Mama Hooch rapist brothers Danny and Roberto Jaz challenge their convictions and sentences
Photo:
NZ Herald / George Heard
Two Christchurch brothers who used their family's bar and restaurant to drug and rape young women are challenging their convictions and sentences
Danny and Roberto Jaz were convicted in 2023 of drugging and violating more than 20 women at the bar Mama Hooch and neighbouring restaurant Venuti between 2015 and 2018.
A High Court appeal was heard by Justice Cameron Mander at Christchurch on Monday, but reporting of the matter was suppressed until 4pm on Tuesday as well as the reasons for that suppression.
Roberto Jaz was jailed for 17 years, and his older brother Danny was jailed for 16-and-a-half years in August 2023 by Judge Paul Mabey, who described their attacks as predatory and heartless.
The pair accumulated almost
70 convictions between them
for sexual violation, drink spiking, stupefying and making an intimate visual recording.
Judge Mabey imposed non-parole periods of half their sentences.
A month later the brothers
lodged appeals against their convictions and sentences
.
RNZ is now able to report on that High Court hearing.
Jaz brothers' lawyers Ron Mansfield KC (left) and James Carruthers.
Photo:
Stuff/Chris Skelton
Lawyer for the Jaz brothers Ron Mansfield KC told the court his clients did not get a fair hearing in the District Court and there was a significant miscarriage of justice.
"There is a significant and concerning danger and, in my submission, an obvious one in putting apparent efficiency of process over and above the interests of justice and standard principles of natural justice in any case, let alone one as serious as this one. That is what the appellants submit that this judge has done," he said.
The trial was complex and involved a substantial number of charges and complainants alleging very serious offending, Mansfield said.
"In effect, the judge simplistically ran roughshod over the defence cases in relation to each grouping of charges. Beyond that he failed to consider all relevant evidence relating to identified charges resulting independently in miscarriages of justice in relation to those specific charges."
Lawyer for the Crown Charlotte Brook said there was a wealth of evidence against the Jaz brothers and disputed Mansfield's claims of complexity or a miscarriage of justice.
"They had access to drugs, their positions at the bar meant they had access to the drinks being served, they were well known for handing out free drinks at the bar, which a number of witnesses said sometimes tasted awful and they didn't want to drink them. There was the internal propensity evidence - the sheer number of victims who the Crown alleged to have been stupefied suggests that the appellants had a propensity to do so," she said.
There was also the evidence of the brothers' own statements to each other in their group chats and to others, where they talked openly about administering drugs to people, Brook said.
"Their description of their preferred drug as 'bitter water' is consistent with the evidence of witnesses who said that sometimes they'd be given a free drink and it would taste so horrible, so bitter that they didn't want to drink it," she said.
Lawyers for the Crown Andrew McRae (left) and Charlotte Brook.
Photo:
Stuff/Chris Skelton
Mansfield argued the judge oversimplified points and failed to consider others, an example being the evidence complainants gave alleging they were drugged.
"There was a lot more to this case than the judge considered applicable when he came to looking at the issues, such as whether the complainants were stupefied, or somehow rendered, so they that could not consent to some sexual assault," he said.
Many of the complainants acknowledged they had consumed substantial quantities of alcohol either prior to going to the premises or while at the premises, and in some cases had used controlled drugs too, Mansfield said.
"When the witnesses said in the lower court that 'look I've been drunk before' or 'I've used drugs before and this wasn't like any of those occasions' the judge would simply say and he said it a number of times: 'the answer is the evidence'. What he didn't do was really query that response in light of the alcohol and or controlled drugs that they'd actually consumed against their age, weight and relative inexperience with consumption of both at that particular time, let alone the realities of both alcohol and drug consumption," he said.
Brook disputed Mansfield's characterisation the trial was complex or there was a miscarriage of justice.
"Of course it was serious, of course it was long, but the Crown says that doesn't necessarily mean it was complex. None of the charges were genuinely novel or complex in and of themselves... most charges were able to be dealt with quite briefly only a couple of paragraphs," she said.
Mansfield said the trial judge also erred in not allowing closing arguments, rendering the trial unfair.
"In my submission really it was the opportunity that all parties required in the District Court, that's the prosecution and defence, to a greater extent the defence... the only opportunity to present the defendants' case in relation to each grouping of charges was by way of the closing addresses," he said.
Justice Mander reserved his decision.
Jaz brothers' lawyer Ron Mansfield KC.
Photo:
Stuff/Chris McKeen
Police began investigating the Jaz brothers in July 2018 after two women reported being drugged and sexually assaulted at the venues.
At a judge-alone trial in 2023, the men were convicted of 69 charges relating to 23 victims, mostly women aged 18 to 24.
The sentences brought an end to five years of complex and detailed investigation work and a drawn-out prosecution process.
Survivors told the brothers during sentencing that their crimes had left them
feeling damaged, fearful and forever changed
.
Lead investigator Detective Inspector Scott Anderson praised the victims for coming forward and seeing the protracted process through.
"Their journey through the process has not been easy, however, because of their courage they have made our community a safer place," he said.
