AfD-Supporting Lawyer Fined €3,000 For Criticizing German Govt, Has Gun License Revoked, Faces Disbarment
Roscher described Vice Chancellor Robert Habeck, Chancellor Olaf Scholz, and Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock as 'malicious failures' in a post on X back in 2021. He was subsequently issued a penalty notice under the controversial Paragraph 188 of the German Criminal Code, which criminalized defamation against individuals engaged in public political life.
Roscher, who has been active on X for over 14 years and is well accustomed to the legal boundaries surrounding political debate, insists that his post was within the bounds of political criticism.
'I actually know myself to be quite well within the red lines,' he told Bild.
'You have to formulate things pointedly to be heard. The lines of freedom of opinion have slipped with the red-green government (ed. the coalition of Social Democrats and Greens).'
He further described his hefty fine as a 'scandal for freedom of expression.'
Paragraph 188, introduced in April 2021, criminalizes insults against politicians if they significantly hinder their public work. It was initially passed under a coalition government of the CDU and SPD but has been increasingly enforced under the current administration. The law has led to numerous prosecutions against individuals who have criticized government officials online.
In Roscher's case, the penalty order claimed that his statements portrayed politicians as 'corrupt, stupid, and arrogant,' constituting 'abusive criticism' that allegedly impeded their political activity.
Will memes be targeted in Germany next?"Misinformation" expert hints that restrictions are coming."There is no right to be heard on social media…This is the problem of the next few years, especially when it comes to ambiguous or cryptic communication, such as memes." pic.twitter.com/OY6kUzUsPK — Remix News & Views (@RMXnews) January 16, 2025
Following the charge, authorities also moved to revoke his gun license, citing 'unreliability.'
Furthermore, his case was forwarded to the Kassel and Braunschweig Bar Associations, raising concerns that he could face professional sanctions.
'If I now claim the same or something similar and get another conviction exceeding 90 daily rates, I can lose my license,' Roscher warned.
'Then you get a job ban as a 61-year-old lawyer!'
Roscher believes that his support for the right-wing Alternative for Germany (AfD) has played a pivotal role in his prosecution. He asserts that the penalty order was politically motivated, arguing that he stood little chance in a legal battle, which led him to pay the fine without challenging it in the courts.
The scrutiny of political affiliations within Germany's public sector was also highlighted by a leaked memo last month revealing that federal police officers who join or actively support the AfD could face disciplinary action, including dismissal. The memo cited a decree by Federal Interior Minister Nancy Faeser, explicitly stating that officers suspected of affiliation with the party could see their employment terminated.
The controversy has drawn international attention from U.S. billionaire Elon Musk and most recently from U.S. Vice President JD Vance, who labeled Germany's online speech laws this week as 'Orwellian.' Responding to a CBS '60 Minutes' interview with German prosecutors, Vance argued that Germany was effectively 'criminalizing speech' and urged Europeans to 'reject this lunacy.'
Roscher's case is part of a broader pattern of speech-related prosecutions in Germany.
Click here to read more…
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Gulf Insider
6 days ago
- Gulf Insider
Knife Crime In Germany Surges, With Foreigners Heavily Over-Represented In Latest Figures
The number of violent knife crimes in Germany has risen sharply once again, with newly released Federal Police figures confirming a worsening trend. In the first half of 2025, 730 cases were recorded under Federal Police jurisdiction, a 17 percent increase compared to the same period last year. The data, provided by the German government in response to a parliamentary query from Alternative for Germany (AfD) domestic affairs spokesman Martin Hess and obtained by Junge Freiheit, show a marked overrepresentation of foreign suspects. Out of the recorded offenses, 278 involved German suspects and 270 involved non-Germans. While foreigners make up just under 15 percent of Germany's population, they accounted for over 36 percent of knife crime suspects. Among them, Syrians formed the largest group with 29 cases, followed by Afghans with 23 and Poles with 20. Algerian and Afghan suspects were among the most likely to use a knife rather than merely carry one, with 83 percent of cases involving actual use. The Federal Police recorded the majority of incidents at train stations, with 409 cases. Hess said the figures were 'largely a direct consequence of mass migration,' accusing left-wing parties of 'denial of reality' and warning that public spaces must not become 'places of fear.' He criticized symbolic measures such as weapon-free zones and said that effective border controls and large-scale deportations had yet to be implemented. Knife violence is not confined to Berlin, though the capital's police force drew ridicule last year for website advice suggesting that victims sing loudly to deter attackers — a tip later removed after public backlash. In North Rhine-Westphalia, Germany's most populous state, knife crime rose 20.7 percent in 2024, following a 44 percent jump the previous year. There, foreigners make up just 16.1 percent of the population but 47.6 percent of knife crime suspects. In May, German criminal lawyer Udo Vetter warned that the country has 'imported knife violence' following several high-profile incidents, including a Kosovar man injuring a 12-year-old girl and two others, a Syrian asylum seeker stabbing five people outside a student bar, and a rioter wounding a police officer. He pointed to cultural norms where knives are carried as status symbols. Manuel Ostermann of the Federal Police Union also called for urgent action, warning that the knife 'always immediately poses a concrete threat to life and limb' and that politicians must use all available measures to curb the trend.
