Boeing and Justice Department seek judge's approval for deal opposed by crash victims' families
The deal enables Boeing to avoid being branded a convicted felon and to escape oversight from an independent monitor for three years that was part of a plea deal struck in 2024 to a criminal fraud charge that it misled US regulators about a crucial flight control system on the 737 MAX, its best-selling jet.
Boeing argued the executive branch solely has the power to decide whether to bring or maintain a prosecution.
'Because it is entirely within the government's discretion whether to pursue a criminal prosecution, an agreement not-to-prosecute does not require court approval,' Boeing said, asking a judge to reject objections filed by the families and grant the government's motion to dismiss the charge.
'Disputing the government's considered assessment of litigation risk, the calculation of the maximum fine, or the appropriate mechanism for compliance oversight, do not demonstrate - even remotely - that the government was clearly motivated by considerations contrary to the public interest.'
The Justice Department said in a court filing it acted in good faith and in accordance with the law, agreeing to dismiss the case for an agreement 'that secures a significant fine, compliance improvements, and a substantial victim compensation fund.'
BT in your inbox
Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox.
Sign Up
Sign Up
The families cited Judge Reed O'Connor's statement in 2023 that 'Boeing's crime may properly be considered the deadliest corporate crime in US history.'
They argue dismissal is not in the public interest and obligations imposed on Boeing are not enforceable.
If the government declined to move forward with the prosecution even if the court rejected the deal, O'Connor should appoint a special prosecutor, the families said.
Boeing and the Justice Department both asked O'Connor to reject appointing a special prosecutor.
Under the deal, Boeing agreed to pay an additional US$444.5 million into a crash victims fund to be divided evenly per crash victim, on top of a new US$243.6 million fine.
Boeing in July 2024 agreed to plead guilty to a criminal fraud conspiracy charge after the two fatal 737 MAX crashes in Indonesia and Ethiopia.
Under the non-prosecution agreement, Boeing will pay US$1.1 billion in total, including the fine, compensation to families and more than US$455 million to strengthen the company's compliance, safety and quality programmes.
The vast majority of the families have settled civil suits with Boeing and collectively have been 'paid several billion dollars,' the Justice Department said. REUTERS
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Times
3 hours ago
- Business Times
Boeing in talks to sell as many as 500 planes to China: sources
[BEIJING] Boeing is heading closer towards finalising a deal with China to sell as many as 500 aircraft, according to people familiar with the matter, a transaction that would end a sales drought that stretches back to US President Donald Trump's last visit in 2017. The two sides are still hammering out terms of the complex aircraft sale, including the types and volume of jet models and delivery timetables, according to one of the people, who asked not to be identified discussing confidential matters. The mega sale to China, years in the making, is contingent on the two nations diffusing the trade hostilities that hark back to Trump's first term in office – and could still fall apart, they said. Chinese officials have already started consulting domestic airlines about how many Boeing aircraft they will need, the people said. The transaction taking shape is similar in scope to the order for as many as 500 jets that China's central planners have struck with Airbus, but have not yet announced, they added. The Boeing order is expected to be the centrepiece of a trade agreement that would benefit both Trump and China's President Xi Jinping, the culmination of long-running and sometimes contentious negotiations. The nation's leaders were close to a similar announcement in 2023, but then-President Joe Biden and Xi left a San Francisco summit without consummating an aircraft sale. Complicating matters for Boeing is a leadership void in China. Alvin Liu, its top executive in China and a fluent Mandarin-speaker with extensive government contacts, left the company in recent weeks. Carol Shen has been named interim president of Boeing China, said people familiar with the matter. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up Boeing declined to comment on any potential deal or management changes. Aircraft orders for Boeing have figured large in US diplomacy since Trump returned to the White House in January, with nations touting new, tentative and existing deals for airplanes, which are as expensive as skyscrapers, to narrow trade imbalances with the US. The US and China have engaged in several rounds of talks since de-escalating tit-for-tat tariffs that soared to as high as 145 per cent, but have yet to reach a final trade deal. Earlier in the summer, Xi, in a phone call, invited Trump to China at an unspecified date. One opportunity for the pair to meet is in late October, ahead of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit in South Korea. For China, the deal would secure aircraft delivery slots that are hard to come by at both Boeing and Airbus, which are largely sold out into the 2030s. The world's second largest's aviation market is expected to more than double its commercial fleet to 9,755 airplanes over the next 20 years, by Boeing's estimation, far more than China's homegrown planemaker Comac could manufacture. The country's top economic planning agency, the National Development and Reform Commission, recently sought input from Chinese carriers about how many jets they want, one of the people said. Talks centreed on the 737 Max series of aircraft, Boeing's popular single-aisle jet, in a sign Beijing is laying the groundwork for a major order. Boeing's last Chinese deal was unveiled in November 2017 during Trump's first state visit to China. The deal amounted to orders and commitments for 300 single-aisle and twin-aisle planes valued at US$37 billion at the time. The next year, Boeing's China deliveries peaked, when a quarter of its jets ended up in the mainland. Airbus has dominated sales and deliveries to China since 2019, when the nation's regulators were the first to ground the 737 Max after two fatal accidents. Boeing has notched only 30 orders with Chinese carriers and leasing companies since the start of 2019, according to the company's website. In an interview with Bloomberg in January, chief executive officer Kelly Ortberg was optimistic that years of talks with Beijing would finally pay off. 'We certainly hope that there's an opportunity for some additional orders in the next year with China,' he said. BLOOMBERG
