Ex-Gloriavale member believes guilty plea to indecency charges by leader Howard Temple, won't change community
Photo:
The Press/Kai Schwoerer
The late guilty plea of Gloriavale's overseeing shepherd to indecent assault charges shows the strength of the testimony of witnesses, a former member says.
Howard Temple
admitted 12 charges in court, including five of indecent assault
, three days into his trial in Greymouth on Wednesday, having earlier denied 24 counts of sexual offending against girls and women.
Charges the 85-year-old pleaded guilty to also included five of doing an indecent act and two of common assault.
The other charges were dismissed.
Temple was remanded on bail until August 11 when a date would be set for sentencing.
Former Gloriavale member John Ready told
Morning Report
he was surprised by the verdict change.
"I thought [Temple] would just fight it till the wheels fell off, I just thought wow he changed, pleaded guilty, the strength of the testimony would've been strong," he said.
Ready did not believe the outcome of the trial would change much in Gloriavale.
"I think the community will just carry on, they already have a leadership replacement in place," he said.
"Their world view its just not in line with reality and that's why we have to go to court to do any sort of negotiation with them because a sit down face to face talk is just impossible with speaking different languages it seems like."
Outside court on Wednesday the mother of one of the complainants, who cannot be named, said she cried in the public gallery
when Temple initially denied the charges
.
"I was thinking you are the shepherd, you are responsible for these people. You didn't show the care of a shepherd," she said.
The Gloriavale compound on the West Coast.
Photo:
RNZ / Jean Edwards
"It's a milestone that our voice has been heard. A leader of Gloriavale has acknowledged that he has done wrong to our children. We do not want future generations of children suffering this and going through the same scenario."
The original offending dated from 1998 to 2022, involving nine complainants ranging in age from nine to 20-years-old.
Five of the nine complainants gave evidence over the first two days of the trial, describing a culture of fierce patriarchy, where women and girls were at risk of being deemed rebellious or worldly for anything from tying the belt on their uniform incorrectly, to allowing too much hair to be visible under their headscarves.
The women described Temple taking advantage of the domestic duties they performed to touch, caress and grope them, such as during meal times, when they would be serving large, heavy jugs of non-alcoholic cider or hot drinks to tables of 50 or more.
One woman said she was left without "any hands free to protect myself".
Temple was also alleged to have frequented the kitchen to "hug" the young women from behind while they were cooking or washing dishes, kissing them on their necks, touching their breasts or making lewd remarks.
The women said there was no way to refuse Temple, nor to report his actions to anyone, in the context of the complete control Gloriavale's leaders wielded over members.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Sweeping reforms to money laundering laws
Photo: 123RF The government has unveiled sweeping reforms to the country's anti money laundering laws to crack down on dirty money. Set to be in place by the next election, the changes to New Zealand's Anti-Money Laundering and Countering Financing of Terrorism (AML/CFT) regime aim to shut down dodgy deals, tighten financial loopholes, and take on the criminal underworld, while cutting unnecessary red tape for law-abiding citizens. It is estimated that a staggering $1.35 billion is generated from money laundering in New Zealand every year. The Detail talks to Lloyd Kavanagh, a financial services lawyer and deal maker from Minter Ellison Rudd Watts, about the changes, which include giving police greater powers to freeze bank accounts more quickly, banning cryptocurrency ATMs, introducing a more risk-based system for selling property from family trusts, and making it easier for parents to open bank accounts for their children. Kavanagh also welcomes efforts to streamline and simplify the system by introducing one supervision layer to oversee the rules. "Currently, we have three supervisors who supervise different segments of the market," he tells The Detail. "You have the Reserve Bank, who is the AML supervisor for banks, you have the FMA who oversees securities market participants broadly, and then you have the Department of Internal Affairs, who looks after casinos and everybody else... lenders, lawyers, accountants, real estate agents, and quite a wide range of smaller businesses. "What the government is proposing is... we should have a single supervisor so that they can be consistent in the guidance that they give to reporting entities, and have a total overview of what's going on in the sector. So that is one measure which I think will have a significant impact. "Some of the other measures ... are actually to relieve the administrative burden - one of them is, at the moment, you have to verify your customer's address, which proves to be really difficult for a lot of people.... so, the change will mean you only have to do that if you have got reasons for thinking it's a high-risk customer. "I am actually optimistic that by removing some of the mandatory bureaucracy, resources will get refocused in doing what I think, and I