Lawyer seeks to add Alberta corporations to list of plaintiffs in COVID-related class-action lawsuit
Alberta corporations negatively impacted by unlawful provincial COVID-19 measures should be added to the class of plaintiffs suing the government over business losses, a lawyer argued Wednesday.
Article content
Jeffrey Rath said there is likely a large group of corporations impacted by the measures who should be entitled to join a class-action lawsuit proceeding on behalf of individual business owners who lost money due to government actions.
Article content
Article content
Article content
Rath said concerns raised by Justice Colin Feasby and Alberta Justice lawyer John-Marc Dube that major corporations would join the fray are unfounded.
Article content
Article content
He said adding corporations to the lawsuit, which Feasby certified as a class-action case last fall, would allow smaller mom-and-pop companies to be represented before the court.
Article content
'Just because there are multi-billion-dollar corporations in Alberta should not mean that these smaller corporations should be precluded,' Rath said.
Article content
While major corporations have the resources to proceed with their own litigation, the vast majority of Alberta companies would be small operations, he argued.
Article content
'There are lots of mom-and-pops running their own corporations.'
Article content
Rath, who currently represents a class certified by Feasby of Alberta business owners impacted by the measures introduced at the height of the coronavirus pandemic, said many smaller incorporated operations are in the same boat.
Article content
Article content
'They're still suffering from these orders. They're still suffering from a massive debt burden,' the lawyer said.
Article content
But Dube said the group would not be limited to just small corporations.
Article content
'The proposed class of all corporations in Alberta run the whole gamut,' he said.
Article content
Last Oct. 30, the Calgary Court of King's Bench judge ruled the class action could proceed on behalf of individual business owners who may have suffered losses due to unauthorized restrictions imposed by the Jason Kenney government.
Article content
Feasby said the case can proceed on six common issues impacting all business owners affected by measures imposed by provincial cabinet and issued in the name of Chief Medical Officer of Health Dr. Deena Hinshaw.
Article content
In 2023, Justice Barb Romaine ruled the measures ordered were unlawfully imposed under the Public Health Act because the decisions to issue the CMOH orders were made by cabinet and not Hinshaw.
Article content
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
4 hours ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Evotrux loads up online subscription seeking freight efficiency
Manitoba entrepreneur Daniel Santos has high hopes for the coming months. Evotrux, the business he co-founded seven years ago, is making its presence known after years of operating in what Santos describes as 'stealth mode.' 'We're essentially launching Evotrux to the world,' he said. 'It's been behind closed doors to the world until now.' Evotrux offers an on-demand freight marketplace that does away with phone calls, emails and spreadsheets. The name reflects the evolution of trucking Santos believes the company is bringing to the shipping industry. The online platform connects shippers (businesses that need to transport goods) and carriers (trucking companies and freight brokers). The platform allows carriers to provide more shippers with real-time pricing on available shipments. Shippers can compare and negotiate rates, review carrier profiles and then select their preferred option with the click of a button. From there, the shipper and carrier are connected through live chat and the shipper receives live tracking updates, including time-stamped pick-up and delivery statuses. The platform also enables users to collaborate and analyze real-time market insights so they can maximize efficiencies and streamline overall operations. Santos said while there are other digital solutions for shippers, most use a commission/transaction fee business model 'and they are almost never transparent.' Some services add a 20 per cent markup on the carrier price, he added. Evotrux doesn't do that, Santos said. Customers pay a monthly subscription fee of $199 to access the network and whatever price they are quoted by the carrier is the actual price they end up paying. There are no hidden fees, markups or commissions. Evotrux coined the term 'open shipping' to describe the platform. '(It's) a fair, transparent marketplace where everyone competes on a level playing field,' said Santos, who works from his home in Ste. Anne, some 50 kilometres southeast of Winnipeg. The 42-year-old has worked in logistics for 25 years. Prior to starting Evotrux, he spent seven years as a freight broker — the middleman between shippers and carriers. He said he managed roughly 300 emails and 100 phone calls a day trying to get his job done. The idea for Evotrux came to him as he wondered if there might be a way to create better communication across a wider platform. Santos founded the company with Ross Prentice and Norm Curtis. The company launched in 2018, but supply chain disruptions during the COVID-19 pandemic 'stopped us in our tracks,' Santos said. He and his colleagues sensed they could improve on their product, so they spent more than 18 months rebuilding it. They quietly relaunched in 2022. Logistics and shipping are areas businesses almost never look at when they're trying to optimize costs, Santos said. Now they can. 'Businesses don't need to look at logistics as a necessary evil,' he said. 'Evotrux helps them to unlock and uncover the opportunities.' The company has a satisfied customer in Mike Friesen, president and CEO of Elmer's Manufacturing Ltd. The farm equipment manufacturer is based around 100 kilometres south of Winnipeg in Altona and ships its products across North America. It has used Evotrux for around three years. Friesen said he likes the platform because it's an efficient way for the company to explore its options. 