Resignation of army chief over Gaza occupation would further divide Israel
's top general has warned that the country will be falling into a strategic trap that endangers the lives of hostages if it pushes ahead with plans to occupy the entire
Gaza Strip
.
Israel's cabinet is expected to convene on Thursday to approve such a move, despite the opposition of the top military echelon.
A senior official close to Israeli prime minister
Binyamin Netanyahu
was quoted as saying this week: 'The die is cast – we are going for a full occupation of the Gaza Strip. There will be operations even in areas where hostages are being held. If the chief of staff doesn't agree, he should resign.'
Israel Defense Forces (IDF) chief of staff Lieut Gen Eyal Zamir was personally appointed by Netanyahu five months ago, as part of the policy to replace generals connected to the debacle of the October 7th 2023 Hamas attack. He was chosen, partly to appease Netanyahu's right-wing base, as an 'aggressive' general who could defeat Hamas.
READ MORE
But, with the IDF already controlling some 75 per cent of the coastal enclave and following the collapse of the Gaza ceasefire talks, Zamir has made clear his opposition to a manoeuvre to conquer the entire territory. Instead, he presented a plan to seal off Gaza city, the central refugee camps and the Muwassi humanitarian zone in the south, enabling Israeli forces to carry out what the plan called pinpoint raids against remaining Hamas militants.
But Netanyahu rejected the plan, opting for a full-scale assault despite the dangers, and issuing a statement saying the army was 'ready to implement any decision the security cabinet makes'.
In August 2024 Hamas gunmen murdered six hostages being held in a tunnel in Rafah when they believed IDF troops were approaching. The IDF is concerned that the remaining 20 hostages believed to be alive will be in danger if it advances into areas where the hostages are held. Militants guarding the bodies of 30 deceased hostages may also flee or be killed, raising the possibility that the bodies will be lost forever.
[
Egyptian president condemns Israel over reported plan for full military takeover of Gaza
Opens in new window
]
Zamir is also worried by the possibility of high IDF casualties and about burnout among combat soldiers after 22 months of fighting, particularly among reservists who have served hundreds of days in uniform since the start of the war. An escalation of the war will likely require a substantial call-up of additional reservists, while Netanyahu's government is working to ensure that ultra-Orthodox Jews do not have to enlist.
According to some analysts, Zamir will be forced to resign if the cabinet approves an occupation of all Gaza, causing further division in Israeli society, with polls showing more than 60 per cent of people support a ceasefire to end the war.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Donald Trump could meet Vladimir Putin for Ukraine war talks ‘as soon as next week'
Donald Trump could meet Vladimir Putin as soon as next week to discuss the war in Ukraine, White House officials have said, although senior administration officials have warned that serious 'impediments' remain to achieving a ceasefire. White House officials briefed US media that Trump would seek a summit with Putin after the US special envoy Steve Witkoff met the Russian leader at the Kremlin on Wednesday. A White House official said that while the meeting had gone well and Moscow was eager to continue engaging with the United States, secondary sanctions that Mr Trump has threatened against countries doing business with Russia were still expected to be implemented on Friday. On Wednesday the US signalled its intentions by doubling import tariffs on goods from India to 50 per cent over New Delhi's purchases of Russian oil. READ MORE After Mr Witkoff met Putin, Mr Trump claimed 'great progress was made' during the talks on ending the war in Ukraine. Mr Trump later told European leaders he was planning to meet Putin one-on-one as soon as next week and then follow up with a meeting with Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelenskiy. Marco Rubio, the US secretary of state, said he did not want to exaggerate the progress made during Mr Witkoff's talks with Putin. 'Hopefully if things continue to progress an opportunity will present itself for the president to meet with both Vladimir Putin and president Zelenskiy, hopefully in the near future,' Mr Rubio told reporters. 'But obviously a lot has to happen before that can occur.' Many 'impediments' to peace remained, he said, especially concerning territorial claims made by Russia, and there was no concrete proposal for a ceasefire on the table. 'What we have is a better understanding of the conditions under which Russia would be willing to end the war,' he said. The US would then need to compare that with 'what the Ukrainians are willing to accept'. Mr Witkoff's three-hour talks came two days before a deadline the US president set for Russia to reach a peace deal in the war or face fresh sanctions. 'My special envoy, Steve Witkoff, just had a highly productive meeting with Russian president Vladimir Putin,' Mr Trump wrote on social media. 