EU media freedom law takes effect, but who gets protection online unclear
The European Media Freedom Act (EMFA) aims to safeguard press freedom and bolster democracy by introducing transparency measures regarding media ownership and state advertising, as well as robust safeguards for journalists and their sources.
The law also seeks to help traditional media outlets compete with social media-based outlets and adapt to the rise of technologies such as generative AI.
One provision requires Very Large Online Platforms (VLOPs), such as YouTube, Facebook, Instagram and TikTok, to promote diverse media content and prevent the arbitrary removal or algorithmic downgrading of recognised Media Service Providers (MSPs). The law defines MSPs as professional media outlets with editorial responsibility and oversight.
According to a recent report by the Reuters Institute, people are increasingly using these platforms to consume news, and the growing influence of the platforms, based on which content they amplify or suppress, is contributing to a 'fragmented alternative media environment' filled with podcasters, YouTubers, and TikTokers.
The tricky task of defining MSPs
The law requires VLOPs to allow MSPs to self-declare, but the European Commission is yet to issue guidelines on how this process will work.
Although the Commission sought input in a consultation that closed on 23 July, defining who qualifies as an MSP is proving difficult. The law already sets out criteria relating to editorial responsibility, transparency and independence, but the forthcoming guidelines could expand on these.
Online platforms have long struggled with the kind of assessments needed to identify bad faith actors, which makes the task even harder. In its response to the Commission's consultation, the European Broadcasting Union (EBU) recommended that MSPs have access to a contact within VLOPs who has expertise in this area.
Additionally, while public broadcasters are relatively easy to verify, commercial media and less traditional entities, such as social media influencers, present more of a challenge. Some EU countries maintain databases of recognised news organisations, though these are not harmonised across the bloc.
The EMFA provision lists criteria for MSP status, such as oversight by a national regulator or membership of a self-regulatory body, but the Commission suggested clarifying that these are not cumulative. The European Federation of Journalists (EFJ) backs this.
What about influencers?
On influencers, News Media Europe states that the EMFA's rules on editorial responsibility, transparency, and independence are sufficient to distinguish between professional news outlets and non-professional entities, such as influencers.
However, the EFJ argues that influencers or bloggers who operate professionally and ethically by following best practices provided by a recognised self-regulatory body for instance, should be included.
For Constantin Gissler, Director General of tech lobby DOT Europe, tightening the "definition of 'media service provider' (MSP) is key."
"Otherwise, there's a real risk of bad faith actors claiming protections meant for legitimate media."
(nl, de)
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Euractiv
a day ago
- Euractiv
Zelenskyy says no to territorial concessions: ‘Ukrainians will not give their land to the occupier'
Ukraine won't surrender land to Russia to buy peace, President Volodymyr Zelenskyy warned Saturday, after Washington and Moscow agreed to hold a summit in a bid to end the war. Presidents Vladimir Putin and Donald Trump will meet in the US state of Alaska next Friday, to try to resolve the three-year conflict, despite warnings from Ukraine and Europe that Kyiv must be part of negotiations. Announcing the summit on Friday, Trump said that "there'll be some swapping of territories to the betterment of both" sides, without providing further details. "Ukrainians will not give their land to the occupier," Zelenskyy said on social media hours later. "Any decisions against us, any decisions without Ukraine, are also decisions against peace. They will achieve nothing," he said, adding that the war "cannot be ended without us, without Ukraine". Zelenskyy also urged Ukraine's allies to take "clear steps" towards achieving a sustainable peace, during a call with Britain's Prime Minister Keir Starmer. National security advisors from Kyiv's allies -- including the United States, EU nations and the UK -- were gathering in Britain on Saturday to align their views ahead of the Putin-Trump summit. French President Emmanuel Macron, following phone calls with Zelenskyy, Starmer and German Chancellor Friedrich Merz, said "the future of Ukraine cannot be decided without Ukrainians" and that Europe also had to be involved in the negotiations. Later Saturday, in his evening address, Zelenskyy added: "There must be an honest end to this war, and it is up to Russia to end the war it started." A 'dignified peace' Three rounds of talks between Russia and Ukraine this year have failed to bear fruit, and it remains unclear whether a summit could bring peace any closer as the warring sides' positions are still far apart. Tens of thousands of people have been killed since Russia launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, with millions forced to flee their homes. Putin has resisted multiple calls from the United States, Europe and Kyiv for a ceasefire. Putin, a former KGB officer in power in Russia for over 25 years, has ruled out holding talks with Zelenskyy at this stage. Ukraine's leader has been pushing for a three-way summit and has frequently said meeting Putin is the only way to make progress towards peace. Far from the war The summit in Alaska, the far-north territory which Russia sold to the United States in 1867, would be the first between sitting US and Russian presidents since Joe Biden met Putin in Geneva in June 2021. Nine months later, Moscow sent troops into Ukraine. Zelenskyy said of the location that it was "very far away from this war, which is raging on our land, against our people". The Kremlin said the choice was "logical" because the state close to the Arctic is on the border between the two countries, and this is where their "economic