Tory MP appeared to make ‘offensive' Irish potato famine remark, House of Commons told
Shadow business secretary Andrew Griffith, responding to a question, said he was not sure if a person could 'subsist entirely on a seed potato' before adding it 'may have been tried historically and not with enormous success'.
Labour MP Adam Jogee said the words appeared to reference the mid-19th century tragedy, which resulted in around one million deaths after the potato crop failed in successive years.
Speaking during a Commons debate on the economy on Wednesday, Liberal Democrat MP Jamie Stone intervened to raise the seed potato industry.
He said: 'We have been crying out to get the best of Scottish seed potatoes into European markets, and therefore I do say thank you to the Government for this, it means a lot to farmers, and I have had very positive comments about it. I am being absolutely fair-minded about that.'
Advertisement
Griffith, in his reply, said: 'I am not sure if one can subsist entirely on a seed potato, I think that may have been tried historically and not with enormous success, but I congratulate the honourable member on the success of his seed potato industry.'
On Thursday, Jogee raised a point of order in connection with the remarks made by Griffith.
After Mr Jogee read out the words spoken by Griffith in the debate, one MP could be heard saying: 'Shocking.'
Jogee, who chairs the all-party parliamentary group on Ireland and the Irish in Britain, added: 'These words appear to be referencing the tragedy of the Irish potato famine which, if true, is of course offensive and insensitive and, of course, would have taken place at the time in the United Kingdom.
'So can you please advise on how best we can remedy any offence caused by outlining the process for an honourable member to withdraw such a statement?'
Deputy Speaker Judith Cummins replied: 'The chair is not responsible for the shadow secretary of state's remarks but the honourable member has put his point on the record.'
Griffith and the Conservative Party have been approached for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
41 minutes ago
- Irish Times
‘It knocked my self-belief': Adi Roche reflects on ‘shockingly dirty' presidential campaign
Former presidential candidate Adi Roche has said those running for the Áras 'need to be strong', citing her experience in a 'shockingly dirty campaign' which she said continues to haunt her. Ms Roche, who is founder and chief executive of Chernobyl Children International , ran as a Labour Party candidate in the 1997 presidential election. However, her bid was derailed by a 'politically motivated' smear campaign, she later said. Speaking to The Irish Times on Wednesday at a commemoration event of the Hiroshima bombing , Ms Roche said she is still 'haunted' by some of what happened during that time. 'It often penetrates my dreams because it knocked my confidence and my self-belief,' said the 70-year-old. READ MORE Ms Roche said prospective candidates 'need to think very carefully' before going forward. 'I had always felt, naively, that it was above and beyond the political arena, that it was a statesman's role of diplomacy, and what I learned was that it actually was the most political position of all. 'When the gloves were off, it was a shockingly dirty campaign, so I would say to anyone considering going forward, to really check with yourself how resilient you are and can be,' she said. Describing it as a 'smear campaign,' it emerged during the campaign that Ms Roche's brother, Dónal de Róiste , was dismissed from the Defence Forces in 1969. He was never officially told the reason for his forced retirement, nor did he receive a court martial, though it was suggested to him that his dismissal was because of his alleged association with republican militants. A review of his case completed in 2022 found that Mr de Róiste's departure was made 'on foot of a fundamentally flawed and unfair process and was not in accordance with the law'. He subsequently received an apology from then minister for defence Simon Coveney. [ Ex-Army lieutenant Dónal de Róiste: 'I can walk with my head high' Opens in new window ] While Fianna Fáil-backed candidate Mary McAleese went on to win the election, Ms Roche finished fourth out of five candidates. She subsequently disappeared back into her humanitarian work, she said, which helped at the time. However, it was the State apology to her brother that 'meant the world to us'. 'It restored my brother's good name and that of our family, and how dreadfully it had been used against me in my campaign,' she said. She ruled out another potential run for Áras an Uachtaráin, saying she is 'too busy' in her humanitarian work, 'between the war in Ukraine, Chernobyl and also Gaza ... there's too much going on.' Ms Roche said the next president will have a hard act to follow. 'Michael D Higgins is such a champion for the rights of our nation, for the rights of our people, and against injustice. He always has his finger on the pulse of every issue,' she said, and hopes the next president will be one of a 'similar moral compass'. Fianna Fáil and the presidency Meanwhile, asked if Fianna Fáil has approached or had meetings with any potential candidates, Taoiseach Micheál Martin said the party 'will make its decision closer the end of the month and we will take soundings over the month'. He said the party had not approached businessman and former dancer Michael Flatley. Labour backs Connolly, and Flatley jumps the shark Listen | 50:26 Speaking at a Daniel O'Connell commemoration event in Caherdaniel, Co Kerry, Mr Martin said: 'I believe the presidency doesn't necessarily belong to any one party. I believe it belongs to the people of Ireland and it's important that the person who is elected who can bring honour, and distinction to that office ... Fianna Fáil certainly will be making a contribution to that debate.' Asked about his thoughts on MMA fighter Conor McGregor's petition to change the Constitution so people can run without needing the support of four local authorities or 20 Oireachtas members, Mr Martin said, 'we will continue to adhere to the Constitution'. 'I'm not sure he [McGregor] has asked anybody – what happened in previous presidential elections. People went to county councils, some got nominations from the requisite number of county councils, so the Constitution creates a pathway there for people to secure a nomination through that route.'
