Amit Shah must take responsibility for ‘security lapse' at Pahalgam: Mallikarjun Kharge in Rajya Sabha
Participating in the "Special discussion on India's strong, successful and decisive 'Operation Sindoor' in response to terrorist attack in Pahalgam" in the Rajya Sabha, he attacked the government citing Jammu and Kashmir Lt Governor Manoj Sinha's statement admitting to the security lapses that led to the terror attack.
Mr. Kharge also questioned the silence of Prime Minister Narendra Modi on U.S. President Donald Trump's repeated claims of mediation and brokering a ceasefire with Pakistan, and asked whether India had accepted a third-party mediation with Pakistan.
"India's strategic interests were not secured despite Howdy Modi, Namaste Trump, because nobody stood by you despite such deep friendship. No country, not even the U.S. openly condemned Pakistan. This shows nobody supported you...," Mr. Kharge said.
He asked why India did not object to economic packages for Pakistan by the World Bank and the IMF.
The leader of opposition posed four questions to the government, asking why India accepted a ceasefire even when Pakistan was on the backfoot and what are the terms of the ceasefire. He also asked whether U.S. intervened during Operation Sindoor and at whose behest was that done.
The Congress president asked whether the operation against Pakistan was halted on the threat of trade, as claimed by Trump repeatedly.
"Did the U.S. President broker this ceasefire as he is repeatedly claiming, and if so, isn't this against India's no-third party mediation policy?," Mr. Kharge said.
Mr. Kharge said the government should release a report on the Pahalgam terror attack, as was done after the Kargil war.
The Congress president took a jibe at PM Narendra Modi's unscheduled visit to Pakistan in 2015, and said foreign policy is not 'event-baazi', urging the government to formulate a proper policy.
"Here we (Congress) criticise (Pakistan) and there you go to their daawat and embrace them," Mr. Kharge said, using the term "Vishwa Guru" without naming the PM.
Mr. Kharge questioned the Prime Minister's silence when BJP MPs and Ministers insult the country's armed forces, and also criticised the BJP for eulogising PM Modi and treating him like God, noting that democratically-elected people should be respected but should not be equated to God.
He said the government has not drawn any lessons from the repeated terror attacks that have taken place in Kashmir and other parts of the country.
"Uri and Pathankot terrorist attacks in 2016, Pulwama in 2019 and now Pahalgam in 2025. All these incidents make it clear that there is a recurring intelligence failure and failure in national security," said Mr. Kharge.
He then posed direct questions to Amit Shah, "I would like to ask the Home Minister, who is responsible for this? What did you do to rectify the mistake?I would like to ask the Home Minister, that who is responsible for this? Vacate your post if you are. If no, what action is the PM taking?" Demanding accountability, Mr. Kharge said the government should admit its 'lapses' and 'failure' in stopping terror attacks.
He asked if Jammu and Kashmir Lt Governor's statement on security lapses was aimed at "saving" the home minister.
"Jammu Kashmir LG Manoj Sinha himself admitted that Pahalgam was a security lapse and what happened in Pahalgam was unfortunate, innocent people were brutally killed. (Sinha said) I take all responsibility for the incident.
"However, the Home Minister must take responsibility for security lapse not the LG," Mr. Kharge said.
He asked when the accountability will be fixed and also accused the Modi govt of being arrogant, and not responding to letters by opposition.
Mr. Kharge also questioned how terrorists were able to carry out the Pahalgam attack after entering India, while citing claims of the government that terrorist infrastructure has been crippled in the country.
Citing media reports, the Congress president said even as the Prime Minister was silent, three key security officials made important disclosures.
He referred to reports quoting Chief of Defence Staff (CDS) General Anil Chauhan in Singapore saying "tactical mistakes were made during the first two days of the operation", and sought to know the government's views regarding it.
Mr. Kharge further cited a report quoting the defence attache in Indonesia as saying that political constraints hampered military decision-making.
He said if no Indian fighter jet has been downed, the Prime Minister should tell the country. He further asked why the PM is silent on Trump's claim on ceasefire and the media reports about downed fighter jets.
Mr. Kharge asked if there was any intelligence about the terror attack in Pahalgam, as Prime Minister Modi cancelled his scheduled visit to Kashmir three days before the attack.
"Was there intelligence about an attack? If so, why were tourists and pilgrims allowed?" the Congress chief asked.
He claimed that the government failed to take adequate steps to protect Indians living along border from Pakistan shelling during Operation Sindoor.
