
How relegated clubs bouncing back to the Premier League makes the rich richer
For the second year running, all three clubs promoted from the Championship to the Premier League will make an immediate return to the second tier. It would be tempting to say this is the natural order of things given the financial challenges faced by clubs suddenly thrown into the world's richest domestic football competition.
Even when they do spend huge amounts in order to give themselves a chance of survival, as Southampton and Ipswich did, respectively spending £62.8m and £106m net in the summer of 2024, the gap appears too big to close. Yet what has happened to them used to be an exceptional occurrence.
Only once before this season and last had all three promoted clubs immediately returned whence they came, in 1997-98. It was more common for them to remain in the top division together, which has happened four times since 2002, last and most remarkably in 2021-22 when Fulham, Bournemouth and Nottingham Forest not only survived but prospered and grew into contenders for a place in European competitions. This, however, looks like an aberration.
The parachute payments system introduced in its current form in 2015-16 by the Premier League, the only major league in the world to have adopted such an arrangement, was not just meant to cushion the fall of relegated clubs but enable them to hang on to the core of their squad. And in that regard, it did what it was supposed to do, at least for some.
Newcastle rejoined the elite at once in 2017-18 after receiving a first payment of £40.9m, one of several example of how the scheme could benefit clubs who knew how best to make use of these extra resources. Aston Villa, Norwich, West Brom, Bournemouth and Sheffield United were others, all in the past seven years.
While not hostile to the principles of the system, the Football League has been unstinting in its criticism of the Premier League's version of it, arguing that the sums involved and the way they are split distort competitiveness in the Championship. But the EFL's efforts to have this system modified, or even scrapped, have been fruitless.
Its hope that the new football regulator would intervene in the debate were also dashed when the sport minister, Stephanie Peacock, said in October that the government 'absolutely [doesn't] want [parachute payments] to be abolished'. It is understood that the system would be reviewed only if the regulator could establish a 'direct causal link' between those payments and the risk of clubs facing insolvency. In other words, the arrangement is here to stay.
Not everyone will be disappointed by this. Burnley, say, have done well out of the system, to the extent that it is now part of the economic model of the Lancashire club, one of the most profitable of the Premier League era. The Clarets have been relegated or promoted in seven of the past 12 seasons, picking up tens of millions in parachute payments each time they dropped to the Championship, sharing in the riches of the top tier while they were there, spending well within their means.
As a result, they posted a cumulated profit of £111m in the past six years they played in the first tier – their accounts for the 2023-24 season are yet to be published – while minimising losses when they were in the second, with the sole exception of the 2022-23 season, which saw them promoted again. If you know how to play the system and are not obsessing about punching above your weight, it can work for you.
Yet this is only part of the story. There is a little-known provision in the regulations which directly benefits elite clubs when beneficiaries immediately go up from the Championship. Parachute payments, which constitute more than half of the £1.6bn over three years which the Premier League devotes to 'solidarity payments' to English football, are not awarded as a lump sum but over three seasons.
Relegated clubs receive 55% of the allocated money in the year after their demotion, then the rest over the two seasons after that. The catch is that should the club be promoted in the interim, it will cease to receive those payments.
Sign up to Football Daily
Kick off your evenings with the Guardian's take on the world of football
after newsletter promotion
The money 'saved' that way, the amount of which is calculated as a proportion of the broadcasting rights shared on an equal basis by all 20 Premier League clubs, is not channelled back into the budget set aside for solidarity payments and distributed to less privileged clubs through a separate scheme.
Instead it goes back into the pot which Premier League clubs share between themselves. So it is in the interest of elite clubs that those relegated bounce back as quickly as possible and rejoin the top tier within three years.
This is not to say that the system was devised to produce such a result but rather that the cycle self-perpetuates through a mechanism which was meant to level the field but does not do anything of the sort, and has ended up being yet another rampart built around the closed circle of the Premier League.
Do you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article? If you would like to submit a response of up to 300 words by email to be considered for publication in our letters section, please click here.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Scottish Sun
30 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
Arsenal star David Raya dresses as an air stewardess and serves passengers in hilarious pics from Las Vegas stag do
Arsenal ace David Raya was joined by other footballers UP IN THE AIR UP IN THE AIR Arsenal star David Raya dresses as an air stewardess and serves passengers in hilarious pics from Las Vegas stag do ARSENAL ace David Raya jetted off to Las Vegas for his stag do with close friends. Raya, 29, helped the Gunners finish second in the Premier League with some solid performances between the sticks that also contributed to his team's run to the Champions League semi-finals. Advertisement 8 Arsenal ace David Raya flew to Las Vegas for his stag do 8 Raya was joined by his brother, a comedian and some LaLiga footballers 8 Raya dressed as an air stewardess and served cookies to fellow passengers 8 Raya shared a series of snaps from his trip to Las Vegas ARSENAL TRANSFER NEWS LIVE: All the latest rumours from the Emirates But now the goalkeeper is gearing up for his wedding with model fiancee Tatiana Trouboul. The Spain international proposed to Tatiana in October of last year and they are now set to marry. And the Spain international has kicked off the wedding preparations with a bachelor party in Sin City. Advertisement Raya was joined by