Concerns escalate over condition of Columbus' fire fleet and division budget
COLUMBUS, Ohio (WCMH) — The Columbus fire union is asking the city for help addressing a 'critical' vehicle shortage.
Despite years of requests for more funding, Columbus fire union President Steve Stein said the city has not properly maintained the Columbus Division of Fire's (CFD) fleet of vehicles. Stein said the union is drawing a line in the sand now that the vehicle shortage is limiting CFD trainees' ability to properly complete their training. City representatives disagree, saying the fleet is in fine condition.
'When we increase needlessly the risks of this job because of deferred investments and using equipment beyond its useful life, that's unacceptable,' Stein said.
Gov. DeWine denies claim of 'anti-LGBTQ+ climate' in Ohio
The union is protesting the choice between undertraining recruits or delaying the 122 Class's April 11 graduation, both of which Stein said they would not stand for. He said these difficult decisions should not have to be made because CFD has been alerting the city about fleet concerns for years.
Emails sent in 2022 show Fire Chief Jeffrey Happ requesting a budget increase, where he said the average $7.4 million for fleet funding could not keep up with inflation or the growing demands on CFD. Stein said the Chief's office has requested monetary support every year, but unfulfilled requests have reached a 'breaking point.'
Stein said even if every vehicle needed was purchased immediately, it would still take years to get them on Columbus' streets. Manufacturing backlogs after COVID-19 have increased wait times from 12 months to up to four years for new vehicles.
'Our people will work as hard as possible to always get the job done for the citizens of Columbus,' Stein said. 'But the reality is, too often we're having to make it work and use work arounds to get the job done.'
DOGE claim of saving $1 million at Ohio State doesn't match records
City representatives said rising vehicle costs have made them be more carfeul with their money. However, the city said CFD's response time has not been affected by any vehicle concerns. Further, the city said the fleet is in 'relatively good shape.'
'City of Columbus Fire apparatus is in better condition than it has been in many years because of the capital commitments from the administration over the last 10 years,' A Division of Fleet Management spokesperson said.
However, maintenance records obtained by NBC4 Investigates show trucks are spending more and more days in the shop. Documents listing apparatus servicing from March 2016 show 409 combined days out of commission for repairs. As of March 2025, the monthly average length of time vehicles are out of service is 584 combined days.
'In some cases, you have equipment that is duct taped together. In other cases, there's pictures where you have a pump panel where the throttle that controls how much water is coming to the fire hose is being held on the truck with a wrench,' Stein said.
City representatives said the Division of Fleet Management takes more into consideration than how long vehicles have been in repairs when assessing the state of its fleet. The city also said it just approved six vehicle purchases on March 24, with three more set to be voted on in April.
Liv's Law: Harsher drunk driving penalties to take effect in Ohio
CFD's Standard Operating Procedures document outlines how many front line and reserve vehicles the city should have. NBC4 Investigates compared these standard procedures with the vehicles listed in CFD's 2024 fleet analysis. When compared side-by-side, CFD appears to be 11 engines, five ladders, three rescues and five medics short as of 2024.
Even if the city approved all pending City Council requests, these investments will likely not arrive in Columbus for several years and the fleet would still be short 15 vehicles. Of the vehicles CFD does have, the fleet analysis found 31 medics, 19 fire engines, four ladder vehicles and 11 specialty vehicles need replaced immediately.
'The predictability of this problem, I think, is really what cuts to the frustration our firefighters have, because it has been years the fire administration's been asking for increases in equipment funding, and it hasn't occurred,' Stein said.
As Columbus grows, Stein said CFD is under increased demand, further adding to the wear and tear of these vehicles. He's asking the city to come to the table to help address these concerns and publicly acknowledge the crisis. The city said it is proactively seeking funding to replace vehicles but did not echo Stein's concerns.
