Ethical questions surround the NHS sampling babies' DNA
In line with previous predictions, when individuals who submitted to a PCR test (which amplifies genetic material) during Covid-19 had their DNA sold for profit without their consent, infants now face their private, personal, biological data being captured, stored and used by who-knows-what corporations on behalf of the NHS.
Not everyone wants to know what potential diseases they might suffer from in the future, especially if there is no known treatment. And for what purposes might it be used, other than 'prediction of disease risk'? Testing of new drugs? Testing of vaccines? Clearly an infant cannot give consent to its DNA being used for these purposes and research on children is unethical unless they stand to benefit. Will parents have the opportunity to give informed consent and can it even be informed if they are unaware of the many potential uses of the material?
A global genomics market of $32.65bn in 2023 suggests that this is big business. Genomics England already makes available patients' genomic data to businesses.
The association with AI additionally raises the spectre of surveillance in the form of digital IDs, incorporating not only biometric data, such as fingerprints, retinal scans and facial recognition, but potentially even the human genome itself. The NHS data of 57 million patients has already been used to train AI outside of the intended purpose.
Will doctors recognise these risks and take steps to inform patients? Or will technology roll on regardless?Janet MenageRetired GP, Llanybydder, Ceredigion
Have an opinion on anything you've read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
26 minutes ago
- The Independent
8 best hypochlorous acid sprays to cleanse and soothe, tested by a beauty expert
Want to give your skincare routine a boost? The best hypochlorous acid sprays offer multifunctional benefits, from calming inflammation to minimising breakouts. The versatile mists lend a hand when it comes to banishing germs and bacteria. Originally used in medical settings, skin expert Dr Lauren Jamieson explains that they 'can be used for wound care, skincare, skin cleansing before procedures and general disinfection.' But while the medical applications of hypochlorous acid (HOCl) long predate its popularity in the world of beauty, the industry is catching up. Brands like Mario Badescu Tower 28, and Kanzen have all launched hypochlorous acid mists, combining the acid with other skin-loving ingredients. The claim is that the antibacterial properties in the acid can stop breakouts before they start, and ease skin conditions like eczema and rosacea. With so many brands making formulas – and as claims about the benefits of hypochlorous acid get more and more outlandish – it can be hard to work out which of these sprays actually lives up to its marketing. As more and more makeup brands jump on the bandwagon, I went to work separating the good formulas from the bad. Scroll on for my top picks, with suggestions for every skin type and budget. How I tested For several months, I tested the following hypochlorous acids in multiple situations, including after the gym (pictured), over makeup and when my skin was breaking out. During this period, I paid attention to the following: Odour: Hypochlorous acid is related to chlorine and often smells similar, but the best formulas cleverly mask this swimming pool scent. Sensitivity: As a product designed to soothe irritated skin and benefit those with damaged skin barriers, I ensured all the formulas featured were gentle, no matter how frequently they were applied. Results: It can take a minimum of six weeks to see reliable results from a single product, which is why I used these sprays for months. I noted any differences in my skin and recorded any brands that stood out from an anti-inflammatory perspective. Value for money: Taking into account size, cost, packaging (including pump and spray dispensers) and ingredients, I weighed up which formulas had the most to offer. Why you can trust IndyBest reviews Lucy Smith has been reviewing beauty products for IndyBest since July 2024, covering everything from the best micellar waters to the best hyaluronic acid serums. When it comes to face mists, she's on top of the latest trends, and reviewed Rhode's glazing mist when it launched earlier this year. She's also experienced symptoms of rosacea on her face, so she was perfectly placed to assess the claims of these hypochlorous sprays. The best hypochlorous acid sprays for 2025 are:
The Independent
26 minutes ago
- The Independent
The popular A-level subject that the UK isn't very good at
