India Finds Stability in Fragile Kashmir Region
As India marked the completion of 78 years of independence on 15 August 2025, the nation reflected not only on its storied past but also on the quiet transformation of one of its most volatile frontiers: Jammu & Kashmir (J&K). Once synonymous with conflict and separation, the Union Territory under Lieutenant Governor Manoj Sinha has become a study in the delicate alchemy of security, development, and trust.
From Fragility to Forward Motion
Since 1947, India has grown into the world's largest democracy and a burgeoning economic power. Yet for decades, J&K remained India's most enduring challenge — beset by insurgency, political instability, and strained relations with neighbours. The government's bold move to revoke Article 370 in August 2019, revoking the region's special status, was met with global apprehension.
Five years later, India's Independence Day provided a revealing prism through which the world could assess whether governance could reconcile integration with growth — and J&K's apparent trajectory under Sinha suggests it can.
Manoj Sinha: Navigating Stormy Seas with Purpose
Arriving in August 2020, Sinha inherited a region under strict security and international scrutiny. Yet his tenure has, by many accounts, succeeded in altering the narrative.
Highlights include:
• A 40% reduction in militancy-related incidents since 2019. • A record 21 million (2.1 crore) tourists in 2023, fueling local economies. • Completion of the Kathua Waterfront in just four months, signalling administrative agility.
• High-turnout elections reaffirmed democratic engagement and civic trust.
On India's 78th Independence Day, Sinha captured the broader sentiment:
"Jammu & Kashmir is creating a new history by forgetting its troubled past. Democracy here has become stronger, and development is no longer a promise — it is visible in every corner of this land."
After waves of public dissent against militant influence, he added:
"When ordinary citizens openly resist Pakistan-backed terrorism, it is the strongest message of peace. People of J&K have chosen life, not violence."
He also assumed accountability for security lapses — including the devastating Pahalgam attack — affirming, "I take full responsibility for the incident, which was undoubtedly a security failure." Yet he emphasized that terrorism remains contained and progress continues.
Credibility Born of Delivery
Kashmir has historically been described as a place where "outsiders" struggle and often fail. But this time, the local sentiment appears different. An senior Indian bureaucrat posted in Delhi, observes:
"Kashmir has always been a place where outsiders struggled to govern and usually exited in failure or disgrace. Manoj Sinha has rewritten that history... Ordinary Kashmiris — not traditionally inclined to embrace Delhi's appointees — speak of him as their own. Many believe that if he were to contest elections tomorrow, he would win by a landslide."
A Lahore-based security analyst Ahmed Rashid's call surprised many,
"Sinha's economic-security balance is masterful. But Kashmir's real test begins when Delhi restores statehood." (A Pakistani praising an Indian? Unprecedented.)
Lessons for the World
For Singapore and other democracies or fragile-state watchers, J&K's evolution under Sinha offers key insights:
1. Stable Governance in Volatile Regions
Much like how Singapore maintained political continuity during its early years, J&K's steady leadership has provided the bedrock for normalization.
2. Development as a Strategic Stabiliser
Beyond force, infrastructure, tourism, and livelihoods have emerged as powerful peacebuilders — a model seen in places from Aceh to northern Ireland.
3. Democracy Recast in Post-Conflict Terrain
Conducting credible elections in a formerly conflict-rife landscape echoes successful peace transitions in other global contexts.
The Road Ahead
Speculation continues about Sinha's future — whether his role in Delhi's national leadership or governance in politically pivotal Uttar Pradesh will beckon. But for now, maintaining his leadership in Jammu & Kashmir appears crucial for consolidating gains and ensuring long-term transformation.
