Automated income tax refund system: FBR has failed to enforce IHC's directive
ISLAMABAD: The Islamabad High Court's landmark judgment for effective enforcement of an automated income tax refund system remains unimplemented by the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) despite assurances from Member (Policy) FBR
The court's directive aimed to facilitate taxpayers and minimize interaction with tax functionaries, but the FBR has failed to take concrete steps in this regard.
According to tax lawyer Waheed Shahzad Butt, the FBR's failure to enforce the court's directive appears to be a case of 'planned negligence,' allowing certain field formations within the department to continue obstructive practices when there is an issue of returning taxpayer money in the shape of tax refunds.
Automated income tax refund system: FBR fails to implement IHC judgement
Instead of embracing automation and transparency as directed by the IHC, some FBR officials are playing a hide-and-seek game with refund claimants. This deliberate inaction undermines taxpayer trust and perpetuates a corrupt manual culture that the court sought to eliminate.
The FBR demanded $25 million from the donor agency to effectively enforce an automated tax refund system under the ITO 2001. The FBR submitted a report titled 'Findings and Recommendations of Committee for Effective Enforcement of Section 170A' before the IHC in a public interest petition.
Report submitted by the FBR revealed that the FBR's e-portal had no direct electronic linkage with the biggest government withholding agents i.e. Accountant General Pakistan Revenues (AGPR), which deducted income tax on gross salary of the government employees. This is perhaps the most glaring impediment in the way of enforcement of automated tax refunds process.
Tax deducted by other withholding agents such as power distribution companies (Discos), excise and taxation departments, educational institutes, travel agents, airlines, Sui Northern Gas Pipelines Limited (SNGPL), Sui Southern Gas Company Limited (SSGCL), telephone and internet service providers, semi-autonomous government entities, government departments etc was not visible in the FBR's database.
The judgment in question was intended to streamline the refund process through automated means, reducing human intervention and curbing discretionary power. However, despite the passage of time, the FBR has yet to roll out the mandated system, and no official explanation has been provided for the delay, Waheed Butt added.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
17 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Sentence suspension in £190m case: IHC grants 7-day to NAB for appointing special prosecutor in IK, Bushra's pleas
ISLAMABAD: The Islamabad High Court (IHC) granted seven days to the National Accountability Bureau (NAB) for appointing special prosecutor in Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) founder Imran Khan and his spouse Bushra Bibi's appeals seeking suspension of their sentence in £190 million case. A two-member bench comprising Acting Chief Justice Sardar Sarfraz Dogar and Justice Muhammad Asif, on Thursday, heard the case and adjourned the hearing until June 11, when the NAB told the court that it needed time to prepare arguments for the case. During the hearing, Barrister Salman Safdar, representing the Imran Khan and Bushra Bibi argued that the petitions for suspension of the sentence were heard, after much prayers and supplications, adding that today's date has not been given easily. NAB Prosecutor Rafay Maqsood appeared before the court and said that his request is that the federal government had to appoint a special prosecutor in this case but he has not been appointed yet. Rafay prayed the court to grant four week, stating that they had received the notice yesterday. The acting chief justice said for issuing notification for the prosecution team seven days are enough. Salman Safdar contended that more than 300 cases have been filed against the founder of PTI and the trial court sentenced him. Lawyer Latif Khosa said 'the PTI founder is in jail without any evidence; the PTI founder neither will go abroad nor is there any risk of tampering with the record.' The court directed the NAB prosecution team to notify the special prosecutor within seven days and adjourned the hearing until June 11. In this matter, founder PTI Imran Khan and his spouse Bushra Bibi approached the IHC seeking suspension of their sentences in the £190 million case. They moved the court through their counsel Barrister Salman Safdar and cited the state and the chairman NAB as respondents. Counsel Salman stated in petition that the petitioners were convicted by the Accountability Court (I) Islamabad through judgment dated 17.01.2025, wherein, they were held guilty for commission of offence of corruption and corrupt practices as defined u/s 9(a)(ii)(iv)(vi) of the National Accountability Ordinance, 1999 and Imran was sentenced u/s 10(a) of the National Accountability Ordinance, 1999 to undergo rigorous imprisonment (RI) for 14 years and fine amounting to Rs1,000,000. Through the instant petition, they sought indulgence of this court for 'Suspension' of conviction and sentence awarded to them, till the final disposal of the main appeal already filed in the IHC. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
17 hours ago
- Business Recorder
ST returns filing: PCDMA concerned at FBR's new requirement
KARACHI: The Pakistan Chemical & Dyes Merchants Association (PCDMA) has raised serious concerns about difficulties faced by traders in filing their sales tax returns, following a new requirement introduced by the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR). Through SRO 55(I)/2025, the FBR has made it mandatory for all registered commercial importers, distributors, and wholesalers to declare their stock position in Annexure H1 with every monthly sales tax return. However, PCDMA Chairman Salim Valimuhammad said the lack of clear instructions from the FBR has created unnecessary confusion and hardship. He explained that many traders submitted their March 2025 returns without Annex H1 simply because they didn't understand the process. As a result, they're now unable to declare their opening stock for April, and the delay continues even in June. 'PCDMA has received many complaints from members who are still unable to file their April 2025 returns due to this confusion,' Valimuhammad stated. He added that many traders were forced to go back and forth with the FBR for clarification. Eventually, the FBR allowed revised returns without needing to change Annex A or C or seek commissioner approval—but by then, it was too late for many. To address the issue, PCDMA is urging the FBR to grant traders a 60- to 90-day grace period to submit Annexure H1 after filing their returns. This would be similar to the 120-day window already available to manufacturer-exporters. 'PCDMA believes that such decisions should be made after proper consultation with trade bodies,' Valimuhammad said. He emphasized that timely and clear communication is crucial to ensure compliance and avoid similar problems in the future. PCDMA continues to push for reforms that protect traders' interests and promote smoother tax procedures. The association urges urgent action before more disruptions affect business operations, confidence, and overall revenue collection in the coming months. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
18 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Senate body approves ‘Civil Servants (Amendment) Bill, 2024'
ISLAMABAD: The Senate Standing Committee on Cabinet Secretariat approved, 'The Civil Servants (Amendment) Bill, 2024' which makes mandatory for Grade-17 and above officers to declare their assets. The committee met with Senator Rana Mahmoodul Hassan in the chair at Parliament Lodges on Thursday. According to the bill, senior civil servants will now be required to disclose not only their own assets but also those of their spouses and dependent children. The declaration must also include foreign assets and liabilities. The asset details will be submitted to the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR), which will be authorised to make them public, while ensuring a balance between public interest and individual privacy. The bill also mandates the protection of personal information, including national identity card numbers, residential addresses, and bank account details. During the meeting, the cabinet officials to the committee that civil servants will be legally bound to disclose their assets once the bill becomes law. Senator Farooq H Naek said, 'this is a good piece of legislation,' Senator Anusha Rehman from Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) also endorsed the bill, pledging full support. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