'Great progress was made! Afterwards, I updated some of our European allies. Everyone agrees this war must come to a close, and we will work towards that in the days and weeks to come.' Mr Trump gave no further details of what was discussed, and some analysts will be wary of reading too much into the comments, after previous claims by Mr Trump that Putin was ready to negotiate resulted in little progress. Putin has given little indication he is ready to make concessions or willing to adjust Russia's core war aims. However, there have been unconfirmed reports in recent days that the Kremlin could propose a halt to long-range strikes by both sides as an offer to Mr Trump. It is not yet known if the possibility was discussed during Wednesday's Kremlin talks. On Wednesday evening, Mr Trump called Mr Zelenskiy, who was travelling back to Kyiv from a visit to frontline areas in the north-east of the country. 'Our joint position is very clear: the war has to end, and it has to be a just ending,' Mr Zelenskiy wrote on social media afterwards. 'European leaders also took part in the call and I am grateful to each of them for support. We discussed what had been said in Moscow. Ukraine has to defend its independence. We all need a long-lasting and reliable peace. Russia must finish the war that it started.' Mr Trump had promised to introduce secondary tariffs on countries that import Russian oil if no progress was made towards a peace deal by Friday. On Wednesday, he issued an executive order imposing an additional 25 per cent tariff on Indian goods, citing India's continuing imports of Russian oil. India's external affairs ministry said it was 'extremely unfortunate that the US should choose to impose additional tariffs on India for actions that several other countries are also taking in their own national interest'. Russia has described any attempts to target its trading partners as 'illegal'. Ukraine is also trying to secure more US support through economic co-operation, and its new prime minister Yulia Svyrydenko said the first three projects under a new US-Ukraine reconstruction investment fund should be launched within 18 months. Ms Svyrydenko signed off in April on creation of a fund that gives US firms priority access to Ukraine's rare earth minerals and other natural resources. Ukrainian officials said on Wednesday that Russian air strikes had killed at least seven civilians and injured at least 37 over the previous 24 hours, and damaged energy infrastructure in Odesa and Dnipropetrovsk regions. – Additional reporting: Reuters and The Guardian.
Irish Times
7 hours ago
- Irish Times
Israel's military chief opposes Gaza war expansion
Israel 's military chief has pushed back against Binyamin Netanyahu 's plans to seize areas of Gaza it doesn't already control, three Israeli officials said, as the prime minister faces increasing pressure over the war both at home and abroad. During a tense, three-hour meeting on Tuesday, Eyal Zamir, the military chief of staff, warned the prime minister that taking the rest of Gaza could trap the military in the territory, which it withdrew from two decades ago, and could lead to harm to the hostages being held there, the sources briefed on the meeting said. The Israeli military says it already controls 75 per cent of Gaza after nearly two years of war, which began when militant group Hamas attacked southern Israeli communities in October 2023. It has repeatedly opposed imposing military rule, annexing the territory and rebuilding Jewish settlements there – policies advocated by some government members. Mr Netanyahu is under intense international pressure to reach a ceasefire in the coastal enclave, which has been reduced to rubble in the fighting. Most of the population of about two million has been displaced multiple times and aid groups say residents are on the verge of famine. The UN has called reports about a possible expansion of Israel's military operations in Gaza 'deeply alarming' if true. READ MORE The military, which accuses Hamas of operating among civilians, has at times avoided areas where intelligence suggested hostages were held and former captives have said their captors threatened to kill them if Israeli forces approached. Mr Netanyahu told Mr Zamir that so far the military had failed to bring about the release of the hostages, the officials said, speaking on the condition of anonymity. Most of those freed so far came about as a result of diplomatic negotiations. Israel's military chief Eyal Zamir pushed back against Binyamin Netanyahu's plans to seize areas of Gaza it doesn't already control. Photograph: Menahem Kahana/AFP via Getty Images Defence minister Israel Katz wrote on X Wednesday that the military chief has both the right and the duty to voice his opinion, but said that the military would carry out the government's decisions until all war objectives are achieved. The prime minister's office confirmed the meeting with Mr Zamir on Tuesday but declined to comment further and the military did not respond to a request for comment. The prime minister is scheduled to discuss military plans for Gaza with other ministers on Thursday. A fourth source said Mr Netanyahu wants to expand military operations in Gaza to put pressure on Hamas. Mr Netanyahu, who in May said that Israel would control all of Gaza, leads the most right-wing coalition government in Israel's history and some of his key partners have in the past threatened to quit if the government ended the war. [ Analysis: Resignation