As India embraced its 78th Independence Day, its renewed experiment in J&K offers not just a national uplift but a global story: that even the most fragile places can find resilience when governance is steady, visionary, and rooted in action.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
4 hours ago
- Straits Times
US adviser Navarro says India's Russian crude buying has to stop
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox White House trade adviser Peter Navarro said it was risky as New Delhi was 'now cozying up to both Russia and China'. White House trade adviser Peter Navarro said India's purchases of Russian crude were funding Moscow's war in Ukraine and had to stop, adding that New Delhi was 'now cozying up to both Russia and China'. 'If India wants to be treated as a strategic partner of the US, it needs to start acting like one,' Mr Navarro wrote in an opinion piece published in the Financial Times. India's Foreign Ministry has previously said the country is being unfairly singled out for buying Russian oil while the United States and European Union continue to purchase goods from Russia. US President Donald Trump an additional 25 per cent tariff on Indian goods earlier in August, citing New Delhi's continued purchases of Russian oil, taking total tariffs on imports from India to 50 per cent. 'India acts as a global clearinghouse for Russian oil, converting embargoed crude into high-value exports while giving Moscow the dollars it needs,' Mr Navarro said. The adviser also said it was risky to transfer cutting-edge US military capabilities to India as New Delhi was 'now cozying up to both Russia and China'. Longtime rivals China and India are quietly and cautiously strengthening ties against the backdrop of Mr Trump's unpredictable approach to both. Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi is set to meet Chinese President Xi Jinping at the end of August, while Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi will visit India from Aug 18 , for talks on the disputed border between the two countries. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore NDR 2025 a rallying cry amid significant challenges facing Singapore, say analysts Singapore NDR 2025: The case for growing old at home in super-ageing Singapore Singapore WP urges Government to engage widely, explore all solutions following National Day Rally 2025 Opinion A 'we first' Singapore is the hardest policy for PM Lawrence Wong to deliver Singapore Age Well Neighbourhoods, job-matching by CDCs: 10 highlights from PM Wong's National Day Rally speech Singapore LTA, SMRT join anti-vaping effort with stepped-up enforcement on public transport World Trump, tech and Texas: What's next for the US? Singapore 3 foreigners arrested for working illegally as delivery riders in Singapore: Koh Poh Koon A planned visit by US trade negotiators to New Delhi from Aug 25 to Aug 29 has been called off, a source said over the weekend, delaying talks on a proposed trade agreement and dashing hopes of relief from additional US tariffs on Indian goods from Aug 27. REUTERS
Straits Times
4 hours ago
- Straits Times
Trump's tariffs will crush India's exporters, threatening livelihoods
NEW DELHI - A big part of India's economy is facing a nightmare scenario. On Aug 27, the extraordinarily high tariff of 25 per cent that President Donald Trump imposed on its exports to the United States is set to double. Businesses that were viable are bound to go bust quickly as orders dry up. 'We were shocked with the 25 per cent tariff, and thinking about how to meet this problem, how to face this,' said Ishtiaq Ahmad Khan, a fourth-generation carpet maker in Bhadohi, in the giant state of Uttar Pradesh. 'But now it's 50 per cent, so it became impossible. We're afraid that a lot of people will be unemployed.' Carpetmaking is a big business in India, with 98 per cent of the product shipped overseas. In recent years nearly 60 per cent of that stock has gone to buyers in the US. For US importers, that US$500 (S$641) rug now comes with a US$125 tariff and possibly a US$250 one. Bhadohi is at the heart of north India's carpet belt, home to hundreds or thousands of manufacturers like Mr Ishtiaq's company, Ajaz Carpets. They eke out their profits, so they don't have the means to absorb the giant price increases their US customers now face. Mr Ishtiaq, who led the industry's trade promotion council, estimates that 2.5 million people who live in the region could be plunged into subsistence-level poverty. Other industries in line to face unbearable wipeouts include textiles and garments, aquaculture – mainly farmed shrimp – and furniture. They are not India's flashiest businesses, but together they employ many millions of workers, and the billions they earn have helped keep India financially strong during periods of crisis. Carpets are nowhere near the highest-value component of the India-US trade in goods, which was worth US$129 billion in 2024. But for now, questions about the even bigger, more strategic parts of the two countries' trading relationship have been postponed. India is the primary producer of generic pharmaceuticals used in the US, for instance, and