certainly hope all New Zealanders are keen to do, which is to use the pressure on what happens to the proceeds of crime to help us detect crime in the first place." He does have some concerns about giving greater powers to police - "I'm a little reserved about simply giving additional powers to the police if you don't have the right checks and balances" - and questions the ban on cryptocurrency ATMs, which are kiosks that allow users to buy and sell cryptocurrency using cash. "I'm somewhat puzzled by that inclusion because I haven't seen the evidence as to why that would be a particular priority." But ultimately, he believes the law changes will make a difference. "We all benefit if there is less crime in New Zealand. These people [money launderers] make business decisions as to which countries are easier to operate in and profitable to operate in. "And we know from the reports that have come from the government over the last year that New Zealand has an increasing level of drug abuse. We know that we are more and more connected in a world where there are all sorts of transactions going on. "What we need to do is just make ourselves a little bit harder to do bad things in. So, I think these [law changes] are positive steps." Check out how to listen to and follow The Detail here . You can also stay up-to-date by liking us on Facebook
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Prominent figure with name supression set to reappear in court
Photo: RNZ / Dan Cook A prominent New Zealander is set to reappear in court on Monday. RNZ earlier revealed a prominent New Zealander had been arrested . After being made aware of the man's arrest, RNZ approached the Wellington District Court to see if there were any suppression orders and when he would be appearing in court. In response, a registrar said the man faced eight charges, all of which are category three offences meaning the offence is punishable by imprisonment for life, or imprisonment for two years or more. However, an application had been granted prohibiting media from being able to report the man's name, identifying particulars as well as the nature of the charges he faced before his first appearance. The man appeared in the Wellington District Court via audio visual link on 3 July. Media opposed the suppression orders. However, the defendant's lawyers asked for the orders to continue on an interim basis until their next appearance. Judge David Laurenson agreed to continue the orders. The man was remanded on bail without plea until his next appearance on Monday. Under the Criminal Procedure Act a court may make an order forbidding publication of the name of a person who is charged with an offence if the court is satisfied publication would be likely to result in eight different outcomes including causing extreme hardship and creating a real risk of prejudice to a fair trial. The fact a defendant is well known does not, of itself, mean that publication of his or her name will result in extreme hardship. At first appearance a defendant only needs to advance an "arguable case" that one of the eight grounds applies. The only section in the Criminal Procedure Act that permits suppression of the charges is section 199C, which permits suppression of "trial-related information" where the court is satisfied publication of that information is likely to create a real risk of prejudice to a fair trial. Trial-related information includes "any other specific information in relation to any trial". Where an interim order is made under section 199C it only lasts until the defendant's next court appearance. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
9 hours ago
- RNZ News
Nine penguins found dead in Golden Bay over past fortnight
Nine penguin have been found dead in Golden Bay over the past fortnight or so. File picture. Photo: 123RF The Department of Conservation is warning dog owners to keep their pets under control, after nine little penguins were found dead in Golden Bay over a nearly two-week period. On Wednesday, three kororā were found dead on Pakawau Beach in Golden Bay and were believed to have been killed by a dog. The dead birds have been sent to Massey University for a necropsy and DNA testing, which would confirm if a dog was to blame. The bodies of six others were found on nearby Parapara beach over the 12 days prior, all of them killed by a dog. DOC acting Golden Bay operations manager Shane Butland reminded owners to keep dogs on leads during the day and contained at night, if there were penguins in the area. "Kororā are the world's smallest penguin, about 25cm long when fully grown. They have a conservation status of 'At Risk - Declining'. "Threats include dog attacks, predation from introduced predators and being hit by vehicles, and they are easily disturbed by people." Golden Bay ward councillor Celia Butler said the situation was not unprecedented. "There is a problem ongoing with penguins being killed by dogs, and part of the problem is that dogs are very, very attracted to the smell of penguins and they are nesting at the moment." Butler said, under council rules, dogs should be under control at all times, which meant they should not be able to roam at night. "This can be a particular threat to penguins. When people allow dogs to roam at night, they are breaking the bylaw, but it's very difficult to know whose dog it is." Kororā are fully protected by the Wildlife Act, and harming or killing them is illegal. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
