Damning footage emerges after Essendon make complaint over illegal Collingwood act
Essendon coach Brad Scott has explained why he sought clarity from AFL House about whether Collingwood were flouting the 'stand' rule in their Anzac clash. Speaking on Channel 7 program 'The Agenda Setters' on Tuesday night, Scott confirmed reports that the Bombers had asked for some clarification this week.
Channel 7 highlighted a number of instances in which Collingwood players encroached on the 'protected zone' after an Essendon player had taken a mark last Friday. The rule involves umpires telling players on the mark to 'stand' in place and not move, otherwise a 50m penalty can be called.
If defenders move within five metres of the player who took the mark, they're not allowed to then retreat out of the protected zone and get back into a better defending position. It's all designed to speed up the pace of play and promote more attacking footy.
On Tuesday night, Scott revealed that AFL officials admitted to him that a number of calls regarding the rule last weekend were wrong. There seems to have been a relaxation of the rule in recent times after it was first introduced in 2023.
"It just seems there's been a bit of 'creep' on the 'stand' (rule) and the protected area," Scott said. "I understand it's a really hard rule to umpire, but do you have to stand or can you just block the 45 (angle)?"
Panellist Dale Thomas said the examples shown from the Collingwood game should have been pinged by the umpires. Scott added: "They (AFL House) come back and said they're all errors. There will obviously be an adjustment to that, but that doesn't help us now."
RELATED:
Buddy Franklin exposes troubling issue hurting Swans
Jack Ginnivan hit with charge from AFL over ugly incident
The Bombers coach said he wasn't complaining about Collingwood, but wanted the rule clarified now before it rears its head in the finals. "We sent the vision in and said 'if this is the way it's interpreted, we'll do the same thing'," he said. "So we just want some clarity.
"I'm not interested in going back in retrospect and saying 'you got this wrong'. It's about what's going to affect us going forward.
"I think the 'stand' and protected area are material to the way the game's played. Steve Hocking (former Executive General Manager of Football at the AFL) and others went to enormous lengths to open up the game offensively. Because defence was starting to win for a long time. Offence is starting to win now, but it seems as though it's creeping back a little bit."
The AFL said in 2023: 'An opposition player cannot run toward the mark (and enter the protected area) and then elect to change their mind and retreat outside of the protected 5m area. Similarly, an opposition player cannot elect to leave the protected area and then change their intent and choose to come and stand the mark. Further all other players from the opposing team must be positioned behind the mark or otherwise outside the protected area.'
The game is in absolute crisis with its rules & adjudication through its umpires. Watch for a major correction Thursday/Friday night with the 'smaller' clubs involved
— William Beehag (@Billybag99) April 29, 2025
Collingwood were literally gifted the round 2 game against us by the umpires, why are we surprised here?
— Purp juice (@PurpJuicey) April 29, 2025
I literally said to a friend that Pies will get stung with some frees against over thisThey were also crowding the mark, really quite relaxedNot their fault, they're taking every inch
— Simon (@Knight_Ryders) April 29, 2025
Stand rule and protected zone are two of the biggest blights on the game, designed to open up scoring, scores over 100 are are the exception rather than the norm.
— Leon (@LDav2312) April 29, 2025
https://t.co/lt6JKpQWdAHighlighted this mid game.. Further highlights that the umpiring is at a very low standard currently.
— Heath (@HeathLyons) April 29, 2025
The best one is Elliot clearly in the protected area and the umpire says 'Jamie keep coming' for him to only get closer and the ump doesn't penalise him.
— ZERODARKTHIRTY (@stejr96) April 29, 2025
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
'We went safe' admits Eagles coach after latest loss
West Coast coach Andrew McQualter says his players need to become more vulnerable and open to risk if they are to learn how to win close games. The Eagles overcame a woeful afternoon in front of goal to lead North Melbourne by 18 points early in the final quarter of Sunday's match in Bunbury. But with victory in sight, they imploded from that point on, committing a host of costly errors as North Melbourne stormed home with the final four goals to snatch a 10-point win. The result left West Coast in last spot with a 1-12 record - two wins adrift of their nearest rivals Richmond. It was also the third close game West Coast have lost this season, following two-point defeats to Essendon and Richmond. Cam IN FRONT!#AFLNorthEagles — AFL (@AFL) June 8, 2025 McQualter feels his players went into their shells when the game was there to be won. "We're going through this little period at the moment where we're clearly playing better football, but we need to learn how to win," McQualter said. "We need to be able to put those games away. "We need to keep being really vulnerable and open about our thoughts and the feelings we have in those moments. "When you're in that position at three-quarter time, you need to keep attacking the game. "I felt like we went safe. We went away from what we had done and it just fuelled North's game. "We need to be able to lean into those moments. You need to look forward to those moments as a player, rather than trying to save the game." McQualter wants to use the club's latest heartbreaking loss as a significant teaching point. "Our players want to win, but we've just got to teach them how," he said. "Sometimes it's just by, 'You don't have to do more'. "Sometimes people try and throw the team on their back and try and do it all themselves, and it's very rare that it happens like that. "We'll use those moments in the last quarter as education points and ensure that we just have to get better." Brockman bobs up in the pocket to get the Eagles going in the final term.#AFLNorthEagles — AFL (@AFL) June 8, 2025 West Coast's horror goalkicking came back to bite them. The Eagles had 1.13 to their name by midway through the third quarter before finally finding their groove. But their inability to apply significant scoreboard pressure earlier in the match proved costly, with North storming home to grab the 9.8 (62) to 5.16 (52) win. "It can be a bit contagious, that's for real," McQualter said of the inaccuracy. "We were 1.11 at one stage. It breaks your heart." McQualter heaped special praise on defender Harry Edwards, who kept star North Melbourne forward Nick Larkey scoreless from 11 disposals. West Coast will be back in action on Sunday when they host Carlton at Optus Stadium.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Kangaroos keen to muscle in on footy-mad WA