Mr. Kharge said the government should find and eradicate remaining terrorists behind Pahalgam attack.
Mr. Kharge said the PM should have been present at all-party meet instead of campaigning in Bihar, and questioned Modi's sincerity towards national security.
"Why was PM Modi not present. Where was he? We attend the meeting (on Pahalgam) while the PM does campaigning in Bihar. Is this your (PM's) patriotism?. He (PM) should have sat in both the Houses (of Parliament) today and heard. If you do not have the ability to listen, you are not worthy of occupying that Chair," Mr. Kharge said.
The Congress president said not a single public sector defence company came up during the present government's rule, while highlighting his party's contribution towards building the nation.
"Tell the truth, listen to the truth, only then something will come out of this," Mr. Kharge said.
He claimed that INDIA parties stood strongly behind armed forces action in Operation Sindoor, unanimously lauded them and supported govt in national interest.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
11 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Mamata slams Shah for SIR: ‘Show your parents' birth certificates first
In a scathing attack on the BJP and Union Home Minister over the detention and deportation of Bengali migrants and the controversial Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls, West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee on Wednesday challenged Amit Shah to produce the birth certificates of his parents. Addressing a Bhasha Andolan rally in tribal-dominated Jhargram, the TMC supremo alleged that SIR, which was recently conducted by the Election Commission in poll-bound Bihar, was a backdoor way of implementing the NRC (National Register of Citizens) in the country 'to systematically disenfranchise minorities, tribals, and opposition supporters'. 'They (ECI) are asking for the birth certificates of people's parents. Where will they get those from? I want to ask today. Do BJP leaders themselves have their parents' birth certificates? Mr Amit Shah, arrest me if I am wrong. Do you have your parents' birth certificates? Show that first. Then talk about removing people's names from the voters' list. When BJP leaders come here, we will hit the streets and protest,' she said. 'Previously, children were born at home. Where will the certificate come from? Now everything is based on 2002. Those who are demanding this, do they have their birth certificates,' she asked. Calling the citizenship notices issued to two West Bengal residents by the BJP government in Assam, 'unconstitutional and illegal', the chief minister said: 'Notices are being served to members of the Tapashili and Rajbanshi communities from Assam… We strongly condemn this. This is a veiled attempt to implement NRC. Shame on the BJP.' 'People are committing suicide out of fear of the NRC. Who will take responsibility for this? Tribals, minorities, and Tapashilis are facing persecution across the country. If they try to snatch away the rights of the people, they'll have to go over our bodies,' the chief minister asserted, urging people not to respond to the notices. 'This conspiracy of implementing the NRC through the back door will not be tolerated. We will not give up an inch of land without a fight. How dare they serve NRC notices to people here? Do not respond to those notices. Live here in Bengal peacefully,' the chief minister said. Mamata also threatened to take up the issue of persecution of Bengalis at global forums if it didn't stop immediately. 'If they remove the names of genuine Bengalis from the electoral rolls, I will travel the world and expose their (BJP's) true faces,' Banerjee warned. 'I never speak about our country to the outside world. But if this continues, I will not remain silent. If Bengal faces atrocities, I will tell the whole world how this government is torturing us,' she said, after taking part in a 3-km-long protest march. Referring to BJP IT Cell chief Amit Malviya's comment that there is no language called Bengali, the TMC supremo said if the Opposition party leaders attack the Bengali language or Bengal's people, she will not stay silent. 'Who gave birth to India's freedom struggle and social awakening? Without Bengal, neither India nor the world can move forward. Bengal's talent is spread across the globe. And what are you doing today?' she said. Drawing from history to bolster her point, the TMC chief said, 'Today, if someone speaks Bengali, they are jailed and labelled as Bangladeshi or Rohingya. I want to ask them, in which language did Rabindranath Tagore, Kazi Nazrul Islam, Netaji, Swami Vivekananda, and Raja Ram Mohan Roy speak? In which language was the National Anthem written? Who composed our National Song?' The Bengal BJP condemned her attack on Amit Shah, calling her remarks 'unbecoming of a chief minister' and reflective of her 'growing political desperation.