Mathematics at A-level is going from strength to strength. Maths is the most popular subject choice, and further maths, which is a separate A-level course, has seen the most growth in uptake. Despite this, concerns still remain about the mathematical skills of young people who do not choose to study maths after they are 16. Students in England who have passed GCSE maths at grade four or above, but who are not taking A-level or AS-level maths, are eligible to take a core maths qualification. Core maths was introduced in 2014-15 to attempt to remedy a lack in mathematics education after 16. But the number of entries remains well short of what they could be. Many students who would benefit from maths after 16 are not taking this subject. A 2010 report from the Nuffield Foundation found that students in the UK lag behind their peers in other countries in participation in mathematics after the age of 16. Further research from the Royal Society and higher education charity AdvanceHE showed that, as a consequence, many were not well prepared for the demands of their university courses or careers. Survey data has also found that over half of UK adults' maths skills are low. Many courses at university include mathematical or quantitative elements, but do not require AS or A-level maths for entry. These include psychology, geography, business and management, sociology, health sciences, biology, education and IT. When many students have not studied mathematics since GCSE, this results in a lack of fluency and confidence in using and applying it. Core maths consolidates and builds on students' mathematical understanding. The focus is on using and applying mathematics to authentic problems drawn from study, work and life. This includes understanding and using graphs, statistics and tools such as spreadsheets, as well as understanding risk and probability. Take-up remains low despite incentives – schools receive an additional £900 in funding for each student who studies core maths. In 2025, 15,327 students took core maths – a 20% increase on 12,810 entries in 2024, which is very encouraging. However, research from the Royal Society in 2022 found that fewer than 10% of the number of A-level students who were not taking A-level mathematics had taken core maths, which will not have changed significantly even with the current numbers. Increasing enrolment There remains a strong commitment from the government to increasing participation in mathematics after 16 in England through core maths. Many schools and colleges have embraced the subject, and universities have expressed support too. However, a real incentive for teenagers to study this subject would be if it was rewarded in entry to university. Universities can allow students entry to a course with lower A-level grade profiles than normally required if they also passed core maths, for instance. But the number of universities making this kind of offer is low. Schools and colleges need stronger signals from universities to induce them to offer students the opportunity to study for a core maths qualification, and to encourage their students to do so. Shifting today's landscape to one where the vast majority of learners aged 16 to 19 in England are studying some form of mathematics which is relevant to their current and future interests and needs will require reform. The Royal Society's 2024 report on mathematical and data education sets out several reforms necessary to develop the mass mathematical, quantitative and data skills needed for the careers of the future. These include compulsory maths and data education in some form until 18. Extending the take-up of core maths would be an excellent way to begin achieving this. Paul Glaister CBE is a Professor of Mathematics and Mathematics Education at the University of Reading.
BBC News
26 minutes ago
- BBC News
Man recovering after 40ft fall at North Yorkshire beauty spot
A man who fell 40ft (12m) after slipping on a footpath at a North Yorkshire beauty spot has said medics "couldn't believe" he survived without significant Hoyle, from Hull, fell from the path at Beck Hole, near Thomason Foss waterfall, on was rescued by members of the Scarborough and Ryedale Mountain Rescue Team (SRMRT) before being taken to hospital where he was treated for cuts and the volunteers, his mother, Kayleigh Hoyle said: "If they weren't there, what would have happened? You just don't know, do you?" Marshall said a friend who had witnessed the fall said he had landed on a thick tree branch with boulders beneath it."I snapped it clean in half," he said."If that wasn't there we wouldn't be having this conversation now, without a doubt." Recalling the incident, Marshall added: "The last thing I remember was grabbing onto the floor and anything I could get my hands on, falling for a split second and then waking up with a local holding my neck in place just in case it was broken."He said he had felt "pure relief" when the first emergency responders arrived, saying members of the SRMRT had been "so helpful, talking to me, having a bit of a laugh".After undergoing a series of scans in hospital, he said medics "couldn't believe that I haven't broken one bone". Mrs Hoyle said when her son had called her from hospital at first she thought he was joking but when she realised he was not said she and her husband "were just sat at home in sheer terror really, fearing the worst."She said it had been an emotional ordeal, saying: "You don't ever think about your children falling 40ft." A spokesperson for SRMRT said members had arrived on the scene at about 15:10 BST to provide an initial assessment and medical treatment before paramedics said it had been a "difficult extraction down stream, then up out of the steep gorge," adding that they wished Marshall a "speedy recovery". Listen to highlights from North Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North.
