Cancer care divide
Depending on the severity of the illness, cancer treatment may require a single radiation session or somewhere around five sessions per week for several weeks. With private radiation therapy costing Rs15,000 to Rs20,000 per session, this can cost up to Rs400,000 per month excluding multiple caregiving expenses. The average monthly household income in Sindh stands at around Rs40,000 — which is 10% of the cost. Private treatment therefore is entirely out of the question for low-income patients. This leaves them with no other option but under-resourced, understaffed and overcrowded government hospitals that can barely manage to handle existing patients. Modern medicine is a 21st century miracle. But unfortunately for many, this miracle remains stuck behind a paywall. Limited access to healthcare, late diagnosis and general socioeconomic disparities all contribute to higher mortality rates in lower-income populations.
Government hospitals are in dire need of funding and attention. The disparity between diseased persons and inbound patients is too high to be fixed without targeted intervention. The government must recognise the lapse in equitable healthcare facilities across all socioeconomic classes as it is duty-bound to provide care to its citizens, and accessibility is the first step to care. Without such measures, the cycle of preventable deaths will only persist.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
19 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Orthopaedic treatment stalled at govt hospitals
Although the Sindh government claims free medical treatment is available in all public hospitals, the reality for patients needing complex surgical procedures — particularly those with fractures — is quite the opposite. Reportedly, patients requiring operations for various types of fractures are often asked to purchase all surgical tools themselves. In nearly 95 per cent of cases, patients at public hospitals are expected to procure orthopaedic rods and plates used in bone repair surgeries from external suppliers. These orthopaedic implants, imported from abroad, are costly and often beyond the reach of the average patient. For instance, Zaheer Ahmed Khan was hit by a motorcycle near Khudadad Colony late at night nearly four months ago. After emergency treatment, it was determined that his left shinbone had been fractured. Due to overcrowding and lack of surgical materials at the Jinnah Hospital, his family moved him to a private hospital, where the surgery including the implant of a metal plate cost around Rs200,000. Although Zaheer is now able to walk considerable distances even without a stick, his family had to incur considerable expenses on medical check-ups, medication, a walking frame and a walking stick. Similarly, the father of Rashid, who is receiving treatment at Jinnah Hospital, shared that his son sustained fractures in one arm and one leg during a motorbike accident. "My son's limbs were placed in a cast, and we were told that the actual procedure involves inserting a plate through surgery to align and heal the bone. A doctor at the Jinnah Hospital instructed us to return after three months with the required surgical equipment. When I inquired about the cost of the recommended items, I discovered that various types of plates were available in the market, all of which were extremely expensive. We took out a loan to purchase the surgical supplies and proceeded with the operation for my son," recounted the father. Dr Muhammad Suleman, Joint Executive Director of Jinnah Hospital and an orthopaedic surgeon, explained that there were various methods of treating fractures. "These include conservative treatment, where a plaster is applied to the broken bone for a few weeks, followed by an X-ray to decide if surgery is necessary. In some cases, the fracture does not heal with plaster alone and surgery becomes essential. It is true that in government hospitals, patients are asked to arrange their own surgical equipment for such procedures. However, in cases of extreme need, assistance may be sought from welfare organizations or philanthropic individuals, though this process can take time. Dozens of fracture cases arrive daily, and it is simply not possible to provide surgical supplies to all patients, free of cost," justified Dr Suleman. Dr Atiq Qureshi, Medical Superintendent at the Sindh Government Liaquatabad Hospital, added that district hospitals operated on significantly lower budgets than tertiary care centers. "Our hospital sees a high volume of road accident victims in the emergency ward daily. In the absence of adequate surgical facilities, these patients are stabilized and then referred to Civil or Jinnah Hospital. The average cost of a leg bone implant surgery ranges between Rs15,000 and Rs20,000, and with multiple patients daily, the expense can easily exceed Rs0.1 million. This exceeds our limited budget. The majority of district hospital funds are allocated towards medicines and diagnostic tests," claimed Dr Qureshi. Over the past two years, prices of medicines have increased by 60 to 70 per cent. Likewise, the prices of imported orthopaedic implants have seen a significant surge. Hospital administrations have confirmed that the worsening condition of Karachi's roads has led to a spike in traffic accidents, resulting in a daily influx of patients with broken bones. Typically, these patients receive only plaster casts at public hospitals since they do not have the capacity to offer permanent treatment.
