BBC breached editorial guidelines over Gaza documentary narrated by son of Hamas official
A report into the controversial programme said three members of the independent production company knew about the role of the boy's father - but no one within the BBC was aware.
The independent report - commissioned by the corporation - criticised the BBC team involved in the documentary for not being "sufficiently proactive" with initial editorial checks, and for a "lack of critical oversight of unanswered or partially answered questions" ahead of broadcast.
While the report said there was no evidence "to support the suggestion that the narrator's father or family influenced the content of the programme in any way," it concluded the use of a child narrator for the programme was "not appropriate".
Gaza: How To Survive A Warzone aired on the BBC in February but was pulled from iPlayer after it emerged that the child narrator was the son of Ayman Alyazouri, who has worked as Hamas's deputy minister of agriculture.
How To Survive A Warzone was made by independent production company Hoyo Films, and features 13-year-old Abdullah al Yazouri, who speaks about life in Gaza during the war between Israel and Hamas.
The review was led by Peter Johnston, the BBC's director of editorial complaints and reviews, who reports directly to director general Tim Davie.
The report said a fee of £795 was paid for the narrator, paid to his sister. The report found that was not "outside the range of what might be reasonable in the context".
The report did not name any individuals facing disciplinary action, but a new job has been created in News documentaries and current affairs.
The BBC say they will advertise the leadership role, which has a director role on the BBC News Board, in the next seven days.
While the BBC said the report found that Hoyo Films did not "intentionally" mislead the BBC, they said the independent production company "bears most responsibility for this failure".
They added that the BBC also "bears some responsibility".
Flagging "a significant failing" in the documentary, Mr Davie said "I am sorry for this failing".
He said action would now be taken, to ensure "proper accountability" and also "prevent such errors being repeated".
Hoyo Films said they take the report findings "extremely seriously," and also apologised.
They said they were "working closely with the BBC" to see if they could find a way to bring back parts of the documentary to iPlayer, adding: "Our team in Gaza risked their lives to document the devastating impact of war on children.
"Gaza: How To Survive A Warzone remains a vital account, and our contributors - who have no say in the conflict - deserve to have their voices heard."
Speaking to the Culture, Media and Sport Committee earlier this year, Mr Davie described the fallout over the documentary as "damaging," and said the corporation "were not told" about questions asked around Abdullah's father.
Media watchdog Ofcom previously warned that recent controversies could "start to erode public trust and confidence".
Israel does not allow international news organisations into Gaza to report independently.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
6 hours ago
- Yahoo
BBC calls in police to investigate new Strictly allegations
The BBC has asked the police to investigate Strictly Come Dancing amid fresh allegations, according to reports, after claims two of its stars used cocaine. The Sun On Sunday reported that the corporation has alerted the Metropolitan Police to new allegations about the hit dance competition show, the details of which it does not specify. A BBC spokesperson said on Saturday the corporation does not comment on police investigations. It comes after reports in The Sun earlier this month alleged two Strictly cast members' drug use was discussed on the BBC dancing show, and said that the corporation had appointed law firm Pinsent Masons to lead the investigation. The scandal-hit show was also the subject of a review in 2024, when the BBC looked into allegations of bullying and harassment against former professional dancer Giovanni Pernice, made by his former dance partner Amanda Abbington. The corporation upheld some, but not all, of the complaints made – and introduced a series of new measures aimed at improving welfare. This included the introduction of a chaperone who is present 'at all times' during training room rehearsals. EastEnders star James Borthwick was also suspended from the BBC after a video emerged of the actor using a disabled slur on the set of the dance programme. The cocaine use allegations were reportedly made in a legal submission by law firm Russells in March on behalf of former contestant Wynne Evans, who was dropped by the BBC after apologising for using 'inappropriate language' during the launch of the Strictly tour. It is understood that the BBC often appoints external law firms to help it lead investigations. The BBC spokesperson previously said: 'We have clear protocols and policies in place for dealing with any serious complaint raised with us. 'We would always encourage people to speak to us if they have concerns. It would not be appropriate for us to comment further.' The Metropolitan Police has been contacted for comment.
