Prosecution did not prove case in Canada hockey sex assault trial: judge
The accused -- who all previously played in the National Hockey League -- stood trial over allegations they assaulted the woman in a hotel room following a June 2018 celebration for a national men's junior team.
Michael McLeod, Alex Formenton, Dillon Dube, Carter Hart and Callan Foote denied wrongdoing, insisting the accuser -- whose identity is protected -- consented to a variety of sex acts in a London, Ontario hotel room.
"Having found that I cannot rely upon the evidence of (the complainant) and then considering the evidence in this trial as a whole, I conclude that the crown cannot meet its onus as on any of the counts before me," Superior Court Justice Maria Carroccia told a packed court room.
"I do not find the evidence of EM to be either credible or reliable," the judge further said.
The complainant, 20 at the time, met McLeod at a bar in London before having sex with him.
That initial encounter was not at issue in the trial, which focused on events that occurred after McLeod messaged a team-wide group chat asking if anyone was interested in a "three-way."
Prosecutors argued the players engaged in sex acts with the complainant without taking steps to ensure her consent.
Defense lawyers said the woman willingly participated and only made the assault allegations after regretting her choices.
Criminal trials in Canada are often decided by a jury, but the case shifted to a judge-only trial after two juries were dismissed.
An initial police investigation into the allegations produced no charges.
But subsequent media probes revealed Hockey Canada, a governing body, used funds from subscription fees paid by ordinary families for a $3.55 million CAD ($2.6 million USD) out-of-court settlement with the woman, forcing the resignation of Hockey Canada's leadership.
London police re-opened the case, and brought charges against the players last year.
The case, which focused on the evolving definition of consent under the law has been one of the most closely-watched in recent Canadian history and sparked debate about culture in hockey, the cherished national sport.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
15 hours ago
- News.com.au
Sri Lankan cricket star cleared of assaulting Tinder date shows off his new girlfriend
Sri Lankan cricket star Danushka Gunathilaka, who was cleared of sexually assaulting a woman Down Under, has poked fun at the court case as he flaunted his new girlfriend on social media. Gunathilaka was arrested in November 2022 and charged with allegedly sexually assaulting a Tinder date while in Sydney. The 34-year-old was part of the Sri Lankan side Down Under for the T20 World Cup. He was accused of stealthing – removing a condom without consent – during a sexual encounter with a female in Sydney's eastern suburbs. He was acquitted the following year during a judge-alone trial. Since then, he returned to Sri Lanka and restarted his cricket career, but hasn't made it back into the national team since. And on Friday, Gunathilaka took his chance to poke fun at the ordeal as he debuted his new relationship on Instagram. 'I'm not sure what's more terrifying, the wedding or the potential for a future court date. Send wine … and maybe a lawyer referral, ' he wrote, alongside a photo carousel of him and his new flame. Fans were quick to celebrate the cricket star's new love interest. 'Looking beautiful together,' one wrote. 'Good luck man,' another said. While others were greatly amused by the caption writing 'cheeky caption' and 'cheeky cheeky boy'. Gunathilaka was supported during his trial by his girlfriend Celine, but the post suggests the pair quietly went their separate ways in the months that followed. What happened during Gunathilaka's trial Gunathilaka was arrested in the early hours of November 6 at the Hyatt Regency and taken to Day Street Police Station, where he answered questions for more than two hours. During his recorded interview, the cricketer became emotional as he spoke about a spiritual conversation he had with the alleged victim, where she said she had the power to 'see the future'. He told police he was 'interested' as he was a Buddhist. 'We were talking about religious things … she can see in a past life and we chatted about that kind of stuff,' he said in the interview as he broke down in tears. Gunathilaka told officers he asked the woman to tell him about his past life. He said she told him they used to be neighbours in Thailand. The cricketer told police he became scared and 'got a feeling' the woman was 'a bit weird', prompting him to leave. She ordered him a taxi. During his trial, he was asked if at any point he put his penis 'into her without a condom on'. 'No, no, definitely not,' Mr Gunathilaka replied. In the end, Judge Sarah Huggett described aspects of the police's handling of the woman's complaint as 'deeply troubling' and acquitted the Sri Lankan cricketer. 'Aspects of the handling of her complaint were far from satisfactory and, to be frank, very concerning,' she said. In particular, it was said that notes taken by officers during the woman's first interview with police 'make no record of an offence of stealthing'. She also said that 'for no good reason at all, those notes were destroyed.'
ABC News
a day ago
- ABC News
Five Canadian ice hockey players have been acquitted of sexual assault. What happened?