Straits Times
7 hours ago
- Straits Times
Russian strikes kill one, injure 18 people in largest aerial attack of August
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox Firefighters work at the site of the Russian missile strike, amid Russia's attack on Ukraine, in the village of Sknyliv on the outskirts of Lviv, Ukraine August 21, 2025. REUTERS/Roman Baluk KYIV - Russian overnight attack killed one person, injured at least 18, and struck a U.S. electronics manufacturer in western Ukraine, Ukrainian officials said on Thursday. A missile attack injured 15 people and destroyed storage facilities at the manufacturer in the town of Mukachevo, emergency services and local authorities in the western Zakarpattia region said. National television showed the region's governor Myroslav Biletskyi, standing near the building engulfed in smoke, who said the plant was producing consumer electronics, while Foreign Minister Andrii Sybiha condemned the strike in a post on X. "A fully civilian facility that has nothing to do with defense or the military," he said. "This is not the first Russian attack on American businesses in Ukraine, after strikes on Boeing offices in Kyiv earlier this year and other attacks." In the western city of Lviv, the attack killed one person, injured three more, and damaged 26 homes, according to Governor Maksym Kozytskyi. Ukrainian Air Force said that Russia used 574 drones and 40 missiles in the overnight attack on the country, which was the biggest one so far in August. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore Singapore Parliament releases seating plan for 15th term: Find out who is sitting where Singapore District judge signals sterner penalties for vaping offences, cites public concerns Singapore Alleged vape seller faces new charge after he was found with more than 190 Kpods Singapore 3 people taken to hospital after fire at Bukit Purmei flat Singapore Police looking for car driver after hit-and-run incident with lorry in Kallang Singapore Fullerton Healthcare Corp co-founder admits approving falsified claims of over $213k Life Bucking sluggish retail, Singapore brands commit to wowing with experience-driven physical stores Singapore Continuing to ensure credibility non-negotiable for Straits Times: Editor Jaime Ho "This is why efforts to force Russia to end the war are so critical," Sybiha said. The strike took place at a time of intense efforts by U.S. President Donald Trump to bring an end to the Russian war in Ukraine. Russia, which denies targeting civilians, has used missiles and drones to strike Ukrainian towns and cities far from the front lines of the war. Thousands of civilians, the vast majority of them Ukrainian, have been killed since Moscow invaded in 2022. REUTERS
Business Times
7 hours ago
- Business Times
Musk's Starlink courts luxury airlines to grow in-flight Wi-Fi business
[WASHINGTON] For the past three years, Elon Musk has steadily elbowed his way into the booming market for in-flight Wi-Fi, with his Starlink service signing up blue-chip carriers from Air France to Qatar Airways to United Airlines. Alaska Air Group said on Wednesday (Aug 20) it will install Starlink starting next year and Virgin Atlantic in early July reached a deal to use the SpaceX-owned satellite network. Arch-rival British Airways might be not far behind, according to people familiar with the matter, in a deal that would let Musk lock up another flagship airline on the lucrative trans-Atlantic route. But Musk has his eyes on an even bigger prize: the Middle East, home to some of the most trend-setting airlines in the industry and a global connecting hub for long-haul travel. SpaceX has been in conversation with Emirates, the Dubai-based airline that commands the world's biggest long-haul fleet of Boeing and Airbus aircraft, Bloomberg has reported. Members of Musk's team have also pitched Starlink to other carriers including Gulf Air and FlyDubai, and are now in advanced talks with Saudia, the region's No. three airline, according to people familiar with the matter. Winning business with Middle Eastern airlines, particularly those like Emirates recognised for their luxury brands, would mark a watershed moment in Starlink's global competition against legacy operators like EchoStar, Viasat and SES. Those rivals aren't willing to cede ground without a fight. Instead, they are reworking business plans and pursuing a wave of deal-making as the battle accelerates over a fast-growing slice of the US$100 billion satellite communications market. