Senate impeachment court 'duty-bound' to respect SC ruling on VP Sara's case
In a statement, Senate impeachment court spokesperson Atty. Regie Tongol said the SC decision affirms the impeachment court's stance that 'constitutional issues surrounding the Articles required clarity before trial proceedings could commence.'
'The Senate, sitting as an Impeachment Court, has always acted in deference to the Constitution and the rule of law. As a co-equal branch of government, we are duty-bound to respect the finality of rulings issued by the High Court,' Tongol said.
'The Court's ruling validates the prudence and restraint exercised by the Senate majority in recognizing those legal uncertainties from the outset,' he added.
The SC has unanimously declared the Articles of Impeachment against Duterte as unconstitutional, saying that it is barred by the one-year rule under Article XI Section 3 paragraph 5 of the Constitution, and for violating the right to due process.
The High Court also pointed out that the Senate cannot acquire jurisdiction over the impeachment proceedings.
"However, the Court said it is not absolving Vice President Duterte from any of the charges against her. But any subsequent impeachment complaint may only be filed starting February 6, 2026," SC spokesperson Atty. Camille Ting said Friday.
For the Senate impeachment court's part, Tongol said that it is awaiting for the formal transmittal of the SC decision 'and any related guidance that may affect the Impeachment Court's jurisdiction moving forward.'
'The Senate remains committed to upholding constitutional order, ensuring due process, and protecting the integrity of our democratic institutions,' he emphasized.
The high court's ruling is in relation to the consolidated petition filed by Duterte, lawyer Israelito Torreon, and others seeking to declare the Articles of Impeachment against her as null and void.
To recall, three impeachment complaints were filed against Duterte in December 2024, all of which were connected with the alleged misuse of confidential funds.
It was the fourth impeachment complaint that was endorsed by over one-third of lawmakers from the House of Representatives, and was later on transmitted to the Senate.
The Vice President was accused of betrayal of public trust, culpable violation of the constitution, graft and corruption, and other high crimes.
Duterte had entered a 'not guilty' plea in the verified impeachment complaint filed against her, which she called merely a 'scrap of paper.' — RSJ, GMA Integrated News
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
GMA Network
4 hours ago
- GMA Network
VP Sara's counsel defends SC ruling on impeachment
Vice President Sara Duterte's legal counsel has defended the decision of the Supreme Court to dismiss the 'unconstitutional' Articles of Impeachment against her. The statement came amid rebuttals from the House of Representatives and the possible filing of motion for reconsideration. 'Hiwalay naman ang mga committee hearings. If I'm not mistaken, sa aking interpretation, and tinatalakay ng Supreme Court doon ay 'yung due process mismo doon sa pag-initiate ng impeachment proceedings, which includes 'yung pagbibigay sa kaniya ng kaukulang pagkakataon upang sumagot doon sa draft articles of impeachment or draft impeachment complaint,' Atty. Michael Poa said in an Unang Balita report by Jonathan Andal on Monday. (The committee hearings are separate. If I'm not mistaken with my interpretation, the Supreme Court tackled the due process on initiating the impeachment proceedings, which includes providing her with enough opportunities to answer the draft articles of impeachment or draft impeachment complaint.) Poa also shared that their legal team is prepared for the impeachment trial, and will be waiting for what will happen at the impeachment court. Earlier, House of Representatives spokesperson Atty. Priscilla Marie 'Princess' Abante said that the bases for the dismissal of Duterte's impeachment were 'alarming.' 'Ang Kamara, matapos ang masusing pag-aaral, ay maghahain ng motion for reconsideration dahil ang desisyon na nagsasabing ang Articles of Impeachment na ipinadala sa Senado ay barred or unconstitutional ay nakaangkla sa mga factual premises o findings na mali at salungat sa opisyal na record ng Kamara,' she said. (The House, after a thorough study, will file a motion for reconsideration because the decision declaring that the Articles of Impeachment transmitted to the Senate are barred or unconstitutional is based on factual premises or findings that are incorrect and contrary to the official records of the House.) Abante noted that the decision made by the Supreme Court had incorrectly interpreted the timeline of the Congress' movements, and based it on news articles instead of the official House Journal. She also added that there were no clauses in the Constitution that states that Duterte must be informed regarding her impeachment, especially considering that it was signed by no less than 1/3 of the Congress. 