interests intersect". Moscow has also invited Trump to pay a reciprocal visit to Russia later. Trump and Putin last sat together in 2019 at a G20 summit meeting in Japan during Trump's first term. They have spoken by telephone several times since January with Trump trying to broker peace in Ukraine without making a breakthrough. On Friday, Putin held a round of calls with allies, including Brazil, China and India, in a diplomatic flurry ahead of the Alaska summit. In a 40-minute phone conversation Saturday between Putin and President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva, the Brazilian leader reiterated his support for dialogue "and the pursuit of a peaceful solution", his office said. The US president had earlier imposed an additional tariff on India for buying Russia's oil in a bid to nudge Moscow into talks. He also threatened to impose a similar tax on China, but so far has refrained from doing so. Fighting goes on Russia and Ukraine continued pouring dozens of drones onto each other's positions in an exchange of attacks in the early hours of Saturday. A bus carrying civilians was hit in Ukraine's frontline city of Kherson, killing two people and wounding 16. The Russian army claimed to have taken Yablonovka, another village in the Donetsk region, the site of the most intense fighting in the east and one of the five regions Putin says is part of Russia. Four people were killed as of Saturday morning in Donetsk after Russian shelling, Ukrainian authorities said. In 2022, the Kremlin announced the annexation of four Ukrainian regions – Donetsk, Lugansk, Zaporizhzhia and Kherson – despite not having full control over them. Russia had previously annexed the Crimean peninsula from Ukraine in 2014. As a prerequisite to any peace settlement, Moscow demanded Kyiv pull its forces out of the regions and commit to being a neutral state, shun Western military support and be excluded from joining NATO. Kyiv said it would never recognise Russian control over its sovereign territory, though it acknowledged that getting land captured by Russia back would have to come through diplomacy, not on the battlefield.
Euractiv
2 days ago
- Euractiv
EU media freedom law takes effect, but who gets protection online unclear
The EU's new media freedom law came into effect on Friday, offering stronger protections for journalists, but a key provision on online platforms is sparking debate over which media qualify for certain safeguards. The European Media Freedom Act (EMFA) aims to safeguard press freedom and bolster democracy by introducing transparency measures regarding media ownership and state advertising, as well as robust safeguards for journalists and their sources. The law also seeks to help traditional media outlets compete with social media-based outlets and adapt to the rise of technologies such as generative AI. One provision requires Very Large Online Platforms (VLOPs), such as YouTube, Facebook, Instagram and TikTok, to promote diverse media content and prevent the arbitrary removal or algorithmic downgrading of recognised Media Service Providers (MSPs). The law defines MSPs as professional media outlets with editorial responsibility and oversight. According to a recent report by the Reuters Institute, people are increasingly using these platforms to consume news, and the growing influence of the platforms, based on which content they amplify or suppress, is contributing to a 'fragmented alternative media environment' filled with podcasters, YouTubers, and TikTokers. The tricky task of defining MSPs The law requires VLOPs to allow MSPs to self-declare, but the European Commission is yet to issue guidelines on how this process will work. Although the Commission sought input in a consultation that closed on 23 July, defining who qualifies as an MSP is proving difficult. The law already sets out criteria relating to editorial responsibility, transparency and independence, but the forthcoming guidelines could expand on these. Online platforms have long struggled with the kind of assessments needed to identify bad faith actors, which makes the task even harder. In its response to the Commission's consultation, the European Broadcasting Union (EBU) recommended that MSPs have access to a contact within VLOPs who has expertise in this area. Additionally, while public broadcasters are relatively easy to verify, commercial media and less traditional entities, such as social media influencers, present more of a challenge. Some EU countries maintain databases of recognised news organisations, though these are not harmonised across the bloc. The EMFA provision lists criteria for MSP status, such as oversight by a national regulator or membership of a self-regulatory body, but the Commission suggested clarifying that these are not cumulative. The European Federation of Journalists (EFJ) backs this. What about influencers? On influencers, News Media Europe states that the EMFA's rules on editorial responsibility, transparency, and independence are sufficient to distinguish between professional news outlets and non-professional entities, such as influencers. However, the EFJ argues that influencers or bloggers who operate professionally and ethically by following best practices provided by a recognised self-regulatory body for instance, should be included. For Constantin Gissler, Director General of tech lobby DOT Europe, tightening the "definition of 'media service provider' (MSP) is key." "Otherwise, there's a real risk of bad faith actors claiming protections meant for legitimate media." (nl, de)
Euractiv
2 days ago
- Euractiv
Defence
