
Should Cockpits Have Video Cameras? Air India Crash Rekindles Debate
The deadly Air India crash last month has renewed a decades-old debate in the aviation industry over installing video cameras monitoring airline pilot actions to complement the cockpit voice and flight data recorders already used by accident investigators.
One of the industry's most influential voices, International Air Transport Association head Willie Walsh, a former airline pilot, said on Wednesday in Singapore, there was a strong argument for video cameras to be installed in airliner cockpits to monitor pilot actions to complement voice and flight data recorders already used by accident investigators.
Aviation experts have said a preliminary report from India's Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB) raised questions over whether one of the pilots of Air India flight 171 cut off fuel to the Boeing 787's engines seconds after takeoff, leading to an irrecoverable situation.
The crash in Ahmedabad, India, killed 241 of the 242 people aboard, as well as several others on the ground.
As of now, "based on what little we know now, it's quite possible that a video recording, in addition to the voice recording, would significantly assist the investigators in conducting that investigation on the issue of mental health," Walsh said.
Advocates for cockpit video cameras say the footage could fill in gaps left by the audio and data recorders, while opponents say concerns about privacy and misuse outweigh what they argue are marginal benefits for investigations.
Video footage was "invaluable" to Australian crash investigators determining what led to Robinson R66 helicopter breaking up in mid-air in 2023, killing the pilot, the only person aboard, according to the Australian Transport Safety Bureau's final report, which was released 18 days after the Air India crash.
The video showed "the pilot was occupied with non-flying related tasks for much of this time, specifically, mobile phone use and the consumption of food and beverages," the report said.
The ATSB commended Robinson Helicopters for providing factory-installed cameras and said it encouraged other manufacturers and owners to consider the ongoing safety benefits of similar devices.
In 2000, US National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) Chairman Jim Hall urged the Federal Aviation Administration to require commercial airliners be equipped with cockpit image recorders.
Hall's recommendation came in the wake of 1999's Egyptair Flight 990 crash, when the first officer intentionally crashed the Boeing 767, according to the NTSB, killing all 217 people on board.
"In the balance between privacy and safety, the scale tips toward safety, unequivocally," air safety expert and former commercial airline pilot John Nance said. "Protecting the flying public is a sacred obligation."
Another aviation safety expert, Anthony Brickhouse, said that as an accident investigator, he is in favour of cockpit video, but acknowledged that commercial pilots have real concerns.
Video on Air India flight 171 "would have answered lots of questions", he said.
Air India declined to comment. India's AAIB, which is expected to release a final report within a year of the crash under international rules, did not reply to request for comment.
PILOT OBJECTIONS
US pilots' unions such as the Air Line Pilots Association (ALPA) and Allied Pilots Association (APA) say the voice and data recorders already provide enough information to determine the cause of a crash and that the cameras would be an invasion of privacy and could be misused.
Calls for cockpit cameras are an understandable reaction to "the stress of not knowing what happened immediately after an accident," said APA spokesperson Dennis Tajer, an American Airlines pilot.
"I can understand the initial reaction of the more information, the better," but investigators already have enough data to adequately determine an accident's cause, leaving no need for cameras, he said.
To make flying safer, current safety systems should be enhanced to record higher-quality data, rather than adding video cameras, an ALPA spokesperson said.
There are also concerns the footage could be used by airlines for disciplinary actions or that video could be leaked to the public after a crash, said John Cox, an aviation safety expert, retired airline pilot and former ALPA executive air safety chairman.
A pilot's death being broadcast on "the 6 o'clock news is not something that the pilot's family should ever have to go through," he said.
If confidentiality can be assured around the world, "I can see an argument" for installing cameras, Cox said.
Cockpit voice recordings are typically kept confidential by investigators in favour of partial or full transcripts being released in final reports.
Despite that, the International Federation of Air Line Pilots Associations said it was sceptical that confidentiality could ever be assured for cockpit videos.
"Given the high demand for sensational pictures, IFALPA has absolutely no doubt that the protection of (airborne image recorder) data, which can include identifiable images of flight crewmembers, would not be ensured either," the organization said in a statement.
Boeing declined to disclose whether customers are able to order cockpit video recorders, while Airbus did not reply to request for comment.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Indian Express
2 hours ago
- Indian Express
‘Same man, same conclusion': Australian state MP found guilty of raping, sexually assaulting 2 men 2 years apart
An Australian state MP has been found guilty of raping a man and sexually assaulting another in separate incidents that happened two years apart. Gareth Ward, 44, the independent MP for Kiama in New South Wales, was convicted by a jury on Friday at the Downing Centre District Court. He was found guilty of three counts of indecent assault against an 18-year-old man in 2013 and one count of sexual intercourse without consent involving a 24-year-old man in 2015. Prosecutors said the two men did not know each other but gave very similar accounts of what happened. 'Similar behaviour, similar setting, same man, same conclusion. This is not a coincidence,' Crown prosecutor Monika Knowles told the jury, The Independent reported. Ward denied all charges. He claimed the 2015 incident did not happen and said the 2013 incident was being misremembered by the complainant. The defence argued the allegations were false. Earlier, the court heard that in 2013, Ward invited the teenager, who had been drinking, to his South Coast home and assaulted him three times despite his efforts to resist. In 2015, Ward raped a staff member who was intoxicated after an event at the NSW Parliament House. Ward has been granted bail and is living at one of his two homes. A court will consider whether to detain him next Wednesday, the Australian Broadcasting Corporation reported. He first entered the state parliament as a Liberal MP in 2011 and was made a minister after the 2019 election. He left the Liberal Party in 2021 after revealing that he was being investigated by police. He continued as an independent and was re-elected in 2023. Mark Speakman, leader of the opposition in the NSW parliament, said he respected the jury's decision. 'What any victim of sexual abuse endures is appalling and their strength in coming forward can't be overstated,' he said, as quoted by The Independent. 'There is no excuse for the criminal behaviour which the jury has found occurred beyond reasonable doubt — a complete abuse of power which has no place anywhere, let alone by those entrusted by the public to represent them.'


