Apple beats US appeal claiming it shortchanged customers on iCloud storage
In a 3-0 decision, the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco said reasonable consumers in the proposed class action would not have been misled by Apple's promises about storage capacity in its iCloud+ plans.
The plaintiff Lisa Bodenburg said she paid $2.99 a month for 200 GB of storage, believing Apple would add it to the 5 GB that all iCloud customers receive, and was shortchanged because Apple gave her only 200 GB of total storage, not 205 GB.
Circuit Judge Milan Smith, however said Bodenburg "received exactly what Apple promised her" when the Cupertino, California-based company offered "incremental" or "supplemental" storage, on top of the 5 GB she got for free.
He cited dismissals of other cases based on "unreasonable assumptions," including that Diet Dr. Pepper would aid in weight loss, and the net weight on a lip balm label failed to reveal that the dispenser's design left some balm inaccessible.
"Apple's statements are not false and deceptive merely because [they] may be unreasonably misunderstood by an insignificant and unrepresentative segment of consumers," Smith wrote.
Lawyers for Bodenburg did not immediately respond to requests for comment. The decision upheld a May 2024 dismissal by U.S. District Judge Trina Thompson in San Francisco.
The case is Bodenburg v Apple Inc, 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 24-3335.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
17 minutes ago
- BBC News
Trump raises Canada trade tariff to 35%
US President Donald Trump has raised the tariff on Canada to 35%, escalating a trade war with one of Washington's key economic decision, contained in an executive order, increases the rate from 25% and will come into effect at 00:01 US East Coast time (05:01 BST) on 1 said Canada had "failed to cooperate" in curbing the flow of fentanyl and other drugs across the US border, something Prime Minister Mark Carney insisted earlier this month his country was making "vital progress" president also announced sweeping tariffs on dozens of countries on Thursday, as he continued his drive to remake how global trade operates. As the clock ticked towards Trump's deadline to strike trade deals, he announced goods from Mexico would be charged at current rates for another 90 days, avoiding a threatened increase to 35%. However senior White House officials said their Canadian counterparts were less constructive in negotiations than Mexico, prompting the 35% tariff on that levy remained due to come into effect from midnight US East Coast time on Friday, countries affected by the so-called "reciprocal" tariffs would have seven days before they kick that are loaded onto ships by 7 August and those that are already in transit will also not be affected by the rates if they reach the US before 5 by the White House, the orders leave most goods coming into the US facing new taxes of between 10% and 50%.Few nations have been spared in the latest list of tariff rates. Even small economies like Vanuatu and Papua New Guinea in the Asia-Pacific region were issued 15% not mentioned on the list face baseline duties of 10%. Follow live coverage hereHow much cash is the US raising from tariffs? The tariffs, which are a tax on imports, hit Asian countries major trading partners in the region - India and Taiwan - were hit with levies of 25% and 20% President Lai Ching-te said the levy was only "temporary", vowing to complete talks with Washington for a land-locked South East Asian nation Laos is facing the second-highest rate in this round of tariffs. At 40% it sits just behind Syria's unenviable 41%.A day earlier, Trump reached a deal with South Korea, imposing a 15% tariff on its imports in return for investment in the US and other concessions. Economists and financial analysts have warned that the new levies will raise prices for businesses and consumers in the US and weigh on the economy, predictions that the Trump administration has House press secretary Karoline Leavitt told reporters on Thursday that Trump was "proving the so-called economic experts wrong at every turn"."What we are watching is President Trump rebuilding the greatest economy in the history of the world," she said. Follow BBC's coverage of US tariffs ANALYSIS: How much cash is the US raising from tariffs?EXPLAINER: What tariffs has Trump announced and why?CONSUMERS: Six things that will get more expensive for Americans The escalation of the tariffs had been telegraphed for months, starting when Trump unveiled sweeping "reciprocal" tariffs in April, saying they would rebalance global trade flows and reduce America's trade deficit - the gap between what it buys and sells abroad. The measures added to separate levies targeting key sectors such as steel, aluminium and cars. After turmoil in financial markets, he suspended some of the most punishing measures, inviting countries to negotiate, while leaving in place a 10% duty on most products. More than 200 countries reached out to the White House in the months following, according to Trump administration officials, though some struggled to get officials ultimately reached rough "framework" agreements with eight trade partners, including the UK, China, Japan and European Union, which set tariff rates in exchange for promises of investment in the US or other key aspects of those agreements remain unresolved. Talks with other countries, such as India ended without terms. Trump has said India will face a 25% levy on its goods, plus an unspecified "penalty" for its dealings with Russia. Up until nearly the last moment, many countries were still waiting word on what new tariff rates the administration had settled a post on social media, Swiss President Karin Keller-Sutter said she had a last-minute phone call with Trump, which ended without an accord. "The trade deficit remains a central concern of his," she wrote. Switzerland ended up with a 39% tariff.