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
15 hours ago
- Yahoo
'Serious' M11 crash in Essex leaves motorway closed to traffic
A major UK motorway is closed following a 'serious' crash tonight (Friday, June 6 into Saturday June 7). The M11 is shut to traffic southbound between Junction 6 and Junction 5 in Essex. The incident was first reported shortly after 11pm. It is currently unclear how long the closure will be in place for. READ MORE: UKHSA 'stay at home' advice as Covid variant NB.1.8.1 confirmed in UK READ MORE: When UK weather will change as soaring temperatures of 28C set to hit Inrix, the traffic data company, said: "M11 Southbound closed due to serious accident from J6 M25 J27 to J5 A1168 Chigwell Lane (Loughton)." A National Highways spokesperson said: "The M11 southbound is currently closed between J6 (M25) and J5 (Chigwell) due to a serious collision. Emergency services continue to work at scene. There is currently not timescale for how long the road will be closed. We await updates from from Essex Police." ---- Day in day out, our reporters in the Manchester Evening News newsroom bring you remarkable stories from all aspects of Mancunian life. However, with the pace of life these days, the frenetic news agenda and social media algorithms, you might not be getting a chance to read it. That's why every week our Features and Perspectives editor Rob Williams brings you Unmissable, highlighting the best of what we do - bringing it to you directly from us. Make sure you don't miss out, and see what else we have to offer, by clicking here and signing up for MEN Daily News. And be sure to join our politics writer Jo Timan every Sunday for his essential commentary on what matters most to you in Greater Manchester each week in our newsletter Due North. You can also sign up for that here. You can also get all your favourite content from the Manchester Evening News on WhatsApp. Click here to see everything we offer, including everything from breaking news to Coronation Street. If you prefer reading our stories on your phone, consider downloading the Manchester Evening News app here, and our news desk will make sure every time an essential story breaks, you'll be the first to hear about it. And finally, if there is a story you think our journalists should be looking into, we want to hear from you. Email us on newsdesk@ or give us a ring on 0161 211 2920. .
Yahoo
20 hours ago
- Yahoo
Trac Intermodal preps 200K chassis for China container surge
A top executive with the largest provider of intermodal chassis says his company is ready for the coming crush of China container imports headed to the United States. 'We're preparing for a bounce back of volume this summer,' said Trac Executive Vice President and Chief Commercial Officer Jake Gilene, in an interview with FreightWaves. 'We're staying very close to our customers gathering their forecasting data, so we can see what they see. We are preparing now for volume that's coming in late June-early July.' For Trac, which maintains a fleet of 200,000 domestic, marine and specialty chassis, that means making sure there are available chassis in the right markets, and coordinating those efforts across all ports and terminals. After the pandemic supply chain crisis, Gilene said, Trac worked with major railroads to establish strategic chassis reserves.'Post-COVID, we began a strategic chassis reserve program where Trac worked with Union Pacific to set aside chassis at specified locations where it makes sense for our host and our customers. This was done in the event of a black swan event. We are actively looking to expand this in other markets where it makes sense,' Gilene said. To build up sufficient fleet resiliency, 'Trac has developed a number of key locations around the country where our usage data and customer demand would indicate the need for safety stock.' In addition to participating in 12 neutral chassis pools across the country, Trac operates four private pools on the West Coast with ocean carriers CMA CGM, Zim (NYSE: ZIM), Evergreen ( and Hong Kong-based Hede International Shipping. During the lull in China traffic precipitated by the trans-Pacific tariff dispute with Washington, Trac looked to reposition chassis where they could do the most good. Upgraded units sitting idle in California were moved to the Midwest to refresh fleets worn by winter is anticipating higher-than-normal container volumes come June. 'The ocean services that were suspended are being reinstated and schedules are now booked,' said Gilene. 'Carriers are swapping vessels into the eastbound trans-Pacific trade lane to bring in more TEUs. From our customer conversations and forecasting, it's a mix of goods that were ready to ship and some new factory production, but mostly new, reinstated production.' One component Trac will be watching closely is dwell time. 'Average dwell is six to seven days, and during COVID we saw that increase [by] two to four times, depending on the market. If the supply chain isn't making a quick turn, the dwell time is longer for where the chassis is going, impacting chassis availability.' The big unknown is how long the surge is going to last. 'We've seen varying timelines for backlog recovery. During COVID, a three-month supply chain shutdown took 18 months. Building on what we learned, we are proactively repairing additional chassis and are exploring reserve expansions where they make sense.' Gilene added that since the pandemic, more motor carriers have acquired their own chassis, making them less dependent on pools. The import surge could give Trac a needed boost. In December, Moody's revised its outlook for the company to negative, saying then that tariffs posed a risk to import volume more articles by Stuart Chirls world order: Ocean rates up 88% as shippers pounce on lower tariffs New week sees ocean container rates soar Dirtier ports will hurt jobs, US maritime revival: AAPA Texas port completes $625M ship channel deepening project The post Trac Intermodal preps 200K chassis for China container surge appeared first on FreightWaves. Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
USA Today
20 hours ago
- USA Today
Uber is trying to help older Americans' transportation troubles. Will it work?