India.com
11 minutes ago
- India.com
Why Is Asim Munir Visiting U.S. Again? Inside Pakistan's Top General's Washington Diplomacy
New Delhi: Pakistan Army Chief Field Marshal Asim Munir is heading to the United States once again this week. His visit comes barely two months after his last trip to Washington. He is expected to attend the U.S. Central Command's change-of-command ceremony. But the real story may not be the ceremony itself. It is the timing and the conversations already in motion. In June, Munir had lunch with U.S. President Donald Trump at the White House. The meeting lasted two hours. No civilian leader from Pakistan was present. It was a first. Never before had a Pakistani military chief been hosted in the Oval Office on his own. According to insiders, their discussion touched on trade, economic ties and the future of cryptocurrency. In his signature style, Trump did not hold back praise. He said, 'The reason I had him here was I wanted to thank him for not going into the war and ending it…' The remark referred to the May conflict between India and Pakistan, four days of cross-border drone and missile exchanges that stopped just short of full-scale war. India later said it acted alone. But Trump claimed credit for helping stop it. Munir seemed to agree. In his own words, he said Trump deserved a Nobel Prize for 'averting nuclear war' between the two nations. The backdrop to that crisis was Operation Sindoor. India launched the operation in retaliation for the April 22 Pahalgam terror attack, which killed 26 civilians. According to Indian officials, nine terror camps in Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Kashmir were targeted and more than 100 militants were killed in the offensive. Trump's role in managing tensions between New Delhi and Islamabad has stirred debate. India has insisted that the eventual ceasefire came after direct talks between the two countries' Director Generals of Military Operations (DGMO). No foreign mediation, New Delhi said, was involved. Still, Trump has not stepped back from the narrative. In fact, he has doubled down. Alongside security talks, he also unveiled a trade agreement with Islamabad. The deal opens access for U.S. companies to Pakistan's oil reserves. But the fine print carries a twist. Trump signed an executive order imposing a 19% tariff on Pakistani exports, lower than the previous 29% rate, but still steep. The trade talks have been branded as a package of both relief and pressure. Munir's return to Washington now comes in that context. A second visit in two months signals something crucial: sustained military diplomacy, with political overtones. Whether the visit brings new deals, more pressure or another round of handshakes remains to be seen. But for now, Pakistan's most powerful man is going back to the United States, and the conversations are far from over.
Time of India
25 minutes ago
- Time of India
Haryana govt notifies new Mansa Devi Shrine Board
1 2 Chandigarh: The Haryana govt's notification of the reconstituted Shri Mata Mansa Devi Shrine Board (SMDSB), comprising regular and associate members, has surprised many, including the heavyweights of Panchkula BJP. Notably, the list of board members notified by the ULB department includes former Speaker Gian Chand Gupta at the top, followed by Kalka MLA Shakti Rani Sharma, Panchkula mayor Kulbhushan Goyal; Banto Kataria, a BJP leader and widow of former MP Ratan Lal Kataria; Kalka civic body president Krishan Lamba, former Panchkula BJP leader R P Malhotra, former city BJP leader Devender Dhawan, Hari Pal Gupta, and Ambala businessman Rishabh Gupta. The associate members include Ishwar Jindal, a staunch RSS worker, and Dr Puneet Bedi, an educationist-turned-politician and head of the intellectual cell of the Panchkula BJP district unit. Though the nomination to the board is a prerogative of the chief minister's office, this time, the induction of RSS men, namely Rishabh Gupta and Ishwar Jindal, along with the induction of Panchkula mayor Kulbhushan Goyal and Krishan Lamba, has surprised and shocked certain BJP leaders, especially those who are eyeing the party's candidature for the Panchkula and Kalka assembly constituencies. In the past, there was a precedent of inducting active visitors and contributors to the shrine. Those associated with the shrine for decades have put a question mark on the criteria. "Barring one or two members, we have hardly seen majority of nominated members visiting Mansa Devi shrine or other shrines. They only come during a CM's visit, or Navratras. This is really beyond our understanding, as the recommendation of heavyweights too has been sidelined," one such disheartened aspirant said. However, businessman Rishabh Gupta said, "This is a sewa given to me and our family, who have been visiting the shrine for many decades. This decision has come from the CMO after detailed deliberation, and we take it as blessings of the deity." Sources informed that district and state-level BJP leaders were lobbying for their respective candidates. "The list was prepared by the CMO, in consultation with CM Nayab Saini and RSS ideologues of the district as well as the state. Former Speaker Gupta, Kalka MLA Shakti Rani Sharma, Banto Kataria, Kulbhushan Goyal, and Krishan Lamba are learned to have been inducted due to their stature in public," sources added. Ishwar Jindal, Dr Puneet Bedi, Rishabh Gupta, R P Malhotra, and Haripal Gupta are said to be backed by RSS. MSID:: 123143273 413 |