Yahoo
9 hours ago
- Yahoo
Amy Schumer, Howie Mandel among 1,000 signees of petition condemning TIFF's handling of Oct. 7 doc
Amy Schumer, Howie Mandel and Debra Messing are among more than 1,000 entertainment figures who have signed an open letter condemning the Toronto International Film Festival for its handling of a film about the Hamas attacks in Israel. The letter comes after TIFF had said it would pull 'The Road Between Us: The Ultimate Rescue" from its lineup, sparking a public outcry over the decision, which the festival subsequently reversed. In a joint statement Thursday, TIFF CEO Cameron Bailey and director Barry Avrich said they had reached a resolution and that the doc will screen at next month's festival. The petition, released by the L.A.-based Creative Community For Peace, accuses TIFF of 'appeasing anti-Israel and antisemitic activists' intent to silence Jewish voices' by disinviting the film. The letter says that while the film has been reinstated, the festival 'has not offered a sincere apology or explanation for the harm it created for the Jewish community.' TIFF did not immediately respond to a request for comment. The petition also calls on TIFF's board of directors to question the organization's leadership, to platform Israeli voices and 'to choose dialogue over exclusion.' The film follows retired Israeli general Noam Tibon's mission to rescue his family during the Hamas attacks on Oct. 7, 2023, during which 1,200 people were killed and more than 250 hostages were taken. Canadian signees of the petition include filmmaker Caitlin Cronenberg and producer Martin Katz, while U.S. actors on the letter include Jerry O'Connell, Mayim Bialik and Jennifer Jason Leigh. Earlier this week, festival organizers said they had pulled the documentary over unmet requirements related to security concerns and the 'legal clearance of all footage.' The move sparked an international backlash, drawing criticism from some Jewish groups and politicians, while the filmmakers accused the festival of censorship. TIFF backtracked Wednesday, announcing it would work with the documentary team to find a way to screen the film. On Thursday, Bailey and Avrich released a joint statement saying they had reached a resolution after hearing 'pain and frustration' from the public. They said they ironed out 'important safety, legal and programming concerns' around the film. 'We have worked together to find a resolution to satisfy important safety, legal, and programming concerns,' the statement said. TIFF runs Sept. 4 to 14. This report by The Canadian Press was first published Aug. 15, 2025. Alex Nino Gheciu, The Canadian Press
Yahoo
13 hours ago
- Yahoo
TOPS OF THE WORLD: The most viral stories of the week
From local and provincial news, Canadian politics, the latest in sports, outrageous entertainment offerings, the Toronto Sun always has you covered. There are stories, however, that are more newsworthy to the masses than others. If you want to keep up with those at the watercooler or on social media, read on to see what stories everyone was talking about this past week: TIFF reverses decision on Oct. 7 doc after backlash Joe Warmington pointed out the 'absurd and insulting censorship' of the documentary The Road Between Us at the Toronto International Film Festival after it was pulled from the schedule because the filmmakers used footage filmed by Hamas but — wait for it — didn't obtain the rights from the terrorist group for the clips. Well, the backlash came fast and furiously, and the film about the Oct. 7 massacre in Israel will be gracing festival screens after all — but only after the pulling of acclaimed director Barry Avrich's film made international headlines, including the front page of the New York Post and being discussed on Fox News. 'It was never my intention to offend or alienate anyone,' TIFF CEO Cameron Bailey wrote in a statement. 'Given the sensitive and significant nature of the film's subject, I believe that it tells an important story and contributes to the rich tapestry of perspectives in our lineup — stories that resonate here at home and around the world.' Taylor Swift announced new album on Kelce brothers' podcast Taylor Swift was the special guest on boyfriend Travis Kelce and his brother Jason Kelce's New Heights podcast on Aug. 13 — after confirming on social media that she was in her showgirl era. The superstar made the big announcement of The Life of a Showgirl, her 12th studio album at exactly 12:12 a.m. on Aug. 12 but for all the details, Swifties and fans alike would have to tune in to the podcast. Crafty buggers. It's her first new record since her epic Eras Tour ended last December, and Swift has shared stunning images from the album on her socials, admitting the Kelces, 'We're going all out. This is a full send. I care about this record more than I can even overstate.' The Life of a Showgirl debuts Oct. 3 (but you can already get it in presales, if you follow Swift on social media). Air Canada's work stoppage More than 10,000 Air Canada and Air Canada Rouge flight attendants walked off the job as of 1 a.m. ET Saturday, which was followed by a company-imposed lockout after the airline and the workers' union were unable to reach a deal. Flights have already been cancelled in anticipation of the work stoppage with a full stoppage now in effect. Air Canada said it would notify customers of cancellations through email and text message, adding it recommends against going to the airport unless they have a confirmed booking and their flight still shows as operating. RECOMMENDED VIDEO Buck Martinez's return to broadcast booth The Blue Jays are tops in the American League East and, as of press time, leading the AL. And with Buck Martinez back on the Sportsnet broadcast, they are the hottest ticket in town. A lot has happened in the last two-plus months that he was MIA, with the Jays being far from the team they were on May 28, when Martinez was last in the booth. But that journey pales in comparison to what Martinez has endured in that time after a diagnosis of lung cancer sidelined him. He's back now, and that voice is as comforting as ever alongside his long-time play-by-play partner, Dan Shulman. There's nothing like listening to Martinez talk baseball with such passion, and he had plenty of words of admiration for the Blue Jays and what manager John Schneider has done for the team. 'These guys, the way they are playing, this is how you play winning baseball. This is how you win championships.' From his lips … KINSELLA: Is Qatar steering TIFF's ship? Taylor Swift's new album has everyone seeing orange: An exploration of the colour What's a Blue Jays TV rally-killer? Another Apple game on Friday to bounce Sportsnet coverage Trump-Putin meeting in Alaska U.S. President Donald Trump and his Russian counterpart Vladimir Putin kicked off their reunion with a warm handshake before getting to the business at hand: A summit to discuss Russia's war on Ukraine and relations between Moscow and Washington. White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt said the previously planned one-on-one meeting between Trump and Putin is now a three-on-three meeting — but no, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy was not in attendance of discussions he should totally be a part of, nor were any other European leaders invited to join in. Rather, U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio and special envoy Steve Witkoff made up Team U.S., while Putin had Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov and foreign affairs adviser Yuri Ushakov by his side. 'HIGH STAKES!!!' Trump posted shortly on his Truth Social account before he boarded Air Force One for Alaska. No kidding.