North Melbourne want to become Western Australia's third-favourite team, and coach Alastair Clarkson hopes the club's rich Sandgroper history will help make it a happy marriage with fans. The Kangaroos' three-year deal to sell two games a season to WA got off to the perfect start on Sunday when they beat West Coast by 10 points in Bunbury. North Melbourne will "host" Fremantle at Optus Stadium on Saturday night, with each game the club has sold to WA worth a reported $1m. The contract helps replace the deal North Melbourne previously had with Tasmania, and coach Alastair Clarkson says WA is a good fit for his club. Cam IN FRONT!#AFLNorthEagles — AFL (@AFL) June 8, 2025 "We have seven or eight West Australians on our list," Clarkson said. "Historically our club has had a strong link - Brownlow medallist in Ross Glendinning, the Krakouer magic of Jimmy and Phil and many others. "Our connection to the west has been strong. "To get an opportunity to play some home games here - it has been such a fertile football state in terms of their passion for AFL footy. "It seems for the state two teams aren't enough, so we've provided them with the third team, and we're happy to do so." The Kangaroos will host one game a year in Bunbury and the other one at Optus Stadium. Sunday's match at Hands Oval attracted a sell-out crowd of 12,715 fans and was the first time an AFL regular-season game had been played in regional WA. The deal appears to create a win-win situation, with North Melbourne receiving vital funds, and West Coast and Fremantle being able to play an extra game in WA, without their usual rigours of travelling to eastern states. "With Tassie (the new club in Tasmania) coming in, we had to find another base to provide us with the opportunity to have a nice, happy marriage," Clarkson said. "We get paid some money to play games here, but we love coming here and fostering relationships with people in the south west. "There are a lot of locals here and a lot came from Perth - Eagles fans - and there are a stack that have jumped on planes that must please Tourism WA, who made the significant investment in getting North to come here and play games of footy." SIMPKIN SEALS IT 🫡#AFLNorthEagles — AFL (@AFL) June 8, 2025 The Kangaroos trailed by 18 points in the last quarter before kicking the final four goals of the match to snatch the 9.8 (62) to 6.16 (52) win. It means North Melbourne, with three wins and a draw to their name, are now two-and-a-half wins clear of wooden spoon favourites West Coast (1-12). Kangaroos defender Charlie Comben was sent off for scans after sustaining a knee to the back in the third quarter.
Yahoo
8 hours ago
- Yahoo
Blues hold off Bombers fightback for crucial win
Carlton have beaten arch-rivals Essendon by eight points in a pulsating duel, finally holding on when threatened in the second half. The Blues' handling of a high hit to Adam Cerra will be a major talking point after the 11.12 (78) to 11.4 (70) win on Sunday night at the MCG. After a hot start that proved decisive, Carlton were in all sorts of trouble in the second half before steadying, partly thanks to an effusive three-quarter-time spray from coach Michael Voss. Blake Acres kicked a booming goal from an acute angle at the start of the last term to fortify Carlton, before Zac Williams added another that gave them crucial breathing space. Just like last week against Brisbane, the Bombers paid dearly for a woeful first term. Blues defender Jack Silvagni was outstanding, keeping Essendon young gun Nate Caddy goal-less, while midfielder Darcy Parish had 10 clearances in his return from injury. The Blues were missing key forward Harry McKay with a knee ailment, but his replacement Hudson O'Keeffe made an excellent AFL debut. Carlton looked like enjoying a night out when they kicked the first four goals in 14 minutes. Bombers debutant Luamon Lual briefly stemmed the onslaught when he joined the "first kick, first goal" club. But the Blues kicked another two goals to close out the first term and broke out to a 38-point lead 10 minutes after the first break. As soon as De Koning laid the tackle, Williams was GONE 💨#AFLBluesDons — AFL (@AFL) June 8, 2025 Two minutes into the second term, Sam Durham collected Cerra with a high bump that looks certain to earn the Essendon on-baller a suspension. Cerra was left with a black eye and was assessed on the ground, but surprisingly did not come off for a HIA. Carlton medical staff reviewed the incident on boundary-line video and finally, after 14 minutes, Cerra was taken off the ground for the HIA, which he passed. It is unclear whether there was any AFL intervention before the Blues decided to take Cerra to the rooms. Meanwhile, the Bombers rallied from their dismal first term and steadily worked into the game. They reduced the margin to 28 points at the main break and went on the attack in the third, kicking four goals to one. Remarkably, Carlton captain Patrick Cripps went stat-less in the third as Essendon surged. The Bombers could have closed to within a goal late in the third, but a desperate tackle from Adam Saad stopped Xavier Duursma from having a shot. Sam Walsh was instrumental again for Carlton, with an equal game-high 32 disposals.
