James Cleverly says leaving ECHR is 'not silver bullet' - and leaves door open for leadership bid
The former foreign and home secretary appeared to diverge from Tory leader Kemi Badenoch's stance on the ECHR in a speech about the challenges facing the Conservative Party and UK politics in general.
Last month, Ms Badenoch launched a review into whether the UK should withdraw from the treaty that is a central part of UK human rights law and has been used to halt attempts to deport illegal immigrants.
She said she is "increasingly of the view" that leaving the ECHR would be necessary.
But Sir James said when he was home secretary, from November 2023 to July 2024, he noticed the UK had "one of the lowest deportation rates" of foreign criminals "amongst our European neighbours" - who are also ECHR signatories.
He said he was looking into why that was but the general election happened "before I got any credible answer".
1:30
"But the bottom line is other signatories to the ECHR are kicking out foreign criminals much more than we are," he told the Institute for Public Policy.
"And other countries who are not signatories to the ECHR are also struggling so I'm not convinced the ECHR is, on its own, a silver bullet.
"Particularly if we don't do something about what I worry is a political activism in the legal system, which is trying to re-write British border immigration law policy through case law rather than through parliament."
His comments are also in opposition to Robert Jenrick, who, like Sir James, unsuccessfully ran to be Tory leader, and has said the Tories must back leaving the ECHR to survive.
I don't want to jump into leadership decision
Sir James left the door open to trying again to become Conservative leader, saying he did not want to "jump" into any future political moves.
Asked if he would try to become London mayor or Tory leader, he said: "I like being in government, I don't like being in opposition, which is why I'm clear that I will play my part in helping to get Conservatives back into government, at every level of government.
"Exactly what I do next? I've forced a discipline on myself which is not to jump at something."
He added that the Tories tried having a new leader "a number of times in the last government - it did not end well".
The Braintree MP said after he lost the last leadership race he promised himself he "would spend some time thinking about exactly what I would do next".
Voters will respond if Reform councils get stuff wrong
In the speech, he also attacked Labour, Reform and all other parties, saying they tell people what they want to hear but do not have any "deliverable" policies.
On the Conservatives' strategy to beat Reform, which has been polling ahead of all other parties, he told Sky News: "So at the moment, Reform are very, very popular, but now they're running stuff.
"And as I've said, we've now got some examples in local government.
"And local government is a bit of government people feel most important.
"This is the bit of government that runs their adult social care, their roads, their schools, their waste collection and when governments get stuff like that wrong, people notice and people respond."
He said if Reform councillors do not "step up and perform" voters will be looking for alternatives - "and that's what we need to do".
"We need to make sure that we once again, are credible alternatives with a genuine plan and some energy and some direction," he added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
10 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Dire jobs data are the canary in the coal mine
The latest employment figures released by the Office for National Statistics this morning paint a stark picture of Britain's economic malaise. For the fourth month running, payrolled employment has fallen, a clear indicator that the UK is now in the midst of a serious jobs recession. Without urgent action, the impact on people will be devastating. According to the ONS, another 40,000 people dropped off payrolls in June, meaning nearly two hundred thousand salaried employees have lost their jobs in the past year – the most significant decline in employment we've seen since the Covid pandemic or the global financial crash. This fall means the Government's goal of boosting the employment rate by bringing two million more people into work is now even further away. Vacancy numbers tell an equally alarming story: for the 36th consecutive period, job vacancies have fallen. Employers – hit by the recent rise in Employer NICs, the increase in the Living Wage, and the looming threat of the Employment Rights Bill – are unsurprisingly choosing not to hire. Last month, the Government faced mass rebellion from MPs as they attempted to make tweaks to the welfare system to encourage more people into employment. But any serious attempt to reform welfare to make sure more people can enjoy the benefits of a good job is reliant on businesses being there to create the employment and training opportunities that support people into work. Without businesses being there to give people a step on that first rung on the ladder of employment, the Government will struggle to ever seriously reform welfare. Clearly, a welfare to work programme requires changes to welfare and the creation of work. Both go hand in hand. As employment stalls, it's not surprising that GDP is contracting too. The heady days of the Chancellor lauding the UK as being the fastest growing G7 nation in the first quarter of this year seem long gone, with two consecutive months of GDP contraction. When looking at GDP per capita, economic growth is even worse. As individuals, we have long experienced falling living standards. And yet, even as employment and GDP figures are flashing red, indications are that the Government is about to make