Lady Carbisdale locked in court battle with Scottish Government to save land from 'pylon vandalism'
The pylons are part of an SSEN plan for a 400kv Spittal to Beauly power line, which crosses into the Carbisdale Castle forests.
Samantha Kane, known as Lady Carbisdale, said she intends to fight the matter 'all the way to the Supreme Court.'
It follows previous legal action against SSEN raised at Tain Sheriff Court last year.
In a letter sent to Lady Carbisdale, which has been seen by the Press and Journal, Scottish Ministers are seeking to a remove a condition on the land which protects it from industrial projects.
Lady Carbisdale said the castle lands were transferred to Scottish Ministers in agreement they would 'look after the land and use it for agricultural and forestry use only'.
'It will not include a use to erect super-structures on the land, deliberately close to the castle,' Lady Carbisdale added.
The Scottish Government wants to remove the condition so pylons for a new power line can be installed along the grounds.
The Spittal to Beauly power line is a Scottish and Southern Electricity Networks project intended to transport the Highland's renewable energy output south to 'areas of demand.'
Scottish Ministers have lodged documents with the Lands Tribunal for Scotland to amend the land agreement's conditions.
Carbisdale Castle has an over 100-year old history but was most recently purchased by Samantha Kane back in 2022 for £1.2 million.
The Iraq-born human rights barrister then took the castle on a £10 million restoration project, which has gone through several visions over the years including as a private members club and Hanging Gardens of Babylon-style attraction.
The various projects were put on ice late last year after a dispute with Ardgay and District Community Council raised tensions into what she called a 'hate campaign' on social media, which local residents denied at the time.
Lady Carbisdale later listed the castle up for sale.
However, the latest venture is a plan to open 'the Highland's first five-star hotel' complete with 'formal landscape gardens' and swimming pool 'with glass front protruding over the Kyle.'
Lady Carbisdale said the hotel 'when it opens' will create upwards of 300 full and part-time jobs for the area.
She said: 'It is utterly insane to disassemble the restoration project and devastate the castle and it's surrounding forest and loch.'
Speaking to the P&J about the court action, Lady Carbisdale says there are alternative routes for the pylons that do not put 'this land that I call home' at risk.
She said: 'Since I received the Minster's application to try to annul the condition that protects the castle,
'I have been inundated with messages and letters of support, telling me that if the Government destroys Carbisdale, it will be an outrageous act of vandalism, vendetta and discrimination.
'The condition in the title will remain.
'Carbisdale Castle will continue standing proud, and will be the world's destination, to visit and enjoy and will benefit the community for generations to come.'
In response to the case, a Scottish Government spokesperson said: 'It would be inappropriate to comment on ongoing legal proceedings.'
The Lands Tribunal for Scotland said no hearing date has yet been set because the case is 'at a very early stage.'
They added: 'We can confirm an application has been received from Scottish Ministers and the respondents are in the process of being notified.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
an hour ago
- The National
Titans of movement didn't get headlines that they deserved
The focus on her and Alex Salmond detracted from the publication of a biography of Neil MacCormick and the sad passing of George Reid. Their contributions to the national cause, especially during very challenging periods, are incalculable. Both were knighted, causing a minor furore among some but the recognition was for their sterling efforts in academia and civic life, not their political activity. Besides, if it made them and their families happy, who could begrudge them considering what both gave to our cause. I was fortunate to know both and be educated and mentored by them in many ways. While Neil's biography was mentioned in legal circles and George's death reported, neither was given the prominence they deserved. Such is the price even for titans for our cause, with the media largely controlled from another land and through a London prism. Neil was my lecturer in Jurisprudence when I attended Edinburgh University in 1976 and where four years before he had been appointed Chair of Public Law at the age of only 31. It was an early elevation but fully merited for someone who had graduated from both Glasgow and Oxford, serving as president of the union at the latter, as well as teaching at both Balliol College and Dundee. But Neil was no single-minded academic, as the book brings out. If not a child prodigy, he was certainly a polymath with a huge hinterland. The son of the great John MacCormick, he was born into a nationalist household. But with his mother was active as a social worker in deprived parts of Glasgow, it was also tempered with a belief in social justice. That upbringing made the social democrat he became. I knocked doors for him in 1979 when he stood as SNP candidate in Edinburgh North an election where the SNP toiled in the fallout from the Scottish Assembly debacle. I'd get to know him better in coming years, especially when he was elected to the European Parliament in 1999 – a fitting destination for someone who had contested so many seats unsuccessfully before, often just flying the flag with no prospects of success. READ MORE: Alex Salmond's widow suing Scottish Government over sexual harassment probe Such were the times then, even for greats such as Neil, that their individual talents were unable to buck a tide towards an opponent of far less ability. Moreover, his support for Europe was well known, even publicly disagreeing with the party line of opposing membership in the 1975 European Economic Community referendum. A huge admirer of Alex Salmond, I recall him saying 'cometh the hour, cometh the man' and he would act as a special adviser to Alex when the SNP first entered government in 2007. His wise counsel also appreciated by me as justice secretary. Tragically dying far too young in 2009, thankfully Neil still saw the restoration of the Scottish Parliament his family had fought for for so long and the attaining of government for the party he'd given so much to. Neil's biography's, Neil MacCormick A Life in Politics, Philosophy and Law, was written by an Australian academic, an indictment on our land. But Professor Maksymilian Del Mar clearly hugely admires Neil's philosophical and jurisprudential work. READ MORE: 'A lad o' pairts who revelled in being of use': An obituary of George Reid Aside from a few errors, the commentary and detailing of Neil's political life is both fair and accurate and I'd forgotten his pivotal role in the rapprochement