
ODPs case another indictment of TCP's urban planning flaws
The order of the high court of Bombay at Goa regarding the outline development plans (ODPs) for five prominent coastal villages — Calangute, Candolim, Arpora, Nagoa, and Parra — brings into sharp focus the long-standing allegations of arbitrary land conversion and procedural violations that have plagued the town and country planning (TCP) department.
This is not the first time the judiciary reversed the department's policies. From putting on hold a circular on ODPs for the five villages to virtually striking down the TCP department's power to unilaterally alter the zoning of private plots through Section 17(2) of the TCP Act, 1974, the courts have emerged as the battleground for Goa's land politics. In most of these cases, the judiciary found the department's actions procedurally flawed, environmentally negligent, or contrary to statutory planning norms, say activists who have taken up cudgels against the department.
The earliest large-scale expression of public distrust began with the Regional Plan 2011. Accusations of arbitrary zoning changes benefiting real estate interests led to the plan's scrapping, triggering the formation of the task force for Regional Plan 2021. This exercise ran into allegations that large swathes of land were converted to settlement zones without public consultation, prompting govt to once again keep it in abeyance.
Since then, successive BJP govts have tried to bring in piecemeal changes in the RP2021 in the guise of amendments designed to 'correct' the errors.
Vijai Sardesai was the first to try making incremental tweaks through Section 16B of the TCP Act during his brief stint as TCP minister in 2018. When this was challenged in the HC, present TCP minister Vishwajit Rane rushed in Section 17(2) in the guise of correcting 'inadvertent errors' in the RP2021.
As public pressure mounted, and with Section 17(2) being challenged through a PIL, Rane brought in Section 39(A) for ease of land conversions.
Under this, the TCP department's chief town planner has been empowered to alter or modify the RP2021 and the ODPs.
According to Goa Foundation, 95% of the applications under Section 39(A) involve changes from orchard (2.4 lakh sqm) and natural cover zones (1.4 lakh sqm) to settlement.
Meanwhile, on March 13, the HC read down Section 17(2) of the TCP Act. Justices M S Karnik and Nivedita Mehta minced no words when they immobilised the amendment, saying that it 'virtually has the effect of mutilating the regional plan'. By then, the TCP department had already converted 26.5 lakh sqm.
The HC order said that such large-scale conversion could have 'disastrous consequences' on an ecosystem as fragile as Goa's.
The HC's order on the ODPs is yet another indictment of the TCP's flawed functioning, said an architect. 'Money is being taken for land conversion, but nobody is talking about need-based planning. Govt must decide what happens to the zone changes that have been done till now,' the architect added.
The HC order comes after a series of back and forth between environmentalists, the TCP department, the HC, and the Supreme Court.
In fact, while hearing a special leave petition by Goa govt against the Bombay HC's order restraining construction based on the ODP for the five villages, Supreme Court Justice Satish Chandra Sharma told Goa's counsel, 'Please don't turn Goa into a concrete jungle.'
The message never got passed down, with govt continuing to defend the ODPs in the HC. While these reversals brought uncertainty upon builders, investors, and landowners in Bardez—many of whom benefited from conversions in the ODP—the courts have signalled a zero-tolerance approach to irregularities in urban planning.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Hans India
12 minutes ago
- Hans India
LS adjourned briefly amid din over voter roll revision, Speaker announces full language interpretation rollout
New Delhi: The Lok Sabha was adjourned till noon on Tuesday following persistent sloganeering and disruptions by Opposition members, who demanded a debate on the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls in Bihar. The House managed to take up only three questions during Question Hour before Speaker Om Birla called for adjournment amid rising chaos. As the session commenced, Speaker Birla made a significant announcement (in Hindi) regarding linguistic interpretation inclusivity in Parliament. He informed members that interpretation services are now available in all languages listed in the Eighth Schedule of the Constitution. Previously, interpretation was provided in 18 languages, including Assamese, Bengali, Bodo, Dogri, Gujarati, Kannada, Maithili, Malayalam, Manipuri, Marathi, Nepali, Odia, Punjabi, Sanskrit, Sindhi, Tamil, Telugu, and Urdu. The addition of Kashmiri, Konkani, and Santhali completes the constitutional language roster. 