Uber is trying to help older Americans' transportation troubles. Will it work? Show Caption Hide Caption Bradley Cooper new documentary sheds light on caregiving crisis A new documentary, "Caregiving," executive produced by Oscar-nominated actor Bradley Cooper, will explore the hidden struggles of caregivers. unbranded - Entertainment Yvette Pegues, 38, lives in a wheelchair full time and travels often for work. Recently, on her way to a conference in Miami, she said she ordered a wheelchair-accessible ride and spent nearly $100 to go 12 miles. Pegues, a board member for disability advocacy group The Arc, said she's had plenty of unfortunate rideshare interactions. She's experienced canceled rides, rude drivers and high prices for extra assistance. 'The worst part, honestly, is once I've actually gotten an Uber ride, the driver doesn't always want to assist," she said. Even if she can "swing into the car" herself, she said, she still needs help from the driver to get her chair in the trunk or the back seat. More: The caregiving crisis is real. USA TODAY wants to hear from you about how to solve it. "I'm really, kind of, at their mercy," Pegues said. Drivers for UberWAV, who offer wheelchair-accessible rides, must complete a third party certification course on how to help riders enter and exit a vehicle, according to the company. Uber can deactivate the account of any driver who denies transportation to a rider because of their age or disability. And Uber has made strides in recent years to support riders in other ways, including the ability to report safety concerns in real-time and supporting domestic violence survivors during COVID-19. On June 4, Uber launched its latest accessibility feature, senior accounts, nationwide. These accounts are part of Uber's family profiles and offer older adults a more streamlined version of the app with larger text, fewer steps and easy-to-follow screens. Their loved ones can help them order a ride and get real-time updates during the senior's journey, too. But while the company's efforts to support diverse riders looks good on paper, experts in the aging and disability worlds aren't sure Uber has the capability to meet all riders where they are without help. Justin Boogaard, co-founder and CEO of GoGoGrandparent, a third-party platform that helps older adults access rideshare apps, food delivery other smartphone services, said it's great to see companies like Uber and Lyft investing in accessibility features for seniors and those with disabilities. But he said most of the clients his company works with need more assistance than what an app redesign can offer. When his clients schedule an Uber ride, Boogaard said, they have difficulty communicating with the driver, confirming their ride and connecting their payment plan − tasks that need an over-the-shoulder assist. And because these clients often don't have alternatives, a canceled ride is a big deal. 'With older adults, in particular, reliability is more important than anything else. It's more important than convenience,' Boogaard said. The worst thing that can happen, he said, is a driver shows up and refuses to help or drives off without even trying to help. That's where GoGoGrandparent comes in, by booking rides for older Americans and communicating the rider's needs to the driver. If the driver isn't comfortable helping with a wheelchair or other accommodations, Boogaard said, GoGoGrandparent can easily redirect the request to another driver who is willing to help. 'An older adult is happy to wait 15 minutes if the driver that shows up is going to load their walker for them," he said. Accessibility 'is about choice,' Uber rep says Older adults often face transportation barriers that can further exacerbate health issues and loneliness. An estimated 18.6 million Americans self-reported travel-limiting disabilities, according to the U.S. Bureau of Transportation Statistics' 2022 National Household Travel Survey. Nearly 8 million of those respondents were 65 and older, and most of them reported health problems as the top reason for taking fewer trips. A 2019 study by University of Southern California, in which 150 patients 60 and older were given three months of free and unlimited Lyft rides, found 12% of the rides were used for medical appointments. Participants in the study also used Lyft to run errands, to make social visits and to get to fitness classes and other entertainment events. The study found 90% of participants reported an increase in quality of life. More: A woman's retirement crisis: Between caregiving and gender wage gap, can they catch up? Transportation is key to independence, and when older adults lose the ability to drive that's often the beginning of the end of their autonomy, said