his brother Oscar as well as Spanish comedian Tomas Garcia Serrano. A number of footballers also linked up with them including Getafe's Diego Rico Salguero as well as Rayo Vallecano's Adri Embarba and Unai Lopez. All of them took to the streets of Vegas wearing Arsenal gear and taking group photos. But before making it to the US, Raya was pictured dressed as an air stewardess during the flight. Advertisement The keeper appeared to be serving other passengers cookies on board the aircraft. CASINO SPECIAL - BEST CASINO BONUSES FROM £10 DEPOSITS Join SUN CLUB for the Arsenal Files every Friday plus in-depth coverage and exclusives from The Emirates Tatiana and Raya have been together since 2021 but left it until June 2022 to go public with their relationship. Advertisement The model heralds from Barcelona but has since moved her life to London to be alongside Raya. Arsenal star David Raya cosies up to model fiancee on yacht as she leaves little to imagination in see-through tights She previously divided her time between the capital and Spain. 8 Raya is engaged to model fiancee Tatiana Trouboul Credit: Instagram @ 8 Raya and Tatiana have been together since June 2021 Credit: Instagram @ @ Advertisement 8 Raya proposed to Tatiana last year Credit: X formerly Twitter / @DavidRaya_22 / Instagram / @


Scottish Sun
an hour ago
- Scottish Sun
Jadon Sancho at centre of three-way Premier League transfer battle with Man Utd misfit not part of Ruben Amorim's plans
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) THREE Premier League clubs are battling to sign Jadon Sancho, SunSport can reveal. The former Borussia Dortmund winger is back at Manchester United after Chelsea rejected the chance to make his move permanent. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 4 Chelsea have turned down the chance to sign Jadon Sancho Credit: Alamy 4 He did score in the Conference League final Credit: Reuters Manager Ruben Amorim has no plans to integrate Sancho back into his first team - meaning the 25-year-old is searching for a fresh start. And SunSport understands Aston Villa, Tottenham and Newcastle are all monitoring developments. Villa are thought to be keen on a loan deal for the player, but United would prefer cash to free up funds for a rebuild. Newcastle and Tottenham both see Sancho as a strong option as they look to build squads that can compete in the League and the Champions League. READ MORE ON FOOTBALL FROZEN OUT Island nation 9 times larger than UK banned from World Cup as statement released Borussia Dortmund were also tracking Sancho, but they've now opted for Jobe Bellingham. Despite netting in the 4-1 Europa Conference League final win over Real Betis, Sancho couldn't seal a £25million switch to Chelsea. Chelsea had initially loaned Sancho from United and had agreed to buy him for £25million, unless they dropped below 14th or coughed up a £5m penalty clause. JOIN SUN VEGAS: GET £50 BONUS After the Blues finished fourth and lifted the Conference League trophy, they opted to pay the £5m penalty. Now, Chelsea's eyes are set on a range of wingers, including Jamie Byroe-Gittens and Nico Williams of Borussia Dortmund and Athletic Bilbao, respectively. Jadon Sancho shares his Chelsea highlights reel as he says goodbye to fans ahead of Man Utd return 4 They are still linked with Sancho's team-mate Alejandro Garnacho, who looks to have been banished to the wilderness by Ruben Amorim in a similar fallout to the one Sancho had with Erik ten Hag. United have set a staggering £70m asking price on the Argentine winger. Garnacho is viewed as one of United's sellable assets this summer as he is considered homegrown, although he does have three years remaining on his contract. Chelsea today confirmed Sancho's return to Man Utd in a 92-word statement on the club website. It said: "Sancho, 25, joined on a season-long loan on August 31 2024 and went on to make a total of 41 appearances for the club. "The winger registered five goals during his time at Stamford Bridge, with his final strike coming in the Blues' UEFA Conference League Final victory against Real Betis on May 28. "Everyone at Chelsea would like to thank Jadon for his efforts and we wish him every success for the future."


The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
Jadon Sancho at centre of three-way Premier League transfer battle with Man Utd misfit not part of Ruben Amorim's plans
THREE Premier League clubs are battling to sign Jadon Sancho, SunSport can reveal. The former Borussia Dortmund winger is back at Manchester United after Chelsea rejected the chance to make his move permanent. 4 4 Manager Ruben Amorim has no plans to integrate Sancho back into his first team - meaning the 25-year-old is searching for a fresh start. And SunSport understands Aston Villa, Tottenham and Newcastle are all monitoring developments. Villa are thought to be keen on a loan deal for the player, but United would prefer cash to free up funds for a rebuild. Newcastle and Tottenham both see Sancho as a strong option as they look to build squads that can compete in the League and the Champions League. Borussia Dortmund were also tracking Sancho, but they've now opted for Jobe Bellingham. Despite netting in the 4-1 Europa Conference League final win over Real Betis, Sancho couldn't seal a £25million switch to Chelsea. Chelsea had initially loaned Sancho from United and had agreed to buy him for £25million, unless they dropped below 14th or coughed up a £5m penalty clause. Now, Chelsea's eyes are set on a range of wingers, including Jamie Byroe-Gittens and Nico Williams of Borussia Dortmund and Athletic Bilbao, respectively. Jadon Sancho shares his Chelsea highlights reel as he says goodbye to fans ahead of Man Utd return 4 They are still linked with Sancho's team-mate Alejandro Garnacho, who looks to have been banished to the wilderness by Ruben Amorim in a similar fallout to the one Sancho had with Erik ten Hag. United have set a staggering £70m asking price on the Argentine winger. Garnacho is viewed as one of United's sellable assets this summer as he is considered homegrown, although he does have three years remaining on his contract. Chelsea today confirmed Sancho's return to Man Utd in a 92-word statement on the club website. It said: "Sancho, 25, joined on a season-long loan on August 31 2024 and went on to make a total of 41 appearances for the club. "The winger registered five goals during his time at Stamford Bridge, with his final strike coming in the Blues' UEFA Conference League Final victory against Real Betis on May 28. "Everyone at Chelsea would like to thank Jadon for his efforts and we wish him every success for the future." 4