Anderson said the men had preyed on their victims in a disturbing way.
"One of their sole purposes was actually using the bar for their own gratification and servicing what they thought was quite all right for them, which it obviously wasn't," he said.
"It just goes to show how premeditated they were in targeting vulnerable people, in particular young girls, to do what they wanted with."
The Jaz brothers' father Michael Jaz owned both Mama Hooch and Venuti. Both venues have since closed and the company Jaz Holdings Limited was
put into liquidation in August 2023
.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

RNZ News
44 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Woman hit by dirtbike: 'Someone's going to get killed in that park'
The dirt bike involved in a collision with a cyclist in Porirua's Bothamley Park in 2022. Photo: Supplied A woman who was off work for a year after she was seriously injured in a head-on collision with a speeding dirt bike on a cycle track believes someone will be killed unless more is done to stop the problem. Joanne was cycling on a bike track at a Porirua Park in 2022 when she was wiped out by a dirt bike rider, and has only just had the metal plate inserted in her leg after the accident removed. She told Checkpoint the fact she survived the crash makes her consider herself lucky. "I was cycling along and it wasn't really even on a corner, a blind corner or anything like that, but suddenly I saw a motorbike coming towards me and I couldn't do anything about it because he was coming so fast... I sort of tried to swerve but couldn't. The next thing [that] went through my mind, this is going to be bad." The bike collided with her head on, and she was thrown into the air. "I ended up with a broken leg. It was a spiral fracture of my tibia. And I had to have that fixed in surgery so they put a plate in my leg." After the accident she had to take a year off from her job as a kindergarten teacher. "I need to be able to jump up and run across a playground... the healing just took a really long time." Joanne recently had to take a further three weeks off work to get the plate removed from her leg, which was giving her pain. The rider who caused the accident was never found, and after a few months of searching Police closed the file. "They sent the dogs out as I was being loaded onto the ambulance. I saw a policeman with a sniffer dog and he was, you know, trying to find the guy. But yeah, they never found him." Three years on, Joanne said she is still haunted by the noise of motorbikes. "I'm terrified. If I hear a motorbike even not close by... I haven't quite got over that." She said it was not until after her accident that she realised how big of an issue dirt bikes were. "That's a known problem in the park. People who live nearby, have the bikers going through their properties and cutting through alleyways and stuff because it's a big park and you just can't close every exit... the entry I took into the park is closed to dirt bikers, but other places aren't." Now Joanne believes dirt bikers need dedicated areas where they can go "rip up the park", to avoid more accidents. "I've heard of other people being hurt in that park. I heard of a young mum with a pram... someone's going to get killed in that park or somewhere else in New Zealand." Sonia lives in Hamilton near a scenic walkway, where like the park where Joanne was hit, she said dirt bikes are a serious accident waiting to happen. She told Checkpoint she has had to call police multiple times over fears about dangerous riders. "The dirt bikes [are] going back and forth up on the Te Awa River Ride where you have cyclists, people walking, walking dogs, loads of people and they just treat it like their personal playground." "The riders don't tend to have helmets. So they've got balaclavas or caps and they're doing wheel stands... it's undulating so the visibility is not always good and I kind of half expect them to take someone out." "But the worst was seeing them ride one handed, holding like a toddler, maybe two or three years old on the petrol tank." Sonia said the bikes are travelling at speeds of up to 60km/h, which has lead her to worry about the injuries they may cause. "There's just high foot traffic and young families and things like that that, they might not be able to get out of the way of one of these bike... they could definitely cause some massive, massive catastrophe." She said while police had responded to her calls in the past, nothing was done to stop the dirt bikers. "It seemed like 10 minutes later they were back out riding you need impound them when they're doing stuff like that." New Zealand Police told Checkpoint that communities needed to come forward and proactively provide them with information - including who was involved and the addresses that they were coming and going from. Police said without this information their capability to respond was severely limited. They want to hear reports of any unlawful or dangerous riding behaviour, and ask people to gather as much information as safely possible - including registrations, bike descriptions and any video footage that can be safely captured. They said if bikes are in the neighbourhood and it is happening now, call 111 or, if they have left the area or it happened previously, call 105. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
"Someone will be killed" woman injured by dirt bike warns
A woman who was off work for a year after she was seriously injured in a head on collision with a speeding dirt bike on a cycle track believes someone will be killed unless more is done to stop the problem. Joanne was cycling on a bike track at Porirua Park when she was wiped out by a dirt bike. Sonia, who lives in Hamilton near a scenic walkway said she also believes dirt bikes are a serious accident waiting to happen. Joanne and Sonia spoke to Lisa Owen. To embed this content on your own webpage, cut and paste the following: See terms of use.

RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
Gloriavale leader assault trial enters third day
Three former Gloriavale members have told a court they were touched, grabbed and groped by the Overseeing Shepherd Howard Temple, on the second day of his trial in Greymouth. Mr Temple has pleaded not guilty to 24 charges of sexual assault and doing an indecent act. Keiller MacDuff was in court in Greymouth and spoke to Lisa Owen. Tags: To embed this content on your own webpage, cut and paste the following: See terms of use.