Video showing alleged bullying of 9-year-old leads to calls for change in P.E.I. schools
The Kinkora man said his child is being violently bullied and that no one in the province's school system is doing anything about it.
"It's not just my kid," he told CBC News. "I've heard stories of other kids … Island-wide. This is not just an isolated incident to our school.
"The whole system's messed up."
Butler decided to speak out after a graphic video was posted to social media showing some of what happened to his daughter back on July 28 at a home in the Prince County community just steps away from his own.
Another child can be seen taunting and kicking the girl and pulling her hair while she sobs.
Butler said the alleged bully, also 9, did send a letter of apology, but he's not convinced it will end his daughter's torment when she returns to Somerset Consolidated School in the fall.
He said the issues between the two children began at the school. He worries they'll carry over.
"No matter if it happened on summer hours, this still stemmed from an issue that started at school that was ignored by both the school and the [P.E.I. Public Schools Branch], so at the end of the day this falls on them," Butler said.
'Hard to watch'
Last year, the results of an extensive survey on youth health on P.E.I. suggested that bullying is a particular problem for students in grades 7 to 12 — and that the problem is worse here than elsewhere in the country.
The annual COMPASS survey found 31 per cent of students had been bullied in the previous 30 days, compared to a national average of 19 per cent.
P.E.I. is one of five provinces that participates in the survey, which is developed and delivered by the University of Waterloo. In 2024, the survey included 35 schools, and 79 per cent of students at those schools participated.
P.E.I. Green Party Leader Matt MacFarlane, who's also the MLA representing Borden-Kinkora, called the video taken of Butler's daughter "hard to watch."
He said school staff need more resources to deal with bullying, pointing out that many school administrators can spend just as much time teaching classes instead of creating more comfortable environments for students.
"Our party has called in the legislature for enhanced supports, for classroom supports, behavioural counselling, behavioural assistance," MacFarlane said.
"Our educational assistants are overworked and under-recognized for the role they play, and oftentimes … schools are sharing guidance counsellors, and that doesn't help address the problem of bullying on the ground."
MacFarlane added that the Public Schools Branch should create a system that tracks bullying incidents in all Island schools.
That's a system that Marv Bernstein, P.E.I.'s child and youth advocate, would also like to see implemented sooner than later.
He, too, has concerns about the Kinkora video and the broader issue of bullying in Island schools.
"I've seen the video, and it certainly is distressing," Bernstein said. "You don't like to see any child placed in those circumstances. We're aware that there are broader concerns from other families who have children in that school.
"Parents have said to us they don't feel believed, they feel frustrated, they don't know where to turn…. We feel as though it's important for some concrete actions to be taken."
The P.E.I. RCMP wouldn't do an interview, but said in a statement that the Criminal Code of Canada dictates that charges can't be laid against children under the age of 12.
"If evidence supports an offence on an accused under 12 then other resources such as parents, schools and Child and Family Services are engaged as appropriate," the statement reads.
"Contacting police in situations of a crime is important as police can make the connections to other social support agencies to address these situations that are suitable. It also helps to inform police about issues that may be going on in our communities."
Province committed to reporting program
In a statement, the P.E.I. Public Schools Branch said it realizes bullying online or in the community can significantly affect students and their families.
"If a connection to the school environment is found when it occurs outside regular school year or grounds, the school may use measures as outlined in the School Code of Conduct, the PSB Safe and Caring Learning Environments Policy, and/or the Education Act," reads the statement.
"These may include suspension, restorative practices, behaviour plans, or referrals to counselling or support services."
During this year's spring legislature sitting, Education and Early Years Minister Robin Croucher committed to implementing a new reporting program for bullying in all Island schools.
It's not clear when that program will be implemented, but it can't come soon enough for Butler and his daughter.
When asked if he felt comfortable with his child going back to school in September, Butler's answer was direct:
"No, not at all."