Reuters
17 minutes ago
- Reuters
Flight attendants sue Boeing over MAX 9 panel blowout incident, paper says
July 31 (Reuters) - Four flight attendants on the Alaska Airlines (ALK.N), opens new tab 737 MAX 9 plane hit by a mid-air cabin panel blowout in January last year are suing Boeing (BA.N), opens new tab for physical and psychological injuries, the Seattle Times said on Thursday. In separate lawsuits seeking compensation for past and future economic damages, they cited physical and mental injuries, emotional distress and other financial costs related to the incident, the newspaper added. "Each of the four flight attendants acted courageously, following their training and putting their passengers' safety first while fearing for their lives," it cited lawyer Tracy Brammeier, who is representing them, as saying. "They deserve to be wholly compensated for this life-altering traumatic experience." The lawsuits, filed on Tuesday in Seattle's King County Superior Court, accused Boeing of product liability for delivering a plane that was unsafe to operate and for negligence in manufacturing practices, the paper said. Boeing declined to comment, while Alaska Airlines and Brammeier did not immediately respond to Reuters' request for comment. Last month, the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) said Boeing failed to provide adequate training, guidance and oversight to prevent the incident. The board criticized Boeing's safety culture and its failure to install four key bolts in a new Alaska Airlines MAX 9 during production, as well as ineffective oversight by the Federal Aviation Administration.
The Guardian
17 minutes ago
- The Guardian
The full list of Trump's tariffs – from India to Taiwan
US president Donald Trump has signed an executive order imposing reciprocal tariffs ranging from 10% to 41% on imports from dozens of countries and foreign locations, shortly after extending the deadline for a tariff deal with Mexico by another 90 days. The order listed higher import duty rates that would start in seven days for 69 trading partners as the 12:01 a.m. EDT (0401 GMT) deadline approached. Below is a list of the countries and the reciprocal tariffs they face, plus a searchable table: Afghanistan – 15% Algeria – 30% Angola – 15% Bangladesh – 20% Bolivia – 15% Bosnia and Herzegovina – 30% Botswana – 15% Brazil – 10% Brunei – 25% Cambodia – 19% Cameroon – 15% Chad – 15% Costa Rica – 15% Côte d`Ivoire – 15% Democratic Republic of the Congo – 15% Ecuador – 15% Equatorial Guinea – 15% European Union: Goods with Column 1 Duty Rate > 15%* – 0% European Union: Goods with Column 1 Duty Rate < 15%** – 15% Falkland Islands – 10% Fiji – 15% Ghana – 15% Guyana – 15% Iceland – 15% India – 25% Indonesia – 19% Iraq – 35% Israel – 15% Japan – 15% Jordan – 15% Kazakhstan – 25% Laos – 40% Lesotho – 15% Libya – 30% Liechtenstein – 15% Madagascar – 15% Malawi – 15% Malaysia – 19% Mauritius – 15% Moldova – 25% Mozambique – 15% Myanmar (Burma) – 40% Namibia – 15% Nauru – 15% New Zealand – 15% Nicaragua – 18% Nigeria – 15% North Macedonia – 15% Norway – 15% Pakistan – 19% Papua New Guinea – 15% Philippines – 19% Serbia – 35% South Africa – 30% South Korea – 15% Sri Lanka – 20% Switzerland – 39% Syria – 41% Taiwan – 20% Thailand – 19% Trinidad and Tobago – 15% Tunisia– 25% Turkey – 15% Uganda – 15% United Kingdom – 10% Vanuatu – 15% Venezuela – 15% Vietnam – 20% Zambia – 15% Zimbabwe – 15% * For purposes of this Executive Order and its Annexes, 'Column 1 Duty Rate' means the ad valorem (or ad valorem equivalent) rate of duty under column 1-General of the Harmonized Tariff Schedule of the United States (HTSUS). ** Minus Column 1 Duty Rate
