Broward Judge Gary Farmer suspended without pay over off-color statements
A Broward judge with a penchant for off-color humor and tough-talking discipline will be suspended without pay until further notice as the Florida Supreme Court decides whether to permanently remove him from the bench.
The suspension of Broward Circuit Judge Gary Farmer takes effect at 11:59 p.m. Monday, by order of the Florida Supreme Court.
The action came just a few days after Farmer, through attorney Michael Dutko, argued that he should not be suspended without pay because the allegations of misconduct against him did not include any allegation that Broward residents were 'victimized by any illegal, dishonest, or immoral conduct.'
What he did do, by his own admission, was make statements from the bench that called into question how seriously he was taking his job as an overseer in the administration of justice.
In one afternoon last summer, he was recorded telling one defendant to wear a condom while on probation, nearly using profanity while having another defendant removed from his courtroom, and repeating flamboyant gay stereotypes from the 1990s sketch comedy show 'In Living Color.'
At the time, Farmer presided over third-degree felony cases, many of which resulted in little to no prison time for first-time offenders, depending on the severity of the case. According to Dutko, Farmer was trying to provide some degree of relief for those who found themselves appearing before him.
Earlier this year, the Judicial Qualifications Commission, which is the state's watchdog for judicial misconduct, filed formal charges accusing Farmer of violating the rules governing judges' behavior on and off the bench.
Farmer was elected to the bench in 2022 after serving in the Florida Legislature, where he rose to the position of minority leader until his fellow Democrats ousted him from the role in 2021.
His suspension is the third ordered against a Broward judge this month. Last week, Circuit Judge Mardi Levey Cohen was ordered to serve a 10-day suspension for spreading unverified information about her opponent in the 2024 election, while Circuit Judge Stephanie Moon was suspended for 10 days after she admitted questioning a lawyer about her campaign from the bench.
In the cases against Levey Cohen and Moon, the suspensions appear to signal the end of the disciplinary action they face. But the Florida Supreme Court made it clear that the case against Farmer was just getting started, and he will not be able to serve as a judge or as an attorney until it's resolved.
Also last week, the JQC filed formal ethics charges against County Judge Lauren Peffer, who was accused of spreading false information during her campaign without vetting it for accuracy.
Rafael Olmeda can be reached at rolmeda@sunsentinel.com or 954-356-4457. Follow him on Threads.net/@rafael.olmeda.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hill
35 minutes ago
- The Hill
Bill Maher urges Democrats to win back Elon Musk
Robby Soave and Lindsey Granger react to Bill Maher's advice to Democrats to reach out to Elon Musk in the wake of his and President Trump's falling out.
Yahoo
40 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Musk's father says Trump dispute triggered by intense stress, has to end
By Guy Faulconbridge MOSCOW (Reuters) -The dispute between Donald Trump and Elon Musk was triggered by months of intense stress on both sides, and the public battle between the U.S. president and the billionaire donor needs to stop, Musk's father told Reuters on Monday. Trump and Musk began exchanging insults last week on social media, with the Tesla and SpaceX CEO describing the president's sweeping tax and spending bill as a "disgusting abomination". Asked whether he thought his son had made a mistake by engaging in a public clash with the president, Errol Musk said people were sometimes unable to think as clearly as they should "in the heat of the moment." "They've had five months of intense stress," Musk told Reuters at a conference in Moscow organised by conservative Russian tycoons. "With all the opposition cleared and two people left in the arena, all they have ever done is get rid of everything and now they are trying to get rid of each other - well that has to stop." Asked how it would end, he said: "Oh, it will end on a good note - very soon." Neither the White House nor Musk could be reached for comment outside normal U.S. business hours. Trump said on Saturday his relationship with Musk was over and that there would be "serious consequences" if the world's richest man decided to fund U.S. Democrats running against Republicans who vote for the tax and spending bill. Musk bankrolled a large part of Trump's 2024 presidential campaign. Trump named Musk to head an effort to downsize the federal workforce and slash spending. Musk's father told reporters he was standing by his son. "Elon is sticking to his principles but you cannot always stick to your principles in the real world," Musk's father said. "Sometimes you have to give and take." Speaking beside sanctioned Russian businessman Konstantin Malofeyev, Musk's father praised President Vladimir Putin as a "very stable and pleasant man." He accused "fake media" in the West of projecting "complete nonsense" about Russia and for casting it as an enemy.
Yahoo
40 minutes ago
- Yahoo
The Minnesota Legislature convenes today for a 21-hour special session. Here's what they plan to do.
May 15, 2025 at the Minnesota State Capitol. (Photo by Nicole Neri/Minnesota Reformer) Minnesota Lawmakers will gavel in at 10 a.m. Monday to begin a 21-hour-long mad dash to pass bills that fund state government for the next two years, including everything from schools to parks to services for people with disabilities. The Legislature adjourned on May 19 without finishing a budget, which is required to avoid a partial state government shutdown on July 1. Democrats and Republicans share control of the House, while Democrats hold a one-seat majority in the Senate, so every bill has to be bipartisan. This has proven to be difficult. Gov. Tim Walz and legislative leaders have been negotiating a budget agreement behind closed doors for the past few weeks and blew through several self-imposed deadlines. On May 15, Walz and leaders announced a budget deal, but it fell apart within minutes of its announcement. Democratic House and Senate members banged on the doors of the press conference, decrying the leaders' agreement to strip state-subsidized health insurance from undocumented adults. Walz and legislative leaders have agreed to a one-day special session in which they need to pass 14 mostly budget-related bills. The special session agreement suggests that leaders have whipped enough votes for the bills to pass. Lawmakers don't have a limit on how long they can speak on the floor for each bill, making it harder to contain the special session to one day. Here's an overview of the larger — and more contentious — issues included in the bills: A rollback of undocumented adults' eligibility in MinnesotaCare, the state's subsidized health insurance program for the working poor. A Department of Human Services budget bill that will cut $270 million over the next two years, mostly from nursing homes and home care programs. A commerce and consumer protection budget and policy bill, which includes the creation of an ombudsperson to mediate disputes between homeowners and their HOAs. An education budget bill that will hold K-12 funding steady for the next two years. It doesn't touch existing subsidies for private schools, a win for the GOP. A $700 million infrastructure package that mostly focuses on asset preservation. Infrastructure packages are known around the Capitol as a 'bonding bill' because they use borrowed money, requiring a three-fifths supermajority — i.e., robust bipartisan support — to pass. A repeal of aid generated from the tax on legal cannabis sales to local government and counties. This cut is expected to generate around $22 million over the next two years for Minnesota's general fund but is irking local governments. Increasing the sales tax on cannabis from 10% to 15%. Cannabis was legalized in 2023 but the state has yet to create a fully functioning legal marijuana market. Repealing an exemption on electricity used by data centers in Minnesota, which is expected to generate $140 million in revenue in the next four years. Capping the maximum payroll tax for the state's new paid leave program, which is scheduled to launch in January. The Legislature will reduce the payroll tax cap from 1.2% to 1.1%. The cap is moot for now; the state says the program will begin next year with a 0.88% payroll tax, which will be split between workers and their employer. Minor changes to the state's earned sick and safe time law that gives employers and their allies in the Senate a small victory. Lawmakers also plan to pass budget bills on health, children and families, higher education, energy, environment and natural resources.
