Romania, oligarch and royal locked in tug-of-war over El Greco painting
But the early 17th-century painting of Saint Sebastian, which shows the martyr's body pierced by arrows, did not go on sale as planned earlier this year. Instead, it has been stranded at Christie's in New York until all the legal wrangling is resolved. The prestigious auction house cancelled its planned bidding war for the El Greco in February 'out of an abundance of caution' after the Romanian government laid claims to the piece, which it says belongs in its royal art collection.
Claiming to be the 'rightful owner', Romania has sued a company through which Rybolovlev acquired the painting in 2010, accusing the firm of not acting in good faith, according to documents reviewed by AFP. On top of that, a third claim by a descendant of Romania's royal family is being contested in the New York courts, with Prince Paul of Romania seeking to recover a work his father believed was stolen by the communists.
Royal wedding, Orient Express
Romanian authorities assume that the painting remained in the country until 1947, but was then 'unlawfully' taken by the country's former king Michael I on a trip to attend the wedding of Queen Elizabeth II in London. In his complaint, Prince Paul, 76, also accuses Michael I of wrongdoing. By loading the El Greco with 'other valuable items into two boxcars of the Orient Express' and then hiding everything in the vaults of a Zurich bank, the former king practically 'stole' the artwork, his nephew argued.
Paul of Romania - whose father was long regarded as an illegitimate son of King Carol II before being recognized - was never acknowledged as part of the royal family. Holding British, French and Romanian citizenship, the disputed royal has taken refuge in France to escape justice in his home country, where he was sentenced to jail for influence peddling. According to Rybolovlev's company Accent Delight, the communists had authorized Michael I to take the painting with him 'as incentive for abdicating the throne and leaving the country' without causing a stir, as they feared 'public unrest because of his popularity'.
'Historic and irreplaceable'
But shortly after Michael I had returned home, he was forced to abdicate and go into exile in late 1947. He would not set foot on Romanian soil again until 1997. In the meantime, he sold the painting in 1975 to French art dealer Daniel Wildenstein, who later resold it. The piece changed hands a few times before being purchased in 2010 by the company of Rybolovlev, president of the AS Monaco football club.
In the past, the Romanian state had already attempted to recover 'Saint Sebastian' alongside other items from the royal art collection. But its attempts so far have been fruitless. Yet, the government has vowed to continue its fight to reclaim the painting it considers a 'unique part of Romania's cultural heritage'. 'If this unique, historically significant, and irreplaceable painting is sold before Romania can have its ownership claims heard and adjudicated, it would cause immediate and irreparable harm to the State of Romania and its people,' Marcel Ciolacu, then Prime Minister, wrote in a letter submitted to the New York court earlier this year. — AFP
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Kuwait Times
16 hours ago
- Kuwait Times
‘Human presence': French volunteers protect sheep from wolves
Carrying staffs like shepherds, Sophie Morice-Couteau and Geoffroy Galliot inspect the nets of a sheepfold on a steep slope in the Baronnies massif, part of their daily mission to keep wolves away. The two Bretons are volunteers who signed up to protect the flock belonging to farmer Nathalie Welker in the Drome Provencal, in France's southeast, from wolf attacks - which have become so common that she feels under 'pressure' from the predators. 'The wolves are here, there's nothing to be done about that, so we need to find a response,' said Welker, 57, wearing a T-shirt that reads: 'I'm a farmer and proud of it' as she looked across her sun-drenched valley. Wolves have made a comeback in Europe, multiplying attacks on livestock and causing angry reactions from farmers, some of whom say the predators should be shot on sight. The European Union recently downgraded wolves from 'strictly protected' to 'protected', making such killings easier. The French government has authorized 192 wolves to be shot this year, out of the country's total wolf population of 1,013. But some say the killings do little to stop wolf attacks. The best prevention is 'a human presence', said Welker, adding that she had lived alongside wolves for 20 years. But she cannot afford to pay a full-time shepherd to look after her two flocks, and instead turned to an organization of volunteers, Pastoraloup, three years ago for help. Volunteers from Pastoraloup watch over a flock of sheep in the hills above Villebois-les-Pins in central France. Volunteers from Pastoraloup watch over a flock of sheep in the hills above Villebois-les-Pins. Volunteers from Pastoraloup observe the surroundings near a flock of sheep in the hills above Villebois-les-Pins. Volunteers from Pastoraloup watch over a flock of sheep in the hills above Villebois-les-Pins. 'I support wolves' Pastoraloup is run by the Ferus association, dedicated to the defence of large predators. It trains volunteers and sends them out to farmers who need assistance. Welker says she can now 'sleep at night and be much less stressed'. Meeting people and educating them about farming are a bonus of working with the volunteers. Around 35 farmers in the French Alps, the Jura and Brittany are taking part in the scheme this year, up from around 20 two years ago. Morice-Couteau, 45, and Galliot, 48, are among 63 new volunteers who trained last year. 