
Janaki is everywhere. But only CBFC sees a problem
Could such a film, so thoroughly mainstream in 2001, be made today? One might well ask this question, considering the meltdown that the CBFC appears to have had over a Malayalam film called Janaki v/s State of Kerala, beginning with the name of the protagonist, who is a rape survivor. How, the CBFC demanded to know, could a sexual assault survivor be named after the goddess Sita? Its refusal to certify the film unless the title and character name were changed — along with several more cuts — led to the producers seeking relief in the High Court. And as if its objections had not been absurd enough, the CBFC stated in a counter-affidavit, '(the protagonist) is aided by a man belonging to a particular religious community and is cross-examined and asked harrowing questions by a person belonging to another religious community. This religious dichotomy in the treatment of the character bearing Goddess Sita's sacred name has the potential to inflame communal tensions and create divisive narratives between religious groups.'
And here we come back to Lajja, in which not one, but four characters were named after Sita — Vaidehi, Maithili, Janki and Ram Dulaari. The very choice of these names was meant to drive home the film's message about the horrors that women have to endure in a deeply patriarchal society. The same year, a film named Ravanaprabhu was made in Kerala, in which a woman named Janaki falls in love with the title character — it went on to become one of the top-grossing Malayalam films of that year. If these films could be made and released without hurting sentiments or disrupting public order in 2001, one can only despair over how far Indian society has regressed in the 24 years since — at least in the CBFC's imagination.
Because that, too, is among the many troubling aspects of this whole controversy: The wounds that the CBFC is seeking to salve by holding up the release of a film that was already cleared by its regional office in Thiruvananthapuram are entirely imaginary. As the Court itself noted, not one protest has erupted in the state. Not only is the CBFC going beyond its remit to decide what filmgoers in India can and cannot watch, it is hypothesising about how they might feel about a film and acting on it before the film has even been released.
The CBFC has a long history of attempting to circumscribe artistic space and infantilising the audience, but in Kerala the case of Janaki v/s state of Kerala has an especially disturbing resonance given the controversy in March over L2: Empuraan, which suggests that the ground may indeed have shifted. In Empuraan's case, it was not the CBFC that posed the problem, but some social media users and members of the Sangh Parivar who took offence to its depiction of the 2002 Gujarat riots. That the producers of the film and its star, Mohanlal, apologised and agreed to 'voluntary modifications' to dialogues or scenes that may have 'pained' anyone betrayed a sense of being under siege, not by the scissors of official censorship, but by 'sentiments' of the easily offended.
Some in the Malayalam film industry have sought to trace the current controversy back to the capitulation seen during the L2:Empuraan episode, arguing that ceding space to the hurt sentiments brigade at that time has normalised such reactions. That may not be entirely fair; we've been seeing similar controversies and capitulations in the Hindi film industry for a while, after all. Malayalam cinema has, so far, been protected by the unselfconscious sense of religious harmony that has long characterised it and which has mostly kept artistic freedom and creativity from being hijacked by manufactured outrage. Could the furore over Janaki v/s… — whose producers have agreed to add the initial 'V' before 'Janaki' in the title, besides two more cuts — herald a narrowing of this space?
pooja.pillai@expressindia.com
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Indian Express
4 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Fahadh Faasil says his retirement plan is to drive an Uber in Barcelona: ‘Idea of driving someone from one place to another is beautiful'
Back in 2020, Malayalam star Fahadh Faasil made headlines while promoting his film C U Soon, when he candidly shared his unusual retirement dream, was becoming an Uber driver in Spain. Now, five years later, seems like nothing has changed for him. In a recent conversation with The Hollywood Reporter India, when asked if he still stands by that sentiment, Fahadh responded: 'Yeah, yeah. Of course. We were in Barcelona a few months back. I still very much think about it. I think that'll only happen once people are done with me, you know? Jokes aside, but just the idea of driving someone from one place to another, I think that's a beautiful thing. At least you're witnessing someone's destination. And I still do that, every time I get a chance to drive, I drive. There, here, everywhere. Whenever I get the chance, I take the wheel. It's something I still enjoy a lot. That's my time for myself. And it's really good for thinking while driving.' Also Read | Fahadh Faasil accepts he uses a 'dumb phone' that was discontinued years ago: 'In two years, I want to be accessible only by email' Fahadh, known for his low-key public presence and absence from social media, was also asked if not being online makes it harder to stay relevant, especially with younger Gen Z audiences. He dismissed the concern with characteristic clarity: 'I'll get alienated the day I start making bad movies. Nothing else will push me out. The moment I start doing bad films, that's when people will want to move on from me. As long as I believe the attempt is honest, they'll still want to keep me around. Or at least think, 'This guy is up to something,' you know?' The actor is currently promoting his upcoming comedy-thriller Maareesan, which also stars veteran Tamil actor Vadivelu. The film has already caught everyone attention as none other than Kamal Haasan recently took to X (formerly Twitter) to praise the movie, calling it a film that made him laugh, and think at the same time.


News18
an hour ago
- News18
Was 'Virus' Played By Boman Irani In '3 Idiots' Really A Villain?