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up SpaceX has gained a toehold in the global aviation market by delivering the fastest Internet connection speeds across the industry using roughly 8,000 satellites. The company offers its Starlink technology through a subscription model in which carriers pay to install the hardware and an additional monthly price for connectivity per seat. For example, putting Starlink onto a Boeing 737 costs about US$300,000, while a larger 787 Dreamliner model commands a US$500,000 price tag per aircraft, according to a document seen by Bloomberg. Monthly pricing on a per seat basis can vary based on many factors, including the length of the contract a carrier is willing to sign. But in some cases, Starlink has been agreed to sell its service for around US$120 monthly per seat, with an additional US$120 for live television, one of the people said. Negotiations are still underway and carriers could pursue different strategies, the people cautioned. FlyDubai said it's 'currently assessing different options for connectivity to meet our growth plans.' Gulf Air declined to comment. Saudia did not reply to requests for comment. Emirates said it's committed to the best in-flight service, while declining to comment on the deal. British Airways' parent IAG declined to comment. In-flight Web access was long an offering as exotic as it was unreliable and expensive, both for airlines to install and passengers to use. Many carriers are pushing to provide fast and reliable alternatives, since enabling customer to stream, work and communicate on long flights can be a gamechanger for the cabin experience. Carriers with an eye for marketing have also bathed in the halo effect of Musk's star power. Qatar Airways chief executive officer Badr Mohammed Al-Meer was visibly thrilled to be communicating with the SpaceX CEO by video during a Starlink trial at 30,000 feet last October. Starlink Internet 'is only going to get better,' Musk promised at the time. Since then, however, Musk's public standing has shifted from industry disruptor to political iconoclast during his stint as head of the DOGE government-slashing effort under President Donald Trump. That, in turn, has turned off many consumers and has made Musk an increasingly polarising figure. With the Trump-Musk relationship now fractured, some countries may hesitate to authorise Starlink and thus associate themselves with the SpaceX boss, particularly those that have closely aligned themselves with the US president. 'There's a degree of increased sensitivity to all of this political fallout, as seen in things like the falling sales of Tesla cars,' said technology consultant Tim Farrar, an analyst with TMF Associates. 'Those airlines might hold back a bit longer.' Starlink aviation terminals are cheaper than some rival products, according to William Blair . analyst Louie DiPalma, and require less time to install, according to United Airlines. The Starlink network sends signals to an aircraft just as it does to its other six million residential, mobile or maritime active users: A terminal about the size of a pizza box is affixed to an aircraft and connects with a stream of satellites moving across its path roughly about 560 km above Earth, in what's known as low-Earth orbit, or LEO. By comparison, legacy operators like Viasat and SES have achieved global coverage with a small number of much larger, more powerful satellites about 65 times higher, in geostationary orbit. Because these satellites are more distant from Earth, data has a much longer distance to travel, sometimes leading to sluggish Internet connection on flights. But with modern demands for broadband speeds from anywhere, legacy satellite operators are taking a page out of SpaceX's playbook. EchoStar, Viasat and SES have started marketing multi-orbit solutions directly to airlines, pulling together capacity from diversified satellite constellations in geostationary orbits and orbits closer to Earth. In the past few months, Viasat announced deals to power in-flight connectivity with American Airlines and Riyadh Air. Intelsat, acquired in July by SES, announced partnerships with Thai Airways International and planemaker Embraer. A multi-orbit system 'provides resiliency, it provides consistency, it offers the network operator the ability to adapt to changing environments like weather or a concentration of aircraft around certain parts of the world,' said Andrew Ruszkowski, global head of aviation at SES. Other large carriers, including Delta Air Lines and JetBlue Airways, have so far taken a wait-and-see approach on Starlink. Representatives for each declined to comment on discussions with SpaceX. Their resistance may be explained by SpaceX's own lingering challenges and restrictions as the company races to build out and improve its network. SpaceX and airlines have sparred at the negotiating table over Starlink's demand that carriers offer Wi-Fi free to everyone on board. Starlink has budged on that issue in some cases because airlines have pushed to offer the service only to passengers in their loyalty programmes, people familiar with the matter said. Talks are ongoing with other carriers, one of the people said. SpaceX also requires airlines to agree to install the technology on all of their planes before announcing a deal, the people said, a risky gamble particularly for airlines with larger fleets. United's own high-profile bet on Starlink has already hit a snag. In early June, the carrier confirmed it was experiencing issues of static interference with its Starlink system, temporarily shutting off Wi-Fi on two dozen regional planes. United has resolved the issue and installed Starlink on 60 of its regional Embraer planes. Separately, roughly 60,000 customers reported losing Starlink service in an hours-long outage on Jul 24. The network suffered another broad but relatively brief outage on Aug 18. Starlink is also not authorised in many countries, meaning carriers may have to shut off the Internet before landing, aviation executives said. And the service is certain to face competition from networks set to come online in the next couple of years, like Telesat Corp.'s Lightspeed or Inc.'s Project Kuiper, championed by Musk rival Jeff Bezos. The battle for connected skies is only going to intensify, with unpredictable results. But some executives note Starlink's data speeds are industry-leading, customers seem impressed and Musk has a track record of upending old-school industries, from rocketry to automaking. 'The overwhelming response is that people can't get over how fast it is and how they can stream or FaceTime or Zoom,' said Alex Wilcox, CEO of JSX, which provides Starlink-enabled Wi-Fi to passengers on its 30-seat planes. 'And so I think they're going to run away with the market and deservedly so.' BLOOMBERG