'I support wolves, but I also support farmers,' said Morice-Couteau, adding that the presence of the predator could become 'one problem too many' for farmers. Welker fears that 'major attacks' are coming, notably in the autumn, when young wolves learn how to hunt. Volunteers from Pastoraloup analyze wolf droppings found near a flock of sheep in the hills above Villebois-les-Pins. Volunteers from Pastoraloup watch over a flock of sheep in the hills above Villebois-les-Pins. Volunteers from Pastoraloup watch over a flock of sheep on July 31, 2025, in the hills above Villebois-les-Pins. 'Here to help' In October 2023, 17 of Welker's animals were killed after a volunteer left suddenly, leaving the flock without protection. At sundown, her two new volunteers herd around 50 sheep - all meticulously accounted for - into their night shelter, protected by a 1.4-metre (4.6-foot) high electric fence. Morice-Couteau makes a last round in the dark, equipped with a headlamp, before going to bed in a tipi a few metres away, aware that wolves can strike at any time 'if they see an opportunity'. Morice-Couteau, who works in the cinema industry, said that she believed farmers and wolves could co-exist, but that her volunteering experience had also made her 'understand the violent feelings that some farmers harbour towards wolves'. Tensions have for years been building between farmers and environmentalists over the issue of wolf conservation in France as numbers of the predators have grown. Welker said there is 'very strong social pressure' on farmers who use Pastoraloup which discourages others from benefiting from the programme because it is 'labelled environmentalist'. 'We're not here for a debate,' said Morice-Couteau. 'We're here to help.' — AFP
Kuwait Times
a day ago
- Kuwait Times
China vessels collide while pursuing Philippine boat in South China Sea
Incident occurs near the contested Scarborough Shoal MANILA: A Chinese navy vessel collided with one from its own coast guard while chasing a Philippine patrol boat in the South China Sea on Monday, Manila said, releasing dramatic video footage of the confrontation. The incident occurred near the contested Scarborough Shoal as the Philippine Coast Guard escorted boats distributing aid to fishermen in the area, spokesman Commodore Jay Tarriela said in a statement. Video released by Manila showed a China Coast Guard ship and a much larger vessel bearing the number 164 on its hull colliding with a loud crash. Additional footage and photos released later by the Philippine Coast Guard showed the stricken Chinese vessel still afloat but with its entire bow crumpled inward. 'The (China Coast Guard vessel) CCG 3104, which was chasing the (Filipino coast guard vessel) BRP Suluan at high speed, performed a risky maneuver from the (Philippine) vessel's starboard quarter, leading to the impact with the PLA (People's Liberation Army) Navy warship,' Tarriella said in a statement. 'This resulted in substantial damage to the CCG vessel's forecastle, rendering it unseaworthy.' At a later press briefing, Tarriella said that crew members aboard the smaller Chinese vessel had been visible in its front section just before the collision. 'We're not sure whether they were able to rescue those personnel who were in front prior to the collision. But we are hoping that these personnel are in good condition,' he told reporters. Tarriela said the Chinese crew 'never responded' to the Philippine ship's offer of assistance. Gan Yu, a Chinese coast guard spokesperson, confirmed that a confrontation had taken place without mentioning the collision. 'The China Coast Guard took necessary measures in accordance with the law, including monitoring, pressing from the outside, blocking and controlling the Philippine vessels to drive them away,' he said in a statement. China's Ministry of Foreign Affairs did not confirm or deny the collision when asked about it by AFP. Monday's incident is the latest in a series of confrontations between China and the Philippines in the South China Sea, which Beijing claims almost entirely despite an international ruling that the assertion has no legal basis. More than 60 percent of global maritime trade passes through the disputed waterway. Speaking at a morning news conference, Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos said the country's patrol vessels would 'continue to be present' in the area to defend, as well as exercise Manila's sovereign rights over, what it considers to be part of its territory. The Scarborough Shoal—a triangular chain of reefs and rocks—has been a flashpoint between the countries since China seized it from the Philippines in 2012. Earlier in the confrontation, the BRP Suluan was 'targeted with a water cannon' by the Chinese but 'successfully' evaded it, Tarriela's statement said. – AFP
Kuwait Times
2 days ago
- Kuwait Times
Zionist military kills five journalists in Gaza, bringing tally to 237
GAZA: Mourners carry the body of a Palestinian, killed in an overnight Zionist military strike, ahead of a group funeral outside the Al-Shifa Hospital in Gaza City on August 11, 2025. — AFP RAMALLAH: The Zionist entity's war machine killed five Palestinian journalists in the Gaza Strip late Sunday, bringing the total of news personnel covering the genocidal war to 237. The Gaza media office said in a press statement that Al-Jazeera network correspondent Anas Al-Sharif and his colleagues were targeted by the Zionist military while residing in their tent near Al-Shifa hospital. GAZA: Al-Jazeera correspondent Anas al-Sharif reports near the Arab Ahli (Baptist) Hospital in Gaza City on October 10, 2024. Qatari broadcaster Al Jazeera said on August 11, 2025, that five of its journalists were killed in an Zionist military strike, including a prominent reporter. — AFP The assault resulted in the injury of several other journalists, it added. The office insisted that the targeting of journalists in the Gaza Strip was intended to suppress the coverage of the war crimes committed by the Zionist entity, calling on regional and international news outlets and organizations to condemn this heinous crime against the freedom of speech and journalism. — KUNA