Why was Virus so disliked in 3 Idiots? Reddit has revisited '3 Idiots' to shed light on Boman Irani's iconic character. The villains in select Bollywood movies do not enjoy the luxury of being portrayed in the grey area. Their accompanying background score, the 'villainous" dialogues they utter, the animated mannerisms they exhibit, or them being clowned on the screen over and over again by the 'hero" throughout the movie, make the audience return to their homes and wonder, 'Well, that character was a total jerk!" Over the years, Indian janta that enjoys Bollywood movies has revisited cinema and changed their stance on some of the characters they hated growing up. Anshuman in Jab We Met (2007) could have handled the Geet situation with empathy and respect, but was he really the bad guy or just stuck in a sticky situation as his love interest Geet? Sure, Subodh was a walking and talking calendar in Dil Chahta Hai (2001), but isn't it a green flag that a partner remembers the minute details of their dates, which could mean they really care? Dr Asthana's sole crime in Munna Bhai M.B.B.S. (2003) was that he made Munna's father cry, aware that their son was a local gangster with no real medical background. Was Munna hanging out on the hospital campus around real patients safe then? And now, Reddit has turned the clock back and revisited the curious case of Virus aka Viru Sahastrabudhhe, the iconic character portrayed by an exceptional Boman Irani in the coming-of-age comedy-drama 3 Idiots (2009). Out And Out Villain? 'Thoughts On Him? I Am Slowly Realizing He Was Correct All The Time," Reddit user Fun_Cookie7135 titled his post. 'i think the point was simply that even if you are correct you have to be a nice person for other people to respect you and understand you, (sic)" a user, responding to the post, wrote. The OP added to the conversation by saying, 'The movie presented him as a villain rather than showing that his saying was & remains correct in real world." A third asserted that Virus's favourite student succeeded in life, but so did the students he disliked – implying that his teachings were misplaced, and he was wrong in preaching that marks were everything to thrive in the real world. Virus' Impact First Rancho, then Pia (Viru's daughter) – both remind Virus about the suicides of Joy and the director's son. The unempathetic head of the college declines a deadline extension to Joy Lobo, who is building a drone but hasn't completed his project yet owing to his father's ailment. Joy is devastated as he proceeds to take his own life. Additionally, Viru's son is pressured to pursue engineering instead of literature, his preferred career path. Piaa reveals to him in the tail end of the movie that her brother did not lose his life in a freak train accident but had died by suicide. The arrogant director, though not directly involved, refuses to admit his part in the loss of two lives. When pressured by Virus to betray his friend Rancho to avoid expulsion from college, Raju jumps out of the window from the director's office. He, however, survives and makes a full recovery. The movie shows Boman Irani's character in a moment of 'redemption" when he holds his grandchild, whom Rancho and fellow hostlers help deliver at the campus, and says that he could become a footballer instead of imposing his idealistic take on 'excellence". But was that enough to redeem him? Virus was a flawed man who lacked accountability, and his ego damaged those around him. A page called ' Villains Wiki" summed up Virus' crimes which, according to them, were as follows: 1) Abuse of power 2) Psychological abuse 3) Wrongful termination 4) Enforced suicide 5) Attempted sabotage Get Latest Updates on Movies, Breaking News On India, World, Live Cricket Scores, And Stock Market Updates. Also Download the News18 App to stay updated! tags : 3 Idiots view comments Location : New Delhi, India, India First Published: July 24, 2025, 13:22 IST News explainers Was 'Virus' Played By Boman Irani In '3 Idiots' Really A Villain? Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.


News18
an hour ago
- News18
News 18 Afternoon Digest: Passenger Plane With 50 On Board Goes Missing, 9 Killed, 14 Injured In Cambodian Attacks & Other Stories
Last Updated: We are also covering: SC Says 'Won't Make Same Mistake' On HC's Bail Relief To Actor Darshan, First Visuals Show Missing Russian Aircraft's Debris and other stories. In today's News18 afternoon digest, we bring to you the latest on the Russian plane crash, the Renukaswamy murder case, Thailand-Cambodia Border Clash and other top stories. Debris Found After Passenger Plane With 50 On Board Goes Missing In Russia's Far East, All Feared Dead A passenger plane with nearly 50 people on board went missing in Russia's far east on Thursday. According to IFAX, the debris of the plane was found in the eastern Amur region. Multiple reports suggested all people on board the plane died and that there were no survivors. However, there was no official confirmation on the same. Read More The Supreme Court on Thursday reserved its order on the Karnataka government's plea challenging the High Court's decision to grant bail to actor Darshan and others in the Renukaswamy murder case. The court questioned the manner in which the High Court gave the order granting bail to actor Darshan and others. Actor Shilpa Shirodkar, who starred in hits like Hum, Aankhen, and Khuda Gawah, has opened up about her new way of life post her Bigg Boss 18 stint. Shilpa mentioned that after staying in the Bigg Boss 18 house, she doesn't spend much time in the kitchen and only uses three ingredients to cook her food. This move even left her husband surprised. Read More With a full four days left in the Manchester Test, India are in danger of being reduced to 10 batters against England after Rishabh Pant copped a blow to his right foot that forced him off the field on the opening day. While the severity of Pant's injury is still unknown, former cricketers including Ravi Shastri, Ricky Ponting, Michael Atherton are concerned that the reaction from Pant indicates it could be quite serious and potentially end his England tour prematurely. Read More view comments Location : New Delhi, India, India First Published: July 24, 2025, 13:48 IST Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.