'Nagbigay ang korte ng panibagong patakaran na wala naman sa umiiral na batas. Pinawalang bisa nila ang Articles of Impeachment base sa mga bagong pamantayan ng due process para sa respondent. Kung due process at opportunity to be heard ang usapan, ilang beses nang naimbitahan si Vice President Sara Duterte sa mga pagdinig ng committee. Nanatili siyang tikom ang bibig,' Abante said. (The court provided new rules that were not included in the existing law. They have dismissed the Articles of Impeachment based on a new due process for the respondent. If we are talking about due process and opportunity to be heard, Vice President Sara Duterte had been invited in committee hearings several times. She remained quiet.) As of Monday, the Congress yet to provide a specific date for the filing of motion for reconsideration. —Jiselle Anne Casucian/AOL, GMA Integrated News
GMA Network
4 hours ago
- GMA Network
Marcos' take on VP Sara impeachment a key topic in SONA 2025 — UP NCPAG dean
President Ferdinand "Bongbong" Marcos Jr.'s pronouncements regarding the Supreme Court (SC) decision on the impeachment of Vice President Sara Duterte may have profound implications on Congress' next moves, a public administration expert on Monday said about the Chief Executive's fourth State of the Nation Address (SONA). Professor Kristoffer Berse, dean of the University of the Philippines National College of Public Administration and Governance (UP NCPAG), said lawmakers from both chambers of Congress may take cue from what Marcos will say about the high court's ruling during his SONA speech. "Bagamat may independence naman ang tatlong branches natin—judiciary, legislature, executive—magandang mabanggit na rin, tingin ko, ng Pangulo para maibahagi rin at malaman ng tao kung ano ang saloobin niya dito sa usapin ng impeachment," Berse said. (Although our three branches of government—the judiciary, legislature, executive—all have independence, it would be good to let the people know what the President himself thinks about the impeachment issue.) He added, "Nakapagsalita na ang judiciary, SC. Magandang malaman kung siya mismo bilang Pangulo ano ba ang tingin niya lalo ngayon na mayroon ng decision mula sa Korte Supreme. Maaaring 'yan din ang magbigay ng direction para sa members ng Senado at Kongreso," he added. (The judiciary, through the SC, has spoken. It would be good to know how he views the matter, especially now that the Supreme Court has come up with a decision. That may give direction to the members of the Senate and Congress.) Legacy phase Berse said the President should include the government's gains, achievements, and plans for the last three years of his administration for his annual report this year. "Dapat maisama ang achievements ng administration in the past years. Mga tangible gains... Pero higit du'n, maganda rin na mai-report ang mga naging resulta," Berse said. (He should include the achievements of his administration in the past years, tangible gains... but more than that, it would be good to report the results of these projects.) "Magandang marinig natin mula sa Presidente ano ang mga balak niya for the last three years. Pumapasok na kasi tayo sa tinatawag na legacy phase. Kung ano ang gusto niyang maiwan na legasiya sa kaniyang administration sa mga susunod na taon," he added. (It will also be good to hear his plans for the last three years. We are entering what is called the legacy phase: what he wants to leave as the legacy of his administration.) Marcos Jr. will deliver his fourth SONA at the Batasang Pambansa Complex in Quezon City. "Mahalaga ito dahil ito ang annual submission ng report ng Presidente. Dito natin maririnig ang mga ginawa, ginagawa, at gagawin pa sa mga susunod na taon. Maganda malaman para makita natin kung nagkaroon tayo ng magandang decision sa pagpili sa namumuno sa bayan," said Bersa. (The SONA is important because it is the annual submission report of the President. We will be able to hear what was done, what are being done, and what will be done in the coming years. It is important so that we see if Filipinos came up with a good decision in choosing the country's leaders.) — VDV, GMA Integrated News NCPAG
GMA Network
4 hours ago
- GMA Network
Heart Evangelista, Chiz Escudero, children arrive at Batasang Pambansa
Heart Evangelista, Chiz Escudero, and the Senate President's children Chesi and Quino have arrived at the Batasang Pambansa for President Ferdinand "Bongbong" Marcos' fourth State of the Nation Address (SONA). Heart donned a white Filipiniana with folded details and carried a gold clutch. Meanwhile, Chiz and Quino were in classic Barong Tagalog and black trousers, whereas Chesi was in a pink Filipiniana. Prior to arriving at Batasang Pambansa, Heart attended the Opening of the 20th Congress at the Senate of the Philippines in a Michael Leyva modernized barong top and woven Filipiniana skirt. President Marcos is set to give updates about the state of the Philippines in his fourth SONA happening this afternoon. There are no staged ceremonies or photo setups in the red carpet area amid the weather systems affecting the country. —Nika Roque/Jade Veronique Yap/MGP, GMA Integrated News