Gulf Insider
14-08-2025
- Gulf Insider
AfD Tops Poll As Germany's Most Popular Political Party
The poll, conducted by the Forsa Institute for Social Research and Statistical Analysis on behalf of RTL Deutschland, showed that 26 percent of Germans would vote for the AfD. The AfD, an anti-mass immigration party, came second in Germany's national parliamentary elections, earning nearly 21 percent of the vote. The new polling puts the right-wing party ahead of German Chancellor Friedrich Merz's mainstream conservative bloc, the Christian Democrats (CDU) and their Bavarian allies, the Christian Social Union (CSU). The CDU/CSU slid to 24 percent, its worst result since the 2021 federal election. Germany's manufacturing sector, the largest in Europe, has had two years of contraction and is expected to broadly stagnate in 2025, according to an EU Commission macroeconomic forecast. Only 14 percent of poll respondents said they expected the economic situation to improve, while 62 percent anticipated a deterioration, which it said was 'the highest pessimism level' of the current year. Germany is also struggling with the loss of affordable Russian gas, historic Volkswagen plant closures, and fierce competition from cheaper Chinese electric vehicles. The country has gone through a major population change, with its net population increasing by more than 3.5 million between 2014 and 2024, driven entirely by migration. During this period, the number of German citizens fell by 2 million to 71.6 million, while the foreign population grew to 13.1 million from around 7.5 million, Statistics Office data showed. In 2015, under Chancellor Angela Merkel, more than 1 million refugees, many of them from Syria, as well as Afghans and Iraqis, arrived in Germany. One hundred days after Merz's election as chancellor, his approval ratings have fallen to a record low, with 67 percent 'dissatisfied' with his work. The poll showed that 'dissatisfaction' is particularly pronounced among supporters of the AfD, at 95 percent. In February's general election, Merz fell short of forming a majority government, as is often the case in German politics, and, after lengthy negotiations, his party formed a coalition with the center-left Social Democrats (SPD). At the time, Merz ruled out the party forming a government with the AfD. Forty-three percent of respondents said they expected the CDU/CSU/SPD coalition to end early. AfD's policies include strong support for traditional marriage between a man and woman, the preservation of national independence in the face of the European Union's increasing power, the preservation of German culture amid 'European integration' and Islamization, and border security, including the expulsion of illegal immigrants. Last year, Tesla and SpaceX CEO Elon Musk deepened his support for the party, defending it against accusations of extremism and championing its policies as the nation's best path forward during challenging times. Robin Brooks, a senior fellow in the global economy and development program at the Brookings Institution, said in an Aug. 13 X post that 'Germany is in real trouble.' 'Its political center refuses to confront immigration, which is the issue driving relentless AfD growth,' he said. 'Instead, the political center name-calls AfD voters. Dereliction of duty.' Despite gaining considerable proportions of the vote, populist parties such as the AfD have been frozen out of governing coalitions in Europe by political opponents who regard them as extremist. In Austria, conservatives, Social Democrats, and liberals formed a coalition in March to block the anti-immigration and euro-skeptic Freedom Party from taking power, even after it won an electoral victory with 29 percent of the vote in September 2024. French President Emmanuel Macron on June 9, 2024, called a surprise snap parliamentary election following his centrist Renaissance party's poor performance in European Parliament elections, when the populist and nationalist party National Rally (RN) performed very strongly. RN, which recently polled at 35 percent, has increased its voter share ahead of the French presidential elections, which are scheduled to be held in or around April 2027.