of army chief over Gaza occupation would further divide Israel Opens in new window ] Following a 40-minute meeting with the prime minister on Wednesday, opposition leader Yair Lapid told reporters he had advised Mr Netanyahu that the public was not interested in continuing the war and that a full military takeover would be a very bad idea. A public poll last month by Israel's Channel 12 also showed support for a diplomatic deal that would end the war and secure the release of the hostages. There are 50 hostages still being held in Gaza, of whom at least 20 are believed to be alive. Videos released by Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad, another militant group in Gaza, last week of two extremely emaciated captives triggered international condemnation. Close to 200 Palestinians have died of starvation in Gaza since the war began, about half of them children, according to Gaza's health ministry. More than 20 died on Wednesday when a truck believed to be carrying food overturned as it was swarmed by a desperate crowd, according to local health authorities. The latest ceasefire talks in Qatar broke down last month. Hamas insists any deal must lead to a permanent end to the war, while Israel accuses the group of lacking sincerity about giving up power afterwards and says it must be defeated. An expansion of the military offensive in heavily populated areas would likely be devastating. 'Where will we go?' said Tamer Al-Burai, a displaced Palestinian living at the edge of Deir Al Balah in central Gaza. 'Should people jump into the sea if the tanks rolled in, or wait to die under the rubble of their houses? We want an end to this war, it is enough, enough,' he told Reuters by phone. [ Gaza is also a war on the human instinct for compassion Opens in new window ] The war in Gaza has also overextended Israel's military, which has a small standing army and has had to repeatedly mobilise reservists. It is not clear if more reservists would be needed to expand operations and take more territory. The military continued to carry out air strikes across Gaza on Wednesday, killing at least 135 people in the past 24 hours, the Gaza health ministry said, with the death toll since the beginning of the conflict now at more than 61,000, mostly civilians, it says. About 1,200 people were killed, including more than 700 civilians, and 251 hostages taken to Gaza after the Hamas attack on Israel, according to Israeli tallies. – Reuters
Irish Times
8 hours ago
- Irish Times
Resignation of army chief over Gaza occupation would further divide Israel
Israel 's top general has warned that the country will be falling into a strategic trap that endangers the lives of hostages if it pushes ahead with plans to occupy the entire Gaza Strip . Israel's cabinet is expected to convene on Thursday to approve such a move, despite the opposition of the top military echelon. A senior official close to Israeli prime minister Binyamin Netanyahu was quoted as saying this week: 'The die is cast – we are going for a full occupation of the Gaza Strip. There will be operations even in areas where hostages are being held. If the chief of staff doesn't agree, he should resign.' Israel Defense Forces (IDF) chief of staff Lieut Gen Eyal Zamir was personally appointed by Netanyahu five months ago, as part of the policy to replace generals connected to the debacle of the October 7th 2023 Hamas attack. He was chosen, partly to appease Netanyahu's right-wing base, as an 'aggressive' general who could defeat Hamas. READ MORE But, with the IDF already controlling some 75 per cent of the coastal enclave and following the collapse of the Gaza ceasefire talks, Zamir has made clear his opposition to a manoeuvre to conquer the entire territory. Instead, he presented a plan to seal off Gaza city, the central refugee camps and the Muwassi humanitarian zone in the south, enabling Israeli forces to carry out what the plan called pinpoint raids against remaining Hamas militants. But Netanyahu rejected the plan, opting for a full-scale assault despite the dangers, and issuing a statement saying the army was 'ready to implement any decision the security cabinet makes'. In August 2024 Hamas gunmen murdered six hostages being held in a tunnel in Rafah when they believed IDF troops were approaching. The IDF is concerned that the remaining 20 hostages believed to be alive will be in danger if it advances into areas where the hostages are held. Militants guarding the bodies of 30 deceased hostages may also flee or be killed, raising the possibility that the bodies will be lost forever. [ Egyptian president condemns Israel over reported plan for full military takeover of Gaza Opens in new window ] Zamir is also worried by the possibility of high IDF casualties and about burnout among combat soldiers after 22 months of fighting, particularly among reservists who have served hundreds of days in uniform since the start of the war. An escalation of the war will likely require a substantial call-up of additional reservists, while Netanyahu's government is working to ensure that ultra-Orthodox Jews do not have to enlist. According to some analysts, Zamir will be forced to resign if the cabinet approves an occupation of all Gaza, causing further division in Israeli society, with polls showing more than 60 per cent of people support a ceasefire to end the war.