the same mistakes that they made in the run up to the autumn Budget last year. Rather than focusing on jobs and investment, ministers now openly flirt with the idea of a wealth tax – with the Chancellor notably refusing to rule this out in her Mansion House speech earlier this week. Speculation is rife that the autumn Budget will contain some form of levy on assets. And business leaders, whose confidence is already in tatters, will now spend the next three months worrying about what tax rises they may face down the line. Whilst some argue that wealth taxes are justified, this would be an act of economic self-harm. These taxes don't just hurt the wealthy. They scare away investment, depress confidence, and send exactly the wrong message to job creators – just when we need them most. The UK is already witnessing the consequences of this, with a record outflow of wealth creators and entrepreneurs. In 2024 alone, over 10,000 millionaires reportedly left the country – a 157 per cent rise on the previous year – and projections suggest more than 16,500 will depart in 2025, making the UK the world's leading exporter of high-net-worth individuals. This exodus is not just a matter of lost tax receipts. It threatens the broader ecosystem of job creation and investment. From venture capital backing for UK startups, to employment in hospitality and professional services, the loss of affluent residents means fewer opportunities and less capital circulating in the domestic economy. As the Government dismantles the non-dom regime and introduces broader global income and inheritance tax liabilities, it must recognise that this risks undermining the very jobs and growth that the UK desperately needs. The fact the catchphrase of advocates of a wealth tax is 'Tax the Rich' and not 'Help the Poor' is telling. More worryingly still, the Government has recently signed up to a UN-led tax manifesto that pushes for higher environmental levies and what it calls 'gender-responsive taxation'. It's questionable as to why committing to international tax pledges is apparently the economic priority of a Government that is focused on boosting economic growth and getting more people back to work. Time is not too late for the Prime Minister and the Chancellor to wake up to the crisis currently happening in the UK's jobs market. A jobs-first economic policy would see a wealth tax immediately ruled out, the devastating hike to Employer NICs reversed, and a commitment to using the autumn Budget to give businesses the environment they need to thrive. If we fail to act, we will look back on the employment figures published this summer not just as a warning sign, but as the start of a prolonged crisis. It's not the high-net-worth individuals that will suffer if this happens, but those who remain locked out of work through a lack of businesses able to give them an opportunity. That would be an unforgivable failure.
Reuters
10 minutes ago
- Reuters
Transfer of Patriot units to Kyiv being prepared, says NATO's top commander
WIESBADEN, July 17 (Reuters) - Preparations are underway to quickly transfer additional Patriot air defence systems to Ukraine, NATO's top military commander Alexus Grynkewich said on Thursday, as the country suffers some of the heaviest Russian attacks of the war so far. "Preparations are underway, we are working very closely with the Germans on the Patriot transfer", he told a conference in the German city of Wiesbaden. "The guidance that I have been given has been to move out as quickly as possible."
BBC News
10 minutes ago
- BBC News
Decision over Highworth golf course housing plans to stand
A controversial decision to progress plans for housing on a former golf course will stand, a scrutiny committee has Swindon Borough Council voted to proceed with a feasibility study for 700 homes on the old golf course in Highworth, Wiltshire, in the decision was reexamined by the council's Corporate Overview and Scrutiny Committee on Wednesday after Conservative councillors used a rare protocol known as a call-in to ask the council to check if proper procedure was leader Jim Robbins told the meeting the project was in the "pre-planning process" stage and a final decision would be made at a later date. The "extraordinary meeting" was called after some opposition councillors cited issues with how the decision to progress the plans to the next stage was made, including that it was not clear whether the cabinet had read the report on the Robbins said it was "simply untrue" to suggest they had not read the papers and "knew nothing about the issue".Closed in 2019, the golf course land has been owned by the council since the resident groups and the town council want the area to officially become a nature park. According to the Local Democracy Reporting Service, at some points, the meeting became heated, with chairman councillor Dale Heenan warning some members of the public after intemperate councillor Steve Weisinger asked for the decision to be returned to the cabinet, but only after the Build a Greener Swindon policy and performance committee had discussed and produced a detailed report on the ward member Nick Gardiner said the decision was "legally shaky, financially short-sighted and environmentally backwards", saying the loss of green open space would have a negative impact on residents and asked for it to be returned for councillor Kevin Small, the cabinet member responsible for the plan, said "even with 700 houses", around "58 per cent of the site will remain as green open space".Mr Heenan pressed Mr Small to assure the committee that no final decision on houses would be taken before a further report was made to cabinet, Mr Small confirming the cabinet would make the final committee voted to confirm the cabinet's decision with voting falling along party lines.