the US is that industry's biggest consumer market. But a carve-out in the Trump administration's tariffs has left it in limbo. It costs nothing to import Indian drugs at the moment. But Trump has promised that there will soon be a 150 per cent tariff, and eventually perhaps 250 per cent, which Trump believes will kick-start production in the US. Similar exemptions for semiconductors make it impossible to predict whether India's thriving electronics manufacturing – exemplified by Apple's shift in iPhone production from China to India – can survive. For the moment, they're off the hook. Oil and gas are complicated, too, as energy products are still exempted from tariffs. India's purchase of Russian oil, as it happens, is Mr Trump's justification for the additional, punitive tariff on its goods. Until that threat was made, the door was open to increasing India's purchase of American products. The potential damage the tariffs could inflict on India's gems and jewelry industry, another big-ticket part of the trading relationship, is not yet fully clear. But insiders are raising alarms, in part because the US is India's biggest buyer of gems. On Aug 7, when Trump announced the 50 per cent rate, Kirit Bhansali, chair of the industry's main association, wrote that 30 per cent of the global trade in Indian gems was at risk. 'A blanket tariff of this magnitude is severely devastating for the sector,' he wrote. Rival sectors in Turkey and Thailand are much smaller, but they will gain an unbeatable advantage over India thanks to lower national tariffs by Mr Trump. If there is any government plan to save the affected businesses, it's in hiding. Federal officials have asked the states to look after their own companies. Ajay Srivastava of the Global Trade Research Initiative, a think tank in New Delhi, said state governments have always depended on the national government to lead the way on foreign trade. Likewise, he said, India's banks will not be ready to forgive loans. On Aug 15, India's Independence Day, Prime Minister Narendra Modi took to the ramparts of the 16th-century Red Fort to deliver a traditional address to the nation. Without naming Mr Trump, who until recently he considered a political friend, or his tariffs, Mr Modi nonetheless delivered a message on the subject. He made reference to tough times ahead – and the need for India to go it alone. That way, he said, 'no selfish interest will ever be able to entrap us.' He extolled the virtues of self-reliance. 'The greater a nation's reliance on others, the more its freedom comes into question,' Mr Modi said, in an echo of Mahatma Gandhi and the leaders who fought for independence from the British Empire and its mercantile domination of India. Mr Modi's attempt to buck up India's 1.4 billion citizens spoke to the domestic political challenges Trump's attacks have dropped in his lap. One of the few new programmes he named will be aimed at creating more jobs for young people. But for the Indian technocrats and economists who for generations have pushed India toward free trade as the best way up the ladder of prosperity, Mr Modi's rally cry sounded like a step backward . NYTIMES
Straits Times
5 hours ago
- Straits Times
Trump is pushing India back toward China
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox Chinese President Xi Jinping and India Prime Minister Narendra Modi meet on the sidelines of the BRICS summit in Kazan, Russia, on Oct 23, 2024. BEIJING – It may be another case of the adage: The enemy of my enemy is my friend. Either way, it has come as a welcome surprise for China to see its top global rival, the United States, pick a fight with Beijing's biggest Asian competitor, India. Relations between Washington and New Delhi are on the fritz after the Trump administration threatened this month to double tariffs on Indian goods to a whopping 50 per cent, citing India's imports of Russian oil. The sudden rift threatens to undermine years of growing cooperation between the United States and India in areas like security and technology that had been fueled in large part by a shared desire to keep China's global ambitions in check. It has also injected new momentum into an easing of tensions between China and India, which had ramped up in recent years. The thaw started in earnest in October 2024 when President Xi Jinping of China met with Prime Minister Narendra Modi of India at a summit of emerging economies in Kazan, Russia. Since then, the two countries have increased official visits and discussed easing trade barriers and the movement of people. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore NDR 2025 a rallying cry amid significant challenges facing Singapore, say analysts Singapore NDR 2025: The case for growing old at home in super-ageing Singapore Singapore WP urges Government to engage widely, explore all solutions following National Day Rally 2025 Opinion A 'we first' Singapore is the hardest policy for PM Lawrence Wong to deliver Singapore Age Well Neighbourhoods, job-matching by CDCs: 10 highlights from PM Wong's National Day Rally speech Singapore LTA, SMRT join anti-vaping effort with stepped-up enforcement on public transport World Trump, tech and Texas: What's next for the US? Singapore 3 foreigners arrested for working illegally as delivery riders in Singapore: Koh Poh Koon 'I assume that there is a certain amount of schadenfreude among some folks in Beijing when they look at the trade issues between India and the United States,' said Mr Manoj Kewalramani, head of Indo-Pacific studies at the Takshashila Institution in Bangalore, India. 