Bringing staff back to office more often will hurt productivity, union conference hears
The union's conference in Portlaoise instructed its leadership to resist any change to current
remote
and blended
working
policies across the public service which currently range from one day a week on-site to five depending on a person's role and place of employment.
Proposing the motion, Tom Morrin, who works at the
Department of Housing
and commutes from Portlaoise to the Custom House in Dublin, said staff there are required to come in three days a week and allowed to work from home the other two, a balance he believes works well.
'If you are commuting like me then you have to leave at a particular time to get the train, whereas if I'm at home I'm not in a rush to get the Luas to the train and I tend to work later.'
READ MORE
The roughly 90-minute trip to and from work significantly impacts his day both personally and professionally, he said.
'In the mornings I can generally drop my four-year-old to the creche so I get to do more bonding with my family then I'm going to get more work done, so it's good for me and for my employer.'
He said the staff in the department all come in on Thursdays in order to facilitate meetings and promote work interactions and socialising but after that they were free to choose the days on which they went to the office.
There is growing concern, however, that there will be moves to bring people in more, something he believes would have negative impacts not just in terms of productivity but also recruitment.
He pointed to a
University of Galway survey
which found 92 per cent of people would be influenced by blended working policies when choosing where to work as evidence of the potential to negatively impact the Civil Service's ability to attract and keep staff.
The AHCPS's deputy general secretary, Paul Malone, said there was already evidence that departments and public sector organisations that require more days in the office were finding it more difficult to recruit.
He said when it came to internal transfers, the figures showed it was 'a pivotal factor' in where people decided to go 'and that's likely also to be the case to in relation to external recruitment'.
The
Department of Social Protection
was repeatedly criticised by the union's officials for the way it handled a recent attempt to double the number of days some staff had to come into work.
Many of the department's staff working in public-facing roles are on-site full-time but about 850 are allowed come to the office just one day a week and it had been suggested this would be doubled to two.
AHCPS general secretary Ciaran Rohan said the issue was one of a number between unions and the department that would now be discussed at the
Workplace Relations Commission
.
He said it was open to any department or public-sector organisation to consider amending their current policies but that they needed to consult on any proposed changes and 'consultation does not mean sending a PDF five minutes before they announce the decision'.
'They've a lot of stuff coming up in relation to that and feel it can be best done when people are together. So they've made those arguments, and a couple of others will probably talk to us but others have done reviews and decided to leave things as they are. We were in last week with the
CSO
where they have three days at home and two in the office and they are going to keep that.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
State's population grew by almost 90,000 last year, EU figures show
The State's population grew by almost 90,000 last year, according to figures produced by the European Union . The population of the Republic stood at 5,439,898 at the end of last year compared with 5,351,681 at the end of 2023. In the 27 EU countries, Ireland's annual population growth, at 1.64 per cent, is surpassed only by Malta and is about seven times higher than the EU average of 0.23 per cent. Eurostat figures show Ireland reached a population of five million in 2020. With current projections, it is likely to reach 5.5 million by the end of this year. READ MORE These figures are different from the estimates produced by the Central Statistics Office (CSO). The Irish office's estimates run from April to April, and the figures for April 2024 to April 2025 have yet to be produced. All indicators suggest the population is growing rapidly since the end of the Covid-19 pandemic, buoyed by a strong labour market with a record 2.8 million people at work. [ 'We can't have nice things in Ireland because no one follows the rules': Emigrants on returning home Opens in new window ] The population increase is largely driven by inward migration. The last figures from the CSO show net migration (immigration minus emigration) to Ireland between April 2023 and April 2024 was 79,300. The natural increase in the population (births minus deaths) was 19,400, making for a total increase in the population of 98,700. Recently, Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe was asked about a column in The Irish Times by David McWilliams suggesting inward migration would have to decrease to allow the housing supply to catch up with population growth. [ David McWilliams: This is what we need to do in Ireland if we want stable, affordable house prices Opens in new window ] [ David McWilliams: Ireland needs immigrants. But our economy can't accommodate an infinite number Opens in new window ] Mr Donohoe responded by saying the expanded labour force is generating tax revenues that can be invested into infrastructure. He said investment in infrastructure will help the State cope with inward migration. 'A growing population with growing investment is how we will support our economy in the years ahead,' he said. A Department of Finance report entitled Economic Insights published this month says labour shortages in the Irish economy cannot be tackled without inward migration. It states that unemployment is at a historic low. While 780,000 people between the ages of 15 and 64 (working age) are not in employment, the potential for many of them to take up work is 'limited', the Department of Finance has concluded. Many have not worked for years because of health issues, while others do not have the necessary skills to fulfil labour shortages in the economy. Unemployment in the construction sector declined to a record low last year, the report added, 'which underscores the importance of either attracting skilled labour from abroad or increasing the pipeline of apprentices or graduates in the sector'. The report predicted labour force growth is unlikely to be sustained because of an increasingly ageing population and an expected slowdown in net migration. 'As a result, it will become increasingly important to maximise the labour force contributions of our existing working age population as well as productivity improvements.' It concluded: 'It underscores the role that both inward migration and productivity improvements will need to play to support employment and economic growth going forward.'