Five former members of Canada's world junior hockey team were this week acquitted in their high-profile sexual assault case. An Ontario judge said prosecutors could not meet the onus of proof for the charges against the men — four of whom were active NHL players. The players' identities were kept hidden for years after a police investigation into the incident was closed without charges in 2019. But, after reports that Hockey Canada used players' registration fees to pay an undisclosed settlement to the woman who made the accusations, the case was reopened and made public. How did it all go down? Here's what we know. Michael McLeod, Alex Formenton, Dillon Dube, Carter Hart and Cal Foote were each found not guilty this week of sexually assaulting a woman in a hotel room after a Hockey Canada gala in 2018 to celebrate the team's world junior championship victory. All five former National Hockey League (NHL) players faced one count of sexual assault, while McLeod faced an additional count of being a party to an offence. They all pleaded not guilty. The woman — known publicly as just EM under Canadian law — testified that a one-night stand with Michael McLeod turned into a group sexual assault. The defence's case centred around the EM's credibility — she spent nine days testifying in the witness box. None of the five men accused took the stand. Ontario Superior Court Justice Maria Carroccia cleared all five men, telling the courtroom that she did not find the complainant's evidence to be "credible or reliable" and that the Crown failed to prove she did not consent to the sexual activity. EM testified that she was naked, drunk and scared when four of the men showed up unexpectedly in her room at the Delta Hotel London Armouries in London, Ontario and felt the only "safe" option was to do what they wanted. "I made the choice to dance with them and drink at the bar, I did not make the choice to have them do what they did back at the hotel," she testified. Prosecutors argued the players did what they wanted without taking steps to ensure she was voluntarily consenting to sexual acts. Years of speculation regarding the allegations — fuelled by a lawsuit settlement, parliamentary hearings and revived investigations by the police and Hockey Canada, along with an NHL investigation — all preceded the complex trial, which began in April and included a mistrial and the dismissal of the jury, leaving the verdict to Judge Carroccia. A police investigation into the alleged incident was closed without charges in February 2019, but investigators reopened it in July 2022 in response to public outrage over reports that Hockey Canada used players' registration fees to pay an undisclosed settlement to the woman who made the accusations. At the time, the public still didn't know of the allegations or the players' identities. In July 2022, Hockey Canada executives told a House of Commons committee that the organisation had paid $CAD8.9 million ($9.8 million) for sexual abuse settlements to 21 complainants since 1989. The scandal prompted the Canadian federal government to freeze Hockey Canada's funding for 10 months while a number of major companies either paused or cancelled their sponsorships with the national governing body. Hockey Canada said it would no longer use a fund financed by player registration fees to settle sexual assault claims, and the organisation's CEO Scott Smith and board of directors stepped down. In 2023, Hockey Canada said an independent adjudicative panel held a hearing on whether certain members of the 2018 national junior team breached the organisation's code of conduct, and if so, what sanctions should be imposed against those players. The players' identities were made public when they were charged in early 2024. The high-profile case sparked a debate in Canada over ice hockey culture, consent and sexual assault. Outside of the courtroom, a crowd of supporters gathered as the verdict was handed down. Fabienne Haller, who held a sign reading "Thank you EM for your courage", told CTV News she was "devastated" at the ruling. "I'm a woman, and I have been in a situation where I can somewhat relate," she said. "I'm devastated because I understand." Karen Bellehumeur, EM's lawyer, told reporters her client — who was not in the courtroom on Thursday but watched remotely — was devastated. "She's obviously very disappointed with the verdict and very disappointed with Her Honor's assessment of her honesty and reliability," Ms Bellehumeur said. "She's really never experienced not being believed like this before. Four of the players were active NHL players when they were charged by police in 2024, which came shortly after they took leave from their respective teams, while Formenton was playing in Switzerland at the time. Following the verdict, the NHL said the players, who are now all between the ages of 25 and 27, are not allowed to sign with a team while it reviews the judge's findings. "The allegations made in this case, even if not determined to have been criminal, were very disturbing and the behaviour at issue was unacceptable," the NHL said in a statement "We will be reviewing and considering the judge's findings. While we conduct that analysis and determine next steps, the players charged in this case are ineligible to play in the league." The National Hockey League Players' Association (NHLPA) said ruling the players ineligible during the review is inconsistent with the collective bargaining agreement. "After missing more than a full season of their respective NHL careers, they should now have the opportunity to return to work," the NHLPA said in a statement. "The NHL's declaration that the players are 'ineligible' to play pending its further analysis of the court's findings is inconsistent with the discipline procedures set forth in the CBA." ABC/wires
Sydney Morning Herald
2 days ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
‘Ridiculous': Hong Kong places bounty on Australian professor
An Australian pro-democracy academic has labelled a warrant for his arrest by Hong Kong's national security police as 'ridiculous', as authorities there pursue 19 overseas-based members of what they describe as a subversive organisation. University of Technology Sydney China studies professor Dr Feng Chongyi – who in 2017 was detained for 10 days while on a research trip to China – now has a bounty on him over his involvement in an unofficial pro-democracy group, Hong Kong Parliament. He is accused of helping to organise or participate in the largely Canada-based group, which authorities in Hong Kong say aimed to subvert state power under a national security law that China imposed on the territory in 2020, following months of pro-democracy protests the year before. Feng and the others are accused of having launched a referendum or run as candidates in the unofficial 'Hong Kong Parliament' group, which authorities say aims at achieving self-determination and drafting a 'Hong Kong constitution'. Hong Kong police said the organisation sought to overthrow the governments of China and Hong Kong by unlawful means, that they were still investigating, and further arrests could follow. Loading Regarding its 'election' process, the Hong Kong Parliament group has said on social media that it drew about 15,700 valid votes through mobile app and online voting systems. It said the candidates and elected members came from around the world including Taiwan, Thailand, Australia, the US, Canada and the UK. Feng isn't from Hong Kong, but said he had agreed to join the group as an academic. 'It's certainly ridiculous, it does not offend me in any sense … they've got the power, they've got the influence overseas, they want to control everything even overseas,' Feng told this masthead on Saturday.