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
9 hours ago
- Yahoo
NY mother accused of jumping in during fight, attacking teen with a metal bottle
LONG ISLAND, N.Y. (PIX11) – A Long Island woman is accused of attacking a 14-year-old girl with a metal water bottle, hitting her in her head repeatedly, according to the Suffolk County Police Department. Toni Monroe, 35, allegedly attacked the victim Tuesday morning at Brentwood High School, according to police. More Crime News Monroe's 14-year-old daughter was allegedly involved in a fight with the victim. That is when Monroe reportedly got involved in the fight and struck the victim in the head multiple times with a metal water bottle. A school security guard stepped in to break up the fight, officials said. The victim, a student at the school where the incident took place, was transported to a local hospital for treatment of non-life-threatening injuries. Monroe faces charges of second-degree assault and endangering the welfare of a child. She is currently being held at a local jail and is scheduled for arraignment in Central Islip on Wednesday, according to arrest records. Matthew Euzarraga is a multimedia journalist from El Paso, Texas. He has covered local news and LGBTQIA topics in the New York City Metro area since 2021. He joined the PIX11 Digital team in 2023. You can see more of his work here. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Yahoo
10 hours ago
- Yahoo
1 person taken to hospital after Sandwich Street fire in Windsor
One person was taken to hospital suffering from smoke inhalation after a fire in the 3200 block of Sandwich Street in Windsor, Ont., Tuesday, fire officials said. One fire engine, one rescue vehicle and another truck all went to the scene, Windsor Fire and Rescue Services said in a post on social media. The fire was reported out at approximately 6 p.m., and crews had completed a primary search of the unit and vented smoke that was trapped inside, the fire service said. It caused less than $50,000 in damage, Chief Fire Prevention Officer John Smith told CBC.
Yahoo
14 hours ago
- Yahoo
MANDEL: Lawyer temporarily suspended over allegations of "reprehensible" conduct
Toronto lawyer Andrew Rogerson once made headlines for launching a $5.5 million lawsuit against Havergal, claiming the private girls' school failed to protect his daughter from bullying. Six years later, the Toronto lawyer's reputation is in tatters with allegations he ignored a court injunction to return a $90,000 retainer and even helped a client move $1 million in gold bars that were ordered frozen. While he denies their findings and appeals the decision of the Northwest Territories court and the Law Society of Ontario investigates the allegations against him, Rogerson has been suspended from practising in Ontario. 'We have reasonable grounds to believe there is a significant risk of harm, both to members of the public and to the public interest in the administration of justice, if the respondent continues to practise law while these investigations continue,' says a recent decision by the Law Society Tribunal. The tribunal quoted from the NWT Supreme Court's 'scathing' judgment that called Rogerson's behaviour 'reprehensible:' 'Refusing to be cross-examined by a female member of the bar, for an invented and meritless reason, and then dismissing her with a sexist remark, is reprehensible,' the court wrote. 'Refusing to properly account for the dissipation of trust funds, much less ones restrained by Court Order, is reprehensible.' Rogerson didn't respond to a request for comment. In 2023, Lutsel K'e Dene First Nation in the Northwest Territories accused Ron Barlas of funnelling millions of dollars that should have gone to the First Nation into companies he controlled, allegations he denied. Just two days before Barlas knew his worldwide assets were going to be frozen over the alleged fraud, he wired the $90,000 retainer to Rogerson. The NWT court found Rogerson not only refused to return the money frozen under the Mareva order issued on April 28, 2023 but he spent it, and not on any legal work invoiced to, or approved by, his client. 'I find as a fact that the purported fees were contrivances to justify draining the retainer,' wrote Justice N.E. Devlin in a March decision. 'Even more troublingly, in May 2023, Rogerson facilitated the shipment of more than $1 million worth of gold and silver bullion (since returned) from Barlas' possession in the Northwest Territories to his offices in Ontario. I find as a fact that he did so in knowing breach of the Mareva Order.' Rogerson was ordered to return the retainer and pay almost $47,000 in legal costs. The judge also sent his ruling to the Law Society of Ontario. A few months later, the LSO applied to the tribunal to have Rogerson's licence temporarily suspended while they investigate. It wouldn't be the first time. Earlier this year, the Law Society Tribunal suspended Rogerson for a month for sexual harassment of a female employee. Recommended video As for the Havergal lawsuit, he's been repeatedly criticized by Ontario judges for flouting court orders, continually delaying the process and not paying $145,000 in legal costs awarded to the other side. He blamed financial and health problems. Last year, Superior Court Justice William Chalmers finally stayed the lawsuit for Rogerson's 'complete disregard' for court processes. In this case, the tribunal found there are enough red flags to warrant suspending Rogerson while the law society investigates the findings in the NWT court decision. 'The allegations of misappropriating or misapplying trust funds are serious. So are the allegations that the respondent consciously defied a court order and obstructed a court process. If proven, they would demonstrate that the respondent profoundly lacks integrity as a lawyer,' concluded Paul Aterman on behalf of the three-member panel. 'The concerns around integrity would be compounded if it is also shown that the respondent treats women colleagues in a sexist manner.' So for now, this lawyer is indefinitely out of office. mmandel@