'India is the world's largest democracy. Let us cooperate to ensure smooth functioning of the House,' Birla urged. To which a few members quipped, 'There is a need to save the constitution.' Despite the appeal, Opposition MPs raised slogans such as 'We want justice' and 'Save the Constitution,' demanding accountability over the voter list revision in Bihar. The din rendered ministerial responses inaudible, even as Question Hour proceeded briefly. Among the few questions addressed, BJP MP Dr Sanjay Jaiswal called for the inclusion of Bhojpuri in the Constitution and sought details on the sanctioned personnel strength for the newly launched Bharatiya Bhasha Anubhag. He also inquired whether Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) had been framed to integrate technology for promoting Indian languages. DMK MP Selvam G. raised concerns about the number of Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, women, and marginalised groups benefiting from the Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana (PMAY-G) in Tamil Nadu, including those still on the waiting list. Before the minister could answer, Agriculture Minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan informed the House that the Tamil Nadu government is deliberately not sanctioning houses for the poor in the state. He said he appealed and urged the Tamil Nadu government to provide houses to the poor. BJP MP Vishnu Datt Sharma questioned the Minister of Agriculture and Farmers Welfare about the Indian Council of Agricultural Research's (ICAR) mandate, seeking clarity on its responsibilities across veterinary science, animal husbandry, fisheries, poultry, apiculture, and natural resource management. The Monsoon Session continues to be marred by repeated adjournments, with the Opposition pressing for transparency and debate on electoral reforms.


Hans India
12 minutes ago
- Hans India
New tunnel road to ease traffic at Hebbal flyover: Shivakumar
Bengaluru: Deputy Chief Minister DK Shivakumar on Monday said that a new 1.5 km long tunnel road is being planned from Esteem Mall to Baptist Hospital to ease traffic at Hebbal flyover. Speaking to reporters after declaring open the new loop of Hebbal flyover from Outer Ring Road to Bellary Road, he said, 'Our government is committed to address the traffic congestion in the city. We have discussed the financial implications of the new 1.5 km tunnel road.' 'The new loop has been built at a cost of Rs 80 crore. The other loop from Esteem mall towards Mekhri circle would be read by November. The total cost of the project is Rs 300 crore. The new loops increase the number of lanes from two to six. BDA Chairman has taken the responsibility to get the other loop ready by November,' he explained. 'We have called tenders for 16.5 km tunnel road at a cost of Rs 17,000 crores. I have briefed the CM about manage traffic between Hebbal and Silk Board junctions,' he added. 'I am very transparent. Money is not important; work needs to be completed at any cost. A young MP has accused me of doing projects for money, but I don't need money. BJP hasn't done any major work during its tenure and its leaders haven't brought any funds from the Centre. Asked if the new loops of Hebbal flyover would lead to more traffic at Mekhri circle, he said, 'I can't respond to everything that is said.'
&w=3840&q=100)

Business Standard
12 minutes ago
- Business Standard
PM Modi appeals to all parties to unanimously elect Radhakrishnan as V-P
Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Tuesday appealed to all parties, including the Opposition, for unanimous election of NDA's vice presidential candidate C P Radhakrishnan, as he praised his life of public service at a meeting of the ruling alliance MPs. Radhakrishnan is likely to file his nomination on Wednesday. Parliamentary Affairs Minister Kiren Rijiju told reporters that Modi, in his address, appealed to various parties, especially the Opposition, to back Radhakrishnan to ensure that he is elected unanimously. Modi introduced the Maharashtra governor, who is a seasoned BJP leader from Tamil Nadu, to the NDA MPs, citing his long public life in which he served ably in different capacities. Rijiju said Radhakrishnan (67) has led a simple life away from any controversy or taint, stressing that his election as vice president will be a matter of delight for the entire country. PM Modi, allies felicitate Radhakrishnan at NDA parliamentary party meeting The National Democratic Alliance's vice presidential candidate C P Radhakrishnan was felicitated at a meeting of the ruling bloc's MPs here on Tuesday by their top brass, including Prime Minister Narendra Modi and several BJP allies. With the BJP-led NDA enjoying a comfortable majority in the electoral college comprising MPs from the Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha, Radhakrishnan's win is a certainty amid indications from the opposition INDIA bloc that it will field its own candidate and force a contest.