'We may know (Manitoba) carriers very well, but we may not know good local carriers in the U.S.,' he said. 'This provides us easier access to that.' Evotrux has also saved Elmer's money, Friesen said: $95,000 in the first four months of 2025 alone. 'One of my sales managers … figures it increased his productivity by about 75 per cent, just because of the streamlined process that Evotrux offers,' Friesen added. Evotrux is set to receive $250,000 from an as-yet unannounced Manitoba Innovates loan program. (Manitoba Innovates is the unification of Tech Manitoba and Manitoba Technology Accelerator.) 'They're a company that's been around for a long time (and) they're starting to see good traction,' said Paul Card, CEO of MTA. 'It's an innovative product we haven't seen anywhere else and Manitoba Innovates is in the business of trying to find innovative Manitoba solutions to local and international problems.' According to Santos, 500 carriers and 15 shippers are subscribed to Evotrux. The company employs five people and will add three staff members in the coming weeks, he added. Last year, its annual net revenue surpassed $120,000. '(We're) hoping to grow that this year,' Santos said. 'This is our big breakout year. No one knew we existed before.' Aaron EppReporter Aaron Epp reports on business for the Free Press. After freelancing for the paper for a decade, he joined the staff full-time in 2024. He was previously the associate editor at Canadian Mennonite. Read more about Aaron. Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Vancouver Sun
5 hours ago
- Vancouver Sun
Opinion: Cascadia's cultural diplomacy could be key legacy of FIFA 2026
King Charles's recent address to Canadian parliament, which carefully delineated the state of Canada's relationship with the United States while also pointing to its future prospects beyond North America, provided an important moment for reflection in the borderlands. Protecting Canadian sovereignty, according to the monarch, will rely on significant investments in the economy and national defence, but also more dynamic engagement with the global community. 'Fundamental change is always unsettling,' the king declared during the speech. 'Yet this moment is also an incredible opportunity.' A daily roundup of Opinion pieces from the Sun and beyond. By signing up you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc. A welcome email is on its way. If you don't see it, please check your junk folder. The next issue of Informed Opinion will soon be in your inbox. Please try again Interested in more newsletters? Browse here. The British royal's words are a far cry from the cross-border rhetoric projected by the White House earlier this year, or the campaign slogans that came to define the recent Canadian federal election. They point to a relationship between Canada and the U.S. that continues to be steeped in mutual interest, but also one that is admittedly transformed by recent politics. That message of opportunity is one that should take on greater significance in the Cascadia region. For years, leaders in the cross-border area that includes B.C., Washington, and Oregon have argued that cross-border integration can deliver greater economic prosperity, cultural exchange, and overall quality of life for those who live in the region. For some critics, that ethos of cooperation might seem quaint in the wake of discouraging newspaper headlines and social media barbs. Much like other Canadians, British Columbians have scaled back their engagement with the U.S. to a significant extent, including economic activity and cross-border tourism. Such sentiments are apparent in the drastic drop of B.C.-plated cars crossing the border into Whatcom County, Washington. A steady post-COVID recovery in travel started to reverse in February 2025, with B.C. vehicle crossings dropping by nearly 30 per cent compared to the previous year. By April, the year-over-year decline accelerated to 51 per cent. And these trends seem likely to hold. A recent opinion survey conducted by Leger Marketing for the Association for Canadian Studies found that 57 per cent of British Columbians polled did not feel safe or welcome in the U.S. — a figure that is higher even than Canada's national average of 52 per cent. And yet at least one future milestone points to the possibility of unprecedented collaboration between the two countries, and between B.C. and Washington: the 2026 FIFA World Cup. The international soccer tournament, the most watched sporting spectacle in the world, is rivalled only by the Olympics in terms of global attention and impact. Among the host cities across Canada, Mexico, and the U.S., Vancouver will host seven of the matches next June and July, while Seattle will stage another six. The intensity of that sporting schedule should turn the I-5 corridor into a hotbed of soccer engagement for fans from both sides of the border and indeed from around the world. The World Cup matches are expected to attract over 1.6 million visitors combined, with an estimated 900,000 projected for Vancouver and 750,000 for Seattle. While predicting the increase in border crossings is likely an exercise in fruition, it goes without saying that there will undoubtedly be surges in traffic, particularly given the alternating timing of the games between Seattle and Vancouver. Summer is already peak travel season in the region, and as we saw during the Taylor Swift concerts in Seattle, and later in Vancouver, cross-border travel is a key component of the visitor experience in Cascadia. And it can get messy. Is the region up to the challenge? Vancouver's successful staging of the Winter Olympics in 2010 would suggest so. So too would Seattle's recent hosting of marquee sporting events like the NHL Winter Classic and Major League Baseball's All-Star Game. Looking further back there's Vancouver's hosting of the World Expo in 1986, and Seattle's hosting of the World's Fair in 1962. Both events left undeniable civic and regional legacies that resonate even today. Yet the 2010 Olympics serve up the most relevant comparison in terms of scope and scale. The Winter Games left behind infrastructural legacies such as an improved Sea to Sky Highway connecting Vancouver to Whistler, and an expanded Skytrain network, but also incremental but symbolically significant regional improvements such as enhanced efficiencies at the B.C.