SA tourism industry pushes back on safety amidst crime narrative from Trump admin
President Cyril Ramaphosa meeting US President Donald Trump at the White House in Washington D.C. for a working visit.The visit provided an opportunity for the two leaders to deliberate on bilateral, regional and global issues of mutual interest, including trade and investment.
Image: GCIS
The South African tourism industry has come into defense of the country's safety and hospitality levels amidst an ongoing narrative about crime in Africa's most-developed economy.
This comes as a group of 59 Afrikaners recently migrated to the United States after taking up the offer of a refugee status as the US government falsely believes there is an ongoing 'genocide' against them in South Africa.
Recent headlines sparked by a widely publicised exchange between US President Donald Trump and President Cyril Ramaphosa have reignited international focus on crime in South Africa.
During the meeting, Trump repeatedly claimed that genocide against white farmers is taking place in South Africa, an allegation denied by Ramaphosa.
'We have many people that feel they're being persecuted, and they're coming to the United States,' said Trump. 'People are fleeing South Africa for their own safety. Their land is being confiscated, and in many cases, they're being killed.'
The latest crime statistics in South Africa show that nearly 10 000 people were murdered between October and December 2024. Of these, a dozen were killed in farm attacks and of the 12, one was a farmer, while five were farm dwellers and four were employees, who are likely to have been black.
The Southern Africa Tourism Services Association (Satsa) on Thursday said much of the coverage of these issues has leaned toward sensationalism, lacking the nuance needed to understand the real experience of travellers to the country.
Satsa CEO David Frost said while crime was a concern and continued to be addressed by government and civil society, incidents involving international visitors remained extremely rare.
'South Africa isn't perfect. Like every country, we face challenges. But what we don't have is a crisis that justifies global panic or distorted narratives,' Frost said.
'What we do have is millions of tourists arriving safely every year, and leaving with stories that have nothing to do with fear and everything to do with awe.
'We don't pretend crime doesn't exist. But context matters. The suggestion that tourists are at significant risk is dangerous misinformation that serves political agendas rather than public interest.'
South Africa has been in the crosshairs with the Trump administration since it passed the Land Expropriation Act, while issues of undermining the US foreign policy have been resurfaced by the country taking Israel to the International Court of Justice over the genocide in Palestine.
Ramaphosa did acknowledge that there was "criminality in our country... people who do get killed through criminal activity are not only white people, the majority of them are black people".
He said that he hoped Trump would listen to the voices of South Africans on this issue of the perceived genocide against white Afrikaners. Ramaphosa pointed out the white members of his delegation, including retired golfers Ernie Els and Retief Goosen, and South Africa's richest man, Johann Rupert.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Eyewitness News
an hour ago
- Eyewitness News
Thabo Mbeki, Nelson Mandela, Ahmed Kathrada foundations left out of national dialogue
JOHANNESBURG - After months of calling for a National Dialogue, the Thabo Mbeki, Nelson Mandela, and Ahmed Kathrada foundations have seemingly not made the cut of those who will guide conversations on the country's future. None of President Cyril Ramaphosa's predecessors were on the list that he announced on Tuesday night. He has, however, appointed 31 prominent South Africans who will champion the National Dialogue. The event, which was initially set for 16 December 2024, will now take place on 15 August. As the Freedom Charter, a blueprint that ultimately birthed the country's constitution marks 70 years, South Africans are being called upon once more to gather and imagine a shared future. Ramaphosa said this idea is not new, as dialogue is in South Africa's DNA. 'Every important moment in the history of our country, we have come together as a nation to confront our challenges and forge a path into the future.' The president's named 31 prominent South Africans to champion the project but has seemingly left out the many foundations who were at the forefront of calling for South Africans to talk among themselves. Former President Thabo Mbeki, who's consistently warned that the country's liberation was in trouble, is not mentioned among those spearheading the dialogue. But the likes of Reverend Thabo Makgoba, constitutional negotiator Roelf Meyer, Mam Gcina Mhlophe, and Miss South Africa Mia Le Roux are included. The dialogue will happen in phases. NOT A ONE-TIME EVENT Ramaphosa said the country's national dialogue will not be a one-time event. He also announced on Tuesday night that a second meeting is scheduled for early 2026. The president's announcement speaks to widely shared concerns about the state of the country and its future. He said this will be a people-led reflection on challenges facing South Africa. 'It will be a participatory process that unfolds in phases, from local consultations and sectoral engagements to provincial and national gatherings.' The 31 prominent South Africans have also been appointed to an eminent persons group aimed at championing the national dialogue. The president said this also presents an opportunity to finalise the long-anticipated social compact. 'This second national convention will reinforce our shared values and adopt a common vision and programme of action for our country into the future. We expect that the next phase will finalise our compact, which will set out the roles and responsibilities of every South African.'