Seth Sternberg, CEO and co-founder of Honor, an in-home care provider. Uber's senior accounts are built for individuals living independently and who don't need as much assistance as those trying to access a wheelchair accessible vehicle, or those connected to a caregiver account. With senior accounts, older adults can save frequent destinations and loved ones can follow along in the app during rides to get real-time updates on each trip. Older adults who aren't part of a family profile can turn on "simple mode," found in the accessibility settings, to use the more streamlined version of the app. Uber's family profiles have accounts for teens and caregivers, too. Family organizers can invite their loved ones to join their account through the app. The company said it will gather feedback from the new senior accounts to inform ongoing work on how to improve user experience for older adults and those with disabilities. 'Senior accounts and Simple mode represent an important milestone in Uber's ongoing commitment to accessible transportation,' said Ashu Manohar, director of product management at Uber. 'These features reflect our dedication to designing technology that meets people where they are and supports mobility at every stage of life.' For some riders, Uber's accessibility features make a world of difference. Three times a week, Michael Cuvilje orders an Uber to his home in New York City to take his mother to her dialysis. His mother, 93-year-old Bettye Cuvilje, has dementia, kidney disease and heart failure. She lives with Cuvilje and his wife and sister. "I do own a vehicle, but I find it difficult to get her in and out because some days she's in, like, a lot of pain," he said. With Uber's wheelchair accessible vehicle feature, he said, "I can just roll her into the back of the vehicle, strap her in and it makes it much more convenient that way.' Wheelchair accessible vehicles are much easier to access in New York than in other areas of the country, Pegues said. Cuvilje always joins his mother for her Uber rides, since she needs assistance getting in and out of the vehicle and into her appointments. He hasn't used the family profile or senior account feature yet, but said he's interested, especially since his sister is 63 and also has difficulty getting around. He said he's in the process of getting her set up on the app. 'We really believe that accessibility for users is about choice," said Briana Gilmore, Uber's head of public policy, accessibility, and underserved communities. Gilmore said she's excited to share the senior account feature with her mom, and wishes she'd had more options when she was a caregiver for her father. 'Many of us built this with our loved ones in mind that we've been caregivers for," Gilmore said. Transportation troubles are larger than rideshare It's a "big step in the right direction," Sternberg said. But when riders have more specialized needs, like help getting in and out of a wheelchair, "it's just a completely different product" than what traditional rideshare companies are made for. And since Uber contracts its drivers, Boogaard said, it's difficult to control how individual interactions play out. 'You kind of have to ask yourself, where does one service end a different service begin?" Sternberg said. The onus to transport older Americans and people with disabilities isn't totally on rideshare companies like Uber. Perhaps rideshare apps just aren't the best products for those users, Sternberg said, and companies that do specialize in care for individuals with disabilities should help solve the transportation barrier. In some cities, wheelchair accessible vehicles are limited or aren't available at all. Pegues said she's used medical transport services before, but that can cost hundreds of dollars. And people with disabilities aren't all old, she said. It's about time the country's transportation infrastructure and services caught up "so that we can become more independent." 'I think in order to solve that problem, that's where you really start needing the help − especially for older adults that are at the poverty line − you really start needing the help of insurance companies or government support to make those economics work," Boogaard said. It's also about individuals being kind, Sternberg said. And that helps everyone, not just older Americans or those with disabilities. In an ideal world, Sternberg said, 'I can actually trust this driver who is coming to pick me up to be courteous.' Madeline Mitchell's role covering women and the caregiving economy at USA TODAY is supported by a partnership with Pivotal Ventures and Journalism Funding Partners. Funders do not provide editorial input. Reach Madeline at memitchell@ and @maddiemitch_ on X.