The Irish Sun
41 minutes ago
- The Irish Sun
Revenue write to almost 70k Irish pensioners over incorrect tax payments amid fears envelope ‘will cause lot of concern'
Revenue is clamping down on pensioners who have owed tax since 2022 TAX TIME Revenue write to almost 70k Irish pensioners over incorrect tax payments amid fears envelope 'will cause lot of concern' REVENUE commissioners have written to almost 70,000 pensioners over concerns relating to incorrect tax payments. These retirees make up a large portion of the 260,000 individuals who Revenue claims may have been incorrectly taxed for the year 2022. 3 The Revenue commission says this campaign is not aimed explicitly at pensioners Credit: Getty Images - Getty 3 According to Revenue, over 260,000 taxpayers may have been incorrectly taxed for the year 2022 Credit: Getty Images - Getty Despite this action, the Revenue Commission says it has not launched a campaign aimed explicitly at pensioners. The letters outline steps taxpayers should take to file a correct end-of-year statement and income tax return. According to RTE, the correspondence says that the vast majority of people, including pensioners, pay the right amount of tax automatically. However, other income sources, such as "a Department of Social Protection payment or private income, Revenue may need to adjust tax credits to reflect that". Notably, social welfare payments are not taxed before they are paid out; as a result, many recipients owe tax on these payments without knowing it. For example, if a person receives a social welfare payment, such as the State pension, but has another source of income, such as a part-time job or private pension, they may owe tax on that payment. Revenue says pensioners whose sole income comes from the state pension will not be effected. Despite the presence of these letters, Revenue says that "the letters are not a demand, but part of our regular efforts to help people check if they have paid the right amount of tax, or if they are due a refund". And that where there is underpayment taxpayers will not be required to make an immediate payment. Instead, any owed funds "will be collected through a reduction of tax credits in future years". "MORE HUMANE APPROACH" CEO of Irish Rural Link Seamus Boland said these Revenue letters will cause much concern. Referencing the time revenue sent letters sent to around 115,000 pensioners in 2012, he said: "I think at that stage there was an apology made for the way people were being treated. "Hopefully this letter is not as brutal as that one was, I'm hoping it's a little softer in terms of people who have overpaid and there will be a category of people who have underpaid as well." He added: "there's lots of pensioners in this category who are going to be affected one way or the other." But that he hopes the commission might adopt a "more humane approach" this time. Revenue has yet to disclose the sums of money involved.
Irish Independent
42 minutes ago
- Irish Independent
Saoirse Hanley: The new Penneys app may change the way you shop – but there is a snag
The app is already top of the Irish shopping charts Penneys (or Primark, as it's known elsewhere) is a long-standing part of Irish culture: after all, the very first store opened on Dublin's Mary Street. It's in our DNA. It's distinct from other shops by virtue of price, certainly, but also because it has never moved its business online. Those who want to say 'thanks, I got it in Penneys' to someone who compliments their outfit get to do so with the smugness of someone who battled the masses to procure said fashion in-store.
