Lions memories: So, who the hell were the 'Geography 6'?
Following the failed Graham Henry experiment in 2001, there was not much enthusiasm for another overseas Lions coach as the emphasis went back to culture.
But then the calamity that was 2005 happened, and all bets were off once again. And, as it turned out, Henry's fellow Kiwi Warren Gatland ended up with a distinguished Lions record after being involved with four consecutive tours.
Having impressed as an assistant on the 2009 tour, Gatland got the lead role in 2013 and oversaw a series win in Australia. Lions head coach Warren Gatland in 2017. Pic:He then got the gig again four years later for the daunting trip to New Zealand in 2017 to take on the back-to-back world champions and, despite intense pressure from the local media, managed to draw the series when the Lions had been widely written off.
An impressive result by any standards, but there was one aspect of Gatland's management of that 2017 expedition which brought a lot of criticism — his selection of what became known as the 'Geography Six'.
This was a decision straight from Clive Woodward's pragmatic, culture-banishing playbook from 2005, with Gatland looking for the best way to protect his Test starters towards the end of the arduous tour. Finn Russell with the Lions in 2017. Pic: INPHO/Dan Sheridan
His solution was to call up six players from the Scotland and Wales tours to Australia and the Pacific Islands, respectively, so that members of his Test squad would not be required for bench duties in midweek games.
This flew in the face of more than 100 years of Lions tradition, where call-ups to tours had always been exclusively due to injury and withdrawal.
The six players involved were the Scots Alan Dell and Finn Russell, along with Cory Hill, Kristian Dacey, Tomas Francis and Gareth Davies from Wales.
This selection decision was based primarily on proximity and it attracted outrage from Lions traditionalists, among the media, supporters and former players. The general consensus was that the history and culture of the institution was being diminished by Gatland in the interests of expediency. Tomas Francis, Kristian Dacey, Liam Williams, Gareth Davies and Cory Hill look on as the Lions took on New Zealand Maori in 2017. Pic: Huw Evans/REX/Shutterstock
The criticism of Lions icon Ian McGeechan – Gatland's head coach on the 2009 tour – was especially damaging.
'It's that geography part – where you are shouldn't determine that you're in a Lions jersey,' said McGeechan, while former Ireland and Lions flanker Stephen Ferris said Gatland was 'devaluing the badge'.
Gatland admitted afterwards that the criticism got to him and the 'Geography Six' were used sparingly, in the clash against the Hurricanes, all six were named on the bench but only one – Russell – was used.The Lions led 31-17 but ran out of gas and ended up drawing the game.
The whole episode was an unfulfilling experience for everyone concerned and while it could not be directly linked to the Lions failing to win the series, it definitely contributed to Gatland failing to emulate the same levels of popularity enjoyed by McGeechan — adding another layer of ire for his detractors on the back of his controversial call to axe Brian O'Driscoll in 2013.
Gatland was retained for the Covid-dominated tour to South Africa in 2021, but that was a slog from beginning to end for all involved — including the fans shut out of the stadiums and forced to watch on TV — and felt like a tour too far for the New Zealander.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
an hour ago
- Irish Examiner
Felipe Contepomi: Sam Prendergast 'probably unlucky' to miss out on Lions selection
Felipe Contepomi has expressed his delight at Johnny Sexton's decision to throw himself into coaching with the British and Irish Lions and Ireland, and predicted that Sam Prendergast may yet feature on Andy Farrell's touring roster in Australia. In Dublin as head coach of an Argentina side that will face the Lions at the Aviva Stadium on Friday evening, Contepomi goes back a long way with Sexton who was an up-and-coming out-half at Leinster when the South American was the province's talismanic No.10. It was an injury to Contepomi in the Heineken Cup semi-final defeat of Munster at Croke Park in 2009 that really opened the door for Sexton who shone at GAA HQ and again when Leinster won their first star against Leicester Tigers in the final. The pair have also worked together more recently, when Contepomi spent four years as backs coach with his old provincial team towards the back end of Sexton's playing career. And now they are masterminds in opposing camps. 'I don't know if surprised, I'm delighted,' said the Argentinian about Sexton's decision to quit a full-time corporate role and give his all to a coaching gig that he had already dipped into with the national team on a part-time basis. 'I think he needs to go into rugby. He has a good rugby brain, very good rugby brain and I'm sure that he will have very good mentors there, you know. He knows [Andy] Farrell, he knows a lot of the staff, and I'm sure that he will get the most out of that experience.' As for Prendergast, Contepomi's successor in the famous No.10 jersey was walking in to the province's academy just as he was exiting the building to take on the role of an assistant coach with his native country. That was in 2022. Prendergast, still only 22, will be joining Jack Crowley on the Ireland squad that is due to play Georgia and Portugal next month on the back of a breakthrough year with club and country that was not without its difficult moments. 