The South African
an hour ago
- The South African
South Africa's National Dialogue: A call for unity
President Cyril Ramaphosa has announced a National Convention to start a national dialogue involving the entire country. The initiative's goal is to bring people from all walks of life together to fight crime, unemployment, inequality, and division, thereby improving everyone's future. President Cyril Ramaphosa said that dialogue has always been the key to South Africa's change. He discussed how unity and negotiation ended apartheid and built democracy. Ramaphosa described the National Dialogue as a process of national consolidation and progress. Ramaphosa stated that a second National Convention will be held early next year. This convention will establish the duties of the government, businesses, communities, and civil society. There will be an Eminent Persons Group in charge of the process. This group will include well-known people like Judge Edwin Cameron, Dr Brigalia Bam, Siya Kolisi, and many more. The National Dialogue will operate under a three-tiered governance model. An inter-ministerial committee led by Deputy President Paul Mashatile on government involvement. A Steering Committee made up of people from the business, political, labour, cultural, and civil society sectors will set strategic priorities. The secretariat at the National Economic Development and Labour Council (NEDLAC) will provide operational support by managing daily activities and making sure that the dialogue continues smoothly through all of its stages. President Ramaphosa's National Dialogue: A staged process that starts at the local level and ends with national unity Ramaphosa said that the next step in the National Development Plan will be based on this process. He ended by calling for unity: 'We are drawing on our traditions of talking and arguing.' Critics view President Cyril Ramaphosa's National Dialogue as a political smokescreen hiding South Africa's diplomatic challenges with strategic allies and the government's growing problems leading to a coalition after the ANC's poor election results. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 11. Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
Mail & Guardian
2 hours ago
- Mail & Guardian
The non-negotiables of South Africa's promised infrastructure surge
Despite expenditure on infrastructure such as Eskom's transmission lines, roads and rail transport, failures persist. Photo: Delwyn Verasamy/M&G President Cyril Ramaphosa's keynote address at the Sustainable Infrastructure Development Symposium – South Africa (SIDS-SA) in Cape Town at the end of May was punctuated by a recurring theme: the country's urgent need for money, and the pivotal role the private sector must play in financing infrastructure development. The government has committed roughly R1 trillion to infrastructure over the next three years with a range of financial instruments set to be introduced, including streamlining public-public partnership initiatives and establishing an Infrastructure Bond by 2026. At the conference, Ramaphosa explicitly called for private sector support to the tune of R2 trillion in medium-term investments. South Africa's infrastructure push holds immense potential, but history warns of pitfalls. The 2010 World Cup, a flashy boom that left little lasting value, proves that spending alone doesn't guarantee progress. Today, the same flawed logic persists, pouring billions into projects while ignoring systemic inefficiencies. Without fixing the cracks, an infrastructure surge risks becoming another short-lived spectacle, leaving people disillusioned with crumbling services and empty promises. Consider this: according to Statistics South Africa, the country's public-sector capital expenditure grew from R200 billion in 2006 to R283 billion in 2023, with infrastructure as a priority. While still below 2015 levels, spending rose by R50 billion since 2021 — led by Eskom (R39 billion on transmission lines), Prasa (R16 billion on rail), and Transnet (R15 billion). Private sector investment has also surged, with Gross Capital Formation (GCF) up 35.2% (R807 billion to R1.09 trillion) from 2016 to 2023. Yet, energy blackouts, water shortages and transport failures persist, worsened by a lack of climate-resilient infrastructure. The deeper structural challenges of inequality, exclusionary ownership and uneven growth remain resistant to financial fixes alone. This disconnection between investment and outcomes raises questions about efficiency, maintenance and systemic barriers. For South Africa's infrastructure push to succeed, the government must first tackle entrenched impediments. Only then can this 'boom' deliver on its core imperatives: which ought to be resilient infrastructure, equitable development, and inclusive empowerment. At the forefront, the government must devise a credible strategy to attend to what I call the municipal governance paradox — that is, while local governments are constitutionally mandated as the primary delivery agents, they are the weakest link in our implementation chain. Constitutionally, municipalities own infrastructure delivery, with national government intervention permitted only under strictly defined failure conditions. Yet, current realities paint a troubling picture: according to the Auditor General Report of 2024, 77% of municipal infrastructure projects showed deficiencies, while only 16% of municipalities achieved clean audits. Poor management leads to delays, cost overruns, and decay — evidenced by a 55.7% surge in infrastructure depreciation since 2016. Fixing these demands urgent action: skills development, enforced maintenance budgets, and climate-resilience incentives. Second, the small, medium and micro enterprises sector must not be treated as preferential, but fundamental. These enterprises are increasingly contributing to employment, with Stats SA reporting that South Africa's construction sector saw the most significant growth in small business turnover (rising by 23 percentage points, from 17% in AFS -what is AFS?- 2013 to 40% in AFS 2023) while also accounting for a growing share of the industry's total workforce. But SMMEs remain chronically underused in national infrastructure planning. The government ought to quickly realise that South Africa's infrastructure revolution will be built by SMMEs or it will not be built at all. Last, innovation must become the critical differentiator, not just a piecemeal activity. South Africa's research and development crisis, reflecting weak investment in innovation, persists, with spending at just 0.6% of GDP, far below the 2.7% global average. This deficit undermines infrastructure development and long-term competitiveness. While we have the technical expertise, we require our national infrastructure planning to support the creation of a system that rewards efficient and sustainable solutions. We ought to institutionalise mechanisms that prioritise speed, cost efficiency and sustainability. Anything less condemns us to repeating past failures at future costs. Increased investments into the sector are certainly warranted, but principle before payout is key. How we steward the increased investments over the next three years will determine whether we construct mere projects or forge lasting national value. Siseko Maposa is the director of Surgetower Associates Management Consultancy. He is a regular commentator on South Africa political economy and industry.
