Lack of trained construction workers 'a major issue' in delivery of housing, report finds
The Joint Oireachtas Committee on Infrastructure and National Development Plan (NDP) Delivery has published its first report, which identifies a number of areas of concern for Ireland's ability to build.
In the report, the committee said employers' group Ibec noted the lack of trained construction workers was "a major issue", and in the region of 100,000 extra construction workers would be needed to meet the commitments in the NDP.
Ibec also outlined the need to "build resilience into our materials supply chain", as shortages are deterring construction companies from bidding on certain projects as they "need to charge too much to cover their costs".
Delays in projects due to the planning process were also flagged as a major issue, the committee said. These delays "make it unattractive for private companies to bid to deliver large-scale projects".
The report said strategic infrastructure projects should be "flagged by the minister, and these should be expedited through the planning process, while having due regard to public consultation and environmental matters".
The committee said all of its stakeholders highlighted the "urgent need for multi-annual funding for any infrastructure project".
"Currently, funding is allocated on an annual basis. The lack of security of funding results in projects being delayed," the report said.
"In some instances, construction companies have indicated an unwillingness to bid for projects if the future funding is not fully guaranteed. There is uncertainty within the bodies who are charged with delivering these projects. There must be certainty that the funding will remain available until the project is completed."
The revised NDP is due to be published next week, and is expected to include a further almost €20bn investment in housing, energy, water, transport, and health digitalisation.
However, the committee said while this represented an increase of 12% in spending, this was "not sufficient to meet the requirements of Ireland's growing population and inflation since the current NDP was published".
"In addition, this €20bn will primarily come from windfall tax receipts from Apple and the sale of AIB shares. Funding key infrastructure projects of national importance should not depend on windfall taxes."
The committee also said major issues in the planning system "can result in severe delays to projects, as any objection may result in a full judicial review and High Court proceedings, lasting several years".
It added this "can result in a ripple effect where an environmental impact assessment may become out of date and have to be repeated after the judicial review has finished, adding to the delay".
"Additionally, policies such as construction standards that were in place when the project was first mooted, may be replaced by new policies, again resulting in further delay. The common good should be given greater weight in the planning process.
"It is the intention of the committee to examine planning regulations as they apply to large infrastructure projects, to explore this matter further."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
6 hours ago
- RTÉ News
'Difficult' to ban services from Occupied Palestinian Territories
The employers group IBEC has warned that it would be "incredibly difficult" for businesses to implement a ban on services coming from the Occupied Palestinian Territories. The group's Executive Director of Lobbying and Influence, Fergal O'Brien, told the Oireachtas Committee on Foreign Affairs and Trade tonight that such services were "incredibly hard" to identify. Asked if he could quantify the value of services in the Occupied Palestinian Territories, Mr O'Brien said he did not have such data. He said each business would have to conduct a customer by customer analysis to establish the facts, and this would be "extremely difficult." Mr O'Brien said, unlike goods which are labelled, services are part of an integrated complicated trading system and so the likely impact would be that activities would be served by another jurisdiction. He said even if only goods were banned by the proposed legislation, his members would be concerned at the likely international reputational damage which would flow from adopting such a bill. Mr O'Brien indicated that US companies based in Ireland are deeply concerned with anti-boycott legislation in many US states, which were introduced to protect Israel, and the damage this could pose on them. He said an IBEC survey suggested that Ireland's US trading partners view the country as having taken "an isolationist approach" in considering such legislation, and was possibly acting "outside of EU" - even though we're "interlinked with the US more than any EU country." Mr O'Brien said Irish companies are being asked a lot of questions about what Ireland is doing and the sense is that the approach is being viewed as "anti-Israel." He said it appeared that Ireland conducted "minuscule" trade with the Occupied Territories and therefore the financial impact pf a ban on goods would be "minimal." However, he said there could be complications due to Ireland's all-island economy, as well as goods from the Occupied Territories entering the EU.