'Sam was lurking around in in the academy before I left. I could see his talent coming through, I didn't have to be a rugby brain to detect that he was a talented player. He is very talented, he's very good and it's probably debatable and probably unlucky to have to missed out the Lions. 'But he's a very young player and he will have a lot of opportunities. You never know what happens. The Lions, from what I recall, they never finished with the same [number of players] whatever, say, 40 something players they have. 'They never finished the tour with the same [number] who started. So, you need to be ready and, I'm sure he's on the fringe of that. So, I don't know, I'm just assuming, right? I don't have inside information.' Contepomi is working with a squad that is missing a dozen men still involved in the Top 14 playoffs, including the likes of Santiago Chocobares and Juan Cruz Mallia of Toulouse and Guido Petti from European champions Bordeaux-Begles. Centre Justo Piccardo will make his debut and there are three potential debutants off the bench for Argentina who have eleven uncapped players in all in their squad, eight of them from the fledgling Super Rugby Americas scene. ARGENTINA: S Carreras; R Isgró, L Cinti, J Piccardo, I Mendy; T Albornoz, G García; M Vivas, J Montoya (capt), J Sclavi; F Molina, P Rubiolo; P Matera, JM Gonzalez, J Oviedo. Replacements: B Bernasconi, B Wenger, F Coria Marchetti, S Grondona, J Moro, S Benitez Cruz, M Moroni, S Cordero.
The Irish Sun
2 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Disgraced horse trainer known as ‘Juice Man' set for release from prison after ‘extreme' doping scandal and £19m fine
A DISGRACED horse trainer known as 'Juice Man' is set to be released from prison - after his role in an 'extreme' doping scandal that shamed the sport. Jorge Navarro, 50, was ordered to pay a £19million fine when he was sentenced to Advertisement 2 Disgraced horse trainer Jorge Navarro had his own 'Juice Man' shoes - a dark reference to his prolific doping of racehorses 2 Jorge Navarro is set to be released from prison after admitting his role in one of racing's biggest ever doping scandals Credit: Rex The leading US trainer, who had more than 1,000 winners and bagged huge races including the Golden Shaheen in Dubai, was described as a 'reckless fraudster' and, amid tears, pleaded guilty to doping horses in a Manhattan courtroom. He said at the time: "I was hungry to be a winner and somewhere along the line the pressure got to me. "I thought I had to win to be respected in the racing industry. "I became a selfish person who only cared about winning and I lost my way. Advertisement "I take responsibility for all that I have done and apologise to the people that I have hurt." A post from respected journalist Ray Paulick showed Navarro was due for release from a Miami prison on Tuesday, June 18. US District Judge Mary Kay Vyskocil handed down Navarro's sentence four-and-a-half years ago and, in summing up, described the scale of his cheating. She said: "For years, Mr Navarro, you effectively stole millions, cheating other trainers, owners and jockeys you competed against. Advertisement Most read in Horse Racing "You also demonstrated a collective, callous disregard for the wellbeing of the horses. "The bottom line is you likely killed or endangered the horses in your care. "The reality is someone who loves horses does not subject them to such cruel and dangerous treatment." While US Attorney Damian Williams said: "Jorge Navarro's case reflects failings, greed, and corruption at virtually every level of the world of professional horse racing. Advertisement "For money and fame, corrupt trainers went to increasing extremes to dope horses under their care. "Unscrupulous owners, who stood to profit directly, encouraged and pressured trainers to win at any cost. "Veterinarians sworn to the care and protection of their patients routinely violated their oaths in service of corrupt trainers and to line their own pockets. "Assistants and grooms all witnessed animal abuse in the service of greed, but did little to stop such conduct, and engaged in myriad ways to support notoriously corrupt trainers. Advertisement "Structures designed for the protection of the horses abused in this case failed repeatedly; fixtures of the industry – owners, veterinarians, and trainers – flouted rules and disregarded their animals' health while hypocritically incanting a love for the horses under their control and ostensible protection. "Standing as the keystone for this structure of abuse, corruption, and duplicity was Jorge Navarro, a trainer who treated his animals as expendable commodities in the service of his 'sport.' "This sentence appropriately condemns the danger inherent in Navarro's crime and reflects the seriousness with which this Office takes the kind of abuse that Navarro practiced." Navarro's most famous horse was 2019 Shaheen winner X Y Jet, who he regularly drugged with a substance he called 'monkey'. Advertisement The grey sprinter died from an apparent heart attack in January 2020. FREE BETS - GET THE BEST SIGN UP DEALS AND RACING OFFERS Commercial content notice: Taking one of the offers featured in this article may result in a payment to The Sun. You should be aware brands pay fees to appear in the highest placements on the page. 18+. T&Cs apply. . Remember to gamble responsibly A responsible gambler is someone who: Read more on the Irish Sun Establishes time and monetary limits before playing Only gambles with money they can afford to lose Never chases their losses Doesn't gamble if they're upset, angry or depressed Gamcare – Gamble Aware – Find our detailed guide on responsible gambling practices here.