Mint
6 hours ago
- Mint
US DEA busts massive meth trafficking operation from LA to Australia, Surrey man held
The United States have detained a Surrey man – Opinder Singh Sian – for alleged links to the international drug trade in connection with alleged attempt to traffic 530 lbs. of methamphetamine from Los Angeles to Australia, reported Surrey Now-Leader. The report added that Sian had been charged with conspiracy to export at least 50 grams of methamphetamine and allegedly trafficked them on or around the summer of 2023 in Los Angeles. Citing the court documents, the report said that Sian is an "alleged member of a criminal gang" and had links with the Irish organised crime Kinahan family and Italian and Canadian organised crime groups. Also, Sian was linked to the B.C.-based Brother Keepers gang, reported the Vancouver Sun. Earlier in 2022, the Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA)'s high-intensity drug trafficking area group received a tip from the DEA's Ankara regarding inserting a confidential source into an international drug trafficking organization. Surrey Now-Leader added that the organisation allegedly needed help from someone acting as the transportation coordinator for moving drugs from Los Angeles to Australia. When the DEA agent contacted the source on the phone, they gave them Sian's number. The warrant notes that Sian was living in Vancouver at the time, but the Vancouver Sun article noted his connections to Surrey. Reports claimed that the source and Sian met in person and spoke over the phone several times. They even allegedly discussed coordinating "multiple deliveries of methamphetamine from co-conspirators" to the confidential source in Southern California for shipment to Australia, added the reports. "Sian advised the source that he and his criminal associates would be delivering a total of an estimated 500-750 kilograms of methamphetamine that would be made in separate deliveries being coordinated by Sian's criminal associates," the court documents read. The document added that Sian and his associates arranged for four drop-offs to the source, which would be shipped off to Australia. Sian also created several group chats with the source and his criminal associates to arrange the deliveries. In mid-October 2023, DEA and Australian law enforcement "packaged sham methamphetamine and placed a tracking device inside." In the meantime, Sian has waived his right to a detention hearing in Nevada so he could have one in California. Until he is transferred to California for a detention hearing, he remains in custody.
&w=3840&q=100)

Business Standard
7 hours ago
- Business Standard
Delhi court denies bail to businessman in ₹48,000 crore PMLA fraud case
Delhi's Rouse Avenue Court has rejected the bail plea of businessman Harsatinder Pal Singh Hayer, accused in a money laundering case linked with the alleged cheating of investors to the tune of ₹48,000 crore. Hayer, the son-in-law of the late Nirmal Singh Bhangu, is one of the accused in the case linked to PACL. He is on bail granted by the Delhi High Court in a related case filed by the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI). Special Judge (CBI) Jagdish Kumar rejected Hayer's bail plea in the money laundering case in view of the nature of allegations levelled against him. The court observed that the allegations against Hayer are that he has committed a white-collar economic offence involving the misappropriation of hard-earned money of gullible investors. "The gullible investors were allegedly duped to the tune of about ₹48,000 crores. The economic offences are considered grave in nature," the Special Judge stated in the order passed on July 25. The court also noted that the accused had allegedly attempted to destroy electronic evidence. "Although the trial of the case will take considerable time, considering the allegations against the accused and his role, I deem that he is not entitled to relief for enlarging him on bail. The application for grant of bail to the applicant/accused is dismissed accordingly," the order stated. During the hearing, the counsel for the accused, Harsatinder Pal Singh Hayer, argued that he had been in custody for about four months and that the investigation against him had been completed. So his further custody is not required. He also argued that Hayer was not the Director of any company which has allegedly collected money from gullible investors. He further contended that accused was not a guilty mind or knowledge that the amount infused in Australian companies were collected illegally hence it cannot be presumed that Hayer was having knowledge of the same being collected by illegal means. However, the Enforcement Directorate (ED), represented by Special Public Prosecutor (SPP) Naveen Kumar Matta and Mohd. Faizan, opposed the bail plea. ED submitted that Hayer is the son-in-law of Shri Nirmal Singh Bhangoo, and he was also one of the Directors of the two Australian Companies, namely M/s Pearls Australasia Pty Ltd from February 2012 to January 2016, and M/s Australasia Mirage I-Pty Ltd from 13.02.2012 to 14.08.2014. These are the companies to which POCs, generated by duping gullible investors, were diverted via M/S. PIPL, an associate company of M/s. PACL, ED argued. The ED also argued that Hayder had deliberately not disclosed the properties being purchased from the proceeds of crime being layered through PACL and its associated entities, either in his personal account or in the accounts of companies of which he was a director. Special Public Prosecutor (SPP) for ED also argued that Hayer is one of the Directors of M/s Pearls Australasia Pty Ltd and M/s Australasia Mirage I-Pty Ltd, in which ₹657.18 Crore was infused. It was further argued that a FIR registered at Police Station Zira, Punjab in 2020 and through investigation of that FIR, facts were revealed that Hayer was involved in the sale and purchase of properties being acquired from the proceeds of crime laid by PACL.