SC adds NHRC to PIL for law on mental health care
A bench comprising Justices P S Narasimha and Atul S Chandurkar asked petitioner Gaurav Kumar Bansal to file an application to make rights body NHRC a party to the PIL filed in 2018.
The bench said the PIL may be transferred to the NHRC for implementing the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017.
Bansal said a committee headed by a former apex court judge could be set up to oversee the implementation.
"We cannot create a parallel mechanism just because the existing system has any flaws," the bench said.
The bench, in the meantime, asked Additional Solicitor General Aishwarya Bhati, representing the Centre, to share its affidavit with Bansal and posted the hearing after three weeks.
The bench had previously said Parliament enacted the Mental Healthcare Act in 2017 which contemplates establishment of "Central Mental Health Authority (CMHA), State Mental Health Authority (SMHA) and Mental Health Review Board (MHRB)".
The top court on March 2 directed Centre to file an affidavit indicating the establishment and functioning of the Central Mental Health Authority, State Mental Health Authority and Mental Health Review Board.
The affidavit was further ordered to show the statutory and mandatory appointments to the authority and the review board.
On January 3, 2019, the apex court issued notices to the Centre, all states and Union Territories on the petition which has claimed that non-implementation of provisions of the Act by the states and UTs was a gross violation of life and liberty of the citizens.
Taking note of an incident, the bench said chaining people with mental illness was violative of their rights under Article 21 of the Constitution, which deals with life and personal liberty, and their dignity cannot be compromised.
The PIL argued persons with mental illnesses were chained in a faith-based mental asylum in Budaun district of Uttar Pradesh in violation of provisions of the Mental Health Care Act 2017.
The court examined the photos of such patients calling it a matter of great concern.
The PIL said chaining a person suffering from mental illness was a blatant violation of a provision of the 2017 Act which says that every such person shall not only have a right to live with dignity but he or she shall be protected from cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment.
Referring to the National Mental Health Survey 2016, he has claimed that around 14 per cent of India's population requires active mental health interventions and around 2 per cent Indians were suffering from severe mental disorders.>
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
2 hours ago
- The Hindu
Hyderabad Collector orders crackdown on quacks illegally practising medicine
Hyderabad District Collector Hari Chandana Dasari has directed Health department officials to carry out inspections of hospitals where quacks are practising medicine without proper qualifications. She instructed that such practices be thoroughly investigated and legal action initiated wherever necessary. Speaking at the District-Level Registering Authority Committee meeting on Tuesday, the Collector said that a special drive is underway to crackdown on unregistered clinics operating during the night without permission. 'Such violations compromise patient safety and must be dealt with firmly,' she said. The Collector also stressed that all permissions for running medical establishments must strictly adhere to the provisions of the Clinical Establishments (Registration and Regulation) Act, 2010, and its amended rules from 2022. She instructed that applications for new registrations or renewals be granted only after thorough verification of documents and credentials. The Collector further asked police officials to verify inspection checklists and focus on the medical staff's qualifications and any existing complaints or criminal cases linked to hospitals or practitioners.
The Hindu
2 hours ago
- The Hindu
Hyderabad Collector orders crackdown on AYUSH doctors illegally practising allopathy
Hyderabad District Collector Hari Chandana Dasari has directed Health department officials to carry out inspections of hospitals where AYUSH practitioners are allegedly offering allopathic treatment without proper qualifications. She instructed that such practices be thoroughly investigated and legal action initiated wherever necessary. Speaking at the District-Level Registering Authority Committee meeting on Tuesday, the Collector said that a special drive is underway to crackdown on unregistered clinics operating during the night without permission. 'Such violations compromise patient safety and must be dealt with firmly,' she said. The Collector also stressed that all permissions for running medical establishments must strictly adhere to the provisions of the Clinical Establishments (Registration and Regulation) Act, 2010, and its amended rules from 2022. She instructed that applications for new registrations or renewals be granted only after thorough verification of documents and credentials. The Collector further asked police officials to verify inspection checklists and focus on the medical staff's qualifications and any existing complaints or criminal cases linked to hospitals or practitioners.
The Hindu
3 hours ago
- The Hindu
Hospitals to face action over billing irregularities
District Medical and Health Officer (DMHO) S. Jeevan Rani has issued a stern warning to hospitals, nursing homes, diagnostic centres, and laboratories across Vizianagaram district for failing to prominently display tariff charts, as mandated under the Clinical Establishments (Registration and Regulation) Act, 2010. It has come to light that despite repeated warnings and reminders, many healthcare facilities in the district fail to display tariff details. Speaking to The Hindu on Monday, Dr Rani announced: 'Special inspection teams will be formed to conduct checks at every healthcare facility in the district. Hospitals must display the fee structure boards at the entrance and patient waiting areas. Hidden charges and lack of transparency in billing will not be tolerated.' She further added that many hospitals in Vizianagaram were hiding the fee structure and collecting excess fees without informing the patients. Additionally, patients were being forced to make payments at the cash counters where staff fail to provide proper answers. Another serious concern that Dr Rani highlighted was that many hospitals are not issuing hard copies of prescriptions and test reports to patients. Instead, doctors are sending the prescriptions directly to the in-house pharmacies, leaving patients unable to purchase medicines from elsewhere. 'Outstation patients have complained that they cannot buy medicines in their hometowns due to the absence of physical prescriptions,' Dr Rani added. However, hospital authorities claim that reports and prescriptions are being sent to the WhatsApp numbers of patients. Interestingly, when The Hindu tried to find out how poor patients who do not use smartphones can access their reports and prescriptions, none of the hospitals responded. B. Ramachandra Reddy, an attendant of a patient said: 'Sometimes, WhatsApp messages may be deleted. How can patients retrieve deleted data? Additionally, in case of an emergency when patients are referred to hospitals in Visakhapatnam and other places, it is not easy to take printouts. Hard copies are essential for maintaining lifelong medical records. ' Dr. Rani reiterated that hospitals must adopt transparent procedures in billing and treatment. It is mandatory. 'Patients with grievances can contact us and we will take action on errant hospital authorities,' she added.