Good afternoon, wherever you may be (presumably, hopefully, not in Brussels). This will be our last newsletter before taking a two-week break. But don't worry, we might still peep into your mailbox if you're subscribed to the guerrilla missive for all the latest on politics, lobbying, and the media. Before we sign off, we'd like to send you off in style. And in true Euractiv form, we're making sure you have your cross-policy-related reading needs met, wherever you are. Politics Even as Brussels is now a ghost town, the criticism of the EU's response to Israel over Gaza has remained very much alive all week. Staffers still in the institutions have been contemplating strike action, accusing the EU of failing to pressure Israel to allow vital humanitarian aid into Gaza, despite an agreement struck back in July. Commission data, obtained by Euractiv on Wednesday, showed that fewer aid trucks are entering the Strip from Israel than the terms of the deal demand. For many in Brussels, the EU's inaction is a question of moral authority, which is, at its core, a mishmash of cultural taboos, laws, and historical legacy. But it's not inevitable. As Israel pressed ahead with its plans to 'take control' of Gaza City on Friday, Germany – a staunch Israel ally – responded with an unprecedented suspension of exports of weapons that may be used in Gaza. Over in Poland, the new President Karol Nawrocki, who is backed by the national-conservative Law and Justice (PiS) party, promised a more assertive stance towards Brussels in his inauguration speech on Wednesday, saying that the country cannot be "a subsidiary farm" of the EU. What exactly did he mean by that, and what does that mean for the strained-cum-hopeful Warsaw-Brussels relationship? Find out. On Thursday, Trump's 15% tariffs – which have made policy-makers, industry, and consumers hold their breath for months – came into effect. If you want to know the man behind the EU's deal, we have got you covered: Read our profile on Maroš Šefčovič, the Soviet-trained diplomat and the bloc's forever commissioner. Energy, Environment & Transport This week, we went native on biodiversity by giving one of Europe's hotly contested biodiversity hotspots an in situ visit, Friche Josaphat, in the north of Brussels – will it be bulldozed to make way for much-needed housing? Some lawmakers are pushing for a moratorium. We also had a look at neighbouring France, too. There, the mysterious power of vineyards managed to halt the country's worst wildfire in 75 years, prompting politicians to rethink their plans to tear them down in a bid to protect wine prices. Agrifood Euractiv's agri-food policy team took you on a foodie journey across the continent this week – though not without a sprinkle of policy action added into the mix. We begin in Spain, where rice producers in the Mediterranean region of Valencia – the cradle of paella – are unhappy about brands using imported Asian rice while cashing in on local cultural imagery in their packaging. They argue the practice is misleading and urge Brussels to impose stricter labelling rules and measures to curb imports. And from Valencia to Cádiz, an invasive algae is putting an end to centuries-old artisanal fishing traditions, with fishers warning that the invader is spreading. Staying in the South, a Maltese MEP wants the European Commission to launch an investigation into Italian and Tunisian neighbours fishing for lampuki , a national favourite – before the official season begins next week. Further north in Germany, another culinary staple is under pressure. A workers' strike at a major supplier of kebab meat is sparking fears of higher prices – and strained supply. Tech Tech eyes have this week been turned to the US, as the Trump administration repeatedly attacks the EU's tech rulebook. The EU's content moderation rules – the Digital Services Act (DSA) – have been a major bone of contention since Trump's arrival in office. The White House is now dialling up attacks on the EU digital rulebook, looking to lobby 'to repeal and/or amend' the law. Bernd Lange, chair of the European Parliament's international trade committee, warned in an interview with Euractiv that the Commission might cave in under US pressure. Despite closing a trade "deal" two weeks ago, the terms of the agreement differ between the White House and the EU. US Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick said that the EU tech laws were still on the table, something the Commission repeatedly denied. Closer to home, we also reported on the Commission's plans for AI Gigafactories, meant to put Europe back in the AI race. Here's a map of the projects that have so far been submitted by the industry. Finally, the frustration of video gamers made headlines thanks to a popular citizens' initiative that begs the EU to help regulate the gaming sector in a bid to keep games alive. Health Trump has kept the pharmaceutical sector busy this week by escalating his threats to impose tariffs on medicine imports. 'It's going to go to 150%, and then it's going to go to 250%, because we want pharmaceuticals made in our country,' he said in a CNBC interview on Tuesday. Four weeks earlier, he had stated that he would start with relatively low tariffs and raise them to 200% 'in about a year, a year and a half.' It's not the only deadline he has set in his long-standing (and so far fruitless) effort to lower drug prices. There is also a deadline for a so-called Section 232 investigation into the sector, as well as one mentioned in a letter he sent to 17 pharmaceutical companies. A growing number of major pharma companies are weighing in on Trump's trade policies. While some stress that they're engaged in constructive talks, Bayer's CEO has warned that tariff uncertainty is already fuelling "volatility". Apart from that, we've been following the story of a €9.7 million stockpile of still-usable, USAID-funded contraceptives that is set to be incinerated in France. NGOs fear the products may already have been destroyed. Denmark , The Netherlands , Norway, and Sweden were first in sending multi-million US military equipment packages to Ukraine, following a new arrangement under which European allies cover the cost of US defence equipment sent to Kyiv. The deliveries will include the highly coveted air-defence Patriot parts and systems. European military aid to Ukraine could also grow bigger in the coming days, with potential new bids on the Commission's €150 billion defence loans to boost Europe's and Ukraine's stockpiles. The Commission gave the nine countries – Austria, Denmark, Germany, Ireland, Luxembourg, Malta, the Netherlands, Slovenia, and Sweden – who still haven't expressed interest in the programme until 15 August to do so. In the Baltics, alleged Russian drone incursions into Lithuania's airspace further exposed long-standing air defence gaps in the region.