Extra.ie
4 hours ago
- Extra.ie
Lions memories: So, who the hell were the 'Geography 6'?
Following the failed Graham Henry experiment in 2001, there was not much enthusiasm for another overseas Lions coach as the emphasis went back to culture. But then the calamity that was 2005 happened, and all bets were off once again. And, as it turned out, Henry's fellow Kiwi Warren Gatland ended up with a distinguished Lions record after being involved with four consecutive tours. Having impressed as an assistant on the 2009 tour, Gatland got the lead role in 2013 and oversaw a series win in Australia. Lions head coach Warren Gatland in 2017. Pic:He then got the gig again four years later for the daunting trip to New Zealand in 2017 to take on the back-to-back world champions and, despite intense pressure from the local media, managed to draw the series when the Lions had been widely written off. An impressive result by any standards, but there was one aspect of Gatland's management of that 2017 expedition which brought a lot of criticism — his selection of what became known as the 'Geography Six'. This was a decision straight from Clive Woodward's pragmatic, culture-banishing playbook from 2005, with Gatland looking for the best way to protect his Test starters towards the end of the arduous tour. Finn Russell with the Lions in 2017. Pic: INPHO/Dan Sheridan His solution was to call up six players from the Scotland and Wales tours to Australia and the Pacific Islands, respectively, so that members of his Test squad would not be required for bench duties in midweek games. This flew in the face of more than 100 years of Lions tradition, where call-ups to tours had always been exclusively due to injury and withdrawal. The six players involved were the Scots Alan Dell and Finn Russell, along with Cory Hill, Kristian Dacey, Tomas Francis and Gareth Davies from Wales. This selection decision was based primarily on proximity and it attracted outrage from Lions traditionalists, among the media, supporters and former players. The general consensus was that the history and culture of the institution was being diminished by Gatland in the interests of expediency. Tomas Francis, Kristian Dacey, Liam Williams, Gareth Davies and Cory Hill look on as the Lions took on New Zealand Maori in 2017. Pic: Huw Evans/REX/Shutterstock The criticism of Lions icon Ian McGeechan – Gatland's head coach on the 2009 tour – was especially damaging. 'It's that geography part – where you are shouldn't determine that you're in a Lions jersey,' said McGeechan, while former Ireland and Lions flanker Stephen Ferris said Gatland was 'devaluing the badge'. Gatland admitted afterwards that the criticism got to him and the 'Geography Six' were used sparingly, in the clash against the Hurricanes, all six were named on the bench but only one – Russell – was Lions led 31-17 but ran out of gas and ended up drawing the game. The whole episode was an unfulfilling experience for everyone concerned and while it could not be directly linked to the Lions failing to win the series, it definitely contributed to Gatland failing to emulate the same levels of popularity enjoyed by McGeechan — adding another layer of ire for his detractors on the back of his controversial call to axe Brian O'Driscoll in 2013. Gatland was retained for the Covid-dominated tour to South Africa in 2021, but that was a slog from beginning to end for all involved — including the fans shut out of the stadiums and forced to watch on TV — and felt like a tour too far for the New Zealander.