'A breakdown of political trust between New Delhi and Washington works in Beijing's favor.' To be sure, there is still much that divides the two Asian giants. That includes control of a 2,100-mile (3379km) shared border; China's coziness with India's adversary, Pakistan; and India's ambition to attract the multinational manufacturers that have been trying to reduce their dependence on China. The October meeting between Mr Modi and Mr Xi was the first time the two leaders had spoken in person since a 2019 summit in India, a year before relations cratered following a deadly Himalayan border fight between Chinese and Indian troops. Since the Russia talks, the two countries have eased travel visa restrictions and are working to restore direct flights. In June, Beijing allowed pilgrims from India to visit holy sites in Tibet. China and India are also in discussions to reopen three trading posts along their mountainous boundary, Mr Randhir Jaiswal, the spokesperson for India's foreign ministry, said last week. China's top diplomat, Mr Wang Yi, is scheduled to arrive in India on Aug 18 for the latest round of talks on border issues. It would be the first time Mr Wang has visited India in more than three years. This month, Mr Modi will visit China for the first time in seven years to attend a regional security summit meeting in the northeastern city of Tianjin. Mr Xi and President Vladimir Putin of Russia will also attend, bringing together three leaders at odds, to varying degrees, with the United States. The Modi government has also been careful not to raise the Indian public's ire over the way China helped Pakistan's military during a clash with Indian forces in May – a sign of New Delhi's commitment to smoother relations with Beijing. Mr Vijay Gokhale, a former Indian ambassador to Beijing, said in an opinion piece in The Times of India published Tuesday that China and India still had many diverging interests. But he wrote that China provided India and other developing countries a crucial counterbalance to 'Trumpian disorder' as a source of capital and technology and as a partner in fighting climate change. 'China is beginning to look better than at any time in the previous five years,' Mr Gokhale wrote. Beijing has responded to India's friendlier posture with cautious optimism, taking into account the chance that the reorientation could simply be a play to hedge against the Trump administration, analysts said. Mr Xi called this year for relations to resemble a harmonious 'dragon-elephant tango' in a nod to the two countries' symbolic creatures. Despite the gesture, China continues to fortify its border with India by building new roads, rail networks and villages that can also serve the Chinese military. The two powers are also vying for influence across the Indian Ocean, the crucial waterway for Beijing's Belt and Road Initiative, a global infrastructure project intended to deepen China's supply chain networks. One of the biggest drivers of tension with India from China's perspective is the suspicion that New Delhi was abandoning its historically nonaligned foreign policy to move further into Washington's sphere. Beijing points to the Quad defense group, which brings together four large democracies – India, the United States, Japan and Australia – to counter China's military rise. Whether the next meeting of Quad leaders, expected later this year in India, goes ahead will depend on whether the Trump administration and New Delhi are able to mend their trade spat and rebuild trust, an Indian official said. Still, if Indian officials want to improve ties with China, they will have to do it on Beijing's terms, analysts said. That means opening up India more to Chinese firms and investment and continuing to loosen restrictions on visas for Chinese businesspeople. India has blocked Chinese carmaker BYD from setting up factories and has banned Chinese apps including TikTok. 'If India seeks to improve its relations with China, China welcomes that,' said Mr Lin Minwang, an expert on China's relations with South Asia at Fudan University in Shanghai. 'However, China will not make significant concessions or sacrifices to accommodate India's so-called diplomatic posture.' Mr Lin said China will not budge on its national interests, even those that irk New Delhi the most, such as Beijing's close support for Pakistan. India is also wary, Mr Modi having been bitten once before after trusting Xi too readily, other analysts have said. 'India's current approach is primarily driven by strategic calculations,' Mr Lin said. 'Given its deteriorating relations with the United States, it has adopted some China-friendly gestures. I believe the Chinese side will at least assess these developments cautiously.' NYTIMES