Irish Times
8 hours ago
- Irish Times
Presidential election: Heather Humphreys giving ‘very serious' thought to running for Fine Gael
Fine Gael's executive council is to meet on Monday evening to consider the presidential election campaign as support grows inside and outside of the party for Heather Humphreys to run. The former minister has yet to decide if she will seek the party's nomination to contest the election, but has said she is giving the matter 'very serious consideration'. She had ruled out the possibility in May. Ms Humphreys, who did not contest last year's general election, has emerged as the favourite to replace former MEP Mairead McGuinness , who on Thursday announced she was stepping down as the Fine Gael candidate on health grounds. The party's executive council had been expected to meet on Sunday to consider its options, but a spokeswoman confirmed the meeting would instead take place on Monday evening. READ MORE 'To tell you the truth, I'm giving a run very serious consideration. I'm using my time to speak to the people I trust and the people who know me best, both inside and outside politics, before I make a final decision,' she said in a statement to the Sunday Independent. A number of Independent politicians have come out in support of Ms Humphreys running to succeed Michael D Higgins . Ministers of State Michael Healy-Rae , Noel Grealish and Seán Canney have said they would support her candidacy, noting her 'broad' appeal and ability to 'bring a lot of people together'. Ms Humphreys is also understood to be the preferred candidate for a number of senior Fine Gael ministers. In order to be nominated, Ms Humphreys would need the support of at least 20 members of the parliamentary party, 25 councillors and five members of the executive council. It is understood she would easily secure the necessary backing. Fine Gael MEP Seán Kelly , a former GAA president, on Saturday said he was weighing up his options about seeking the party's nomination after this week's news about Ms McGuinness. He said last month that he would not run, describing it as the 'most difficult decision' of his political life, but on Saturday told Newstalk 'the goalposts have changed'. Mr Kelly said the discussion within Fine Gael on who it would now run as its candidate 'hasn't started really' out of respect for Ms McGuinness. 'I think next week will be time enough to reflect properly on that and take action, there's no rush,' he added. Frances Fitzgerald , a former MEP and minister for justice, on Friday said she did not intend to contest the election. Independent Galway West TD Catherine Connolly is currently the only candidate who has the required support to appear on the ballot paper.
Irish Times
13 hours ago
- Irish Times
Export figures are hard to interpret right now, given flux around tariffs
It's hard to know where the State's trade with the US will land once the tariff impact has been digested. There's a lag effect to these levies combined with an uncertainty as to who will ultimately bear the cost. Trump and his Maga operatives are acting as if the burden falls totally outside the US and are boasting about the billions of dollars the US exchequer is likely to garner. But precedent suggests the tariff hit tends to fall on importing firms and ultimately domestic consumers. That's why everyone is looking at the US economy for signs of a slowdown. In the interim, we've got volatile trade numbers. The latest figures from the Central Statistics Office (CSO) show the value of exports from Ireland to the US fell by whopping 60 per cent between May and June, dropping from €10.8 billion to €4.4 billion. READ MORE The headline June figure was also down by a quarter on the same month last year. Most of this merely reflects a levelling of the surge seen in the earlier part of the year when firms rushed to stockpile goods in the US in advance of Trump's Liberation Day tariff announcement on April 2nd. The trade will presumably find its level once all this settles down. The European Union and the Government will be hoping for a manageable decline. From Ireland's perspective, the 15 per cent tariff on pharma , the main element of the State's export trade with the US, represents damage but controlled damage in the context of the US's retreat from free trade. Pharma firms here make big profits, big enough to absorb the hit without uprooting themselves. These companies work around 10-year cycles of investment and are therefore unlikely to jump ship on the whim of one of Trump's policy announcements. The biggest buyer of pharma is state healthcare and therefore much of the trade is inelastic, less sensitive to price changes. That's probably why Trump, in parallel to tariffs, is demanding these firms reduce their prices in the US. His threat to hike tariffs on EU pharma imports up to 250 per cent within a few years flies in the face of the EU-US trade deal and any notion of certainty it might signify. But that's the world we're in at the moment and why the CSO and other data points are so volatile.