Gulf Insider
28-07-2025
- Gulf Insider
German Police Raid AfD MEP's Property
German police have raided Alternative for Germany (AfD) MEP Petr Bystron's property for the 22nd time, using the pretext of his connection to the defunct Voice of Europe website, which was run by a man exiled from house raid came while Bystron was in Washington D.C., meeting with Trump officials, including congressmen and allies of President Donald Trump and Vice President J.D. early Tuesday morning, German police searched an older warehouse where Bystron conducted business a decade ago. 'This is targeted terror against the opposition,' Bystron said in a press release. 'There is no other way to classify the absurd behavior of the authorities.' Bystron was the target of Czech intelligence services last year, who decided to release a variety of allegations surrounding their investigation at a rather opportune time—right before EU parliamentary elections. The raid against Voice of Europe (VoE) and the accusations against Bystron, which Remix News covered, was widely seen as damaging the AfD's reputation before voters headed to the polls. Notably, Czech intelligence claimed to have voice recordings that revealed Bystron was involved with a scheme to provide politicians with money in exchange for conducting interviews with the outlet VoE. The Czech authorities have never made the recording of Bystron public despite demands from the AfD to release it. Nobody has ever been charged to date in connection with the allegations, including Bystron himself. Bystron, however, was the only name that was released in connection with the case, although authorities claimed six European politicians received money from VoE. The raid against Bystron may be seen as especially provocative as it was conducted at a time when Bystron was out of the country and meeting with Trump officials and congressmen. He is seen as the AfD party's key bridge to American policymakers and is known for his connections to the Republican Party. Bystron himself said that despite his properties being raided 21 times, the police have not turned up any incriminating information against him. He also said that the police have even raided his elderly mother's room in her retirement home and took testimony from her, despite her having been officially declared by the court as a dementia patient. 'Every single one of these 22 searches was illegal. Each one marks a step away from a democratic constitutional state and toward an authoritarian regime that seeks to silence dissent by any means necessary,' Bystron told the Gateway Pundit. Notably, the house raid of Bystron also occurred on the same day that a top German court in Leipzig rejected a significant AfD's appeal. The party was working to overturn its current designation as a 'suspected extremist' party by the powerful domestic spy agency, the Office for the Protection of the Constitution (BfV). With all appeals now exhausted, this means the BfV can conduct extraordinary surveillance on the AfD, including targeting members with wiretaps, reading their chats and emails, and using informants to infiltrate the party. A number of prominent commentators on the German right have already highlighted the case on X, with Naomi Seibt stating: 'They are spitting in the face of J.D. Vance.' 🚨 RUSSIA HOAX IN EUROPE – 22 HOUSE RAIDS‼️🇩🇪'They are spitting in the face of J. D. Vance!'@PetrBystronAfD is the Trump administration's favorite AfD is a THREAT to the they fabricated a FAKE Russia smear campaign.I met Bystron in DC with @Deu_Kurier. — Naomi Seibt (@SeibtNaomi) July 25, 2025 Other news outlets have also met the news of the incredible number of house searches targeting the AfD MEP with concern about Germany's quickly evolving totalitarian methods for dealing with dissent. 'Anyone who expresses critical views on war preparations must apparently expect house searches,' said a reporter from AUF1 in a video post shared by Bystron himself. AUF1 berichtet über die 22. Hausdurchsuchung bei Petr Bystron:"Wer sich kritisch zu den Kriegsvorbereitungen äußert, muss offenbar mit Hausdurchsuchungen rechnen." — Petr Bystron (@PetrBystronAfD) July 25, 2025 Pressure has grown on the German government over the incredible growth of the AfD. In the latest Yougov poll, the party is tied for first place with the CDU, with 25 percent of the vote. The CDU lost 3.5 percent of the vote, while the AfD has jumped 4.2 points. Also read: Most Dangerous City In Germany Is The One With The Most Migrants