resolving the 79 Group expulsion. The book captures the intellect, decency and bonhomie of a truly great man. Sections on his academic life and work are challenging. I sat with a dictionary at my side and Googled philosophical and jurisprudential concepts and phrases. But it just made me smile. The failing was all mine and the genius of the man is acknowledged by his peers as the writer details. George Reid, meanwhile, was from a humble background in Tullibody. He came to national attention in 1974 when he won the Clackmannan and East Stirling seat in the February General Election, showing the SNP could win in what until then had been considered Labour heartlands. Having had a successful career as a TV journalist before his election, after defeat in 1979 George went off to work in communications for the International Red Cross. His work, especially in earthquake-devastated Armenia won global plaudits. Returning to Scotland in the Constitutional Convention, George (below) was recruited by Alex Salmond for the push for a Scottish Parliament and to stand for it. His speech on the Iraq war, both passionate and forged from experience, remains one of the finest ever given in the Chamber. George became presiding officer in 2003 at a difficult time with the fledgling institution tarnished by the building fiasco and other failings. But he stabilised the political wobbles and resolving the building's construction issues, his gravitas restoring faith in the Parliament. I recall a Tartan Day in New York where he oozed class, resplendent in his kilt and every inch the consummate statesman, a sharp contrast to the then first minister Jack McConnell. In our movement we stand on the shoulders of giants. Greats who proved their genius and talents in many fields and who we were blessed in supporting our cause. Both Neil and George rest in the pantheon of independence greats and must remembered.
The National
an hour ago
- The National
I can take on 'climate change denying' Farage in TV debates, says Lorna Slater
The Lothian region MSP is the only incumbent co-leader taking part in the contest, after Patrick Harvie announced he was stepping back ahead of the looming Holyrood ballot in 2026. Slater, fellow MSPs Gillian Mackay and Ross Greer, and Dominic Ashmole are all vying for the two co-leader positions, with the results due to be published on Friday August 29. Speaking to The National, Slater said it is critical to keep climate change on the political agenda – particularly with the rise of outright "denial" from Reform and the Scottish Conservatives. READ MORE: Police Scotland 'breaching human rights to subdue Palestine protests' 'With the Tories now having gone from climate sceptic to climate denial under Russell Findlay and Reform in that place as well, it's going to make it much harder to do,' she said. 'It's wild to me that I can go into my place of work and be called a dangerous extremist for repeating what climate scientists say. 'That's where we are, and it's a very upsetting place for Scotland to be.' Slater said that, in her opinion, one of the reasons the Bute House Agreement collapsed was that while there is a pro-independence majority in Holyrood, there is no consensus on tackling climate change. Since the Greens left government, Slater accused the SNP of 'dialling back' on climate commitments. From watering down the heat and buildings bill to 'prevaricating' over publishing the long-awaited energy strategy because they are not 'brave enough' to explicitly state there should be no more oil and gas, Slater said the Scottish Government was 'not doing enough' to tackle emissions. Slater has served as co-leader since 2019 (Image: Jane Barlow/PA Wire) The former Greens minister gained praise for her performance during televised debates at the last election, and said that this was one of the many reasons she wanted to take on the top job again, to make the case for tackling climate change in the face of far-right talking points. 'I've got the confidence to take on Nigel Farage and Russell Findlay and all the others in terms of setting that out, because they are the dangerous extremists for denying that climate change is happening and that we need to make serious, serious changes to how we get about, to how our industries emit, to how we use our land in Scotland in order to preserve the future for young people,' Slater said. With Reform being an inevitable part of the 2026 Holyrood campaign, Slater said she fears it will pull other parties 'to the right because they'll be afraid of losing voters'. She added: 'The Scottish Greens are a different cup of tea. We're a values based party. We know what we believe. 'Our goal is to try and persuade people that what we believe can be implemented and will make Scotland a better place. We're not going to shift where we sit on the political spectrum in the hopes of winning votes.' Despite the collapse of Bute House Agreement in April 2024, Slater describes the power sharing agreement as 'brilliant', particularly due to the number of Green policies the party were able to enact before former first minister Humza Yousaf ended the deal. READ MORE: SNP councillor hits back at 'lie' he defected to Reform UK She firmly believes that while the Greens should have an activist element to their party, they should focus on the political, and that the party should 'build on its successes'. 'The unique thing that we can do, that other parts of the Green movement can't, is make changes to legislation…is negotiate with the party of government…is influence budgets,' she said. 'Therefore we need to focus our time and efforts on those things. So yes, I'm absolutely at the political end of that. 'We are a political party. We win seats in councils and in the Scottish Parliament in order to influence the future of Scotland politically. 'I think the Scottish Greens have done very well at that – things like rolling out free school meals to more children, free bus travel for young people, changing the taxation structure of Scotland to make it more fair, and then using that money to really invest in public services. 'That has changed the nature of Scotland. You can look at the differences between Scotland and England to see some of those effects, and we want to continue that going forward.' On independence, Slater was firm in her belief that John Swinney's strategy is 'nonsense', as an SNP majority does not guarantee a referendum, particularly as Prime Minister Keir Starmer had not agreed to those terms. Starmer has repeatedly said he would not allow a referendum to go ahead. She insisted that a pro-independence majority does make the case for allowing Scotland to decide, and that because it is important to so many people in Scotland it still 'needs to be part of the discussion'. Slater said: 'Over and over again, you'll hear the Unionist parties hoping that we'll forget about it, because they're like, 'We don't let them have a referendum, they'll forget about it and it will go away'. 'It's not going to go away.'
