
More than half of koalas relocated to NSW forest died in failed government attempt at reintroduction
The translocation and deaths of seven out of 13 koalas in April were not made public by the government, prompting questions about whether something went wrong with the project and calls from the NSW Greens for a review.
The project was aiming to re-establish a koala population in an area of south-eastern NSW where the species is locally extinct. Translocation is part of NSW's koala strategy to try to improve the trajectory of the endangered species, at risk of extinction in the state.
Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email
A spokesperson for the NSW environment department told Guardian Australia 13 koalas were selected for translocation in April and moved from 'a high-density population' in the Upper Nepean state conservation area west of Wollongong to the South East Forest national park near Bega.
They said three koalas died within a two-day period in early April, which led the department's project team to put the remaining 10 animals into a wildlife hospital. Four more koalas died.
They said necropsy results from two of the first three koalas that died revealed chronic and acute infections of the lungs and liver, suggesting septicaemia – a bloodstream infection – 'as the likely cause of death'.
The spokesperson said the remaining six koalas were healthy and returned to their original habitat in the Upper Nepean. They said the reintroduction project was immediately put on hold for research to try to establish what caused the deaths.
The team was 'investigating a potential link between septicaemia in koalas and adverse weather conditions, as the mortalities occurred four to five days after a significant rainfall event,' they said.
'We believe prolonged wet weather can pose serious health risks to koalas, disrupting feeding behaviour, inhibiting thermoregulation, and weakening the immune system.'
They said the project team, in collaboration with researchers and veterinarians, would continue investigating 'the potential impact of heavy rainfall, as well as factors such as diet, nutrition, and gut microbiome on the success of future translocations'.
The state Greens environment spokesperson, Sue Higginson, said the incident was 'deeply distressing' and sent 'a very cynical message that the government is focused on [a] high risk and failed koala program effort' while habitat destruction for development and logging continued.
'This koala translocation experiment has been a catastrophic failure and raises serious questions about how it happened,' she said.
'The control settings around this translocation experiment must now be brought into question and reviewed because it would appear they were flawed.
'It is deeply concerning that the government allowed this program in the circumstances and given the outcomes, it's clear they shouldn't have.'
Carolyn Hogg, a professor of biodiversity and conservation at the University of Sydney, said wildlife translocation could be complex and the deaths were 'a really unfortunate event'.
'We do know unexpected weather events may cause pathogens to unexpectedly appear,' she said.
Hogg said for NSW koala populations under pressure from habitat fragmentation and isolation, translocation projects were a management tool that could improve gene flow and genetic diversity.
Valentina Mella is a senior lecturer in animal behaviour and conservation at the University of Sydney. Speaking generally, she said there were important scientific questions that should be considered before translocating wildlife into a new area.
'When you move an animal into a habitat that is considered suitable for that species but that species is not actually present, you have to ask yourself why,' she said.
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
'You have to do a really thorough investigation of why the animal is absent.'
In the case of koalas, she said one consideration should be if suitable food was available because they were specialist folivores – leaf eaters – that only ate particular types of leaves.
The department said all of the animals underwent a veterinary assessment and were found to be healthy and chlamydia negative before the translocation. They said the project was developed in consultation with stakeholders, including traditional owners, researchers, conservation groups, landholders and government agencies.
They said the koalas were closely monitored after their release using satellite and VHF (very high frequency) collars, 'in accordance with strict animal ethics and scientific licensing requirements'.
'The koalas were observed regularly changing trees, foraging, and producing scat of normal quality. All of these are healthy behaviours we would hope to see post translocation,' they said.
They said two other recent translocation projects had taken place in the state. The first relocated koalas from the Upper Nepean State Conservation Area to a predator-free fenced area in Yiraaldiya National Park in western Sydney. All the koalas were alive and healthy, the department said.
A second had commenced in the Northern Rivers region, where there is competition for limited food trees. To try to improve the welfare of koalas in the area, nine animals were translocated to nearby Bungawalbin National Park.
The department said three of the koalas had since died, with likely causes being tree fall or predation. The remaining koalas appeared healthy.
'There are many examples of successful koala translocations in Victoria, South Australia, Queensland and Narrandera in NSW,' they said.
'Koala translocations are not a substitute for protecting koala habitat where healthy populations currently exist; both conservation actions have their role.'
The NSW environment minister Penny Sharpe was unavailable for comment.