Express Tribune
4 days ago
- Express Tribune
BBH faces governance, financial collapse
Several dengue patients are isolated in mosquito nets at the Benazir Bhutto Hospital, Rawalpindi. PHOTO: ONLINE The Special Monitoring Unit's inspection report has revealed serious mismanagement, financial irregularities, patient exploitation, and a systemic breakdown of governance at Benazir Bhutto Hospital (BBH), Rawalpindi. The findings have been submitted to the Punjab Chief Minister, accompanied by recommendations for urgent reforms. The report describes the state of healthcare delivery and basic facilities at the hospital as "extremely poor". Inspectors found that the majority of doctors and paramedical staff were absent, while ICU patients were left lying on bloodstained beds without the supervision of either doctors or nurses. Despite overwhelming crowds in the Emergency and Outpatient Departments, only two service counters were operational. It was further revealed that 80% of prescribed medicines were unavailable, compelling patients to purchase them from outside. Government-supplied drugs were missing from the pharmacy, while cartons of expired medicines were discovered on-site. Members of staff were found soliciting bribes from patients, including at token counters where payments were demanded in exchange for services. In one case, a patient was asked to pay Rs90,000 to avoid queues and obtain surgery. The inspection team also observed doctors and nurses distracted by mobile phones during duty hours, while pharmaceutical companies appeared to wield undue influence. Promotional brochures and calendars of pharmaceutical firms were found displayed in the office of the Medical Superintendent (MS). Sanitation across the hospital was described as "paralysed". Toilets were declared unusable, water filtration plants were out of order, and drinking water supplies were unsafe. Additional complaints were received about exposed electrical wiring and leaking ceilings in the OPD building. The hospital is burdened with liabilities totalling Rs440 million, while CCTV cameras were disabled and no biometric attendance system was in place. Nor was there a designated waiting area for patients and their families. Conditions at the hospital canteen were also found to be deplorable, with unhygienic food, inflated prices, and piles of waste. Parking contractors were reportedly charging Rs50 per vehicle, despite the official rate being Rs30. The Special Monitoring Unit, attaching all evidence, has submitted the report to the chief minister with a call for immediate remedial action. The monitoring exercise identified critical shortcomings in the provision of medicines, parking, sanitation, food services, washrooms, water filtration, and surgical procedures, and urged comprehensive reforms without delay.
Express Tribune
4 days ago
- Express Tribune
Cancer care divide
The city of Karachi is facing a concerning crisis in healthcare with gravely inadequate facilities for cancer treatment at government hospitals, practically barring an entire socioeconomic class from receiving medical aid. Apart from those at private hospitals, there are only two radiation units in the city, one at Jinnah Hospital and the other at Kiran Hospital. Civil Hospital, which is another public care facility, only has 44 beds in its cancer unit. To put these numbers into perspective: Civil Hospital receives over 100 cancer patients in its cancer OPD daily, while Jinnah Hospital receives nearly 180. Depending on the severity of the illness, cancer treatment may require a single radiation session or somewhere around five sessions per week for several weeks. With private radiation therapy costing Rs15,000 to Rs20,000 per session, this can cost up to Rs400,000 per month excluding multiple caregiving expenses. The average monthly household income in Sindh stands at around Rs40,000 — which is 10% of the cost. Private treatment therefore is entirely out of the question for low-income patients. This leaves them with no other option but under-resourced, understaffed and overcrowded government hospitals that can barely manage to handle existing patients. Modern medicine is a 21st century miracle. But unfortunately for many, this miracle remains stuck behind a paywall. Limited access to healthcare, late diagnosis and general socioeconomic disparities all contribute to higher mortality rates in lower-income populations. Government hospitals are in dire need of funding and attention. The disparity between diseased persons and inbound patients is too high to be fixed without targeted intervention. The government must recognise the lapse in equitable healthcare facilities across all socioeconomic classes as it is duty-bound to provide care to its citizens, and accessibility is the first step to care. Without such measures, the cycle of preventable deaths will only persist.