The National
an hour ago
- The National
MoD slammed after ministers not told about US troops on Scottish soil
Last year, it emerged that a new base in Lossiemouth, in Moray, would host American Poseidon P8 anti-submarine spy and war planes. When the site opened in May 2024, it became the first time the US military had a presence in Scotland since the end of the Cold War. The Scottish Greens raised concerns that the move signalled the UK Government forging 'closer military relations' with Donald Trump while he is cosying up to Russian president Vladimir Putin. Stop the War said that the decision to allow US troops to be stationed in Scotland without consulting Holyrood should be 'condemned'. READ MORE: Police Scotland 'breaching human rights to subdue Palestine protests' The National lodged a Freedom of Information (FOI) request with the Scottish Government for any correspondence from the MoD regarding the decision to allow US troops to have a presence in Scotland. 'The Scottish Government does not hold the information you have requested, as matters relating to Defence are reserved to the UK Government,' the response from an official in the Veteran's Unit said. 'As a result, this information is not shared with the Scottish Government. As such, I hereby provide you with formal notice under section 17(1) of FOISA that the Scottish Government does not have the information you have requested.' The MoD previously refuted any suggestion there was a US military base in Scotland, following an investigation by the Ferret. Instead they insisted it was a US 'presence' with a 'US naval detachment' at Lossiemouth. The US navy helped to fund the construction of the new facility where its war planes will be housed, and are set to work alongside UK aircraft. Arianne Burgess, the Scottish Greens MSP who represents the area covering Lossiemouth, said: "A lot of local people will be shocked by these revelations and with the lack of any announcement or basic information. (Image: AP) "The last thing we should be doing is forging even closer military relations with Donald Trump, especially at a time when he is cozying up to Putin and arming genocide against the people of Gaza. "It's time for the Ministry of Defence to level with people and come clean about its arrangements. "With Keir Starmer seemingly joined at the hip with the White House it's more important than ever that Scotland forges its own foreign policy based on human rights, peace and a rejection of the values of Donald Trump." A spokesperson for Stop the War said that there should be 'no US troops or weapons on UK soil'. 'They do not make us any safer from the threats that the warmonger politicians are so enthusiastic about talking up in order to justify increases in defence spending while cutting welfare and hitting the most vulnerable in society the hardest,' they added. READ MORE: SNP councillor hits back at 'lie' he defected to Reform UK 'That the MoD has stationed US troops at RAF Lossiemouth without consultation with Holyrood is of course to be condemned, but comes as no surprise given the Westminster government also allowed US nuclear weapons to be placed at RAF Lakenheath in Suffolk without any transparency or debate in Parliament." A spokesperson for the MoD said: "The United States is the UK's closest defence and security partner. As NATO allies, we regularly conduct exercises and operations together to support European and global security. "Defence supports hundreds of thousands of high-skilled jobs across the UK, including over 26,000 in Scotland." US troops had been based in Scotland since the 1960s, including nuclear armed submarines at Holy Loch on the Clyde. After the Cold War ended in 1991, US forces left Holy Loch in 1992. They then left Machranish on the Mull of Kintyre, where nuclear mines were housed, in 1995, and Edzell in Aberdeenshire, a signals intelligence network, in 1997. It comes amid concerns that Trump is in favour of a Russian land grab to end the war in Ukraine, following a meeting with Putin in Alaska. Following the summit, the US President suggested he wants to move straight to a full peace deal, rather than negotiating a ceasefire first. The shift in Trump's position appears to echo the Russians' refusal to agree to a ceasefire before engaging in peace talks. Ukrainian president Vlodymyr Zelenskyy is set to visit the US on Monday, and is set to take UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer and top European leaders with him to DC for crunch talks with the US President.