Do you know more? Email lisa.cox@theguardian.com
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Guardian
19 hours ago
- The Guardian
‘No clinical benefit' to blood test for Pfas, government says, after ‘forever chemical' found in Blue Mountains
A new report from the government has found there is 'no clinical benefit' to having a blood test for Pfas after the so-called 'forever chemical' was found in local water supplies in the Blue Mountains. The NSW Health Expert Advisory Panel on per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (Pfas), convened by the state's chief health officer, Dr Kerry Chant, to provide advice on the evidence and guidance related to the potential health effects, published its findings in a final report on Tuesday. All recommendations have been accepted by NSW Health. The panel included science and health experts in cancer, hormone and heart health, epidemiology, pathology, primary care, public health and risk communication. They found, based on the substantial research related to Pfas already undertaken, 'the health effects of Pfas appear to be small'. Sign up: AU Breaking News email Pfas are a class of manufactured chemicals used to make products that resist heat, stains, grease and water – sometimes called 'forever chemicals' as they are difficult to destroy and can remain in soil, groundwater and travel long distances. The report acknowledged that studies have reported an association with some health effects, but noted the findings are inconsistent across different studies with 'limited evidence of a dose-response relationship'. The report also found that 'while clinical testing for Pfas is commercially available, the current scientific evidence indicates that there is there is no clinical benefit for an individual to have a blood test for Pfas'. The authors stated Pfas blood tests were unlikely to guide medical care 'because Pfas will be detected in most people, there are many different Pfas types and blood levels do not predict any current or future health outcomes'. They also warned that Pfas blood test results can cause unnecessary concern and subsequent interventions may cause harms. The report recommended that 'should a health care provider order a blood test for Pfas for a patient, the health care provider should provide clear contextual information about the test and its limitations to the patient, to manage expectations and avoid misinterpretation'. The authors also suggest doctors can support patients concerned with their serum PFAS levels by engaging in usual preventative health interventions, 'as many of the health conditions potentially associated with PFAS are common in the community and are associated with well-established risk factors'. The panel acknowledged their recommendation differs from the National Academies of Science Engineering and Medicine (NASEM), an independent institution in the United States, whose guidance documents recommended individual blood testing and the use of blood levels to inform clinical care. They also noted the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry, overseen by the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, gives advice to clinicians on managing and evaluating Pfas exposure and has not adopted NASEM's recommendations on individual blood testing and health-based screening based on Pfas blood levels. Jon Dee, the convener of the Stop Pfas community group in the Blue Mountains, said 25 people in the area had paid $500 out of pocket to have the blood test for Pfas. Dee said they wanted to see how their blood test compared with the areas of Williamtown, Oakey and Katherine, which were contaminated with Pfas due to firefighting activities on nearby defence force bases. 'If you look at the average blood test level of people in the Blue Mountains, we are two to three times higher than the average Pfas levels in those defence communities that have been compensated by the federal government,' Dee said. Dee said what concerned the community was how many of them with high Pfas levels in their blood have also had health issues that have been known to be associated with Pfas, including cancer. 'It's been totally ignored by NSW Health … We've demanded free blood tests for everyone else.' Dee said the group was taking a class action against the New South Wales government and Sydney Water. 'The findings of this report clearly are more to do with reducing the legal liability of Sydney Water than actually looking after the health of people in the Blue Mountains,' Dee said. The panel acknowledged genuine concern in communities about Pfas exposure. 'There is considerable concern, particularly in the Blue Mountains community, about exposure to Pfas through drinking water, and NSW Health takes these concerns very seriously,' Chant said. 'NSW Health will continue to support local clinicians with information for GPs who may be managing patients with concerns about Pfas exposure including evidence about potential adverse health effects, counselling patients, the utility of blood tests for Pfas and the role of further investigations.'