Irish Examiner
7 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Taoiseach hits back at US ambassador's 'vat of Guinness' comments over Occupied Territories Bill
Taoiseach Micheál Martin has hit back at claims from a senior Trump administration figure that the Government "fell into a vat of Guinness" when drawing up the Occupied Territories Bill. US ambassador to Israel Mike Huckabee had posted on social media that Ireland should "sober up" and apologise to Israel for the bill's passage through the Oireachtas. "Did the Irish fall into a vat of Guinness and propose something so stupid that it would be attributed to act of diplomatic intoxication?" Mr Huckabee said in the post. "It will harm Arabs as much as Israelis. Sober up Ireland! Call [the Israel foreign ministry] and say you're sorry!" Trade ban The bill will ban the trade of goods with illegal Israeli settlements on Palestinian land. The Government said there is a narrow legal basis, based on an advisory opinion from the UN's top court, to ban the trade of goods with illegal Israeli settlements. The Government has said this is being done to comply with the International Court of Justice, which said last year that countries should "take steps to prevent trade or investment relations" that maintain illegal Israeli settlements on Palestinian land. In response, Mr Martin said that he "rejects the comments made by the ambassador". "The situation is very serious in Gaza, including an appalling loss of human life. Terrible war crimes are being committed," he said. "Ireland has consistently condemned Hamas and we equally condemn Israeli breaches of international humanitarian law in Gaza. The slaughter of children must stop. The slaughter of innocent civilians queuing for food must stop. What is going on is beyond any moral compass. "Ireland stands for peace and a political pathway forward." Mr Huckabee's criticism was echoed by others in the US, including the pro-Israel organisation, the Anti-Defamation League, which said it was "deeply concerned" about the bill, which will impact a small amount of trade. On Wednesday in the Seanad, Senator Michael McDowell roundly rejected all and any claims that the actions of Ireland, its Government, or its Houses of Parliament were motivated by, or amounted, to anti-semitism. Claims that Ireland's position reflected anti-semitism, which he defined as hatred of Jews, were grossly defamatory and untrue. 'Our position on Gaza is shared by many Israeli Jews, including a former Israeli prime minister.' Referring to the appearance of former deputy Alan Shatter at an Oireachtas committee, Mr McDowell cited a passage in a book written and published by Mr Shatter in which the former justice minister had claimed that an accusation of 'arrogance' made against him by Willie O'Dea in the Dáil was an 'anti-semitic' trope. 'It is simply defamatory and untrue to assert that Ireland's position on Gaza and recognition of the Palestinian state was motivated by anti-semitism or hatred of Jews.' Read More Crush at Gaza aid site kills at least 20, GHF blames armed agitators
Irish Independent
7 hours ago
- Irish Independent
ESB boss acknowledges stress caused to 80 families locked out of new homes without power
Nicholas Tarrant, managing director of ESB Networks, said work was under way to resolve the situation at the Sand Wood estate in Portlaoise, where 80 homebuyers have been left waiting months for an electricity connection. However, he did not say when the new development would have power. The plight of the families – who had originally expected to move in last Feburary - was highlighted in the Irish Independent last Monday. Mr Tarrant said ESB Networks staff had visited the estate since as part of the preparations for providing a connection. He told the Oireachtas climate, environment and energy committee that Portlaoise was a high-growth area where electricity was constrained. Population in the town had increased by 16pc in a decade, he said. 'I acknowledge there's been considerable uncertainty and stress for the families that are involved in this development,' he said. 'The developer in question [UK-based Hollybrook] applied to us back in March 2024. There was a revised application in August to cater for a commercial unit they were putting in and updated demand for that. 'We issued a connection offer to them in May of this year. During that time, we have to look at the various other applicants in that area.' He said one of the factors involved was that Portlaoise needed two large new transformers to add capacity to the town. ADVERTISEMENT They were now in place and the developers had been given details of the work they needed to do on site to accommodate the connection. 'As soon as that site is ready for our electrical connection work to be done, we will work with the developer to get that done over the next period of time,' he said. Asked by committee members whether there were other similarly constrained areas, he agreed there were, citing north and west Dublin and other 'areas where you have seen the biggest population growth'. ESB Networks' own capacity registers show that half the country's substations have little or no room to connect new housing or other developments. Mr Tarrant said efforts to keep up with the fast-growing demand for electricity were being hampered by delays in the supply chain for key equipment. 'We have seen some lead times double and [it is now] over 24 months for large electrical transformers. 'The demand for this equipment across Europe and globally has dramatically increased as countries invest to support the decarbonisation of their networks to meet their climate change targets.' Mr Tarrant said ESB Networks, as a semi-state operating under licence, could not prioritise connections for housing over developments such as data centres, but had to allocate on a first come, first served basis. Asked whether he would prefer if he could put housing first, he said such a decision would have to come from government policy or a direction from the energy regulator.
