' Louise Casey wrote in the National Audit on Group-based Child Sexual Exploitation and Abuse which was published on 16 June. Casey's report was commissioned by Keir Starmer in January, after the Labour government came under extreme pressure to hold an inquiry into the Grooming Gangs scandal. Outrage was triggered by posts on X by the platform's owner, Elon Musk, who accused Starmer, and the Home Office Minister, Jess Philips of being complicit in a cover up of the scale of the abuse. In the months since, the government has repeatedly refused to hold a national inquiry, saying that councils would be best placed to investigate the issue at a local level instead. That was until Sunday, when Starmer, surrounded by reporters on a flight to the G7 meeting in Canada, quietly let slip that the government had changed its mind: there will be a national inquiry. This U-turn was, in no uncertain terms, due to the findings of Casey's report, which directly recommends that an investigation should be held. But it has left Labour MPs reeling. For months, MPs have been forced out on the defensive telling concerned constituents, many of whom were adamant of the need for an inquiry, that it wasn't necessary to hold one. As one insider told me, many MPs now feel that residents who were likely to feel mistrustful of the government on this have been pushed further away. Another enraged back-bench MP said: 'I'm properly pissed off… I've had far right leaflets going around saying I voted against an inquiry and now we're having one.' They added: 'It's what happens when you have a govt on a death spiral and simply reacting to what it thinks the public wants. Weak, weak, weak.' The report is damning. And the strength of its findings have clearly (and rightly) forced Starmer's hand. 'We need a vigorous approach to righting the wrongs of the past,' Casey wrote, 'using known vulnerability factors to identify and bring perpetrators of these terrible offences to justice; holding agencies to account for any part they played… and delivering justice for more victims.' These 'known vulnerability factors' are two-fold. The first relates to the 'collective failure to address questions about the ethnicity of grooming gangs'. In other words, Casey found that the institutions' (the police, social services, and councils) whose job it was to ensure they had completed a thorough investigation into those involved in grooming gangs, utterly let down those whom they are supposed to protect. The ethnicity of perpetrators was, according to Casey 'shied away from' for fear of appearing racist. As a result, ethnicity data remains unrecorded for 'two-thirds' of perpetrators with 'flawed data' being used to 'repeatedly dismiss claims about 'Asian grooming gangs' as sensationalised, biased or untrue'. Casey said: 'This does a disservice to victims and indeed all law-abiding people in Asian communities and plays into the hands of those who want to exploit it to sow division.' When it looked at the data held in three local areas, the report found evidence that men of Asian ethnicity are over-represented as perpetrators in group-based child sexual exploitation in those areas. Subscribe to The New Statesman today from only £8.99 per month Subscribe The second 'known vulnerability factor' is what Casey terms, the adultification of the teenage victims of grooming gangs. Due to prejudice, classism and misogyny – victims of child sexual abuse (many of whom grew up in care) are still treated with 'uneasiness and awkwardness' by some professionals who seem to find these cases 'less easy to deal with without applying judgements or stereotypes than…exploitation involving…drugs, knives or money'. This could manifest in their not being believed or the key signs of exploitation being missed: it is much easier for a police officer to realise that a child is being criminally exploited after finding them with drugs, than it is to spot the subtle signs of sexual abuse. Indeed, some victims have been criminally prosecuted for things they did under coercion, for example, encouraging another child to come with them. 'Children need to be seen as children,' Casey wrote, 'We let them down when we treat them or see them as adults'. Casey's review also found that despite the age of consent being 16, there have been 'too many examples' of child sexual abuse cases being either downgraded from rape to lesser charges or dropped altogether in cases in which it had been argued that a 13–15-year-old had been 'in love with' or had consented to sex with the perpetrator. This is despite a known technique used by men involved in grooming gangs encouraging victims (who are often vulnerable or neglected and desperately seeking love) into thinking they are their 'boyfriend'. The review recommends that the law in in England and Wales should be changed so adults who intentionally 'penetrate the vagina, anus or mouth of a child under 16 receive mandatory charges of rape'. Whatever happens next, this report is not good news for Starmer. After spending at least half of his premiership convincing the public, his detractors and even his own MPs that an inquiry doesn't need to be held, he has changed his mind at the last minute. Casey's exhaustive report – sensitively done and uncompromising in its call for change – is a turning point. [See more: A new force is stirring on the left] Related
Sky News
2 hours ago
- Sky News
The Wargame podcast: Fictional prime minister addresses the nation after Russia launches attack
The prime minister of a fictional British government is preparing to deliver an address to the nation after the UK came under armed attack from Russia in the latest episode of The Wargame podcast. Were this happening for real, it would mark the most significant public broadcast by any British leader since the Second World War. "Am I actually going to do it?" Sir Ben Wallace asks, breaking briefly from character in the new podcast series by Sky News and Tortoise. The former Conservative defence secretary is playing the part of the prime minister, leading a team of fellow former top politicians and military and security chiefs in the scenario. The British side is pitched against an imagined Kremlin. The Russian attack has triggered a state of emergency in the UK. Normal, everyday life has stopped. People across the country are being told to stay at home. Travel is restricted and the UK airspace has been closed. The threat of a new wave of attacks is very real. 0:52 Needing to inform the public about what is going on and how the UK is fighting back, the prime minister is told that he really is going to deliver an address. He exits a Cobra crisis meeting and enters a small radio booth for the broadcast. 4:35 The address to the nation is a key moment in episode 3 of The Wargame podcast series by Sky News and Tortoise, which is released on Tuesday along with episode 4. The first two episodes were released last week and the fifth episode is out next week. The scenario is designed to test the UK's defences after decades of cost-saving cuts. It also explores the reliability of Britain's NATO allies, in particular the United States.