-Washington border crossings. Through bi-national collaboration, the region leveraged the occasion of the Olympics to get a second passenger train on the Amtrak Cascades route and developed the enhanced driver's license for cross-border travel. Much like the expanded infrastructure, these gains in cross-border mobility continue to benefit the region today. Unlike the Olympic boosters from two decades ago, FIFA organizers and backers in Vancouver and Seattle aren't promising that same combination of infrastructural innovations and civic amenities. In fact, planning for the cross-border dimension of travelling between Seattle and Vancouver has been largely left to local stakeholders. This dynamic practically necessitates a spirit of collaboration. If there is one thing the Cascadia region has proven time and time again, it is that through cooperation we can rise to the occasion – in ways that benefit both sides of the border. Now is the time for a renewed and compelling narrative for the borderlands predicated on the values of engagement and diplomacy. The World Cup's legacy, therefore, won't be defined by athletic venues, transportation systems, or urban redevelopment — although the existing versions of these criteria will be crucial to the staging of FIFA 2026 in Cascadia. Rather, the tournament's legacy in the region could be defined by how it recalibrates the narrative of the Canada-U.S. relationship. In this sense, Cascadia could serve as a model for the rest of the continent. Already, the region's policy makers, industry leaders, and government agencies have come together to foster this shared goal. While this has become more challenging in recent months, the common vision that we share as Canadians and Americans is still apparent. But there's also a significant role for folks on the ground in the communities where FIFA's matches are staged or simulcast. That includes Cascadia's largest metropolitan regions but also a multitude of fan engagement sites in between, creating massive opportunities for fans and volunteers from both countries to co-mingle and cheer on their favourite teams. International soccer, therefore, provides a timely and perhaps necessary mode for citizen- and community-driven diplomacy that just might change the shaky trajectory of Canada-U.S. relations. That won't come easy in this era of acrimony and tough talk. But given the stakes of the bi-national relationship, and the historic opportunity of hosting a World Cup as a unified region on a global stage, we can't afford not to embrace this critically important occasion. Laurie Trautman is director of the Border Policy Research Institute at Western Washington University; Derek Moscato is a professor in the department of journalism and a Border Policy Research Institute research fellow at Western, where he also teaches in the Canadian-American Studies program.
Calgary Herald
6 hours ago
- Calgary Herald
Lawyer seeks to add Alberta corporations to list of plaintiffs in COVID-related class-action lawsuit
Alberta corporations negatively impacted by unlawful provincial COVID-19 measures should be added to the class of plaintiffs suing the government over business losses, a lawyer argued Wednesday. Article content Jeffrey Rath said there is likely a large group of corporations impacted by the measures who should be entitled to join a class-action lawsuit proceeding on behalf of individual business owners who lost money due to government actions. Article content Article content Article content Rath said concerns raised by Justice Colin Feasby and Alberta Justice lawyer John-Marc Dube that major corporations would join the fray are unfounded. Article content Article content He said adding corporations to the lawsuit, which Feasby certified as a class-action case last fall, would allow smaller mom-and-pop companies to be represented before the court. Article content 'Just because there are multi-billion-dollar corporations in Alberta should not mean that these smaller corporations should be precluded,' Rath said. Article content While major corporations have the resources to proceed with their own litigation, the vast majority of Alberta companies would be small operations, he argued. Article content 'There are lots of mom-and-pops running their own corporations.' Article content Rath, who currently represents a class certified by Feasby of Alberta business owners impacted by the measures introduced at the height of the coronavirus pandemic, said many smaller incorporated operations are in the same boat. Article content Article content 'They're still suffering from these orders. They're still suffering from a massive debt burden,' the lawyer said. Article content But Dube said the group would not be limited to just small corporations. Article content 'The proposed class of all corporations in Alberta run the whole gamut,' he said. Article content Last Oct. 30, the Calgary Court of King's Bench judge ruled the class action could proceed on behalf of individual business owners who may have suffered losses due to unauthorized restrictions imposed by the Jason Kenney government. Article content Feasby said the case can proceed on six common issues impacting all business owners affected by measures imposed by provincial cabinet and issued in the name of Chief Medical Officer of Health Dr. Deena Hinshaw. Article content In 2023, Justice Barb Romaine ruled the measures ordered were unlawfully imposed under the Public Health Act because the decisions to issue the CMOH orders were made by cabinet and not Hinshaw. Article content