Daily Mail
21 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Aussie dad suddenly dies while caring for his two daughters - and the one thing he made sure of before he took his final breath
Aussie dad Shaun Skinner and his fiancé had just started to plan their wedding for next year after 14 years together and three daughters when he died in their family home. The 36-year-old was taking care of two of the girls on August 4 when his pacemaker, which he had been fitted with nearly two decades before, went off. He rang fiancé Ashlee Tyrrell about 1pm from the family home in Melbourne 's south-east suburb of Rowville to alert her and she left work. 'We had had no hiccups since his diagnosis at 17-years-old,' she told Daily Mail on Tuesday. 'He got a pacemaker put in and everything was fine. He was going to his specialist every year.' As she was driving home, she rang him to say she was on the way and he told her he thought it was a panic attack. She said she wasn't far. 'I got a phone call from Ambulance Victoria and they told me Shaun had called an ambulance but he was terrified because he was home alone with that two daughters, so the three year old and the seven year old,' she said. 'He didn't want them to be scared or alone. So I got off the phone and I called my dad who got there quickly because it was just around the corner from his work.' When Ashlee's father arrived, he lost consciousness. 'Shaun lost consciousness when he knew his girls were taken care of. He waited and then he never regained consciousness again,' she said. 'When the paramedics got there, my three year old was lying on her dad but I'm forever grateful because they never got to see the scary part.' Mr Skinner was found lying on his bed but was moved to another room before paramedics began attempts to resuscitate him. By the time Ms Tyrrell reached the home, he was unresponsive after what is now known to have been a fatal heart attack. The couple, who had met while working at the manufacturer Stegbar in 2011, shared three daughters Sophie, Violet and Everly, between nine and three-years-old. 'I knew then that I didn't want Shaun to come back if he wasn't going to be Shaun. I started preparing myself,' she said. Paramedics had been attempting to resuscitate Mr Skinner for 45 minutes and told her they would have to stop after an hour had passed. 'So 15 minutes later, they told me they were sorry, but there was nothing more they could do. I had my very sad moment. Then my brain went to my kids,' she said. Ms Tyrrell's father collected her nine-year-old from school while the two other daughters said goodbye to their father. 'I knew I've got to do this right, my kids need to say him to say goodbye. They need to do it now, while he still looks like Daddy,' she said. 'It was the hardest thing I've ever had to do in my life. 'My dad told my nine-year-old and I heard her scream from the car. Then she ran to me and I hugged her. I took her in and she said goodbye.' Ms Tyrrell has taken time off work to care for her daughters until she can make sure they are well enough for her to return. She and Mr Skinner fell in love at first sight in 2011 and were engaged a year later but held off getting married until their girls were old enough to be involved in the wedding. 'We'd only just started planning so we didn't have much set. Instead, I get to plan his funeral,' she said. 'Shaun was the best dad in the world. He was funny, he made everyone laugh and that was his main thing in life. He loved to make people happy. 'We're absolutely heartbroken and devastated but I can't change it so I'm just trying to make sure that I do the right thing for the kids.' Ms Tyrrell and her daughters have moved out of the rental to stay with her parents in Pakenham after the ordeal. Friends have organised a GoFundMe page, which has already raised $38,842, to help financially support the grieving family. They also created an email account for Ms Tyrrell and the girls for people to share words of support and memories of Shaun which will be consolidated into a book.


Daily Mail
a day ago
- Daily Mail
Little girl ends up in intensive care after incident at her childcare centre: What the hell happened?
A family is still without answers after their little girl spent Christmas in intensive care following an unexplained incident at childcare. Three-year-old Lexi was fine when her parents, Sarah and Matt, dropped her off at Little Amigos Childcare in Winston Hills, in Sydney 's west, on December 23 last year. Hours later, they received a call from staff saying Lexi 'wasn't herself' after she woke from a nap feeling unwell. They went to the centre to collect a rapidly deteriorating Lexi and rushed her to hospital, where she was placed on a ventilator in intensive care. 'She was limp and the side of her face was drooping,' Sarah told Seven News. 'Thirty minutes more, I may not have had a daughter.' Her partner added: 'What we were told on the phone, compared to what we witnessed, to what we were told at the centre and to what was told to emergency doctors, is all different events.' Almost eight months on, they still don't know what happened to Lexi, who has made a full recovery and now attends a different childcare. 'Parents deserve to know where they're sending their children,' Sarah said. Extensive tests in hospital were unable to determine the cause of Lexi's symptoms. Lexi's parents told Seven News that the matter is being investigated by NSW Police - a claim that Little Amigos Childcare Winston Hills strenuously denied in a detailed response to Daily Mail. The centre, which has since undergone a change in management, insists that staff notified the department about the incident and that the correct policies and procedures were followed. The matter was investigated by the regulatory bodies, and no compliance action was issued. 'The child was conscious and communicative, and staff did not believe an ambulance was required, given her symptoms at that time,' the centre told Daily Mail. 'Proper care, first aid and supervision were provided to the child. Food and drink were taken by the child. 'The centre was under a new management and all staff involved are no longer with us. We do extensive training with staff on child safety and protection with new staff.' The childcare insists that staff notified the department about the incident and that the correct policies and procedures were followed The Australian Children's Education and Care Quality Authority ruled in April that the centre required 'significant improvement' in relation to national standards. The NSW Education Department initially cancelled the centre's service approval licence, which was recently overturned by NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal upon appeal after the facility changed providers. The centre has also had its assessment rating amended to 'working to towards a national quality standard'. 'The department initially drafted a significant improvement in rating due to concerns of the case,' the new operator told Daily Mail. 'This was overturned by an independent review panel that concluded no evidence to suggest any major breaches of duty of care. 'And as the department's own investigation did not result in any compliance action of this case, it is an unanimous decision that assessment and rating could not be downgraded to significant improvement required.'